You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.21am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 66 of 80 < 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 >
Hoof Hearted 08 Aug 14 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)


It also stops them getting more accurate/powerful weapons.

If you were Israel would you end the blockade when Hammas has stated that it's intended aim is the destruction of Israel and keeps firing rockets at every opportunity?

 

ghosteagle Flag 08 Aug 14 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)

Makes sense.

 

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 08 Aug 14 4.58pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Aug 2014 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)


It also stops them getting more accurate/powerful weapons.

If you were Israel would you end the blockade when Hammas has stated that it's intended aim is the destruction of Israel and keeps firing rockets at every opportunity?

Hamas have said that they want a lifting of the blockade so that Gaza is no longer the worlds biggest prison and that there is freedom of movement. They also said that they would be happy to have international observers and UN peacekeepers as much protect the Palestinians as to reassure the Israelis.

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

Hoof Hearted 08 Aug 14 5.03pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.58pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Aug 2014 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)


It also stops them getting more accurate/powerful weapons.

If you were Israel would you end the blockade when Hammas has stated that it's intended aim is the destruction of Israel and keeps firing rockets at every opportunity?

Hamas have said that they want a lifting of the blockade so that Gaza is no longer the worlds biggest prison and that there is freedom of movement. They also said that they would be happy to have international observers and UN peacekeepers as much protect the Palestinians as to reassure the Israelis.


They keep firing the rockets though and ending the ceasefires.... that doesn't really send out a message that they are to be trusted.

 

ghosteagle Flag 08 Aug 14 5.07pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Aug 2014 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)


It also stops them getting more accurate/powerful weapons.

If you were Israel would you end the blockade when Hammas has stated that it's intended aim is the destruction of Israel and keeps firing rockets at every opportunity?

The blockade is stopping medical supplies and building materials getting through to an oppressed people. It's a convenient lie, but weapons getting in has little to do with the reasons for the blockade.

 

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 08 Aug 14 5.45pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Aug 2014 5.03pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.58pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 08 Aug 2014 4.55pm

Quote Palacetinian at 08 Aug 2014 4.48pm

The reason Hamas won't accept the current ceasefire is that Israel intends to continue the blockade of Gaza so there will be no chance for Gazans to get the material they need to rebuild the massive damage that has been inflicted on them.

If anything the nature and size of the Israeli attack and human and physical damage inflicted has hardened attitudes to Israel and shored up support for Hamas just as it was waning.

Perhaps this is what Netanyahu wanted all along so he can present himself as a flexible peace maker and Hamas as inflexible and militant?

Edited by Palacetinian (08 Aug 2014 4.48pm)


It also stops them getting more accurate/powerful weapons.

If you were Israel would you end the blockade when Hammas has stated that it's intended aim is the destruction of Israel and keeps firing rockets at every opportunity?

Hamas have said that they want a lifting of the blockade so that Gaza is no longer the worlds biggest prison and that there is freedom of movement. They also said that they would be happy to have international observers and UN peacekeepers as much protect the Palestinians as to reassure the Israelis.


They keep firing the rockets though and ending the ceasefires.... that doesn't really send out a message that they are to be trusted.

Was it really a ceasefire? The Israelis said they had achieved their military objectives and were pulling out their ground forces in any case. It suits them to end the one sided war as they are getting all this bad publicity and their supporters in the West are giving them earache about their disproportionate response to the fireworks that Hamas send over.


 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 08 Aug 14 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 08 Aug 14 7.53pm

US Secretary of State John Kerry said the world needed to wake up to the threat posed by the IS group.(in Iraq and Syria, etc.)

Its "campaign of terror against the innocent, including the Yazidi and Christian minorities, and its grotesque targeted acts of violence show all the warning signs of genocide," he said. (BBC 8/8/14)


Hmmmm

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

reborn 08 Aug 14 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 08 Aug 14 9.17pm

Quote reborn at 08 Aug 2014 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.

How can you be so sure?

Its not like Hamas have that in their manifesto or anything...

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 08 Aug 14 9.26pm

Quote reborn at 08 Aug 2014 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.


I think you are right, but if the Zionists had not had the backing of the US and their own financial resources, Israel would not exist in terms of its modern incarnation. The neighbouring/displaced Arab nations demonstrated, from Day 1, that they opposed the 'land grab' even though they had no chance of winning the battle.

I think there is a reasonable expectation that, if you reclaim land and displace people after 1000+ years, and impose your right to do it through military strength, then the least you can do is show some respect to those you have displaced and some humility in your diplomacy.


 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 08 Aug 14 10.28pm

[Link]

...thought this was a very interesting report.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

legaleagle Flag 08 Aug 14 10.47pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 08 Aug 2014 9.26pm

Quote reborn at 08 Aug 2014 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.


I think you are right, but if the Zionists had not had the backing of the US and their own financial resources, Israel would not exist in terms of its modern incarnation. The neighbouring/displaced Arab nations demonstrated, from Day 1, that they opposed the 'land grab' even though they had no chance of winning the battle.

I think there is a reasonable expectation that, if you reclaim land and displace people after 1000+ years, and impose your right to do it through military strength, then the least you can do is show some respect to those you have displaced and some humility in your diplomacy.



Agreed. Though worth bearing in mind the establishment of Israel had both US and Soviet support at the time.

One not so mentioned factor (and not in any way lessening criticism of Israeli treatment of Palestinians, and the Nakba) is that about 1 million Jews in Arab countries basically had to relocate out of those countries due to the very hostile climate against them (admittedly also encouraged to leave by the Israelis and come to Israel)which cannot simply be attributed to zionism. Their descendants now form a very large part of the Israeli population and (massively generalising) are amongst the more extreme, fermented by their own bitter past experiences (it was the fusion between their vote and the formerly minority extremist Likud Party that led to the sea change in Israeli politics in 1977 reflected ever since by a swing to the right).

[Link]

Edited by legaleagle (08 Aug 2014 10.50pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 14 12.02am

Quote SloveniaDave at 08 Aug 2014 9.26pm

Quote reborn at 08 Aug 2014 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.


I think you are right, but if the Zionists had not had the backing of the US and their own financial resources, Israel would not exist in terms of its modern incarnation. The neighbouring/displaced Arab nations demonstrated, from Day 1, that they opposed the 'land grab' even though they had no chance of winning the battle.

I think there is a reasonable expectation that, if you reclaim land and displace people after 1000+ years, and impose your right to do it through military strength, then the least you can do is show some respect to those you have displaced and some humility in your diplomacy.


The Zionists were off to establish the nation of Israel with or without the US support. Zionist groups had generally been involved with Partisan groups throughout WWII and then rather than disarming simply headed to the holy land and engaged in a campaign of terror against the British.

Until the 1960s, the biggest supporter in terms of arms for Israel was the French. US AID during this period wasn't particularly noteworthy.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 09 Aug 14 1.25am

This is an interesting development. To quote Naomi Wolf "Am I alone in thinking that these demands for a ceasefire are not crazy -- in fact are surprisingly (given that Hamas is defined as a terrorist group) -- sensible in terms of building a peaceful civil society? They are not 'wipe Israel off the face of the map" -- they are things like -- a port under UN supervision..."

[Link]


Report: Hamas offers Israel 10 conditions for a 10 year truce

Hamas is offering Israel a 10-year truce if it accepts 10 conditions. The Jerusalem Post reports, based on an Israeli Channel 2 newscast, that Azmi Bishara announced the proposal on Al Jazeera television today. Bishara, a former Israeli Knesset member, fled Israel in 2007 after being accused of spying for Hezbollah. He is currently living in Qatar where he is a high level government advisor.

According to Ma’ariv (Hebrew) these are the conditions:

Withdrawal of Israeli tanks from the Gaza border.

Freeing all the prisoners that were arrested after the killing of the three youths.

Lifting the siege and opening the border crossings to commerce and people.

Establishing an international seaport and airport which would be under U.N. supervision.

Increasing the permitted fishing zone to 10 kilometers.

Internationalizing the Rafah Crossing and placing it under the supervision of the U.N. and some Arab nations.

International forces on the borders.

Easing conditions for permits to pray at the Al Aqsa Mosque.

Prohibition on Israeli interference in the reconciliation agreement.

Reestablishing an industrial zone and improvements in further economic development in the Gaza Strip.

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

legaleagle Flag 09 Aug 14 1.29am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 09 Aug 2014 12.02am

Quote SloveniaDave at 08 Aug 2014 9.26pm

Quote reborn at 08 Aug 2014 7.55pm

Quote pefwin at 08 Aug 2014 7.28pm

I have always wondered if the Zionist apologists would feel the same if the area designated to Jews was the size of Gaza, and the military strength was reversed.

I guess they would still feel that the same.


If the military strength was reversed then we would see an ACTUAL genocide as every Jew would be purposefully massacred.

I am no fan of Israels actions, but that point seems to escape many.


I think you are right, but if the Zionists had not had the backing of the US and their own financial resources, Israel would not exist in terms of its modern incarnation. The neighbouring/displaced Arab nations demonstrated, from Day 1, that they opposed the 'land grab' even though they had no chance of winning the battle.

I think there is a reasonable expectation that, if you reclaim land and displace people after 1000+ years, and impose your right to do it through military strength, then the least you can do is show some respect to those you have displaced and some humility in your diplomacy.


The Zionists were off to establish the nation of Israel with or without the US support. Zionist groups had generally been involved with Partisan groups throughout WWII and then rather than disarming simply headed to the holy land and engaged in a campaign of terror against the British.

Until the 1960s, the biggest supporter in terms of arms for Israel was the French. US AID during this period wasn't particularly noteworthy.


First para is not quite right.

I am simplifying and being general but the major armed Jewish fighters in Palestine pre-war and post war pre-1947 were long time Palestine-based groups. The by far majority socialist- oriented Hagganah (who attacked British "assets" but not personnel post 1945) and the right-wing Stern Gang, who attacked personnel post 1945. The Hagganah had allied with the British during the war and many joined the British army and fought with distinction. After the war, these trained soldiers returned and rejoined the Hagganah. The Stern Gang had not sent its members off to fight with the British. The partisans (many of which were not pre-war Zionists but socialist anti-Zionist "Bundists" were in small scattered groups. Many ended up in Palestine smuggled in by the Hagganah. Many spent a long period first in "displaced persons" camps. They didn't generally suddenly waltz off from the forests they were based in during the war in Ukraine, Poland etc off to Palestine.

In Europe, zionism only started to get anything like majority support amongst Jews after the war and after ,for example, Jews had tried to return to Poland from where they'd been deported to the camps, but found their homes taken by Poles who wouldn't return them and, in some cases, faced massacres at the hands of the Poles. So, generally, that's what turned the majority tide amongst the survivors of the holocaust into feeling they had no future in Europe. Zionists from Palestine and elsewhere were very active in the welfare organisations in the displaced persons camps and large numbers of survivors began to see Palestine as a refuge from persecution (and yes of course I get the irony of that)...and adopt the desire for a Jewish state.

Re the second para, in the 1948 war, the main supplier of arms was Czechoslovakia. But, agreed, the French later became the main backers.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 2.02am)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Aug 14 1.32am


.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 1.35am)

 

legaleagle Flag 09 Aug 14 1.57am

The truce offer is interesting. HAMAS have been offering 10 year truces since 2004,though always caveated it has emerged with confirmation they see it as a "truce" with the endgame of retaking the whole of Israel after the 10 years, having spent 10 years becoming much stronger.

There is a big PR battle going on as to how a deal will be done to end the recent strife, who the world will view as the reasonable people, and how both sides will present it to their constituencies as having gained something from it.

Were this kind of truce agreed, HAMAS would very much enhance their prestige and might even beat Fatah in elections in the West Bank

Maybe HAMAS could offer an unconditional carrot in return: Kick out the HAMAS charter? Then the offer would become very interesting.


Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 2.05am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 09 Aug 14 9.44am

I think if Hamas could secure a truce and maintain it for ten years along those grounds, it could tip the balance towards a longer lasting peaceful solution, largely on the basis of an economic upswing creating prosperity.

In order to achieve a peaceful future, Hamas needs to be able to show something significant in terms of a political victory it can sell that marginalises the influence of hardliners and the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades.

The problem though would always be getting the other factions that are not Hamas to go along with it (such as Palestinian Islamic Jyhad). If they delivered on the ten years truce, then they'd be in a position by the end of that time where they'd either be in a stronger position militarily* or equally in a position where they could arguably sell the idea of a political resolution easier.

* Militarily they'd never be in a position where they could threaten Israel seriously.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 09 Aug 14 11.58am

Agree re not being strong enough in "conventional" military terms to directly challenge Israel in 10 years, but 10 years of mobilising for effective "guerrilla warfare" inside the 1967 boundaries coming from Gaza and the West Bank could be a game changer. viz how effective a force Hezbollah became in Lebanon..

The problem is how would a short-termist right wing government in Israel (would that the Labour Party was in power) sell it to their constituency, having so successfully sought to ramp up public opinion for political ends to date.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.00pm)

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.07pm)

 

Page 66 of 80 < 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine