This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Three Israeli hostages were mistakenly killed by the IDF yesterday, as reported by an Israeli military official. The hostages were shirtless, waving white flags and had written ‘SOS, help, three hostages’ on the wall in Hebrew. Separately, an Israeli sniper has killed two women in a Catholic Church in Gaza - the church has been put under siege, no food or power, tanks and snipers surrounding it with over 100 civilians trapped inside - these reports from the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (18 Dec 2023 6.29pm) War is not a computer game. Killing the wrong people is nothing unusual sadly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Three Israeli hostages were mistakenly killed by the IDF yesterday, as reported by an Israeli military official. The hostages were shirtless, waving white flags and had written ‘SOS, help, three hostages’ on the wall in Hebrew. Separately, an Israeli sniper has killed two women in a Catholic Church in Gaza - the church has been put under siege, no food or power, tanks and snipers surrounding it with over 100 civilians trapped inside - these reports from the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (18 Dec 2023 6.29pm) Perhaps it's that famous IQ they talk about.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
War is not a computer game. Killing the wrong people is nothing unusual sadly. Murdering those who are half naked and standing under a white flag is an atrocity - there’s nothing else to call it. They may not have known they were Israelis, but they certainly knew they weren’t military- it’s an insight into how the IDF view Palestinian civilians, which they have demonstrated over and over again. The British army killed 14 people on Bloody Sunday and were still held to account nearly 50 years later - please stop pretending carte blance murder of civilians is, or ever has been, acceptable or reasonable in times of conflict.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Murdering those who are half naked and standing under a white flag is an atrocity - there’s nothing else to call it. They may not have known they were Israelis, but they certainly knew they weren’t military- it’s an insight into how the IDF view Palestinian civilians, which they have demonstrated over and over again. The British army killed 14 people on Bloody Sunday and were still held to account nearly 50 years later - please stop pretending carte blance murder of civilians is, or ever has been, acceptable or reasonable in times of conflict. You spend a lot of time criticising Israel, which I don't necessarily disagree with, but you don't say too much about Hamas.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
You spend a lot of time criticising Israel, which I don't necessarily disagree with, but you don't say too much about Hamas. Because Hamas isn’t murdering civilians every day - they did on one day over 2 months ago, and I unreservedly condemned them for that as did most of the world, but the other side have been committing atrocities ever since, so not sure why it’s surprising that’s where my attention now is. It doesn’t matter what Hamas wanted - none of it justifies acts of genocide. That’s such a nonsensical position. ‘Ah well the terrorists wanted this, so we have to do it’. Illogical rubbish.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Murdering those who are half naked and standing under a white flag is an atrocity - there’s nothing else to call it. They may not have known they were Israelis, but they certainly knew they weren’t military- it’s an insight into how the IDF view Palestinian civilians, which they have demonstrated over and over again. The British army killed 14 people on Bloody Sunday and were still held to account nearly 50 years later - please stop pretending carte blance murder of civilians is, or ever has been, acceptable or reasonable in times of conflict. None of those soldiers started that day with that intention but the IRA who murdered our soldiers for decades did. We prosecuted our own while letting murderers walk free. The example you use may feel morally right for you but not to me.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
None of those soldiers started that day with that intention but the IRA who murdered our soldiers for decades did. We prosecuted our own while letting murderers walk free. The example you use may feel morally right for you but not to me. Bad things happened on both sides. Tony Blair made a huge mistake in letting off the terrorist whilst not doing the same to the police and soldiers. We should have had a Truth and Reconciliation Commission for all.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Bad things happened on both sides. Tony Blair made a huge mistake in letting off the terrorist whilst not doing the same to the police and soldiers. We should have had a Truth and Reconciliation Commission for all. Agreed. Blair's administration was full of decisions that turned out to be long term disasters. Mass migration, devolution, PPP to name some others. He was a good talker and master politician but that old poster the Tories had of Blair with red eyes turned out to be more accurate than we thought. He's still fecking things up today....determined to bring in his digital state control system. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Dec 2023 9.41am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Because Hamas isn’t murdering civilians every day - they did on one day over 2 months ago, and I unreservedly condemned them for that as did most of the world, but the other side have been committing atrocities ever since, so not sure why it’s surprising that’s where my attention now is. It doesn’t matter what Hamas wanted - none of it justifies acts of genocide. That’s such a nonsensical position. ‘Ah well the terrorists wanted this, so we have to do it’. Illogical rubbish. Logic? The logic dear boy is that Israel wants to rid themselves of Hamas and expand into Gaza and Hamas gave them an excuse. It's clear which side you sympathise with, as do many on the left, but you can't escape the fact that Hamas have done this to their own people with eager assistance from Netanyahu. The West will not stop supporting a major ally in the region. The global chess game will not allow for sentimentality. Any noises in that direction are for the masses. There is your logic, hard to swallow as it is.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
None of those soldiers started that day with that intention but the IRA who murdered our soldiers for decades did. We prosecuted our own while letting murderers walk free. The example you use may feel morally right for you but not to me. No idea what you’re on about - the point was to highlight that killing civilians, even in times of conflict, is not just par for the course.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Logic? The logic dear boy is that Israel wants to rid themselves of Hamas and expand into Gaza and Hamas gave them an excuse. It's clear which side you sympathise with, as do many on the left, but you can't escape the fact that Hamas have done this to their own people with eager assistance from Netanyahu. The West will not stop supporting a major ally in the region. The global chess game will not allow for sentimentality. Any noises in that direction are for the masses. There is your logic, hard to swallow as it is. I sympathise with the side being murdered in their tens of thousands, yes. The bit in bold is more illogical nonsense - it suggests that any nation state that suffers a terrorist attack has the right to simply ignore international law, commit as many atrocities as they would like and displace millions of innocent people in response. The world has not worked like that for many many decades. I completely understand the practical reasons why Israel is doing what they are doing - I’m not sure why you keep repeating this bit under some weird guise of telling ‘the hard truths’ - every genocidal regime in history could sit down and tell you why they are doing what they’re doing and why their cause is right - that doesn’t make it acceptable.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
No idea what you’re on about - the point was to highlight that killing civilians, even in times of conflict, is not just par for the course. You don't know what I'm on about? Seriously? Ok, whatever. Anyway civilians get killed in wars....often in even higher numbers than soldiers....WW2 is just the famous example, but it's a feature of many wars. The morality of it, now there we would probably agree....which is why people always have to be careful around the politics that lead to wars. They aren't of course....but hey. The wars in Israel/Palestine are existential ones. They won't stop until one side wins. Avoiding a world war over it is the best we can hope for....something that is the case in multiple situations around the world. Unfortunately we are living at a time of low quality elites. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Dec 2023 12.08pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Glazier#1
There are a lot of things I had no idea about. It is indeed an interesting read which does seem to conclude the futility of the situation. From memory - and I admit I cannot find the expression that I am about to describe - there is a phrase in certain parts of the Arab world that roughly translates to: anything that is weak is to be subjected to control or destruction. Consequently what we may see as a positive trait of seeking peace and reconciliation, to certain Arab minds means that we are showing weakness. This may be why Israel continues to do 'anti-western' actions; unfortunately this means fighting Hamas using its own rules of engagement.
hats off to palace, they were always gonna be louder, and hate to say it but they were impressive ALL bouncing and singing. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
You don't know what I'm on about? Seriously? Ok, whatever. Anyway civilians get killed in wars....often in even higher numbers than soldiers....WW2 is just the famous example, but it's a feature of many wars. The morality of it, now there we would probably agree....which is why people always have to be careful around the politics that lead to wars. They aren't of course....but hey. The wars in Israel/Palestine are existential ones. They won't stop until one side wins. Avoiding a world war over it is the best we can hope for....something that is the case in multiple situations around the world. Unfortunately we are living at a time of low quality elites. Edited by Stirlingsays (19 Dec 2023 12.08pm) In the context of this conversation I don’t really want to get into my views on Bloody Sunday - it was just an example. I don’t think WW2 is a particularly good yardstick for morality in war. There were atrocities committed all over the place and you had numerous leaders with zero regard for civilian life. There were an estimated 45,000 civilians death in the War in Afghanistan which lasted the best part of 20 years. The IDF are almost at half that total after two months.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Three Israeli hostages were mistakenly killed by the IDF yesterday, as reported by an Israeli military official. The hostages were shirtless, waving white flags and had written ‘SOS, help, three hostages’ on the wall in Hebrew. Separately, an Israeli sniper has killed two women in a Catholic Church in Gaza - the church has been put under siege, no food or power, tanks and snipers surrounding it with over 100 civilians trapped inside - these reports from the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (18 Dec 2023 6.29pm) This could be a tipping point. What was missing from Ben Wallace's column about NI (which I thought was a good, balanced article, by the way) was that one of the reasons for peace in NI was 9/11. Americans had experienced local nut job right acts of nut jobbery, but a terrorist attack from foreign agents on their soil was new and horrific. Suddenly the penny dropped for many Irish diaspora that the money they had been pouring into liberating Ireland was not going into the accounts of grieving widows of British imperialism but actually into the pockets of murdering terrorists. Imagine! The money running dry, the IRA displayed a lightening 180 degree turn around. Israel depends on its existence from the US and, in particular, from the Christian right. An unholy alliance if ever. Not blessed with large brains, sadly they also vote. But I imagine the existence of Palestinian Christians must have come as a surprise as big as US Irish nationalists discovering that the majority of the NI population are actually protestant unionists. They represent about 9% and are being blown back to the Old Testament by the very bombs they have supplied. I said it could be a tipping point. We need the US Christian right to understand this before their support wanes. Like I said, not blessed with intelligence...
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I sympathise with the side being murdered in their tens of thousands, yes. The bit in bold is more illogical nonsense - it suggests that any nation state that suffers a terrorist attack has the right to simply ignore international law, commit as many atrocities as they would like and displace millions of innocent people in response. The world has not worked like that for many many decades. I completely understand the practical reasons why Israel is doing what they are doing - I’m not sure why you keep repeating this bit under some weird guise of telling ‘the hard truths’ - every genocidal regime in history could sit down and tell you why they are doing what they’re doing and why their cause is right - that doesn’t make it acceptable. I'm not suggesting that it is acceptable. Again, that is your prejudice. I'm merely pointing out the reality. The trouble is that Palestine is run by the 'other team' and unfortunately, the dead civilians will be portrayed as collateral damage. Sadly, despite your complaints, the uncivilised world must also take a large part of the responsibility for what is happening. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (19 Dec 2023 1.42pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Gaza has 2 logistical problems as far as Israel is concerned. It has a very high population density. Israel finds a Hamas hiding place. It fires a precision missile. It takes out the fighters. Sadly it cannot avoid killing 20 innocent people who live within a few yards. Israel describes this wrongly as using the non combatants as human shields. Actually they just happen to live cheek to cheek. An inconvenient consequence of the creation of Israel. It also has a disproportionate number of people under 18. When those bombs drop, Israel will certainly kill loads of kids. It is impossible not to. Israel's position is impossible. I think you're being a little generous to the IDF - obviously population density and demographics are very relevant to civilian death tolls, but so is the volume and type of ammunition being used. Nearly half of the air-to-ground munitions that Israel has used in Gaza in its war with Hamas since October 7 have been unguided, otherwise known as “dumb bombs,” according to a new US intelligence assessment. The assessment, compiled by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, says that about 40-45% of the 29,000 air-to-ground munitions Israel has used have been unguided. For some context; the US has deliberately phased out it's own use of unguided bombs over the last decade. In terms of volume, during the War in Afghanistan the US broke it's own record (since they started counting in 2006) for volume of bombs dropped in a calendar year with 7243 bombs dropped in 2019. As you'll note above, the IDF have dropped 29,000 in a little over 2 months.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.