You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 65 of 80 < 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 >
Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 06 Aug 14 4.02pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 06 Aug 2014 3.37pm

Quote Seth at 06 Aug 2014 3.33pm

Quote elgrande at 06 Aug 2014 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Aug 2014 11.01pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Aug 2014 9.37pm

Or about as much chance as of Wilbraham becoming a premiership level striker

Seriously though, Wahhabism is seriously unpleasant stuff and the fact of the Saudis putting massive monies into "evanglical" work worldwide has zilch to do with Israel or Zionism

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2014 9.45pm)



Not directly, but indirectly the wests support of Israel and the continued plight of the Palestinians
has been a popular rallying point for militant factions throughout the Arabic world since the 60s.



If thats the case Jamie,How come we have not got isis and all the Jihadists from burnley/blackburn...Or any other northern town in Gazza fighting the Jews.

Because Israel has been blockading Gaza for the last 7 years and no jihadi from here or anywhere else would stand a chance of getting in there.

Syria, however, is very easily accessible via Turkey so most choose to go there. Jihadis need to be practical too y'know!


So, if they're under blockade, where are Hamas getting their missiles from?


Welcome to the good ship Falseflag

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

elgrande Flag bedford 06 Aug 14 4.34pm

Quote Kermit8 at 06 Aug 2014 3.52pm

^^^^

ebay


Can imagine loads of Jihadists sitting over their laptop......Only 3 minutes left and we are the highest bidders.

 


always a Norwood boy, where ever I live.

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Aug 14 6.00pm

Quote elgrande at 06 Aug 2014 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Aug 2014 11.01pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Aug 2014 9.37pm

Or about as much chance as of Wilbraham becoming a premiership level striker

Seriously though, Wahhabism is seriously unpleasant stuff and the fact of the Saudis putting massive monies into "evanglical" work worldwide has zilch to do with Israel or Zionism

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2014 9.45pm)



Not directly, but indirectly the wests support of Israel and the continued plight of the Palestinians
has been a popular rallying point for militant factions throughout the Arabic world since the 60s.



If thats the case Jamie,How come we have not got isis and all the Jihadists from burnley/blackburn...Or any other northern town in Gazza fighting the Jews.

Probably because Hamas has resisted allowing foreign Jihadists. Most of its history has largely been around a Palestinian based struggle, with international funding. Back in May Hamas militants were cracking down on Salafi Jyhadist groups that were firing rockets at Israel from within Gaza.

Like Fatah before them, they're quite keen on avoiding the problems inherent with utilising foreign volunteers and Al-Queda affiliated groups (ie ones with loyalty beyond Palestine). The Muhajireen Brigade isn't particularly popular with either Fatah or Hamas (nor are groups like ISIS).

Hamas relationship with even the likes of Hezbollah is tetchy.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Aug 14 6.04pm

Quote Seth at 06 Aug 2014 3.44pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 06 Aug 2014 3.37pm

Quote Seth at 06 Aug 2014 3.33pm

Quote elgrande at 06 Aug 2014 2.50pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Aug 2014 11.01pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Aug 2014 9.37pm

Or about as much chance as of Wilbraham becoming a premiership level striker

Seriously though, Wahhabism is seriously unpleasant stuff and the fact of the Saudis putting massive monies into "evanglical" work worldwide has zilch to do with Israel or Zionism

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2014 9.45pm)



Not directly, but indirectly the wests support of Israel and the continued plight of the Palestinians
has been a popular rallying point for militant factions throughout the Arabic world since the 60s.



If thats the case Jamie,How come we have not got isis and all the Jihadists from burnley/blackburn...Or any other northern town in Gazza fighting the Jews.

Because Israel has been blockading Gaza for the last 7 years and no jihadi from here or anywhere else would stand a chance of getting in there.

Syria, however, is very easily accessible via Turkey so most choose to go there. Jihadis need to be practical too y'know!


So, if they're under blockade, where are Hamas getting their missiles from?

They make the rockets themselves.

Mostly, although the borders with Syria and Jordan are fairly loose (in terms of the West Bank) and the same applies to Egypt for Gaza. For the most part though the missiles are probably better described as home made rockets.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Aug 14 6.08pm

Quote davidpercival at 06 Aug 2014 12.52pm

Ask yourself a question. Who are the USA's biggest allies in the Middle East? Israel and Saudi Arabia. Saudi are covert allies with Israel and it is well known that they have been egging Israel on to attack Iran, as well as secretly supporting them in the attacks on Gaza (coz Hamas are not the right sort of Muslims as far as they are concerned).

The irony is that while the US says it is concerned about Muslim extremism, they prop up the Saudi dictatorship which in turn encourages the most backward looking form of Islamism. The US criticises countries all over the world for breaches of human rights (which is quite rich when you consider they themselves are holding people without trial for years after torturing them) but there is never a breath of reproach to the good old Saudis with their beheadings and absolute oppression of women.

Quote legaleagle at 05 Aug 2014 8.48pm

Thank you. I now realise I had not previously put enough of the blame for the spread of fundamentalist Wahhabi Islam, etc on those damn Zionists and their pervasive "agenda". Silly me thinking the massive funding by the Saudis and related states into spreading this pernicious creed in mosques worldwide coupled with events in Bosnia, Afghanistan, Chechnya and Iraq had been pivotal by far.

Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2014 8.53pm)


Probably the only nation hated more by Al-Queda than the US, is Saudi Arabia. The whole of that movement is about the liberation of Saudia Arabia. The Saudi's aren't big supporters of Israel either, but they are economically tied to the US and West (we buy their oil and they massively invest in the West). Its always been an uneasy alliance, and a problematic one for the Saudi's.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 06 Aug 14 7.20pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Aug 2014 8.48pm

Thank you. I now realise I had not previously put enough of the blame for the spread of fundamentalist Wahhabi Islam, etc on those damn Zionists and their pervasive "agenda". Silly me thinking the massive funding by the Saudis and related states into spreading this pernicious creed in mosques worldwide coupled with events in Bosnia, Afghanistan, Chechnya and Iraq had been pivotal by far.

Edited by legaleagle (05 Aug 2014 8.53pm)

You make a good point about Saudi Arabia, I did not mean it was the sole reason but probably the prime driver in Western and especially US policy in the region.

BTW I find what both regimes are doing right now to Muslims abhorrent.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 14 7.39pm

Today's FT (haven't just put link since FT site doesn't give automatic access to articles):

"When Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, the jihadi leader whose blackshirts over-ran swaths of northern and central Iraq in June, gave his Ramadan rant last month after proclaiming himself caliph, he had it translated into English, French, German, Turkish, Russian – and Albanian. Why did his Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (known as Isis), which now styles itself narcissistically as the Islamic State, take the trouble?

Since the end of the cold war and after the wars of the Yugoslav succession, the western Balkans – in particular Albania, Kosovo, Bosnia, Macedonia and even bits of Bulgaria – have been carpeted with Saudi-financed Wahhabi mosques and madrassas. This is moving local Muslim culture away from Turkic-oriented, Sufi Islam towards the radical bigotry of Wahhabi absolutism, which groups such as Isis have taken to its logical conclusion. This is fertilised ground for jihadi ambition.

Saudi Arabia not only exports oil, but tanker-loads of quasi-totalitarian religious dogma and pipelines of jihadi volunteers, even as it struggles to insulate itself from the blowback; and King Abdullah, in his end of Ramadan address, warns against the “devilish” extremism of “these deviant forces”. Jihadi extremism does present a threat to the kingdom. But in doctrinal terms it is hard to see in what way it “deviates” from Wahhabi orthodoxy, with its literalist and exclusivist rendering of Sunni Islam. Its extreme interpretation of monotheism anathematises other beliefs, in particular the “idolatrous” practices of Christians and Shia Muslims, as infidel or apostate. That can be read as limitless sanction for jihad. The modern jihadi is a Wahhabi on steroids. His main grievance with the House of Saud is that it deviates: its profligate deeds do not match its Wahhabi words.

The late King Fahd, Abdullah’s predecessor, for example, acquired a reputation as a playboy and gambler in his youth. Yet during his reign he built 1,359 mosques abroad, together with 202 colleges, 210 Islamic centres and more than 2,000 schools, according to official Saudi data. There seem to be no figures for Wahhabi “outreach” under Abdullah, a more austere and ecumenical figure. Anecdotal evidence says Saudi mosque-building is powering ahead wherever believers are found, especially in south, central and southeast Asia, home to about 1bn of the world’s 1.6bn Muslims.

The House of Saud, facing a potentially wrenching succession to the ailing Abdullah at a time of upheaval across the Arab world, is in a delicate position. As custodian of the holy cities of Mecca and Medina, it is the closest modern equivalent to the old Islamic caliphate. It thus abominates the violent presumption of Isis as much as it abhors the rival brand of pan-Islamic fundamentalism of the Muslim Brotherhood. Yet the kingdom still spews out the corrosive poison that helps fuel religion-based fanaticism. The Isis rampage of destruction of shrines and mosques, for instance, continues the two centuries-old record of Wahhabi iconoclasm. Nor should it be forgotten that the House of Saud used Wahhabi zealots as its shock troops in the last century to unite by force most of the religiously diverse Arabian peninsula – won by the sword in 52 battles over 30 years. There are no churches in Saudi Arabia, and permits to build Shia mosques are rarer than desert rain.

Saudi Arabia is not solely responsible for the result; resurgent jihadism amid the virulent battle within Islam between the majority Sunni and minority Shia is playing out across the Levant, down into the Gulf and across to the Indian subcontinent. But it is a primary source of doctrinal bigotry, as Saudi schoolbooks enjoining believers to shun all but their own well attest.

The worldwide surge in Wahhabi mosques began in response to Iran’s attempts to export the Shia radicalism of its 1979 revolution. The Anglo-American overthrow of Iraq’s minority Sunni regime in the 2003 invasion of Iraq – which installed a Shia majority and ignited sectarian carnage – and the west’s failure to support the rebellion of the Sunni majority in Syria, have fed Sunni grievances, sharpened by the Iran-backed Shia axis across the region. It is uncertain whether the Saudi state and its Gulf allies finance groups such as Isis, but their citizens do, encouraged by the Sunni supremacist discourse and tactical promiscuity of their rulers, fearful of being outflanked from the religious right.

Saudi Arabia’s position as the world’s leading oil exporter, a leading purchaser of western arms and a counterweight to Iran in the Gulf has shielded it from criticism. In the current turmoil in the Middle East – characterised by an absence of state and institutions, a loss of shared national narrative in mosaic countries such as Syria and Iraq, and the feebleness of previously influential big powers – there is a lack of mainstream Sunni leadership.

The petrodollar theocracy of Saudi Arabia, in its contest with the petrodollar theocracy of Iran, has smothered Sunni space – except for the vacuum in which Isis is building its (also oil-rich) cross-border caliphate, now striking east into Kurdistan and west into Lebanon.

Previous generations of mainstream Sunni Arabs gave their allegiance to pan-Arab nationalists such as Gamal Abdel Nasser, tarnished paladins of a dead-end ideology. The potential disaster now facing the Arabs demands a new generation of Sunni leaders, able to defeat extremism within their own camp. That is something Saudi Arabia, whose Wahhabi absolutism is part of the genetic code of groups such as Isis, cannot do."

Edited by legaleagle (07 Aug 2014 7.42pm)

 

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 07 Aug 14 8.10pm

What's all this got to do with the persecution of the Christian and Muslim Palestinians by the Israelis??

Edited by Palacetinian (07 Aug 2014 8.10pm)

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 14 8.15pm

If you look back, you'll see how it arose. But, yes, it has as much to do (ie v little )with Israel/Palestine (and the not just one sided prejudices) as all the postings about Israel/Palestine elsewhere had to do with the ISIS and Saudi threads last week. Apologies. Thought we might be interested equally in equal rights and justice wherever the matter arose in the region, particularly given the higher level of ISIS massacres and the direct impact of Saudi funding on the spread of Wahhabi doctrine in the UK. Will post anything else on the ISIS or Saudi threads.


Edited by legaleagle (07 Aug 2014 8.36pm)

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 07 Aug 14 8.22pm

^^^^

If you delete the original edit within the new edit the first edit won't appear and so on.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 14 8.36pm

Thanks Kermit. Will try. I am hopeless!

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 07 Aug 14 9.52pm

Quote legaleagle at 07 Aug 2014 8.36pm

Thanks Kermit. Will try. I am hopeless!
Edited by legaleagle at 8.37pm
Edited by legaleagle at 8.38pm
Edited by legaleagle at 8.41pm
Edited by legaleagle at 8.47pm
Edited by legaleagle at 8.51pm

EFA it aint the same...


 

legaleagle Flag 07 Aug 14 10.00pm

 

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Aug 14 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

jcreedy Flag 08 Aug 14 3.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

They had no right to create the blockade in the first place.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Aug 14 3.17pm

Quote jcreedy at 08 Aug 2014 3.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

They had no right to create the blockade in the first place.


I disagree.

If a city state votes in a government that includes a military which has declared war upon you then you.....Are at war with that city state.

Blockage is an act of war. Gaza voted for war.....Maybe some of them didn't understand the implications.....But that was the inevitable outcome and that's is what it has.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Aug 2014 3.19pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 08 Aug 14 3.32pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.17pm

Quote jcreedy at 08 Aug 2014 3.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

They had no right to create the blockade in the first place.


I disagree.

If a city state votes in a government that includes a military which has declared war upon you then you.....Are at war with that city state.

Blockage is an act of war. Gaza voted for war.....Maybe some of them didn't understand the implications.....But that was the inevitable outcome and that's is what it has.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Aug 2014 3.19pm)


Sort of defeats the whole 'we're only interested in defence' argument though doesn't it? How does rationing the food going in to the country and refusing the freedom of travel by boat or plane in any but the most indirect way constitute self-defence? It is a blatant attack on the people of Gaza. Not the hierarchy of Hamas, not the terrorists, the people.

Israel could just content themselves with bombing hospitals and schools, violating all sorts of international laws, building settlements in the Fatah-run West Bank and so on. But this pathological fixation which drives them to control even the food that Gazans eat is why I think even America is showing signs of turning its back on them.

Edited by serial thriller (08 Aug 2014 3.33pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Stirlingsays Flag 08 Aug 14 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 08 Aug 2014 3.32pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.17pm

Quote jcreedy at 08 Aug 2014 3.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

They had no right to create the blockade in the first place.


I disagree.

If a city state votes in a government that includes a military which has declared war upon you then you.....Are at war with that city state.

Blockage is an act of war. Gaza voted for war.....Maybe some of them didn't understand the implications.....But that was the inevitable outcome and that's is what it has.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Aug 2014 3.19pm)


Sort of defeats the whole 'we're only interested in defence' argument though doesn't it? How does rationing the food going in to the country and refusing the freedom of travel by boat or plane in any but the most indirect way constitute self-defence? It is a blatant attack on the people of Gaza. Not the hierarchy of Hamas, not the terrorists, the people.

Israel could just content themselves with bombing hospitals and schools, violating all sorts of international laws, building settlements in the Fatah-run West Bank and so on. But this pathological fixation which drives them to control even the food that Gazans eat is why I think even America is showing signs of turning its back on them.

Edited by serial thriller (08 Aug 2014 3.33pm)


It's wishful thinking if you really think that the US would 'turn its back' on Israel: that won't happen for several reasons that have already been discussed in the thread.

As for the 'self defence' element of what you say the Israelis only push.......Well, there is a self defence element to how Israel deal with Gaza but actions speak louder than words and obviously Israel are far more pro-active than reactive towards Gaza.

Israel is at war with Hamas and Hamas with it and any amount of PR quoting both either side is just so much propaganda.

When you refer to civilians caught up in this war I'm always troubled as are, I'd imagine, most of us.

However, Hamas use the civilian population and this factor really needs to be considered in any discussion over Israeli action and blame.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 08 Aug 14 4.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 4.09pm

Quote serial thriller at 08 Aug 2014 3.32pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.17pm

Quote jcreedy at 08 Aug 2014 3.11pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 08 Aug 2014 3.04pm

Hamas with a golden opportunity to grab an extended ceasefire once again demonstrate that their real interests lie in self justification for conflict rather than representation of Gaza's Palestinians.

Israel would be mad to stop the blockage of Gaza with Hamas in power, absolutely bonkers.

They had no right to create the blockade in the first place.


I disagree.

If a city state votes in a government that includes a military which has declared war upon you then you.....Are at war with that city state.

Blockage is an act of war. Gaza voted for war.....Maybe some of them didn't understand the implications.....But that was the inevitable outcome and that's is what it has.

Edited by Stirlingsays (08 Aug 2014 3.19pm)


Sort of defeats the whole 'we're only interested in defence' argument though doesn't it? How does rationing the food going in to the country and refusing the freedom of travel by boat or plane in any but the most indirect way constitute self-defence? It is a blatant attack on the people of Gaza. Not the hierarchy of Hamas, not the terrorists, the people.

Israel could just content themselves with bombing hospitals and schools, violating all sorts of international laws, building settlements in the Fatah-run West Bank and so on. But this pathological fixation which drives them to control even the food that Gazans eat is why I think even America is showing signs of turning its back on them.

Edited by serial thriller (08 Aug 2014 3.33pm)


It's wishful thinking if you really think that the US would 'turn its back' on Israel: that won't happen for several reasons that have already been discussed in the thread.

As for the 'self defence' element of what you say the Israelis only push.......Well, there is a self defence element to how Israel deal with Gaza but actions speak louder than words and obviously Israel are far more pro-active than reactive towards Gaza.

Israel is at war with Hamas and Hamas with it and any amount of PR quoting both either side is just so much propaganda.

When you refer to civilians caught up in this war I'm always troubled as are, I'd imagine, most of us.

However, Hamas use the civilian population and this factor really needs to be considered in any discussion over Israeli action and blame.

After much consideration i still find that israel's killing of children is unjustified.


Edited by ghosteagle (08 Aug 2014 4.32pm)

 

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 08 Aug 14 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Page 65 of 80 < 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine