You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 7 of 80 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Stirlingsays Flag 21 Nov 12 11.44am

Quote Oliver at 21 Nov 2012 11.36am

My HOL has gone a bit mental


That's not something you hear every day.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 21 Nov 12 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 21 Nov 12 11.53am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?

It was a moronic decision. The Jews should have been given a piece of land in a less controversial location.

But a compilation of Roman-era desert rantings said that Israel was promised to the Jews. So that is naturally what was decided

 

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 21 Nov 12 12.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

Oh come on. Today's Palestinians are descended from the original inhabitants of the Holy Land just as much as the Israelites. Both have a valid claim. And it's worth noting that a large portion of the "returned" Jews are ethnically European, being descended from Jewish converts, rather than from Israels early inhabitants.

 

jcreedy Flag 21 Nov 12 12.01pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Nov 2012 10.49am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


Wow.

What did you do during history or RE at school?

I didn't do history at school. I can have a mean discussion about tectonic plates if you fancy one though.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 21 Nov 12 12.02pm

I'm told there was even a Jewish kamikaze pilot.

He crashed his plane into his uncle's scrap metal yard.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 21 Nov 12 12.03pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Nov 2012 11.53am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?



It was a moronic decision
. The Jews should have been given a piece of land in a less controversial location.

But a compilation of Roman-era desert rantings said that Israel was promised to the Jews. So that is naturally what was decided

OK, that was a bit harsh. Given the pressure applied through terrorism and other means, it is understandable that a British government which just came out of an incredibly brutal conflict, would take that decision.

 

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 21 Nov 12 12.20pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Nov 2012 12.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

Oh come on. Today's Palestinians are descended from the original inhabitants of the Holy Land just as much as the Israelites. Both have a valid claim. And it's worth noting that a large portion of the "returned" Jews are ethnically European, being descended from Jewish converts, rather than from Israels early inhabitants.


Its always easier to maintain that Palestinians/Muslims are descended from the original inhabitants because there are far great numbers of them throughout the ME. But if we look at the basic premise that Judaism predates Islam by a considerable time, then there is no dispute to be had. Jews suffered various pogroms and massacres (ie. Roman, Crusader)throughout their time in Palestine. The is readily accessible information.
That is not to denigrate the fact that Muslims at various times have constituted the majority, but one should not consider the Jews as usurpers. Nb. European Jewry are themselves descended from exiled tribes of Israel.

 

Hoof Hearted 21 Nov 12 12.23pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 21 Nov 2012 12.02pm

I'm told there was even a Jewish kamikaze pilot.

He crashed his plane into his uncle's scrap metal yard.

Genius.

I hope that you are aroused by my praise!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Nov 12 12.35pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 12.20pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Nov 2012 12.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

Oh come on. Today's Palestinians are descended from the original inhabitants of the Holy Land just as much as the Israelites. Both have a valid claim. And it's worth noting that a large portion of the "returned" Jews are ethnically European, being descended from Jewish converts, rather than from Israels early inhabitants.


Its always easier to maintain that Palestinians/Muslims are descended from the original inhabitants because there are far great numbers of them throughout the ME. But if we look at the basic premise that Judaism predates Islam by a considerable time, then there is no dispute to be had. Jews suffered various pogroms and massacres (ie. Roman, Crusader)throughout their time in Palestine. The is readily accessible information.
That is not to denigrate the fact that Muslims at various times have constituted the majority, but one should not consider the Jews as usurpers. Nb. European Jewry are themselves descended from exiled tribes of Israel.

Technically both Islam and Judaism are offshoots of the same religeon - both being Abrahamic faiths. Also the authenticity of the country of Israel, as a historical representative of ancient Israel is far from clear.

Palestine takes its name from a pagan donkey headed diety worshiped in the area in very ancient times, putting it on a par with Judea in terms of historical authenticity.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Nov 12 12.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Nov 2012 12.35pm

Technically both Islam and Judaism are offshoots of the same religeon - both being Abrahamic faiths. Also the authenticity of the country of Israel, as a historical representative of ancient Israel is far from clear.

Palestine takes its name from a pagan donkey headed diety worshiped in the area in very ancient times, putting it on a par with Judea in terms of historical authenticity.


While I often enjoy your posts Jamie, you have confused me. How does Judaism get to be an offshoot of itself?


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

the_mcanuff_stuff Flag Caterham 21 Nov 12 12.54pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 12.20pm

Its always easier to maintain that Palestinians/Muslims are descended from the original inhabitants because there are far great numbers of them throughout the ME. But if we look at the basic premise that Judaism predates Islam by a considerable time, then there is no dispute to be had.

OK, fine. But that is saying that because their ancestors were Jews and they are no longer, this invalidates their claim? They are ethnically the same and have lived there continuously, no matter what religion they now practice.

Quote
Jews suffered various pogroms and massacres (ie. Roman, Crusader)throughout their time in Palestine. The is readily accessible information.

No question. You won't find me disagreeing. Though I don't see the connection to the debate.

Quote
That is not to denigrate the fact that Muslims at various times have constituted the majority, but one should not consider the Jews as usurpers.

Again, these Muslims are not new arrivals, they simply changed their religion at some stage. As a people, they have lived there continuously since day one.

The Arab and Turkish rules didn't much mix with and change the ethnic makeup of the people, it just converted them.

I don't consider the Jews as usurpers. But they have no greater historical claim to Israel than the Palestinians.

Quote
Nb. European Jewry are themselves descended from exiled tribes of Israel.

Not exclusively. As I mentioned, there were converts. But yes, European Jews are in the main descended from these tribes.

Both returned Jews and Palestinians have a claim to the Holy Land dating back to it's origins. The difference is that while Palestinians have lived there continuously, the Jews are relatively recently returned. I'm not saying that invalidates the Jewish claim to Israel. I'm just saying their claim is by no means the more valid.

I can understand that to a Palestinian, a tribe returning en masse after some 1300 years absence and claiming the region in it's entirety, might be seen as usurpation.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 21 Nov 12 4.34pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 21 Nov 2012 12.41pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Nov 2012 12.35pm

Technically both Islam and Judaism are offshoots of the same religeon - both being Abrahamic faiths. Also the authenticity of the country of Israel, as a historical representative of ancient Israel is far from clear.

Palestine takes its name from a pagan donkey headed diety worshiped in the area in very ancient times, putting it on a par with Judea in terms of historical authenticity.


While I often enjoy your posts Jamie, you have confused me. How does Judaism get to be an offshoot of itself?


Cause I said so....

But yeah, essentially Islam and Judaism share a common religeous ancestor (as does Christianity and do the fire worshipping Zoroastrans). Its all blurred, because both claim to be the original faith. However they were almost certainly preceeded by more patheonistic faiths, which many of the nations and people of the area take their names from.

Of note is the donkey headed diety Pale.

Genetically, the palestianians are likely to be dececendents of Jewish and Christians, who themselves were decendents of other groups, and the genetic lineage of the area dates back to pre-history (its a very long settled area).

So realistically, its more accurate to claim that both Islam and Judaism share a common ancestorial religeon from which they stem, rather than saying either really occured first.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 21 Nov 12 6.19pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.


I see nothing revisionist in that post - an accurate description of what happened at the time and accepted since. Not referencing your point about earlier claims on the territory is a separate issue.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Nov 12 7.10pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 21 Nov 2012 4.34pm

Cause I said so....

But yeah, essentially Islam and Judaism share a common religeous ancestor (as does Christianity and do the fire worshipping Zoroastrans). Its all blurred, because both claim to be the original faith. However they were almost certainly preceeded by more patheonistic faiths, which many of the nations and people of the area take their names from.

Of note is the donkey headed diety Pale.

Genetically, the palestianians are likely to be dececendents of Jewish and Christians, who themselves were decendents of other groups, and the genetic lineage of the area dates back to pre-history (its a very long settled area).

So realistically, its more accurate to claim that both Islam and Judaism share a common ancestorial religeon from which they stem, rather than saying either really occured first.


Ah our old chum the donkey headed diety Pale......Them were the days....You always knew where you were with a donkey hybrid....Them were the days.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 21 Nov 12 7.29pm

ee aw ee aw ee aw to know better...

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 21 Nov 12 7.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Nov 2012 7.29pm

ee aw ee aw ee aw to know better...


 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 21 Nov 12 7.37pm

Quote nickgusset at 21 Nov 2012 7.29pm

ee aw ee aw ee aw to know better...


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 21 Nov 12 10.35pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 12.20pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Nov 2012 12.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

Oh come on. Today's Palestinians are descended from the original inhabitants of the Holy Land just as much as the Israelites. Both have a valid claim. And it's worth noting that a large portion of the "returned" Jews are ethnically European, being descended from Jewish converts, rather than from Israels early inhabitants.


Its always easier to maintain that Palestinians/Muslims are descended from the original inhabitants because there are far great numbers of them throughout the ME. But if we look at the basic premise that Judaism predates Islam by a considerable time, then there is no dispute to be had. Jews suffered various pogroms and massacres (ie. Roman, Crusader)throughout their time in Palestine. The is readily accessible information.
That is not to denigrate the fact that Muslims at various times have constituted the majority, but one should not consider the Jews as usurpers. Nb. European Jewry are themselves descended from exiled tribes of Israel.


Although while the PLO, Syria, and Egypt have accepted a two state solution Israel and the USA continue their racist policy of denying the indigenous population self-determination.

Edited by Bert the Head (21 Nov 2012 10.50pm)

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 21 Nov 12 11.37pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 12.20pm

Quote the_mcanuff_stuff at 21 Nov 2012 12.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.

Oh come on. Today's Palestinians are descended from the original inhabitants of the Holy Land just as much as the Israelites. Both have a valid claim. And it's worth noting that a large portion of the "returned" Jews are ethnically European, being descended from Jewish converts, rather than from Israels early inhabitants.


Its always easier to maintain that Palestinians/Muslims are descended from the original inhabitants because there are far great numbers of them throughout the ME. But if we look at the basic premise that Judaism predates Islam by a considerable time, then there is no dispute to be had. Jews suffered various pogroms and massacres (ie. Roman, Crusader)throughout their time in Palestine. The is readily accessible information.
That is not to denigrate the fact that Muslims at various times have constituted the majority, but one should not consider the Jews as usurpers. Nb. European Jewry are themselves descended from exiled tribes of Israel.


There is a problem for athiests with the basic premise that an ancient book that has been shown to be untrust-worthy at best should decide a land dispute.

 

Page 7 of 80 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine