You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 2.13am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 68 of 80 < 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 >
ghosteagle Flag 13 Aug 14 6.20pm

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 6.17pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Aug 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 5.13pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 11.58am

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 9.01am

Quote legaleagle at 09 Aug 2014 11.58am

Agree re not being strong enough in "conventional" military terms to directly challenge Israel in 10 years, but 10 years of mobilising for effective "guerrilla warfare" inside the 1967 boundaries coming from Gaza and the West Bank could be a game changer. viz how effective a force Hezbollah became in Lebanon..

The problem is how would a short-termist right wing government in Israel (would that the Labour Party was in power) sell it to their constituency, having so successfully sought to ramp up public opinion for political ends to date.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.00pm)

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.07pm)


Are you ignorant, on drugs or deluded?

The 'problem' as you put it is not a 'short termist right wing government in Israel [sic]' selling the Hamas truce to its own people, the problem is that the Hamas 'truce' is bulls***. We have been here before. Many times.

Until Hamas starts behaving like a government and treating its own people as people and not human shields/publicity items, it can go f*** itself and expect to be battered by Israel.

I don't get this. As i understood it, Hamas provides medical and social services, has been voted in, and fulfills the function of government within Gaza.


So acting like a government involves using your own people as human shields? It means that you provoke a mightier neighbour all in the name of PR point scoring? It means putting your own desire for power ahead of protecting your people?


The Al-Quassm martyr brigades are a faction of Hamas, but they aren't Hamas (they're independent of the Political Councils and Welfare).


Erm, Hamas spokesman calling for Palestinians to be human shields on TV:

[Link]

Very interesting article. Especially the conclusion -

The verdict

Hamas has made no secret of its policy of encouraging civilians to face down Israeli attacks “with their bare chests”.

But we don’t know how many people have followed this advice, so it’s difficult to say how far Hamas can be blamed for the civilian deaths.

We do know that rockets have been stored in UN-run schools, which may or may not add credibility to Israel’s broader claims that Hamas has a habit of operating in civilian areas.

Even if all these things turn out to be true, they may not exonerate Israel from the accusation of war crimes being levelled by the UN’s human rights chief Navi Pillay.

Israel’s conduct could still be found to be “indiscriminate” or “disproportionate” if it led to excessive civilian casualties or failed to distinguish between military and civilian targets, regardless of the behaviour of Hamas.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Aug 14 6.27pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.20pm

Very interesting article. Especially the conclusion -

The verdict

Hamas has made no secret of its policy of encouraging civilians to face down Israeli attacks “with their bare chests”.


You said the human shield claims had been debunked.

The truth is you have been proven wrong and have just resorted to playing with words.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

ghosteagle Flag 13 Aug 14 6.29pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Aug 2014 6.27pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.20pm

Very interesting article. Especially the conclusion -

The verdict

Hamas has made no secret of its policy of encouraging civilians to face down Israeli attacks “with their bare chests”.


You said the human shield claims had been debunked.

The truth is you have been proven wrong and have just resorted to playing with words.

They have. The claims that Hamas was forcibly using civilians as human shields has been completely debunked. It is the supporters of the Israeli occupation who are playing semantics.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Aug 14 6.31pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.15pm

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 6.11pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 5.26pm

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 5.13pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 11.58am

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 9.01am

Quote legaleagle at 09 Aug 2014 11.58am

Agree re not being strong enough in "conventional" military terms to directly challenge Israel in 10 years, but 10 years of mobilising for effective "guerrilla warfare" inside the 1967 boundaries coming from Gaza and the West Bank could be a game changer. viz how effective a force Hezbollah became in Lebanon..

The problem is how would a short-termist right wing government in Israel (would that the Labour Party was in power) sell it to their constituency, having so successfully sought to ramp up public opinion for political ends to date.

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.00pm)

Edited by legaleagle (09 Aug 2014 12.07pm)


Are you ignorant, on drugs or deluded?

The 'problem' as you put it is not a 'short termist right wing government in Israel [sic]' selling the Hamas truce to its own people, the problem is that the Hamas 'truce' is bulls***. We have been here before. Many times.

Until Hamas starts behaving like a government and treating its own people as people and not human shields/publicity items, it can go f*** itself and expect to be battered by Israel.

I don't get this. As i understood it, Hamas provides medical and social services, has been voted in, and fulfills the function of government within Gaza.


So acting like a government involves using your own people as human shields? It means that you provoke a mightier neighbour all in the name of PR point scoring? It means putting your own desire for power ahead of protecting your people?


The human shields stories have been debunked. I think that Israel has provided the provocation by stealing the Palestinian lands. Your logic would lead to the Palestinians ending all resistance to the Israeli occupation and then gratefully accepting whatever scraps Israel was generous enough to throw their way.


You could take that ignorant stance, both with regards to the human shield or Israel 'points' above, or you could think that I am advocating the rise of credible Palestinian government who are not party to or encouraging provocation of Israel, actively defend their people are are fit to negotiate in a mature & sophisticated manner with Israel rather than proposing empty truces.

When you say 'credible' what you mean is submissive. Israel has provided the provocation by stealing the Palestinian lands. They are prepared to negotiate with Israel, but Israel has never entered negotiations with the Palestinians with any intention of returning their stolen land or allowing them to create a viable state.



Keep pushing your agenda and refusing to accept what I am saying through your prejudice. Everyone who criticises Hamas is of course asking for them to be submissive, aren't they?

A credible government is one who gives concessions in negotiations. It is one who puts its people first, not its own power. Hamas is bad for Palestine and the Palestinian people.

Israel has been close to a two state solution. Look at Camp David talks.

Also, did Israel steal land from the Palestinians or was the West Bank previously Jordanian territory lost in the 1967 war? I would argue that Israel has not stolen the West Bank from Palestinians but is in non compliance of a UN resolution. Although, I am sure that is wrong in your eyes, somehow.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Aug 14 6.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.29pm

They have. The claims that Hamas was forcibly using civilians as human shields has been completely debunked. It is the supporters of the Israeli occupation who are playing semantics.


So now it's about the word, 'forcibly'.......Blimey how is anyone going to know that?

How about this then, Hamas encourage civilians to use themselves as human shields.

Hence showing that Hamas are willing to use civilian deaths as a method of making Israeli attacks look worse.

You say Israel deliberately kill children all the time yet here is proof Hamas couldn't give a monkeys and for you.....nothing.....You are so one eyed.
All the lefties just willingly lap it up even more then.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2014 6.43pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 13 Aug 14 6.58pm

"Keep pushing your agenda and refusing to accept what I am saying through your prejudice. Everyone who criticises Hamas is of course asking for them to be submissive, aren't they?

A credible government is one who gives concessions in negotiations. It is one who puts its people first, not its own power. Hamas is bad for Palestine and the Palestinian people.

Israel has been close to a two state solution. Look at Camp David talks.

Also, did Israel steal land from the Palestinians or was the West Bank previously Jordanian territory lost in the 1967 war? I would argue that Israel has not stolen the West Bank from Palestinians but is in non compliance of a UN resolution. Although, I am sure that is wrong in your eyes, somehow."


In fact Jordan formally renounced its 'control' of the West Bank to the PLO in 1988.

[Link]

The fact is that the Golan Heights, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza are internationally recognised as illegally occupied by Israel (even acknowldeged by the US) seems to have passed you by!


Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 6.59pm)

Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 7.00pm)

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

matt_himself Flag Matataland 13 Aug 14 7.19pm

Quote Palacetinian at 13 Aug 2014 6.58pm

"Keep pushing your agenda and refusing to accept what I am saying through your prejudice. Everyone who criticises Hamas is of course asking for them to be submissive, aren't they?

A credible government is one who gives concessions in negotiations. It is one who puts its people first, not its own power. Hamas is bad for Palestine and the Palestinian people.

Israel has been close to a two state solution. Look at Camp David talks.

Also, did Israel steal land from the Palestinians or was the West Bank previously Jordanian territory lost in the 1967 war? I would argue that Israel has not stolen the West Bank from Palestinians but is in non compliance of a UN resolution. Although, I am sure that is wrong in your eyes, somehow."


In fact Jordan formally renounced its 'control' of the West Bank to the PLO in 1988.

[Link]

The fact is that the Golan Heights, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza are internationally recognised as illegally occupied by Israel (even acknowldeged by the US) seems to have passed you by!


Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 6.59pm)

Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 7.00pm)


A lefty twisting words. What a surprise. As Sterling said, the one eyed nature of your collective defence of the indefensible, Hamas, is incredible.

I said that Israel hadn't 'stolen' land from Palestinians. The West Bank and Golan heights were part of Jordan and Syria prior to 1967. I said that Israel was in non-compliance of a UN resolution with regards to the West Bank.

Furthermore, Israel claims that under UN resolution 242, it has a legitimate claim to the Golan heights. Remember Syria rejected the return of the Golan Heights in return for a peace treaty. Israel claims that under the terms of resolution 242, this means that retaining it provides security for the country from an attack by Syria.

Is the above true or Zionist propaganda?

Edited by matt_himself (13 Aug 2014 7.19pm)

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Oliver Flag Bodega Bay 14 Aug 14 5.51am

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Aug 2014 6.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.29pm

They have. The claims that Hamas was forcibly using civilians as human shields has been completely debunked. It is the supporters of the Israeli occupation who are playing semantics.


So now it's about the word, 'forcibly'.......Blimey how is anyone going to know that?

How about this then, Hamas encourage civilians to use themselves as human shields.

Hence showing that Hamas are willing to use civilian deaths as a method of making Israeli attacks look worse.

You say Israel deliberately kill children all the time yet here is proof Hamas couldn't give a monkeys and for you.....nothing.....You are so one eyed.
All the lefties just willingly lap it up even more then.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2014 6.43pm)


According to the UN it's the IDF who use Palestinian children as human shields

 


I have prepared one of my own time capsules. I have placed some rather large samples of dynamite, gunpowder and nitroglycerin. My time capsule is set to go off in the year 3000. It will show them what we are really like.

Palacetinian Flag Surrey Fam 14 Aug 14 7.03am

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 7.19pm

Quote Palacetinian at 13 Aug 2014 6.58pm

"Keep pushing your agenda and refusing to accept what I am saying through your prejudice. Everyone who criticises Hamas is of course asking for them to be submissive, aren't they?

A credible government is one who gives concessions in negotiations. It is one who puts its people first, not its own power. Hamas is bad for Palestine and the Palestinian people.

Israel has been close to a two state solution. Look at Camp David talks.

Also, did Israel steal land from the Palestinians or was the West Bank previously Jordanian territory lost in the 1967 war? I would argue that Israel has not stolen the West Bank from Palestinians but is in non compliance of a UN resolution. Although, I am sure that is wrong in your eyes, somehow."


In fact Jordan formally renounced its 'control' of the West Bank to the PLO in 1988.

[Link]

The fact is that the Golan Heights, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza are internationally recognised as illegally occupied by Israel (even acknowldeged by the US) seems to have passed you by!


Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 6.59pm)

Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 7.00pm)


A lefty twisting words. What a surprise. As Sterling said, the one eyed nature of your collective defence of the indefensible, Hamas, is incredible.

I said that Israel hadn't 'stolen' land from Palestinians. The West Bank and Golan heights were part of Jordan and Syria prior to 1967. I said that Israel was in non-compliance of a UN resolution with regards to the West Bank.

Furthermore, Israel claims that under UN resolution 242, it has a legitimate claim to the Golan heights. Remember Syria rejected the return of the Golan Heights in return for a peace treaty. Israel claims that under the terms of resolution 242, this means that retaining it provides security for the country from an attack by Syria.

Is the above true or Zionist propaganda?

Edited by matt_himself (13 Aug 2014 7.19pm)

Matt, get over yourself! I was giving you facts not defending Hames.

The only one trotting out Zionist propaganda is you!! Are you seriously suggesting Israel is not occupying Palestinian land? Really??

 


Supporting Crystal Palace since 19.45 on 29th August 1972 (approximately)!

matt_himself Flag Matataland 14 Aug 14 7.13am

Quote Palacetinian at 14 Aug 2014 7.03am

Quote matt_himself at 13 Aug 2014 7.19pm

Quote Palacetinian at 13 Aug 2014 6.58pm

"Keep pushing your agenda and refusing to accept what I am saying through your prejudice. Everyone who criticises Hamas is of course asking for them to be submissive, aren't they?

A credible government is one who gives concessions in negotiations. It is one who puts its people first, not its own power. Hamas is bad for Palestine and the Palestinian people.

Israel has been close to a two state solution. Look at Camp David talks.

Also, did Israel steal land from the Palestinians or was the West Bank previously Jordanian territory lost in the 1967 war? I would argue that Israel has not stolen the West Bank from Palestinians but is in non compliance of a UN resolution. Although, I am sure that is wrong in your eyes, somehow."


In fact Jordan formally renounced its 'control' of the West Bank to the PLO in 1988.

[Link]

The fact is that the Golan Heights, the West Bank, East Jerusalem and Gaza are internationally recognised as illegally occupied by Israel (even acknowldeged by the US) seems to have passed you by!


Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 6.59pm)

Edited by Palacetinian (13 Aug 2014 7.00pm)


A lefty twisting words. What a surprise. As Sterling said, the one eyed nature of your collective defence of the indefensible, Hamas, is incredible.

I said that Israel hadn't 'stolen' land from Palestinians. The West Bank and Golan heights were part of Jordan and Syria prior to 1967. I said that Israel was in non-compliance of a UN resolution with regards to the West Bank.

Furthermore, Israel claims that under UN resolution 242, it has a legitimate claim to the Golan heights. Remember Syria rejected the return of the Golan Heights in return for a peace treaty. Israel claims that under the terms of resolution 242, this means that retaining it provides security for the country from an attack by Syria.

Is the above true or Zionist propaganda?

Edited by matt_himself (13 Aug 2014 7.19pm)

Matt, get over yourself! I was giving you facts not defending Hames.

The only one trotting out Zionist propaganda is you!! Are you seriously suggesting Israel is not occupying Palestinian land? Really??


You said Israel 'stole' Palestinian land. I questionned use of he word 'stolen' because it is land that Israel obtained after wars with Syria and Jordan.

Occupation was not mentioned once.

And good to see you are dodging this by trying to insult me. Typical Lefty Mafia tactics when cornered.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Aug 14 7.36am

If ever you find the opinions of certain left wing posters makes you more nauseated than the shelling of children and other civilians then it really is time to sit down, have a nice cup of tea and try to remember exactly where and when it was you lost your decency and sanity.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


matt_himself Flag Matataland 14 Aug 14 10.09am

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Aug 2014 7.36am

If ever you find the opinions of certain left wing posters makes you more nauseated than the shelling of children and other civilians then it really is time to sit down, have a nice cup of tea and try to remember exactly where and when it was you lost your decency and sanity.


The self righteousness of Comrade Kermit is back.

What has the above got to do with the debate we were having on whether the land was 'stolen' from Palestinians or was acquired by Israel through wars with Jordan, Syria, etc? Where did I say that I was 'nauseated' more by lefty views than by the deaths of children?

It is just an attempt at cheap point scoring and part of your campaign to label me as worse a human than Hitler, Stalin and Pol Pot combined because I disagree and challenge your cut and paste 'ideology'.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Aug 14 10.29am

Quote Oliver at 14 Aug 2014 5.51am

According to the UN it's the IDF who use Palestinian children as human shields

Parts of the UN say that, others don't.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 14 Aug 14 10.30am

Quote Oliver at 14 Aug 2014 5.51am

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Aug 2014 6.40pm

Quote ghosteagle at 13 Aug 2014 6.29pm

They have. The claims that Hamas was forcibly using civilians as human shields has been completely debunked. It is the supporters of the Israeli occupation who are playing semantics.


So now it's about the word, 'forcibly'.......Blimey how is anyone going to know that?

How about this then, Hamas encourage civilians to use themselves as human shields.

Hence showing that Hamas are willing to use civilian deaths as a method of making Israeli attacks look worse.

You say Israel deliberately kill children all the time yet here is proof Hamas couldn't give a monkeys and for you.....nothing.....You are so one eyed.
All the lefties just willingly lap it up even more then.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Aug 2014 6.43pm)


According to the UN it's the IDF who use Palestinian children as human shields


Was that the UN collectively or just one person at the UN expressing a personal opinion?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Aug 14 10.39am


The land that Israel has won in battle isn't stolen......Justly acquired....no but was it stolen no.

The land that the UN gave to the Jews to create Israel in 47 was not based upon self determination and so was automatically unjust. Plus it was far too big, thirty percent of the population were given fifty five percent of the land ......Though even if it had been thirty percent the Arab countries would still have refused the concept, tried to destroy it, and probably would still have lost.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Aug 2014 11.03am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Hoof Hearted 14 Aug 14 12.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Aug 2014 7.36am

If ever you find the opinions of certain left wing posters makes you more nauseated than the shelling of children and other civilians then it really is time to sit down, have a nice cup of tea and try to remember exactly where and when it was you lost your decency and sanity.


Cheap shot Kermy.

Hamas and PFLP (Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine) have a chequered history of terrorism throughout the world, ie suicide bombings, hijacking airplanes, kidnapping etc.

They do not listen to reason and it is they that continually stoke the flames of this situation by firing their rockets and breaking any truce.

You cannot blame Israel for not wanting to lift the blockade which would mean Hamas getting their hands on bigger more accurate weapons.

The land the Palestinians are fighting over is basically a pile of rubble. They are staying there just to make a point.

I have sympathy for the Israelis because of the treatment of Jews by the Nazis throughout the 30's and WWII and their plucky nature to face down the aggression of the Arab states that surround them, they are the underdogs.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 14 Aug 14 9.28pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 14 Aug 2014 12.49pm

Quote Kermit8 at 14 Aug 2014 7.36am

If ever you find the opinions of certain left wing posters makes you more nauseated than the shelling of children and other civilians then it really is time to sit down, have a nice cup of tea and try to remember exactly where and when it was you lost your decency and sanity.


Cheap shot Kermy.

Hamas and PFLP (Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine) have a chequered history of terrorism throughout the world, ie suicide bombings, hijacking airplanes, kidnapping etc.

They do not listen to reason and it is they that continually stoke the flames of this situation by firing their rockets and breaking any truce.

You cannot blame Israel for not wanting to lift the blockade which would mean Hamas getting their hands on bigger more accurate weapons.

The land the Palestinians are fighting over is basically a pile of rubble. They are staying there just to make a point.

I have sympathy for the Israelis because of the treatment of Jews by the Nazis throughout the 30's and WWII and their plucky nature to face down the aggression of the Arab states that surround them, they are the underdogs.


Kermit has shown what he is about by making these comments. He has not come back today and defended himself proving that he is a lefty gasbag of dubious self righteous intention.

What a wimp. What a coward.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

glazedallover Flag Allier 14 Aug 14 10.02pm

Kermit is busy in the parishstein debate.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 14 Aug 14 10.08pm

Quote glazedallover at 14 Aug 2014 10.02pm

Kermit is busy in the parishstein debate.


So, he has never been to Israel and hasn't been to a Palace match for years, yet has opinions on both. No doubt, because he is right and knows everything about everything.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

glazedallover Flag Allier 14 Aug 14 10.09pm

Quote matt_himself at 14 Aug 2014 10.08pm

Quote glazedallover at 14 Aug 2014 10.02pm

Kermit is busy in the parishstein debate.


So, he has never been to Israel and hasn't been to a Palace match for years, yet has opinions on both. No doubt, because he is right and knows everything about everything.


f*** me, you could start a fight in an empty room.

 

Page 68 of 80 < 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71 72 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine