This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Thank you for clarifying my state of mind. Unfortunately Starmer wants to rid the possible deterrent of Rwanda and negotiate with France...which will take how long? The Rwanda scheme has been passed through both Houses, numerous appeals and is ready to go. Exhaust that route first whilst negotiating. You don't sell your car and then wait 6 months for your new one to arrive. I thought I would provide a Link before I continue with my arduous tasks on Election Day.
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Every party is against the boats. Even the Greens. It is just the method and execution that varies. Thus, the Tories have been in power for 14 years with this as a central manifesto pledge... and all they gave us was an outwardly attractive but cost ineffective fig leaf in Rwanda while the numbers increased. There must be a degree of desperate naiveté among those who actually believe it would have worked as an effective deterrent. Migrants in Calais don't and won't care a hoot about Rwanda. Reform? They must be the most effective as they are a party with this as their one and only real policy. They will divert all resources to the task. The question is: will the electorate stand for the collapse in the economy and the cliff edge decline in the provision of all other services? When Sky or the BBC (I can't remember which) did a rundown of each or the parties views on immigration, The Greens were reported as not believing in any borders and believe that migration is not an offence under any circumstances. As for the naivety of people who believe that the Rwanda deterrent would not work; no deterrent at all is not the answer. Starmer is from the legal profession. His mates can rack up some hefty bills for the UK Government whilst the next wave of migrants fight their cases here in the UK, rather than enjoying the sunshine in Rwanda.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Relax folks, I've voted. The whole world will now be a better place for everyone.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I thought I would provide a Link before I continue with my arduous tasks on Election Day. Not sure what that proves, but thank you. Enjoy your day.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
Thank you for clarifying my state of mind. Unfortunately Starmer wants to rid the possible deterrent of Rwanda and negotiate with France...which will take how long? The Rwanda scheme has been passed through both Houses, numerous appeals and is ready to go. Exhaust that route first whilst negotiating. You don't sell your car and then wait 6 months for your new one to arrive. Don't move the goalposts now - you said "they (Labour) are not against free movement of migrants from across the channel" - which is clearly untrue. The Rwanda scheme is not 'ready to go' - it's a childish, illegal, dog-whistle of a policy and I still find it staggering that it's taken remotely seriously as an idea. It will never happen.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I thought I would provide a Link before I continue with my arduous tasks on Election Day. Now I'm really convinced - some big red letters and tabloid headlines.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Behind Enemy Lines
When Sky or the BBC (I can't remember which) did a rundown of each or the parties views on immigration, The Greens were reported as not believing in any borders and believe that migration is not an offence under any circumstances. As for the naivety of people who believe that the Rwanda deterrent would not work; no deterrent at all is not the answer. Starmer is from the legal profession. His mates can rack up some hefty bills for the UK Government whilst the next wave of migrants fight their cases here in the UK, rather than enjoying the sunshine in Rwanda. I may stand corrected on the Greens, but the suggestion that Starmer will let the hordes flood in to create a beano for his mates in the legal profession is barrel-scraping conspiratorial tosh. Any party that seeks to reduce state pensions, effects clear reductions in funding to the NHS, seeks a return to the EU, or demonstrates a laissez faire attitude to immigration will not be in power for long. Starmer may be many things but he ain't dumb.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Now I'm really convinced - some big red letters and tabloid headlines. There is nothing for him to stop. How can he stop something "even if it works" if it will never happen? It was never going to [ahem] take off. Just like national service and the promise on the bus. An insult to the intelligence of the electorate. Do they really think people are that stupid?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I thought I would provide a Link before I continue with my arduous tasks on Election Day. Is this really all the Tories have left to offer? Dire situation when even the blinkered fanatics have run out of ideas.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Don't move the goalposts now - you said "they (Labour) are not against free movement of migrants from across the channel" - which is clearly untrue. The Rwanda scheme is not 'ready to go' - it's a childish, illegal, dog-whistle of a policy and I still find it staggering that it's taken remotely seriously as an idea. It will never happen. It's also insanely expensive. A colossal waste of money on what accounts for 4% of the total intake. (~0.05m). Measly. Could and should have been much better spent on trying to resolve the actual issue of lowering the volume of legal migration, which accounts for 96% (~1.2m). Massive.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Don't move the goalposts now - you said "they (Labour) are not against free movement of migrants from across the channel" - which is clearly untrue. The Rwanda scheme is not 'ready to go' - it's a childish, illegal, dog-whistle of a policy and I still find it staggering that it's taken remotely seriously as an idea. It will never happen. In all fairness I think people were just desperate to see it stop. The Tories realized it was a good central pledge to be judged on... but then further realized that the French won't take them back and there wasn't nearly enough cash in the kitty to provide an effective policy. So.... They dreamed up this scheme based on an Australian concept to appeal to their base. It worked down under as the Ozzies had places to turn the boats back to, other than sending them to "containment camps" in PNG or Nauru. We have France. Not negotiating with the French is madness. Then again, we will be negotiating with the far right anti immigration government you guys love and respect so much. Not a chance in a million that lot will take so much as one migrant back. The Australians said they will never allow any illegal boat people to permanently settle in Australia. That includes any genuine asylum seekers from e.g. Burma. I am pretty sure the UK would never introduce such an illegal law. There is some kernel of an idea. All boat people are immediately taken from their boat to the airport and Rwanda containment camps. Their applications are processed there. If they are successful, they are returned to the UK for settlement. Otherwise..? I'm actually unsure. Let out the gate and released into downtown Kigali. Given a bus ticket back to Kabul? Humanely disposed of?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
In all fairness I think people were just desperate to see it stop. The Tories realized it was a good central pledge to be judged on... but then further realized that the French won't take them back and there wasn't nearly enough cash in the kitty to provide an effective policy. So.... They dreamed up this scheme based on an Australian concept to appeal to their base. It worked down under as the Ozzies had places to turn the boats back to, other than sending them to "containment camps" in PNG or Nauru. We have France. Not negotiating with the French is madness. Then again, we will be negotiating with the far right anti immigration government you guys love and respect so much. Not a chance in a million that lot will take so much as one migrant back. The Australians said they will never allow any illegal boat people to permanently settle in Australia. That includes any genuine asylum seekers from e.g. Burma. I am pretty sure the UK would never introduce such an illegal law. There is some kernel of an idea. All boat people are immediately taken from their boat to the airport and Rwanda containment camps. Their applications are processed there. If they are successful, they are returned to the UK for settlement. Otherwise..? I'm actually unsure. Let out the gate and released into downtown Kigali. Given a bus ticket back to Kabul? Humanely disposed of? Re your last para; my idea would be to keep the Rwanda scheme in situ and make it known that if you turn up with your passport, your claim is dealt with here. If no passport, then instant flight to Rwanda from Manston, Lydd or wherever. That way there is a chance that you dispense with a percentage of economic migrants that have no right to asylum. At the moment we have to treat both the genuine and chancer the same, which is clogging up the system and giving every one of them a bad name.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Don't move the goalposts now - you said "they (Labour) are not against free movement of migrants from across the channel" - which is clearly untrue. The Rwanda scheme is not 'ready to go' - it's a childish, illegal, dog-whistle of a policy and I still find it staggering that it's taken remotely seriously as an idea. It will never happen. What drivel. It is the only kind of policy that will prevent Europe being over run by unwanted migrants. You offer no alternative, as usual.
|
|
|
Pretty good post there XKudu.
|
|
|
Originally posted by XKudu
I think the Labour victory will be just as great as the Tory victory at the last election. Parties get periodically thumped. It happens to them all. Big deal. People always then want a change and the other party gets in a few years down the road. Edited by XKudu (04 Jul 2024 1.18pm) UK National Debt in 2008 was just over half a trillion £. It's now nearly £3 trillion. National Debt now is 105% of GDP, compared with 45% in 2008. But yeah, Labour left the 'truly bankrupt' economy because they left a note.
|
|
|
Originally posted by XKudu
I think the Labour victory will be just as great as the Tory victory at the last election. Parties get periodically thumped. It happens to them all. Big deal. People always then want a change and the other party gets in a few years down the road. The economy is improving so I don’t buy this Labour narrative that they’ll inherit a total bankrupt mess and won’t be able to do anything for years and years. Sounds like a preemptive excuse to me anticipating their own future failings and mismanagement. Talk about a defeatist attitude. They should be more positive. They have a real chance to do something. Ironically wasn’t it Labour that left the Tories with a truly bankrupt economy and a note saying “sorry there’s no money left” The Tories managed to turn things round so should Labour from an even stronger baseline. Edited by XKudu (04 Jul 2024 1.18pm)
I think it's healthy for management to change periodically, it balances things out and can keep things fresh. It's like going from a Defensive manager to an attacking manager - for the first 6 months you can find that a happy medium is struck and the system works well.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
'There won't be a woman PM in my lifetime' - Margaret Thatcher. 'We will not re-join the EU in my lifetime' - Keir Starmer.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.