This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote beagle at 17 Apr 2013 5.46pm
I've been reading the reaction from some mining communities who, predictably, are delighted she's dead and say they can 'never forgive' her for decimating their industry. The inference is that until Thatch, they had a viable industry but she, for political reasons, tore it apart. What I don't understand is why, if the industry is at all viable, aren't any pits being reopened? Shale Gas and fracking has re-energised the oil industry - so why is coal dead? The fact that even under Labour these pits weren't reopened suggests to me that there was/is no future for a profitable national coal industry in the UK - so were the closures under Thatcher inevitable and she's a convenient scapegoat? I know sweet FA about the economics of coal - but would be interested in any thoughts.
Cheaper to import it from Poland etc. So we ship out sterling to another EU country whilst paying to keep entire generations of people and areas unemployed. Of course, we don't let the power companies pay tax as they wouldn't be contrbuting to "call me Dave", Gdieon and their fellow millionaires ... [Link] Edited by Dweeb (17 Apr 2013 5.51pm)
Taking the Sorry to see Lee Hills go, did we ever see Alex Marrow? We did January 2013 |
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
crowds pack into an Edinburgh square to watch the funeral.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
You couldn't move in Bradford...
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
In some places on the route, the crowds were as large as 1 deep!
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Whilst George peeled an onion.
|
|
|
Quote Dweeb at 17 Apr 2013 5.50pm
Quote beagle at 17 Apr 2013 5.46pm
I've been reading the reaction from some mining communities who, predictably, are delighted she's dead and say they can 'never forgive' her for decimating their industry. The inference is that until Thatch, they had a viable industry but she, for political reasons, tore it apart. What I don't understand is why, if the industry is at all viable, aren't any pits being reopened? Shale Gas and fracking has re-energised the oil industry - so why is coal dead? The fact that even under Labour these pits weren't reopened suggests to me that there was/is no future for a profitable national coal industry in the UK - so were the closures under Thatcher inevitable and she's a convenient scapegoat? I know sweet FA about the economics of coal - but would be interested in any thoughts.
Cheaper to import it from Poland etc. So we ship out sterling to another EU country whilst paying to keep entire generations of people and areas unemployed. Of course, we don't let the power companies pay tax as they wouldn't be contrbuting to "call me Dave", Gdieon and their fellow millionaires ... [Link]
Should we therefore still be subsidising a massive shipbuilding industry, and steel industry? And a textile industry while we're at it? We may as well reopen, and subside tin mines in Cornwall. And if so, why discriminate? My own industry, print, has gone south. I know shed-loads of printers who have gone bust - but there has never been a 'help the printers' campaign. So why do miners get the violins and flowers? Its difficult to get an definative answer because when the debate involves just economics the answer is easy. Throw politics into the mix and it all turns muddy. My 'help the printers' point is easy. Simple economics. Rather like Estate Agents when the housing bubble went south. Who cares about a bloody estate agent? Who cares about a printer? However, throw 'mining' into the mix and suddenly we're in socialist heartland, brass-bands, communities, salt-of-the-earth, Hovis and Billy Elliot territory. And although I'm no Thatcher fan, I just don't understand the 'she decimated our industry' line. If not her, a subsequent Government (lib, lab or Con) would have gently (or not so gently) got us to where the industry is now.
When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep. |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.