You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs. Newcastle match thread
November 16 2026 2.29am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs. Newcastle match thread


Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Apr 24 8.33am

That was the best football I have seen from any Palace team ever.
I couldn't believe what I was watching at times.

It has to be said that Glasner is obviously getting the best from this squad.
Hughes was particularly good last night. Richards, Munoz and Ayew excellent. Everyone did their bit.

A brilliant way to celebrate safety for another season.


 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Apr 24 8.56am

Originally posted by monkey

Unbelievable the transformation, sharper, quicker, more movement and energy, moving the ball around quicker, not giving the opposition time on the ball.
I think while other teams are flagging after a long season, we’ve been revitalised by injuries coming back, a couple of excellent signings and of course the new gaffer

We couldn’t beat a team in the top half not so long ago, we’ve now beaten three on the trot and totally outclassed two of them

Happy days

Edited by monkey (25 Apr 2024 1.24am)

I'm not going to nit-pick as we are both very happy so I will respectfully disagree with this point.

Olise coming back has been important. The media focus on the 2 only starting 6 times and that has hurt us. However, other than that, OG is dealing with essentially the same side as RH. Last night no Doucoure, Lerma, Guehi, Johnston or Franca off the bench or Olise to start. And we were up against the form team, 8 places above us for a good reason, who thumped us 4-0 and who had 8 more days than us to prepare. Yet palace players described as "Championship at best" on this site were playing Champions League level. WHO ARE THEY?

That is coaching.

If we can keep our players, make a few sensible improvements and carry this form into next season, people will be talking about us as they are now talking about Villa.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Apr 24 8.58am

Originally posted by Badger11

I think this was a great performance last night as we neutralised an in form Newcastle.

I noticed both Wharton and Hughes had a couple of shots on goal, I wonder if OG has told them to be more attack minded?

However As a palace fan for over 50 years I always look for the dark cloud in the silver lining.

Hanging onto our best players this summer will be the key achievement in the transfer window.

Edited by Badger11 (25 Apr 2024 7.34am)

I know money talks and everyone has a price, but I genuinely think, with the way things are right now, no-one is going to want to leave.

 

WJK1960 Flag 25 Apr 24 9.24am

Absolutely loving all the positive comments. Totally deserved.

I know I shouldn't get worked up about this, but big teams already have enough of an advantage without deliberate gamesmanship/cheating. I saw 3 obvious examples yesterday :

1. Guimaraes going down apparently 'badly injured' in about the 25th minute, giving time for Howe to call in the team for a tactical chat. Guimaraes gets up with no ill effects whatsoever. A coincidence that he did this within earshot of the Newcastle
bench ?
2. Continual haranguing of the ref on any contentious decision. I thought new rules were brought in about dissent.
3. Eze free kick in second half. Newcastle players in the wall moving their feet as the free kick was prepared, gaining about 1 to 2 feet on the marker laid down by the ref and then as Eze ran up another 1-2 feet. Clearly the new rule isn't being monitored properly - but I accept the refs have a lot to consider.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Apr 24 9.52am

Originally posted by silvertop

I'm not going to nit-pick as we are both very happy so I will respectfully disagree with this point.

Olise coming back has been important. The media focus on the 2 only starting 6 times and that has hurt us. However, other than that, OG is dealing with essentially the same side as RH. Last night no Doucoure, Lerma, Guehi, Johnston or Franca off the bench or Olise to start. And we were up against the form team, 8 places above us for a good reason, who thumped us 4-0 and who had 8 more days than us to prepare. Yet palace players described as "Championship at best" on this site were playing Champions League level. WHO ARE THEY?

That is coaching.

If we can keep our players, make a few sensible improvements and carry this form into next season, people will be talking about us as they are now talking about Villa.

I have to agree.

We've gone from a team utterly dependant on a few players with many more written off to one which performs as an effective unit.

We look fitter, sharper and not only purposeful but entertaining and effective in doing so. That is not (primarily) down to the players and perhaps was not so previously. We now have a manager who trumps any fears around that for me. I'm far less concerned with which player(s) stay/go than I am with OG being at the helm.

We could look at Chelsea/United or even pre-Emery Villa for examples of where 'just buying players' can go so wrong and even prove detrimental for the coaching staff. Having a better quality of player helps of course, I'm not arguing that, but Glasner is the most important facet for me.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Apr 24 10.35am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I have to agree.

We've gone from a team utterly dependant on a few players with many more written off to one which performs as an effective unit.

We look fitter, sharper and not only purposeful but entertaining and effective in doing so. That is not (primarily) down to the players and perhaps was not so previously. We now have a manager who trumps any fears around that for me. I'm far less concerned with which player(s) stay/go than I am with OG being at the helm.

We could look at Chelsea/United or even pre-Emery Villa for examples of where 'just buying players' can go so wrong and even prove detrimental for the coaching staff. Having a better quality of player helps of course, I'm not arguing that, but Glasner is the most important facet for me.


Totally agree Nick.

I wasn't able to see the game so have only seen the extended highlights on the club site.

From the comments on here I an struck by the fact that we performed this well without Olise on the pitch until the final 20.

In other words, it's the system and tactics that are working and the team showing that it is greater than the sum of its parts. Yes, we want to keep Eze and Olise if we can because they are both wonderful, creative very special talents but they aren't essential to our success.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Apr 24 11.03am

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I have to agree.

We've gone from a team utterly dependant on a few players with many more written off to one which performs as an effective unit.

We look fitter, sharper and not only purposeful but entertaining and effective in doing so. That is not (primarily) down to the players and perhaps was not so previously. We now have a manager who trumps any fears around that for me. I'm far less concerned with which player(s) stay/go than I am with OG being at the helm.

We could look at Chelsea/United or even pre-Emery Villa for examples of where 'just buying players' can go so wrong and even prove detrimental for the coaching staff. Having a better quality of player helps of course, I'm not arguing that, but Glasner is the most important facet for me.

Glaser has certainly got the team playing, but he wouldn't beat Newcastle if he was managing Rotherham.

You need quality players who can do what you ask of them and do it well.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Apr 24 11.13am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Glaser has certainly got the team playing, but he wouldn't beat Newcastle if he was managing Rotherham.

You need quality players who can do what you ask of them and do it well.

No, but they would not be going down to League 1 either.

 

Fanofzhiyi Flag Kent 25 Apr 24 12.09pm

Originally posted by DenTyler

What a find OG has been. It is like I’m supporting a different team. I cannot believe how much better we are compared to just a few weeks ago. I dont want to get carried away but I’m actually looking forward to next season now. We have just ticked over for so long I’d forgotten how it feels to be positive.

I bet Liverpool are kicking themselves that they never looked at OG as Klopps replacement.

Well done to all involved in bringing him, Wharton and Munoz in. Genius.

Absolutely, A worry in the back of my mind is that a big club might try something if we end the season like this. I suspect Glasner will stick around and build something though. As long as we back his expectations he will be happy.
Let’s enjoy this ride as I feel next season will be unforgettable. Even if people work out our tactics it’s our energy as well they need to match!

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 25 Apr 24 1.27pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

Absolutely loving all the positive comments. Totally deserved.

I know I shouldn't get worked up about this, but big teams already have enough of an advantage without deliberate gamesmanship/cheating. I saw 3 obvious examples yesterday :

1. Guimaraes going down apparently 'badly injured' in about the 25th minute, giving time for Howe to call in the team for a tactical chat. Guimaraes gets up with no ill effects whatsoever. A coincidence that he did this within earshot of the Newcastle
bench ?
2. Continual haranguing of the ref on any contentious decision. I thought new rules were brought in about dissent.


3. Eze free kick in second half. Newcastle players in the wall moving their feet as the free kick was prepared, gaining about 1 to 2 feet on the marker laid down by the ref and then as Eze ran up another 1-2 feet. Clearly the new rule isn't being monitored properly - but I accept the refs have a lot to consider.


Classic Eddie Howe, turning gamesmanship into a cheating mentality .... that's why the victory last night was even more satisfying, some of their lot looked shocked at our ability to play them off the park!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 25 Apr 24 1.42pm

Originally posted by silvertop

No, but they would not be going down to League 1 either.

Possibly. Possibly not.

There seems to be a tendency to see thing in simple terms on the football threads.
Of course the manager has an impact, but the players kick the ball. They are the more important side of the equation.

This is all about an I told you so attitude regarding Roy Hodgson.
People will frame it how they want, but what is most important is that we have our two flair players available and the team reinvigorated.


 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Apr 24 2.06pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Possibly. Possibly not.

There seems to be a tendency to see thing in simple terms on the football threads.
Of course the manager has an impact, but the players kick the ball. They are the more important side of the equation.

This is all about an I told you so attitude regarding Roy Hodgson.
People will frame it how they want, but what is most important is that we have our two flair players available and the team reinvigorated.



Yes but Olise was rested for most of last night's game and we still put on an impressive show without him. That wouldn't have happened under previous managers.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Apr 24 2.18pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Possibly. Possibly not.

There seems to be a tendency to see thing in simple terms on the football threads.
Of course the manager has an impact, but the players kick the ball. They are the more important side of the equation.

This is all about an I told you so attitude regarding Roy Hodgson.
People will frame it how they want, but what is most important is that we have our two flair players available and the team reinvigorated.


So is your point that if Roy was still here and we’d had Eze and Olise available, We’d still have beaten Liverpool and played West Ham & Newcastle off the park?

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 25 Apr 24 2.30pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Possibly. Possibly not.

There seems to be a tendency to see thing in simple terms on the football threads.
Of course the manager has an impact, but the players kick the ball. They are the more important side of the equation.

This is all about an I told you so attitude regarding Roy Hodgson.
People will frame it how they want, but what is most important is that we have our two flair players available and the team reinvigorated.


I know, you're a 10% man.

However, don't look to the 2 flair players but to the journeymen squad fodder. Will Hughes as just one. New found quality and self belief. He's like a new signing.

I was never anti Roy. But when you see a team so comprehensively transformed with essentially the same players you have to say that OG represents more than 10% at this point.

 

george1212 Flag london 25 Apr 24 2.32pm

Saw this on the newcastle forum:

"Their midfield were better than us. The albino ran the show, even against Bruno which just should not be.. but here we are."

That made me laugh! I guess Hughes can take that as a compliment.

On the whole the Newcastle forum were very complimentary of us.

Honestly I'm suprised how sh1t they were after all the media hype about their new ownership and everything and finishing top 4 last season - they look very average. Bruno Guimares was their only standout player...

 

The Dolphin Flag 25 Apr 24 2.42pm

A team is just that - including the management and backroom staff.
OG has got the players fit and given them a plan and a belief.
He trusts all of them to play their role on the pitch and that is what is working.
You can also be sure that everything is rosy behind the scenes and that makes for a happy camp.
It sort of reminds me of Dowie's first game in charge against Millwall. We lost 1-0 but you could immediately tell that he was having a positive effect and it was the most enjoyable defeat I have ever seen because I knew good times were ahead.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Apr 24 2.53pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Possibly. Possibly not.

There seems to be a tendency to see thing in simple terms on the football threads.
Of course the manager has an impact, but the players kick the ball. They are the more important side of the equation.

This is all about an I told you so attitude regarding Roy Hodgson.
People will frame it how they want, but what is most important is that we have our two flair players available and the team reinvigorated.


Have to disagree with this, particularly after the bizarre comment on my last post though I suspected prejudice behind it.

The vitriol thrown Roy's way is unwarranted IMHO, we should be very grateful to him. It was not working this season however and he looked to have run out of ideas to stop our rot and downward slide. This is football and a business at the end of the day.

Mateta/Edouard often looked completely isolated, the defence looked shaky, we did not move the ball well and could hardly muster scoring opportunities. Confidence, morale etc. looked at an all time low and this was reflected in the stands. Olise and Eze's individual brilliance was perhaps highlighted by how poor everything else was.

Glasner plays a completely different system with it's own style. Players have even been posting on social media as to how much they are enjoying it. Olise had very little impact after coming on yesterday in a team that played three days previously and was still missing Johnstone, Guehi, Doucoure, Lerma, Franca and started without him in the first instance. That's 6 players who we'd all expect to feature with all things equal. Players who'd been written off (including by me) such as JPM, Hughes and Clyne now look like star performers. Even the old Jeffrey helped make the second yesterday.

We overran and outplayed both WHU and Newcastle after winning at Anfield. Of the latter two, the first being Liverpool, one of those teams won a European Cup recently and the other was in the CL this season. Guardiola at City, Klopp at Liverpool, Emery at Villa, O'Neill at Wolves and Iraola at B'mouth are just a few recent examples of where managers can change teams.

The players kick the ball but their conditioning, tactics/instruction and morale will dictate the level at which they do so. There has been notable improvement in all the aforementioned. To suggest they just suddenly and coincidentally found form a few games after a new manager arrived with a whole new approach and there is no parallel between the two is a notion which is deliberately choosing to ignore the evidence for this happening.

All those 'hating' Hodgson need to give their heads a wobble however Glasner's arrival and impact has to be noted as it's clear to see. I've never seen a Palace team look so impressive and that's more than just a purple patch.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 25 Apr 24 3.22pm

Originally posted by george1212

Saw this on the newcastle forum:

"Their midfield were better than us. The albino ran the show, even against Bruno which just should not be.. but here we are."

That made me laugh! I guess Hughes can take that as a compliment.

On the whole the Newcastle forum were very complimentary of us.

Honestly I'm suprised how sh1t they were after all the media hype about their new ownership and everything and finishing top 4 last season - they look very average. Bruno Guimares was their only standout player...

Up here in Geordie Land they are not happy. I on the other hand have had a v enjoyable 24 hours. They are an entitled bunch and I wouldn’t be surprised if Howe is moved on in the summer.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 25 Apr 24 3.33pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Have to disagree with this, particularly after the bizarre comment on my last post though I suspected prejudice behind it.

The vitriol thrown Roy's way is unwarranted IMHO, we should be very grateful to him. It was not working this season however and he looked to have run out of ideas to stop our rot and downward slide. This is football and a business at the end of the day.

Mateta/Edouard often looked completely isolated, the defence looked shaky, we did not move the ball well and could hardly muster scoring opportunities. Confidence, morale etc. looked at an all time low and this was reflected in the stands. Olise and Eze's individual brilliance was perhaps highlighted by how poor everything else was.

Glasner plays a completely different system with it's own style. Players have even been posting on social media as to how much they are enjoying it. Olise had very little impact after coming on yesterday in a team that played three days previously and was still missing Johnstone, Guehi, Doucoure, Lerma, Franca and started without him in the first instance. That's 6 players who we'd all expect to feature with all things equal. Players who'd been written off (including by me) such as JPM, Hughes and Clyne now look like star performers. Even the old Jeffrey helped make the second yesterday.

We overran and outplayed both WHU and Newcastle after winning at Anfield. Of the latter two, the first being Liverpool, one of those teams won a European Cup recently and the other was in the CL this season. Guardiola at City, Klopp at Liverpool, Emery at Villa, O'Neill at Wolves and Iraola at B'mouth are just a few recent examples of where managers can change teams.

The players kick the ball but their conditioning, tactics/instruction and morale will dictate the level at which they do so. There has been notable improvement in all the aforementioned. To suggest they just suddenly and coincidentally found form a few games after a new manager arrived with a whole new approach and there is no parallel between the two is a notion which is deliberately choosing to ignore the evidence for this happening.

All those 'hating' Hodgson need to give their heads a wobble however Glasner's arrival and impact has to be noted as it's clear to see. I've never seen a Palace team look so impressive and that's more than just a purple patch.


Excellent post Nick. I, Obviously, concur.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Apr 24 3.37pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I'm not going to nit-pick as we are both very happy so I will respectfully disagree with this point.

Olise coming back has been important. The media focus on the 2 only starting 6 times and that has hurt us. However, other than that, OG is dealing with essentially the same side as RH. Last night no Doucoure, Lerma, Guehi, Johnston or Franca off the bench or Olise to start. And we were up against the form team, 8 places above us for a good reason, who thumped us 4-0 and who had 8 more days than us to prepare. Yet palace players described as "Championship at best" on this site were playing Champions League level. WHO ARE THEY?

That is coaching.

If we can keep our players, make a few sensible improvements and carry this form into next season, people will be talking about us as they are now talking about Villa.

You said you disagree, but then you’re not really disagreeing

Olise and Eze coming back has been important, but I do agree with all your points, it’s not the only factor, as I did state. As I said we seem sharper, more energy, we’re closing down and snapping in with the tackles, not letting teams have time on the ball and the likes of Andersen, JP, Hughes and Mitchell have seriously raised their games, as you say that’s all got to be down to coaching

Edited by monkey (25 Apr 2024 3.38pm)

 

Page 6 of 7 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs. Newcastle match thread