You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...
November 19 2026 5.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Due to no game on Saturday...


Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 5.26pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 18 Feb 2003 5:11pm

Indeed. I wonder if we would have stood aside and done nothing if there was oil in Rwanda, for example.

With the USA's history of meddling in other countries, causing military coups and civil wars, bombing civilian targets and so forth, don't you think we're entitled to be sceptical?

Edited by halfmanhalfslug (18 Feb 2003 5:15pm)


Yes, of course you are right to be sceptical and I'm not saying I agree with US foreign policy over the last 30 years, they have effectively pissed on their chips for a long time. I just believe that Iraq poses a real threat to civilisation and having weighed up the evidence I think that Blair is right on this occasion. I just hope that he can keep Dubya on his leash long enough to convince the cheese eaters not to vito a further UN resolution.

 

Bexter Flag By the Sea 18 Feb 03 5.29pm

and why is it you think we all know about his weapons of mass detruction and no one elses in the world? we find out what we are told to find out. what i don't understand is how america has got away with not only having weapons of mass destruction in abundance but also selling them to extremely dodgy regimes - such as the man himself, and not have any repercussions. how does israel get away with how it treats the palestinians? (another fine mess we created) and why have the un said saddam is being more co operative of late? that with more time they may sort this out peacefully?

Edited by Bexter (18 Feb 2003 5:31pm)

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 18 Feb 03 6.49pm

Winston: We have before us an ordeal of the most grievous kind. We have before us many, many long months of struggle and of suffering. You ask, what is our policy? I can say: It is to wage war, by sea, land and air, with all our might and with all the strength that God can give us; to wage war against a monstrous tyranny, never surpassed in the dark, lamentable catalogue of human crime.

Bexter: Not in my name you won’t! War is not the answer! Where’s the proof? Hitler’s no real threat to Britain! He’s promised to stay out of Poland in any case, do we really care about Poland and what he’s doing to some German Jews or are we declaring war just for ££ and oil? Should we bomb all nasty places now? What about Stalin? He’s killed millions, should we bomb him next? Sod the Jews, send them back to Palestine where they come from!

Winston: That is our policy. You ask, what is our aim?

Bexter: Oil! Money! Empire building. What is Hitler doing that makes him so much worse than say, Stalin? He clearly poses a serious threat to whom? If it’s not actually us, I don’t really care!

Winston: I can answer in one word: It is victory, victory at all costs, victory in spite of all terror, victory, however long and hard the road may be; for without victory, there is no survival.

Bexter: Oh yeah, let’s kill thousands of innocent German children, we’re really tough. We should’ve given Neville Chamberlain more time! How could Chamberlain do his job when he’s not being given the time he needs? He’s produced absolutely no evidence of any 'threat', I am all for Chamberlain having more time to find out before we go wading in.

Winston: Let that be realised; no survival for the British Empire, no survival for all that the British Empire has stood for, no survival for the urge and impulse of the ages, that mankind will move forward towards its goal.

Bexter: Good! I don’t care about the empire, or all that’s British! Who cares, we’re a multicultural society now. If we bomb every country we disagree with, we’re gonna be very busy. We may give a mandate to a government when we elect them to run our country, but when it comes to a war that no one wants which will cost lives - our troops and German citizens, when there is no evidence of any threat - then democracy has failed - it veers on dictatorship when one man makes such a decision with no backing from his people.

Winston: But I take up my task with buoyancy and hope. I feel sure that our cause will not be suffered to fail among men.

Bexter: But most people don’t want this war of yours. Why are you the only one who knows about Germany’s plans? How about all these security threats? If they can see a threat then I would like to see it too as I work in central London thanks! I mean, they must have evidence else they wouldn't be deploying tanks at Dover would they? I understand that they have to be careful with intelligence etc but by saying there is no specific threat of invasion they are either lying or deploying tanks for no good reason, or to make a stronger case for war.... who knows? A bit of honesty wouldn't go a miss at this stage, f*** the intelligence gatherers risking their lives for our sake. We should listen to Italy and Japan, I’m with the spaghetti eaters and the nips on this one. Maybe I just don't think bombing their homes is the answer? Do you think we should bomb every country who has an unsavoury leader just out of interest?

Winston: At this time I feel entitled to claim the aid of all, and I say, "come then, let us go forward together with our united strength."

Bexter: No way, there’s an anti-war march on Sunday in Brick Lane and I’ll be there, if you come, wear a black shirt! War is not the answer. Appeasement is where it’s at.

Edited by Petealiator (18 Feb 2003 6:52pm)

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Meerkat 2 Flag 1957 18 Feb 03 7.21pm

and why is it you think we all know about his weapons of mass detruction and no one elses in the world? we find out what we are told to find out.

Of course, and I have no doubt that there are other's doing the same thing but if Dubya is true to his word about a war on terrorism we will no doubt hear about them in due course. Best not to fight on too many fronts at once maybe?

what i don't understand is how america has got away with not only having weapons of mass destruction in abundance but also selling them to extremely dodgy regimes - such as the man himself, and not have any repercussions.

A valid point although the US is hardly alone in profiting from the arms trade but that's a whole can of worms in itself. Still I don't believe uncle Sam sold Saddam any plutonium, VX or bacterial agents though.


how does israel get away with how it treats the palestinians? (another fine mess we created)

It gets away with it because of the number of Jews in the US administration. It's s*** and Tony Boy should push this to the top of the agenda once Saddam is toppled.


and why have the un said saddam is being more co operative of late? that with more time they may sort this out peacefully?

It's because Saddam allowed one minor scientist to be interviewed privately and somebody with a large moustache held a door open for Hans Blix. I'm sorry, if they have nothing to hide then why has it taken over a decade to even begin cooperating?

 

Glad All Over Flag Bath 19 Feb 03 8.55am

Quote Meerkat 2 at 18 Feb 2003 7:21pm
Best not to fight on too many fronts at once maybe?

Exactly - too many being one.

 

Glad All Over Flag Bath 19 Feb 03 9.13am

I wonder how Bush would take it if, say, China said "We've had a word with the UN and due to you being the worst global terrorists over the last few decades we want you to destroy all your weapons of mass destruction and having done that allow our inspectors free reign to investigate your most secret areas". Do you think he would say "O.K., no problem, we'll do it without a whimper"? Even if he went along with the resolutions, I think he might be tempted to be a little bit obstructive to try and prove that he was still able to assert his power in some way - don't you?

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 19 Feb 03 10.45am

Quote Glad All Over at 19 Feb 2003 9:13am

I wonder how Bush would take it if, say, China said "We've had a word with the UN and due to you being the worst global terrorists over the last few decades we want you to destroy all your weapons of mass destruction and having done that allow our inspectors free reign to investigate your most secret areas". Do you think he would say "O.K., no problem, we'll do it without a whimper"? Even if he went along with the resolutions, I think he might be tempted to be a little bit obstructive to try and prove that he was still able to assert his power in some way - don't you?

Quite.

Meerkat -- the US did sell chemical weapons to Iraq, lots of them. It's well documented.

Pete -- leave Hitler out of this please, there is no comparison.

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

matt_the_eagle Flag Tulse Thrill 19 Feb 03 11.20am

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 19 Feb 2003 10:45am

Quote Glad All Over at 19 Feb 2003 9:13am

I wonder how Bush would take it if, say, China said "We've had a word with the UN and due to you being the worst global terrorists over the last few decades we want you to destroy all your weapons of mass destruction and having done that allow our inspectors free reign to investigate your most secret areas". Do you think he would say "O.K., no problem, we'll do it without a whimper"? Even if he went along with the resolutions, I think he might be tempted to be a little bit obstructive to try and prove that he was still able to assert his power in some way - don't you?

Quite.

Meerkat -- the US did sell chemical weapons to Iraq, lots of them. It's well documented.

Pete -- leave Hitler out of this please, there is no comparison.

Isn't there?


 


I think Keith Murray said it best when he rapped
"If you aint fly you cant play with my yo-yo".

I'm sure you'll agree.

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 19 Feb 03 11.37am

Not really, no.

Hitler actually invaded several countries before we decided to do something about him, and yet we still kept quiet about the Holocaust during the war. Saddam has not invaded anyone lately, and it can be argued that he had a valid claim on Kuwait, since the border is an artificial line drawn in the sand by the Brits. It's just too facile to throw Hitler in to the argument, in the knowledge that nobody can seriously defend that one.

And as for the comments about Bexter, Brick Lane and black shirts.... ouch. Not nice at all. It seems it's all getting a bit personal on this thread again.

Mind you, I still think we should bomb Belgium...

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Bexter Flag By the Sea 19 Feb 03 11.55am

Water off a ducks back Slug old chap!!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 19 Feb 03 12.54pm

Quote halfmanhalfslug at 19 Feb 2003 11:37am

Not really, no.

Hitler actually invaded several countries before we decided to do something about him, and yet we still kept quiet about the Holocaust during the war. Saddam has not invaded anyone lately, and it can be argued that he had a valid claim on Kuwait, since the border is an artificial line drawn in the sand by the Brits. It's just too facile to throw Hitler in to the argument, in the knowledge that nobody can seriously defend that one.

Mind you, I still think we should bomb Belgium...


Slugs, Hitler has nothing to do with my argument, appeasement against evil was my point.
Slugs, the borders of land-locked Arabic nations ARE artificial lines drawn in the sand, whoever draws them!! Should we return Austria to Germany? Should we return Belgium to being just a part of Flanders, I mean, we Brits just drew a line in the dirt after all.
Slugs, Hitler wanted to dominate the western world and eradicate communism. Saddam wants to dominate the Arabic world and eradicate the infidel.
Slugs, like it or not, it's a fact that the Black Shirts also took the anti-war stance and would have happily marched with your lot. My point being, many people take the anti-war (against Iraq) stance, but not all are taking it (especially any Muslims that marched) for honourable reasons.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 19 Feb 03 1.09pm

Are the Austrians and Belgians being murdered by the thousands because of our line drawing? no, thought not.

 

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 19 Feb 03 1.26pm

Pete, how can you say that you're not drawing parallels with 1939 when you wrote an enormously long email imagining a hypothetical argument between Bexter and Churchill. It appears that you have taken direct quotes from Churchill's speeches for his part of the dialogue, and Hitler is mentioned several times in that and other messages.

Personally, I'd say Suez 1956 is a more realistic comparison with previous experiences... and look what happened when we went to war then. Hmmm.

In 1939, the US was then isolationist, largely uninterested in Europe. Stalinist Russia was isolated for other reasons. Britain had to take the concerns of a world empire into account. France was petrified about the growing danger on the other side of the Rhine. The threat was indeed in the very heart of Europe, and unmistakably real. Britain's very existence was at stake. No weapons inspectors were needed to see whether Hitler was building "weapons of mass destruction". Everybody knew he was doing this illegally even before he openly announced it. He then used military might and bullying tactics to force changes to state borders within Europe. The annexation of what was left of Czechoslovakia in 1939, without any pretext of uniting ethnic Germans, finally convinced the government to take a stand, at the risk of a war they did not want.

Today, there is no self-evident threat from Iraq. There is no invasion of a sovereign territory (as in 1991) to repulse. We have to take it on trust that Saddam is building weapons of mass destruction. Even if he has them, he is unlikely to use them against Britain or America - seemingly bent on war and towing Britain in its slipstream. The tanks at Heathrow are not there to fend off an attack from Saddam. But we can't destroy the invisible source of that menace, which is likely to grow, not diminish - fostered by a war for which the reason is far from plain. In 1939, the reason was all too obvious.

In 1939, the Third Reich was the most powerful and highly armed state in the world. To defeat it took six years, even though for much of that time it was fighting on several fronts at once. But although the Nazi party was destroyed, Germany itself was not: divided and occupied for half a century, its essential unity re-emerged with the collapse of the Berlin Wall. Iraq, by contrast, weakened by defeat in 1991 and sanctions since, is so far from being the most powerful state in the Middle East that, even now, hostile forces control its skies and northern territories with impunity. A war with it is likely to take much less than six years but coping with the aftermath will make dealing with postwar Germany look easy.

In 1956, the US opposed war and forced Israel to withdraw from both Sinai and the Gaza Strip by threatening to cut off aid to it entirely. Eisenhower's anti-colonialism is now a distant memory. Today, the US imports half of its total private consumption of oil, and believes toppling Saddam will help it secure this. Will the people of Iraq thank Washington for their liberation? Maybe. But unless a miracle happens and the US - there is no one else - forces Israel to allow a viable Palestinian state, a new Iraq war will also feed terrorism, not starve it. As for weapons of mass destruction, this war may get rid of Saddam's. And then? War on North Korea next? Or Iran? We hear a lot at present about the limits of diplomacy and the virtues of military force. True statecraft appreciates that force has its limits, too. Hitler, the messianic leader of a rising power, never understood this; Churchill, prime minister of a waning one, did. Which role model for our neo-Churchillians now?

[I'm not ashamed to admit I "borrowed" parts of the above, should anyone want to discount my views simply because I've plagiarised someone else's words. Our Government has just done a very similar thing by copying and amending an old student thesis on terrorism to support the war, so I feel fully justified in doing so.]

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 19 Feb 03 4.09pm

I recognised part of Ian Kershaw's argument, Slug, and was wondering whether you would admit it

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

eulalio Flag Girls just wanna have Funt 19 Feb 03 4.35pm

Quote OknotOK at 19 Feb 2003 4:09pm

I recognised part of Ian Kershaw's argument, Slug, and was wondering whether you would admit it

Indeed I did... unlike Blair and his conniving chums...

 


face up to your share of the blame you filthy terrorist sympathiser - Petealiator 8/7/2005
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Intolerance of ambiguity is the mark of an authoritarian personality - Theodor Adorno

Eddie_Hitler Flag Sussex 19 Feb 03 4.40pm

To all the anti-war marchers.

If there was a terrorist attack in Londing involving chemicals that originated from Iraq, would you then justify a war against Saddam??

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 19 Feb 03 4.40pm

Quote Bexter at 19 Feb 2003 1:09pm

Are the Austrians and Belgians being murdered by the thousands because of our line drawing? no, thought not.

So who is then Bexter? Who's death are you now directly blaming Britain for? Palestinians? Can't be, I don't see thousands dying there, I see terrorist attacks on Israel and Israel hitting back. Are you talking about Iraq and Kuwait? Yeah, that'll be our fault too I suppose, that Saddam slaughtered the people of Kuwait for wanting their own state. Sometimes Bexter, you sound like a spoilt silly little girl sulking in the playground.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Bexter Flag By the Sea 19 Feb 03 4.47pm

do you abuse everyone who disagrees with you?

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 19 Feb 03 4.52pm

Slugs, Iraq might not be the power Germany once was, but Germany never had nuclear weapons, Iraq soon will have if you and your liberal pals get your way. One nuclear warhead in the hands of a slavering rabid psychopathic f***er will kill more people in a split-second than fifty Panzer divisions could do in a year and that is what this is all about. Tony Blair does not want to go down in history as the man that condemned millions of Londoners to a terrible death at the hands of a dark-age throwback just because he didn't have the guts to act. Could you? Could you live with that on your conscience? The warnings are there but you fail to act and then, one fine sunny Sunday morning, London ceases to exist!

Yeah, I think you could, so long as no innocent Iraqis get hurt and your fluffy ideals remain in tact, I'm sure you could.

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 19 Feb 03 5.10pm

Quote Bexter at 19 Feb 2003 4:47pm

do you abuse everyone who disagrees with you?


Nope, only annoying little hippies!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Page 6 of 8 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Due to no game on Saturday...