This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
Another mention of appalling management, which has cost us. Ever wondered what caused the Cost of Living Crisis ? French firm Valneva was meant to make more than 100m vaccines at its West Lothian plant, but the deal was controversially scrapped in 2021. Financial records filed by Valneva show it has received hundreds of millions of pounds in non-refundable payments." (BBC website) Edited by Forest Hillbilly (21 Jun 2023 11.37am) We all know it was costly and a lack of preparedness is now being revealed by the enquiry. What we don't know is what the cost would have been if we took any other kind of route. That is, and can only ever be, a hypothesis. Faced with what we didn't understand, knowing only what we knew and that our preparations weren't adequate it was inevitable that mistakes would occur. Decisions were taken on flimsy evidence in a rush, but they still needed to be taken. Being wise after the event is the oxygen of bar room debate. Hopefully, the enquiry will dismiss such pointless froth and concentrate on actually trying to learn things from these events.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We all know it was costly and a lack of preparedness is now being revealed by the enquiry. What we don't know is what the cost would have been if we took any other kind of route. That is, and can only ever be, a hypothesis. Faced with what we didn't understand, knowing only what we knew and that our preparations weren't adequate it was inevitable that mistakes would occur. Decisions were taken on flimsy evidence in a rush, but they still needed to be taken. Being wise after the event is the oxygen of bar room debate. Hopefully, the enquiry will dismiss such pointless froth and concentrate on actually trying to learn things from these events. You keep apologising for the massively costly mistakes (in terms of lives, livelihoods and finances) by making excuses for incompetency, and persist with denigrating posters for saying as such. You really are a very strange one WE. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (21 Jun 2023 2.25pm)
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
We all know it was costly and a lack of preparedness is now being revealed by the enquiry. What we don't know is what the cost would have been if we took any other kind of route. That is, and can only ever be, a hypothesis. Faced with what we didn't understand, knowing only what we knew and that our preparations weren't adequate it was inevitable that mistakes would occur. Decisions were taken on flimsy evidence in a rush, but they still needed to be taken. Being wise after the event is the oxygen of bar room debate. Hopefully, the enquiry will dismiss such pointless froth and concentrate on actually trying to learn things from these events. I used the same argument against my wife when subscribing to BT Sports.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I used the same argument against my wife when subscribing to BT Sports. I use it on mine when I go to the pub.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
You keep apologising for the massively costly mistakes (in terms of lives, livelihoods and finances) by making excuses for incompetency, and persist with denigrating posters for saying as such. You really are a very strange one WE. Edited by Forest Hillbilly (21 Jun 2023 2.25pm) I am not apologising for anything! I wasn't responsible for the decisions. Nor I am competent to do so. I am just explaining what I regard as fact. Whilst we know the cost of what we did, we don't know the cost of what we didn't do. That is surely obvious. Therefore to assume it would be less doesn't make sense. Nor does trying to place a value on any additional, or lower, lives lost. My argument is about what we should be doing now, not what we could have done then, which is just a theoretical exercise anyway. In my view, we are now doing the right thing by taking a calm, studied look at everything that happened and learning the lessons.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
I use it on mine when I go to the pub. I use it on mine about when I might get home.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I am not apologising for anything! I wasn't responsible for the decisions. Nor I am competent to do so. I am just explaining what I regard as fact. Whilst we know the cost of what we did, we don't know the cost of what we didn't do. That is surely obvious. Therefore to assume it would be less doesn't make sense. Nor does trying to place a value on any additional, or lower, lives lost. My argument is about what we should be doing now, not what we could have done then, which is just a theoretical exercise anyway. In my view, we are now doing the right thing by taking a calm, studied look at everything that happened and learning the lessons.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
I use it on mine about when I might get home. Depends whose home it is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
Depends whose home it is. I wish
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
As I said a day or two ago you talk more sense than many others do here, so thanks for that. The best we can do now is learn the lessons so if there is a next time our response will be better.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Hindsight!!! I'm going to bite my lip.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
As I said a day or two ago you talk more sense than many others do here, so thanks for that. The best we can do now is learn the lessons so if there is a next time our response will be better. What I will admit is I’m not overly learned like many on here but if you read my reply to Stirling we had the lesson and didn’t learn from it. My agreement is purely in the fact that it was an unknown at the time and doing nothing wasn’t an option. We could have done it differently and again an unknown outcome. I don’t look at any videos on anti this or pro that like yourself and others have been having tennis with. Contracts here and parties there. I don’t really care that’s way above my head to argue about. I don’t honestly know how bad long covid is but it is becoming obvious it is a thing. What I do know is that this bug has screwed up a lot of people and and the whole world had absolutely no idea the best way to deal with it. We are proven to be stupid lumps of meat on a tiny blue dot in the universe who has and always will be at the mercy of nature. I do think it was a made bug but within that were natural viruses. You cannot make them, you can only join them up to create a bad one. I have had 3 hits of vaccine and are not having anymore; not because I have no faith but by dint of that and having mild covid my protection should be now be natural. All in all it was a s*** show that I never want to go through again!
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
What I will admit is I’m not overly learned like many on here but if you read my reply to Stirling we had the lesson and didn’t learn from it. My agreement is purely in the fact that it was an unknown at the time and doing nothing wasn’t an option. We could have done it differently and again an unknown outcome. I don’t look at any videos on anti this or pro that like yourself and others have been having tennis with. Contracts here and parties there. I don’t really care that’s way above my head to argue about. I don’t honestly know how bad long covid is but it is becoming obvious it is a thing. What I do know is that this bug has screwed up a lot of people and and the whole world had absolutely no idea the best way to deal with it. We are proven to be stupid lumps of meat on a tiny blue dot in the universe who has and always will be at the mercy of nature. I do think it was a made bug but within that were natural viruses. You cannot make them, you can only join them up to create a bad one. I have had 3 hits of vaccine and are not having anymore; not because I have no faith but by dint of that and having mild covid my protection should be now be natural. All in all it was a s*** show that I never want to go through again! I read it. The exercise we ran was called Cygnus and took place in 2016. Jeremy Hunt was Health Secretary at the time and was speaking to the Enquiry about it yesterday. He was pretty scathing that it was a failure of "group think" in that it concentrated on a flu like pandemic and not on a Covid type. We did not pay nearly enough attention to the experience of Korea during the Mers epidemic and the lessons they learned. Which were to take more aggressive action earlier to contain the spread of infection. We thought we knew better, along with all Western nations, and we didn't and as a result we were unprepared and too slow to introduce measures, including isolations and lockdowns.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course, it's hindsight! We know things were done in a rush. We know why. We know mistakes were made. We know alternative strategies were considered and rejected because the outcomes were regarded as worse. What we don't know is how many mistakes were avoided. The enquiry will examine everything to learn the lessons.
Lockdowns are crazy, expense has been hobbled onto entire generations with unpayable debt for doubtful benefit.....something previous older generations would have regarded with shame and just wouldn't have done. The first one can be argued for and against...but what happened after still baffles me. On top of that decisions taken on Ukraine have put the cherry on top.....that people support their own future impoverishment never ceases to amaze me.....As long as they don't complain I suppose, but as I never supported any of this it p1sses me off everyday. Those who spoke most about 'misinformation' were far more guilty of it themselves because they fooled themselves that certainty was available....even though even a rudimentary knowledge of airborne viruses should have given them at least some pause and a little skepticism. But fear baffles brains just as much as BS does. I never had an issue with those who respected the choices of others.....you come into this life on your own and you go out the same. Indeed, I suggested that the old and those vulnerable probably should take the vaccine. However, it always came with trade off risks.....and I was annoyed that our elites stopped the voices that told the truth on this....I refuse to accept that adults should be treated like frightened children. That is not the direction of travel that's better for a good life or for a nation. As for those who made the big decisions....Well, I'm a big believer in merit and the brightest available being in the most important positions....I live in a crazy era where even that common sense position is brought into question. I don't feel as though what transpired was worthy of being called intelligent or wise....I regard it as frightened group think and arse covering. Personally I don't think those types of people should be leading nations and it's a significant problem as modern liberal democracies reward that type of person. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2023 1.35pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I never suggested Bhattacharya rebutted the "GBD"! I said he backed away from it. He has, but he remains a convinced opponent of lockdowns. What he has done is accept that the vaccines were developed more quickly than he thought possible and have made a difference. The "GBD" proposed isolating only the most vulnerable. I did not suggest the "GBD" proposed no protection at all. The critics poured scorn on the idea saying it was impractical, untested, and impossible to know who was actually vulnerable as the impact on co-morbidities was not known. We know there were fake names on the list. Good that you accept that. What we don't know is if any of the others, apart from the original 3, are real, because there was no verification. I don't doubt some are and were initially attracted to the idea. I though doubt too many remain convinced, given the level of opposition from the scientific community as a whole. You appear determined to regard these "names" as providing conclusive evidence of the wisdom of the "GBD" whilst placing no value at all on the overwhelming body of scientific opinion which opposes it. Nor do you pay any attention to its sponsors and the motivations of those behind it. From the BMJ:- [Link] From the Lancet:- [Link] Also from the Lancet:- [Link] From the Science Media Centre, with well-argued dismissals:- From Queens University, Ontario, with well-argued dismissals:- I was away for a few days and so on return considered not replying to this because it's just repeating the same stuff.....but it's important, at least to me, that some points on your post are pointed out. As I stated if there are fake names on the list then there is no way of knowing who was putting them there.....There is a lot of money ranged against criticism of vaccines policies and as I stated that's where I suspect this came from. I will again state that your suggestion that the major figures published in this official announcement are somehow unaware or don't agree with their inclusion comes with no evidence and seems frankly absurd.....similarly you over egging Bhattacharya's comments, which were just clearing up some of the myths people had about what the declaration says. Now to comment on the links you use: The first one is from an organisation that I have some time for in how much I have read it anyway.....The BMJ. The 2021 article you linked to was actually the example I was pointing to when I referring to exposing the motivations behind the commentary...which is frankly quite amusing considering you talk about doubting the motivations of people based upon sponsors yourself yet seem to give your own a pass....and those that supported these policies had all the money behind them. If you scroll down the article the BMJ state that 'Competing interests: Gavin Yamey has received research funding from Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance (Gavi) and the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, both of which support COVID-19 vaccine development and deployment. He was an unpaid member of the World Bank’s COVID-19 Vaccine Development Taskforce and an unpaid adviser to Gavi in the design of COVAX. He has written articles, including in TIME, in support of public health measures to curb COVID-19 (including masks; test, trace, isolate, and support; distancing; workplace and school safety measures; and ventilation of buildings). He was a co-author of a Lancet correspondence, “Scientific consensus on the COVID-19 pandemic: we need to act now” (Lancet 2020;396:E71-E72) that was the basis for the Jon Snow Memorandum. DHG has no competing financial interests. He does however, edit a weblog that has published many posts pushing back against COVID-19 and antivaccine misinformation and has been critical of the GBD in particular.' The rest of those links seem to be from 2020 and are just opposing opinion against the declaration....some reasonable objections, even if I disagree and others make the authors look a little foolish now. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2023 1.32pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly
"I don't feel as though what transpired was worthy of being called intelligent or wise....I regard it as frightened group think and arse covering." (stirling says) Indeed, the decisions made seemed to be based on how best to avoid any culpability for bad outcomes. Career politicians, for the most part, are here for status and a nice bit of raiding and back scratching...all while avoiding any accountability. As turkeys never vote for Christmas it's the norm.....without social conservativism there isn't even any shame in it anymore. Failing upwards is endemic and a significant part of societal decline. Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2023 1.40pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.