This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Greatest Band Ever
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
tetley Wimbledon 23 Nov 04 1.32am |
|
|
can anyone really technically justify their nominations??
everyone says the beatles changed the face of music - which i don't personally disagree with, but it would be nice if you said how rather than just quoting your favourite music magazine.
my choice would be the funk brothers - the people behind the majorty of motown music, and the people responsible for more hit singles than the Beatles, Rolling Stones, Beach Boys and Elvis combined.
when the beatles and stones first toured -which music did they admit was their inspiration and tht they most admired??? that of motown - the funk brothers to be precise.
even in bands such as maroon five, keane and various other contemporary groups (i'm out of touch now) you can hear similar riffs and drum sequeneces that were (proof can be given) first laid down in detroit studios by the funk brothers. they launched the careers of marvin gaye, stevie wonder, diana ross and michael jackson to name but a few - so whilst i have respect for many bands others have mentioned - it is worth thining about how much you can back these claims up.
It's not the fall that's important.....it's the landing All Nature is but Art, unknown to thee; All Chance, Direction, which thou canst not see; All Discord, Harmony, not understood; All partial Evil, universal Good
[Link]
|
tetley Wimbledon 23 Nov 04 1.32am |
|
|
Edited by tetley (23 Nov 2004 3:40pm)
It's not the fall that's important.....it's the landing All Nature is but Art, unknown to thee; All Chance, Direction, which thou canst not see; All Discord, Harmony, not understood; All partial Evil, universal Good
[Link]
|
Jimble Brighton 23 Nov 04 3.51am |
|
|
Can't believe you could all forget the greatest band of all time New Model Army
RIP Rob Heaton, friend and inspiration....
Edited by Jimble (23 Nov 2004 3:52am)
[Link] 
|
Palace Geezer Empire Made 12 Feb 05 3.10pm |
|
|
Pink Floyd Oasis Rolling Stones The Beatles
Growing old is mandatory; growing up is optional.
|
Wilko Walking in a Freedman Wonderland..... 12 Feb 05 3.22pm |
|
|
oasis all the way.
keane are impressing me lateley.
Palace Boys We Are Here. Shag Your Woman And Drink Your Beer!
|
RednBlue_Dan Where White Eyes Roar 12 Feb 05 5.40pm |
|
Quote favershameagle at 26 Sep 2004 2:13pm
I'm stunned that we've got 6 pages of suggestions, and am sad to say that every single one of you is simply WRONG.
There is only one band who can lay claim to the title The Greatest Rock N Roll Band Of All Time.
THE CLASH
Which probably brings an end to this particular topic. No arguement. Nuff said.
WOOOOOOOOO. I think the Clash revolutioned music in a way no-one else has ever done and will ever do.
A few persoanl favourites of the modern day who I would give best band ever to are;
The Libertines (the one and only) Oasis (How they are still making music and great music at that is beyond me) Snow Patrol Keane The Killers Razorlight
Bands who I'm guessing will go on to do great things.......
Bloc Party The Paddingtons
Nothing Left To Inspire Me...
|
red 'n' blue 12 Feb 05 6.26pm |
|
|
- The Ramones - The Beatles - The Clash - Elliott Smith* - The Libertines
*Technically not a band, but he's still the greatest singer/songwriter ever.
|
dave_mc_89 Walkin like a cyclone 20 Feb 05 12.30pm |
|
Quote RednBlue_Dan at 12 Feb 2005 5:40pm
A few persoanl favourites of the modern day who I would give best band ever to are;
The Libertines (the one and only) Oasis (How they are still making music and great music at that is beyond me) Snow Patrol Keane The Killers Razorlight
Keane? They've made a couple of good songs but how can they even come close to being considered one of the greatest?
Best bands:
Oasis Joy Division The Libertines The Stone Roses The Clash Pravda, of course
Burn down the disco, hang the blessed DJ
|
roffeyeagle Freedman Wonderland 20 Feb 05 12.32pm |
|
|
Oasis would be my personal choice, but the Beatles are the greatest band ever. The stats show it.
'Happy being mediocre; if you've got no targets, you can't fail' - Mantra for life and Palace.
Feel free to check out the Expat Eagles Facebook Group [Link]
Viva la revolution!
|
dave_mc_89 Walkin like a cyclone 20 Feb 05 5.42pm |
|
|
The beatles are probably the greatest but theyre not a personal favourite of mine.
Burn down the disco, hang the blessed DJ
|
radge In my solitude. 20 Feb 05 8.57pm |
|
|
The sex pistols!
Total originators. Changed History.
Best track," No Feelings"
Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.
|
HorshamEagle under the union jack 20 Feb 05 9.18pm |
|
|
The Clash for me, revolutionised music of that era, was a brave step to take but they pulled it off.
RIP Joe.
Honourable mentions to -
Madness The Specials The Jam The Wailers
Do you know where hell is?
|
Jonathan West Hampstead 23 Feb 05 10.55pm |
|
|
The Clash The Rolling Stones The Stone Roses The Jam The Kinks Oasis Blur Pulp Dire Straits
They basically form the music that has influenced my taste, and their music defines moments in my life.
P.s. Cheers dad for your fine taste in music.
19/12/06 i was there.
|
freedmans love child Bromley 24 Feb 05 4.34pm |
|
|
Oasis are the greatest band of my generation without a doubt.
The greatest band of all time however has to be the Beach Boys.
Brian Wilson is a legend!
I DEMAND TO SEE A LAWYER!
Preferably a female nudey one!
|
kyle purley 17 Apr 05 2.43pm |
|
|
crowded house!
154th member GKAS 258th member Roffeyeagle/SpikeyMatt School of Optimism appointed by "chollis" the new prince of purley! WASG 8#
the most useless poster 2005!!
|
REDNBLUEARMY69 19 Apr 05 7.40am |
|
|
sham 69
|
Danger Playa del Merstham 19 Apr 05 8.12am |
|
|
I've said it once, and I'll say it again......Westlife
FFS MURRAY
|
JKM Southfields 19 Apr 05 8.15am |
|
|
Biffy Clyro or Jimmy Eat World...
Sing when it's raining! We only sing when it's raining...
|
rachel strood in kent 26 Apr 05 1.47am |
|
|
The specials
everyone loves the specials
esp prat head Jordan
1 good thing bout him he is trying to get them bk 2gether
Be loud be proud be PALACE!!
Come check my profile out at [Link]
|
dartfordmart South Darenth 03 Jun 05 10.11pm |
|
|
Pink Floyd, no doubt.
Try it, roll a spliff, put Floyd on head phones and turn it up loud, really load! It's mind blowing!
"Are you the Judean peoples front?", "Fcuk off, we're the peoples front of Judea"

|