You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?
November 22 2026 9.06am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?


Page 60 of 280 < 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 >
W12 04 Mar 22 8.04pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

let's see your sources, I refer back a few pages, surely you know unless you are just spouting the proverbial.

There is a Forest Gump quote that seems apt.

Sources for propaganda.

1. How about the “ghost of kiev”?
2. How about “Snake Island”?
3. How about the Russian tank that deliberately ran over Ukrainian car in Kiev when there were no Russians in Kiev?

I mean how many do you want?

 

Ouzo Dan Flag Behind you 04 Mar 22 8.04pm

Russian tanks shelling a tower block
[Link]

Russia also has a tactic of randomly shooting at civillian targets purely to see who shoots back & thus they engage those who return fire, they have a name for it but cant remember what its called.

 


The mountains are calling & I must go.

W12 04 Mar 22 8.10pm

Originally posted by Ouzo Dan

Russian tanks shelling a tower block
[Link]

Russia also has a tactic of randomly shooting at civillian targets purely to see who shoots back & thus they engage those who return fire, they have a name for it but cant remember what its called.

How do you know who is shelling who or why?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Mar 22 8.32pm

I can only see two plays for the Ukrainians. One is holdout so that pressure or overthrow results in Putin's forces leaving Ukraine.....I view this as highly unlikely but who knows.

The other is that the west join in a military war.....something I regard as completely bonkers and which significantly increases the risk of us all getting killed and humanity not recovering for god knows how long.

The Russians are obviously shelling and attacking to gain ground....it's a mincer and anyone not in a shelter is carrying a risk of death just being near military because a battlefield carries no guarantees.

Certain attacks that gain large traction in the media need to come with a level of scepticism. The fog of war means that, unless drones are catching footage of it we can rarely be sure of who does what.

I'm not saying that the Ukrainians are committing war crimes against their own side to encourage western military involvement but this kind of thing has happened in the past.....it's a hell mary for them because they aren't going to beat the Russians.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 8.41pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 22 8.44pm

Originally posted by W12

Not scared mate, prepared to take advantage and help my community at the same time. How about you after 3 days with no shops open?

Do you live in Russia or East Ukraine?

 


COYP

W12 04 Mar 22 8.49pm

It’s complicated to say the least:

[Link]

 

W12 04 Mar 22 8.52pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Do you live in Russia or East Ukraine?

sigh….go in then

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 22 8.57pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

While I'm of the dissident right, though I like to think of myself as more of a social conservative, like all groups it comes with different divisions. At the moment this is one of the divisions within it.

I'm not going to defend morons making crass posts on Twitter rejoicing in Putin 'being our guy'. It isn't even true anyway and they have little knowledge nor probably care.

There is that dissident right element, lets call it the Fuentes crowd, who are part troll and will support any anti western regime that is more socially conservative purely upon the grounds that trans story hour and gay marriage isn't allowed. Half of is more for the memes than any serious treatment of the issue, they are rejectionists similar in some ways to the anti western/white elements on the left.

Then there are those who, though they are social conservatives and also against social degeneracy and the poison taught by social liberalism they also believe in the right for any nation to defend itself from an invader. I think this is where I am. Sure, I might agree that this situation has come about via criminal and disastrous mismanagement but at the end of the day the people dying and suffering didn't ask for any of this and when civilians are dying from shells it's Putin's tanks and artillery doing that. I can't defend shedding the blood of the innocent. Putin had other options and he's the criminal.

But that's just my take.

I'm not someone who believes that strongly in creating big deals over disagreements on my own side....the right are autistic enough as it is and everyone is one argument from hating each other which to my mind is not seeing the woods for the trees....variation is natural, only the main core ideas really matter and all views deserve a level of respect rather than lots of bathwater being lost.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 8.36pm)

The main crowd I’m talking about get their info and influence from James Melville. They pretend to know what they’re talking but it’s like the infants have taken over the school. Useful during covid but a potential danger during wartime. They think they’re doing the right thing and you’d find they agree with everything you say too. But they don’t filter anything under their noses and just retweet anything that’s giving the west flack or puts a positive spin on Putin’s views or geographical right’s. What they’re effectively doing is justifying Putin recapturing the Soviet Union without knowing they’re doing it because they can’t break their addiction of being the font of alternative knowledge or untold news.

 


COYP

Grumbles 04 Mar 22 9.00pm

Originally posted by W12

Sources for propaganda.

1. How about the “ghost of kiev”?
2. How about “Snake Island”?
3. How about the Russian tank that deliberately ran over Ukrainian car in Kiev when there were no Russians in Kiev?

I mean how many do you want?

some of this may be crap may be all but where is your source?

do you believe Soros and Jewish bankers started this?

Please expand where you get your information?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Mar 22 9.07pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

The main crowd I’m talking about get their info and influence from James Melville. They pretend to know what they’re talking but it’s like the infants have taken over the school. Useful during covid but a potential danger during wartime. They think they’re doing the right thing and you’d find they agree with everything you say too. But they don’t filter anything under their noses and just retweet anything that’s giving the west flack or puts a positive spin on Putin’s views or geographical right’s. What they’re effectively doing is justifying Putin recapturing the Soviet Union without knowing they’re doing it because they can’t break their addiction of being the font of alternative knowledge or untold news.

Even if that was correct, which I don't agree with why does that even matter?

If Putin attacks a Nato nation we go to war, that's the upshot. Nothing said in the culture war makes the blindest bit of difference.

Personally I think people can walk and chew gum at the same time, meaning....it's a reality that Putin started the war and his army is killing innocents but it's also a reality that Nato created the conditions for it.....Like I said, the US wouldn't accept missiles pointed at them in Mexico would they and Russia obviously feel threatened by missiles pointed at them in Poland and Romania both formerly soviet republics.

None of that should have happened....we had thirty frigging years to sort this out.

None of that changes the fact that if Nato is attacked we are all at war.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 9.08pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Grumbles 04 Mar 22 9.16pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


None of that should have happened....we had thirty frigging years to sort this out.

None of that changes the fact that if Nato is attacked we are all at war.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 9.08pm)

Ah the most naïve "peace dividend".

at least in the cold war we had a mission ....mostly watching and defending the GIUK gap, or defending German plains. nowadays who knows sh1t all is integrated, hence poor spending plans and strategic decisions across the board not just defense.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Mar 22 9.24pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

Ah the most naïve "peace dividend".

at least in the cold war we had a mission ....mostly watching and defending the GIUK gap, or defending German plains. nowadays who knows sh1t all is integrated, hence poor spending plans and strategic decisions across the board not just defense.

As the years have gone on the quality of our leaders has just reduced and reduced. Growing up in the eighties everyone was very aware of just how f***ing dangerous nuclear weapons were.

Nowadays you get the Gary Linekers saying that the threat is meaningless....some in the US congress even asking if small tactical strikes were that bad....these people are f***ing nuts.

If even one button is pressed that starts the whole f***ing lot off.

At this rate I'll be joining frigging CND!

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 9.27pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 04 Mar 22 9.34pm

Originally posted by Grumbles

some of this may be crap may be all but where is your source?

do you believe Soros and Jewish bankers started this?

Please expand where you get your information?

I get my information from anywhere that’s not got an obvious conflict of interest which is basically anything that’s not mainstream media and not state funded.

“Jewish bankers” - FFS

Soros is an interesting case in point mind, the idea that he cares about “social justice” based on his actions is frankly laughable.

There is no amount of “sources” I could provide you that would satisfy you so we are both wasting our time. I hope you wise up one day for your kids and grandchildrens sake. I really mean that.

I was probably very much like you not that long ago. I had massive hubris and no real understanding of power and it’s cut me down to size.

 

Grumbles 04 Mar 22 9.36pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

As the years have gone on the quality of our leaders has just reduced and reduced. Growing up in the eighties everyone was very aware of just how f***ing dangerous nuclear weapons were.

Nowadays you get the Gary Linekers saying that the threat is meaningless....some in the US congress even asking if small tactical strikes were that bad....these people are f***ing nuts.

If even one button is pressed that starts the whole f***ing lot off.

At this rate I'll be joining frigging CND!

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 9.27pm)

What has concerned me over time is I am not ok the the capitalistic nature of the provision of services to the UK public without the strategic dimension which we now see was totally ignored ....across all political colours.

 

Grumbles 04 Mar 22 9.48pm

Originally posted by W12

I get my information from anywhere that’s not got an obvious conflict of interest which is basically anything that’s not mainstream media and not state funded.

“Jewish bankers” - FFS

Soros is an interesting case in point mind, the idea that he cares about “social justice” based on his actions is frankly laughable.

There is no amount of “sources” I could provide you that would satisfy you so we are both wasting our time. I hope you wise up one day for your kids and grandchildrens sake. I really mean that.

I was probably very much like you not that long ago. I had massive hubris and no real understanding of power and it’s cut me down to size.

thank you. I think you have now stated enough about the baseless enough of neo-nationalist opinion .

 

BlueJay Flag UK 04 Mar 22 10.21pm

Originally posted by W12

How do you know who is shelling who or why?


Originally posted by W12

I get my information from anywhere that’s not got an obvious conflict of interest which is basically anything that’s not mainstream media and not state funded.

It doesn't take a lot, no matter your 'source' to have a source of decency towards innocent people besieged by what is happening to their country. It's not hordes of 'neo nazis' and efforts to give them a fighting chance by arming them are not the act of 'war mongering' taking place.

As I said, in Russia, you would not even be able to state an equivalent critique of their culture, or even be able to acknowledge that a war has been waged without fear of imprisonment. And yet you have oh so much time for them compared to the west and your own country.

You've met certain ills in society (that are of course fair to highlight) with a lurch so far in the other direction that you clearly take in anything contrary to it as fact.

In times of human suffering, there are basic realities and norms of decency in the way that we talk about people, that transcend political opinion. They can't be imagined away just because you fangirl over and look to basement dwellers and Putin press conferences for your 'news'.


Edited by BlueJay (04 Mar 2022 10.43pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 04 Mar 22 10.54pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It doesn't take a lot, no matter your 'source' to have a source of decency towards innocent people besieged by what is happening to their country. It's not hordes of 'neo nazis' and efforts to give them a fighting chance by arming them are not the act of 'war mongering' taking place.

As I said, in Russia, you would not even be able to state an equivalent critique of their culture, or even be able to acknowledge that a war has been waged without fear of imprisonment. And yet you have oh so much time for them compared to the west and your own country.

You've met some ills in society (that are of course fair to highlight) with a lurch so far in the other direction that you clearly take in anything contrary to it as fact.

In times of human suffering, there are basic realities and norms of decency in the way that we talk about people, that transcend political opinion. They can't be imagined away just because you fangirl over and look to basement dwellers and Putin press conferences for your 'news'.


Edited by BlueJay (04 Mar 2022 10.39pm)

In amongst the regular insults your claims for some massive difference for social liberalism seems quite weak.

In the US we have people walking through a building still in solitary confinement, in Canada we have protesters fined incredible amounts and in prison using terrorist legalization not designed for the purpose used..

Here just typing on here brought the Police to my door. Do you think just typing on a site with hundreds of people in Russia gets people jail sentences? I doubt it....probably a similar response.

Tommy Robinson is basically persecuted by the state any which way they can think of, essentially because he opposes them but more importantly is very well known....now that's a comparison with those jailed in Russia......are the communists persecuted? Bank accounts closed?

Do you know how many of the convicted grooming gang members have had their bank accounts closed.....I can tell you . None.

That group you like to think I'm recruiting for have also had their bank accounts closed down....is that liberal enough for you?

None of those having bank accounts closed down have criminal records, not one.

Plus new laws proposed to be passed that will strangle freedom of speech like never before.

So forgive me if I regard your claims of some massive difference in how home citizens are treated as something that was more true of the past than it is now.

Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 11.18pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

W12 04 Mar 22 11.03pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

It doesn't take a lot, no matter your 'source' to have a source of decency towards innocent people besieged by what is happening to their country. It's not hordes of 'neo nazis' and efforts to give them a fighting chance by arming them are not the act of 'war mongering' taking place.

As I said, in Russia, you would not even be able to state an equivalent critique of their culture, or even be able to acknowledge that a war has been waged without fear of imprisonment. And yet you have oh so much time for them compared to the west and your own country.

You've met certain ills in society (that are of course fair to highlight) with a lurch so far in the other direction that you clearly take in anything contrary to it as fact.

In times of human suffering, there are basic realities and norms of decency in the way that we talk about people, that transcend political opinion. They can't be imagined away just because you fangirl over and look to basement dwellers and Putin press conferences for your 'news'.


Edited by BlueJay (04 Mar 2022 10.43pm)

I don’t know what to say to this. I am a self declared English nationalist for years now and you seem to have no awareness of the real world. Do you not understand that your own leaders have completely destroyed the ability of nationalists or even vague patriotic sentiment? Do you give a s*** about England?

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 04 Mar 22 11.04pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

However this 'see no evil' claim that it's no threat to Russia needs to be seen in the reality of Nato putting missile systems in Poland and Romania....both countries that Nato gave assurances that they wouldn't expand into.

Would the US be happy with Russian missiles being placed in Mexico....you know....just defence like.

Putin would like the soviet empire back, however he's also pragmatic....though apparently I keep being told he's mad.


Edited by Stirlingsays (04 Mar 2022 3.55pm)

There is a lot in this post that could be picked apart but I'll just respond to a couple of points.

I don't believe Nato could give such assurances. Membership is open to those who meet their criteria. There are disputed accounts of what was said when the re-unification of Germany happened, but they concern conversations between the US Secretary of State and Gorbachev. The US cannot commit Nato, although Russia, via Putin, seems to think it can. They, and some here it seems, have a fundamental misunderstanding of Nato's purpose and it's limitations. It's no threat to anyone. Its role is solely defensive. Maybe read this:-

[Link]

Given the way Putin has behaved in the past it's easy to understand why the Eastern European states would want to join a defensive alliance.

Of course the US wouldn't accept Russian missiles in Mexico. Russia isn't a defensive alliance like Nato! It's an aggressive, untrustworthy country run by an unstable dictator. The defensive forces in Eastern Europe are commanded by Nato, not by the USA or any other individual country. As I have suggested before there seems a way to create demilitarised buffer zones on each side of the borders. Wouldn't have helped Ukraine but might be a way forward.

I don't see much pragmatism in Putin. I see ruthlessness, deceit, and obsession but also miscalculation on an epic scale. However this ends there will never be forgiveness. The west will continue to squeeze, which will make him a very dangerous cornered animal. These are dark days which will last many years. Which is a very sad thought as I reach the final chapters of my life.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

BlueJay Flag UK 04 Mar 22 11.09pm

Originally posted by W12

I don’t know what to say to this. I am a self declared English nationalist for years now and you seem to have no awareness of the real world. Do you not understand that your own leaders have completely destroyed the ability of nationalists or even vague patriotic sentiment? Do you give a s*** about England?

Your attitudes towards your country and the West are abundantly clear. The contrast between those and your deference to the Russian regime and their actions (towards their own and other peoples) is quite something to behold. That said I'm glad that you are able to express your view, because you most certainly wouldn't be able to offer such a critique as a Russian citizen.


Edited by BlueJay (04 Mar 2022 11.12pm)

 

Page 60 of 280 < 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Ukraine Situation - Should We Be Worried?