You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?
November 16 2026 2.28am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Would relegation be such a bad idea?


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
pssguy Flag 09 Feb 24 3.55pm


Just asking

1) There is a very good chance we would bounce right back. Last year's relegated clubs currently occupy the top three positions. The other probable relegated clubs Burnley and Sheff Utd are historically bad and are not obvious promotion candidates
2) Unless Hodgson stays, we should see much more progressive football and lots more wins. This might help keep crowd revenue stable and make fans happier
3) Pretty well all the players people want off the payroll Schlupp, Riedewald, Hughes, Tomkins, Ferguson, Clyne, and Ward are out of contract in the summer. None of them are likely to be picked up by a Premier League club and it might be worth resigning a couple at a reduced wage who could still perform at the Championship level
4) Depending on release clauses, all of our star players are signed for at least the summer of 2026. Having said that, I imagine Olise, Guehi and Andersen would all go. and I imagine we could get a reasonable fee for Johnstone or Henderson. I would think Mateta would also be pushing to leave. Doucoure is coming off an injury and Eze might stay at least whilst we are looking good for promotion. There should be 150 million+ available though the loss of TV revenue will take a chunk
5) We sign a new younger manager who has shown promise but is not at a team as good as Palace. Preferably from the Championship as he should be familiar with the top players in that division we might be after
6) Parish might learn a lesson (especially as his net worth will have taken a hit) and be more proactive in the future if he is still around
7) The Americans might bail and we could get one owner in
The youngsters will get much more play at a level where they can shine and gain confidence. Some of the current loanees may be squad-ready

Our first team could look something like

Henderson
Munoz
Richards
Holding
Mitchell
Doucoure
Wharton
Eze
Rak-Sayki
Edouard
Franca

With judicious signings, it should be stronger and some of the above would be squad players

subs would include Lerma, Ayew, Ebiowei, Ozoh, Umeh, Adamarola, Imray, Goodman/Whitworth + any holdovers (see 3)

I reckon that should be enough for 100 points!

p.s. please don't mention Charlton

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 09 Feb 24 4.03pm

My answer is 'yes' although you forgot one point and that's a bit more room in the stadium on match days!

I understand where the sentiment comes from but I still can't subscribe to any theory that suggests we will progress in any way, shape or form by being relegated from the PL.


 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 09 Feb 24 4.09pm

The squad would be decimated by relegation

Olise - Gone
Eze - Gone
Guehi - gone
Andersen - gone
Johnstone - highly suspect will be gone
Doucoure - probably gone (depending on fitness)
Wharton - could even snapped up by another PL side - ie. Newcastle wanted him.
Edouard - probably try and offload to get his wages off the books.
Mateta - wants out anyway.

We would be left with players no other PL teams want, and we would probably end up re-signing all those out of contract. And how much of the revenue brought in by those sales would be spent on the team ? I would have serious doubts.

In conclusion, would relegation be bad idea, YES. Yes it would.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Feb 24 4.14pm

Doesn’t bother me in the slightest. I started in mid-table division 3 so we’ll still be higher than that
Relegation just means we’ll have the chance of getting promoted again, which is some of our greatest memories in the past.
One way or another, relegation will freshen it up, clear out of players, new manager, it’s all become a bit stale hasn’t it, in fact I think if we go down I’ll be looking forward to next season more. I know it could get worse if we do go down, but any true Palace fan will still be around and we’ll be shot of most of the annoying know it all glory hunters and tourists who’ve jumped on board in recent years

 

taylors lovechild Flag 09 Feb 24 4.27pm

Originally posted by monkey

Doesn’t bother me in the slightest. I started in mid-table division 3 so we’ll still be higher than that
Relegation just means we’ll have the chance of getting promoted again, which is some of our greatest memories in the past.
One way or another, relegation will freshen it up, clear out of players, new manager, it’s all become a bit stale hasn’t it, in fact I think if we go down I’ll be looking forward to next season more. I know it could get worse if we do go down, but any true Palace fan will still be around and we’ll be shot of most of the annoying know it all glory hunters and tourists who’ve jumped on board in recent years

Good luck finding the glory with us!

The football in our last stint in the second tier was mostly awful. If we went down we'd likely get rid of our real stars and if the current board were still in charge they would likely be conservative with reinvesting the money, the new stand might get shelved, we'd find it even harder to find a decent manager and we'd have to get it in the ear from Brighton supporters.

On the plus side we'd be back to crowds of 12-15,000 so there'd be space for me to put my feet up.

 

pssguy Flag 09 Feb 24 4.31pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

The squad would be decimated by relegation

Olise - Gone
Eze - Gone
Guehi - gone
Andersen - gone
Johnstone - highly suspect will be gone
Doucoure - probably gone (depending on fitness)
Wharton - could even snapped up by another PL side - ie. Newcastle wanted him.
Edouard - probably try and offload to get his wages off the books.
Mateta - wants out anyway.

We would be left with players no other PL teams want, and we would probably end up re-signing all those out of contract. And how much of the revenue brought in by those sales would be spent on the team ? I would have serious doubts.

In conclusion, would relegation be bad idea, YES. Yes it would.

Unless they have release clauses, none of those players are out of contract for another two years. Are you suggesting they will all just down tools? (I guess they might if Roy is renewed!). I suggested some would go and could be replaced by younger players that would be outstanding at Championship level. There will be money available and great incentive on the board to buy

Sometimes you have to take one step forward to take two steps forward

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 09 Feb 24 4.45pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Unless they have release clauses, none of those players are out of contract for another two years. Are you suggesting they will all just down tools? (I guess they might if Roy is renewed!). I suggested some would go and could be replaced by younger players that would be outstanding at Championship level. There will be money available and great incentive on the board to buy

Sometimes you have to take one step forward to take two steps forward

Just out of interest, who are the younger players that would be outstanding at Championship level.

 

pssguy Flag 09 Feb 24 4.48pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Just out of interest, who are the younger players that would be outstanding at Championship level.

How would I know? That's up to Freedman and the new manager to determine. That is why they are paid the big bucks

 

BelfastEagle Flag 09 Feb 24 4.59pm

It would be catastrophic

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 09 Feb 24 5.12pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

Good luck finding the glory with us!

The football in our last stint in the second tier was mostly awful. If we went down we'd likely get rid of our real stars and if the current board were still in charge they would likely be conservative with reinvesting the money, the new stand might get shelved, we'd find it even harder to find a decent manager and we'd have to get it in the ear from Brighton supporters.

On the plus side we'd be back to crowds of 12-15,000 so there'd be space for me to put my feet up.

Believe me there’s plenty of them, who are only interested because we’re premier league.
I know after a few years back in the championship or worse when it all gets a bit bleak again I’ll be singing a different tune and yearning for promotion again. But as it stands at the moment relegation doesn’t frighten me and next season will be a fresh start after a few years of turgid stuff.

It’ll be nice not having to bother with old big ears Lineker on a Saturday night as well

Edited by monkey (09 Feb 2024 5.14pm)

 

est1905 Flag 09 Feb 24 5.44pm

I didn't even read your post but in answer to you silly question, take a look at how long it took Forest (a bigger club than us) to get back up. 25 years!
Take a look at Sheffield Wednesday and where they are now. There is NO guarantees a club will make an instant return and every year you are not in the Premiership clubs like us are bleeding a lot of money.
Relegation from the Premiership is never ever a good thing no matter how you try and dress it up.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 09 Feb 24 6.06pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Unless they have release clauses, none of those players are out of contract for another two years. Are you suggesting they will all just down tools? (I guess they might if Roy is renewed!). I suggested some would go and could be replaced by younger players that would be outstanding at Championship level. There will be money available and great incentive on the board to buy

Sometimes you have to take one step forward to take two steps forward

It's a compelling argument with an interesting twist. If we could hang on to the above list of players AND get £150m parachute payment AND another £150m on the way back up, plus say £150m of sales of players (Olise, Anderson Guehi and Henderson) as per the above list, and assume most of their contracts include a 20% pay cut, there is some appeal from the business perspective. And if it found a new owner for an attractive price.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 09 Feb 24 6.14pm

Yes, an extremely bad idea which I, for one, cannot possibly countenance. The financial loss alone would be catastrophic, the competition is less attractive and we don't have the team capable of bouncing right back.

We will, almost certainly, lose Olise. Eze, Guehi and Andersen are also likely to want a move and although they should fetch a good price we'll be relying on Dougie and team to rebuild for the future.

I sincerely hope we have the quality and strength of character to earn enough points to stay in the Prem.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 09 Feb 24 6.14pm

Originally posted by monkey

Doesn’t bother me in the slightest. I started in mid-table division 3 so we’ll still be higher than that
Relegation just means we’ll have the chance of getting promoted again, which is some of our greatest memories in the past.
One way or another, relegation will freshen it up, clear out of players, new manager, it’s all become a bit stale hasn’t it, in fact I think if we go down I’ll be looking forward to next season more. I know it could get worse if we do go down, but any true Palace fan will still be around and we’ll be shot of most of the annoying know it all glory hunters and tourists who’ve jumped on board in recent years

I am leaning towards this view. More matches to see and hopefully a bit more entertaining than what we currently endure.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 09 Feb 24 6.32pm

Yes, IMO, it does matter if we get relegated because every year we're not in the Premier League will make it more difficult for us to retain Premier League status if we ever get promoted again. It's about the money. The money we've earned over the past 10 years has enabled us to at least tread water in this league. We may be moving forward at a snail's pace but we are moving forward with the Academy in place, a new stand due to be started in a few months time and a good number of international players on our books. A spell back in the Championship won't do the club's future much good IMO.

Edited by doombear (09 Feb 2024 7.49pm)

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 09 Feb 24 6.38pm

Originally posted by doombear

Yes, IMO, it does matter if we get relegated because every year we're not in the Premier League will make it more difficult for us to retain Premier League status if we ever get promoted again. It's about the money. The money we've earned over the past 10 years has enabled us to at least tread water in this league. eE may be moving forward at a snail's pace but we are moving forward with the Academy in place, a new stand due to be started in a few months time and a good number of international players on our books. A spell back in the Championship won't do the club's future much good IMO.

Exactly so doombear.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Plaistow Eagle Flag 09 Feb 24 7.01pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Yes, an extremely bad idea which I, for one, cannot possibly countenance. The financial loss alone would be catastrophic, the competition is less attractive and we don't have the team capable of bouncing right back.

We will, almost certainly, lose Olise. Eze, Guehi and Andersen are also likely to want a move and although they should fetch a good price we'll be relying on Dougie and team to rebuild for the future.

I sincerely hope we have the quality and strength of character to earn enough points to stay in the Prem.

Exactly this..!!

In answer to OP’s question ridiculous suggestion - are you really saying with Sheff U and Burnley basically gone - we should hold up the white flags to Luton, with the quality in our squad - no, no and no again.

Beyond that as Old Geezer says - the financial loss would be catastrophic and possibly terminal.

You don’t just waste 11 years of building to the point where you are just 2 or 3 players and decent Manager away from being a real Prem force - just because things get a little difficult.

No you fight to maintain everything you have achieved thus far and for the potential that is in front of you and going forward..!!

The Championship is not as easy as you seem to suggest - it’s tough, even tougher if/when we lose our best players.

Then also there’s the question of investment, which we desperately need - we’re finding it hard enough now as an established Prem side - you can double, triple and quadruple that if we are relegated..!!

So in answer the question - no, nope, non, nein…!!

COYP

 

pssguy Flag 09 Feb 24 7.09pm

Although I raised the topic, I hope that we stay up but that it gives the board such a shock that they improve the manager and squad - something they should have done last summer

However, if they did not react as above, unless there are some more point deduction occurrences we will be in much worse straits next season. At least two of Leeds, Southampton and Leicester will likely come back up and they will neither have the naivety of Sheff Utd and Burnley nor make the mistake of having severely sub-standard goalies this time around

If there was any season to go down (and probably most of us think it will happen sooner than later) with teams like Burnley and Sheff Utd unlikely to be our standard, this would be the best time for a reset

 

AERO Flag 09 Feb 24 7.57pm

Some of the players we have brought seems to me parish was preparing for relagation .

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 09 Feb 24 8.11pm

Originally posted by AERO

Some of the players we have brought seems to me parish was preparing for relagation .

Huh - who exactly..??

Wharton is quality, Munoz is a huge upgrade over both Ward and Clyne - so who exactly are you referring to..??

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Would relegation be such a bad idea?