You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer


Page 7 of 17 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
crystal-purley Flag Purley 26 Jan 14 1.42pm

Quote braunstoneagle at 26 Jan 2014 11.34am

Quote gazzaaa at 26 Jan 2014 11.26am

Quote homes at 26 Jan 2014 11.04am

Quote gazzaaa at 26 Jan 2014 10.48am

I would have thought TP will walk if he doesnt get the players he has asked for.

Why employ a top manager, promise him funds and then dont deliver your promise. TP told SP that players were wanted at the beginning of the window, here we are in the last week of the window and not 1 player has crossed the line. What exactly is Ian Moody doing? He was brought in as the messiah for transfers as SP f***ed up so badly in the summer. Waste of money so far.

Those that think this squad of players can stay up are deluded, we are the lowest scorers in the league, please tell me where goals are going to come from?

Got to slacken the purse strings to stay up.

TP stated that it was hard to get players to go to Stoke, seems the same can be said for CP.


We will know if sp f***ed up during the summer at the end of the season. Admittedly a few mistakes were made but under the circumstances i personally feel that they are acceptable.


Marange
Dobbie
Phillips
Gayle
Jerome
Campana
Hunt

Theres 7 mistakes, players not good enough for the prem at present.

Please dont say some of these are for the future, its NOW we need players.

Wouldnt be acceptable if it was my money that was being spent.


i dont think gayle or campana were mistakes...

gayle has had 1/4 of the starts chamakh has and scored 1 goal less...i honestly think if gayle had started every game like chamakh has he would be on 8 goals by now.

campana has been underused...has looked like a very clever player with a great pass but hasnt seen the light of day since fulham!

ward...obviously injured, and im intrigued to see how he works out.

Hunt although a well rated defender is all of 5'9", we needed a decent cb.
Phillips although a class act was never going to get as much out of pl defences as he did in the championship.
Marange signed and the IH decided he was too slow, this worried me at the time but now with other stories/rumours surfacing one wonders more.
Gayle is one for the future but is doing adecent enough job as an impact sub.
Dobbie yet another (pl) squad player rather than a first teamer.
Campana looks very good but at the same time as signing him we also signed Guediora and Bannan while already having Garvan
Jerome does a decent enough job tiring out the defences but using the usually accepted definitions is not really a striker.
So a generous 1.5 out of seven rather than the 0.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

geoff Flag Midhurst 26 Jan 14 1.44pm

My argument would be that i presume that when TP was recruited part of him agreeing was that he would know the transfer budget for January and have a thorough understanding of the wage structure. There is rumour that he wanted crouch but was vetoed because of his age and no sell on value. TP is responsible for getting results to keep us up and in my opinion as long as he sticks within the budget and wage structure he should be allowed to bring in whoever he likes in an attempt to meet his objectives which would have been set to him by the board.
If he meets his objectives or fails in them it has to be done to him as long as he sticks to the parameters set. Lets say he wants to buy striker A who we can afford and fits the wage structure for this season and next season if we are relegated. There are a few discussions and TP is then told yeah he fits the structure we told you but he doesn't have a resale value so you can't have him. Thats wrong.
Its also rumoured that TP knew nothing of a bod for Ramis. How can that be!!!! He runs the football side of the business within set parameters let him do it or lets see SP and Moody in the dugout.

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 26 Jan 14 1.51pm

Quote bubble wrap at 26 Jan 2014 1.10pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 26 Jan 2014 1.03pm

Quote sidman at 26 Jan 2014 12.48pm

Who knows if the story is true or not, but you do have to think is this why Dougie Freedman went?

You do have question why Parish went on holiday in the transfer window?


It was Steve Browett who went to Barbados a few weeks ago.


Steve Browett went to Hong Kong and around that region, Parish went to Barbados for 10 days

tbh I am no big fan of SP but the summer transfer window is between the last game of one season and the first of the next, so when exactly would he/they go on their hols?


 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

geoff Flag Midhurst 26 Jan 14 1.58pm

I have a feeling that Tuesday against Hull will be a massive game for lots of reasons. Our transfer activity will either be justified or slated. Win and people will be happy hoping we will get a couple in before the window ends. Draw at home and it will be points dropped especially if we miss some good chances or show little quality. Lose and and especially if one of their new signings scores and that relationship with SP/TP will be under scrutiny as will the lack of transfer activity.
So far signing nobody has not cost us any points. If we are honest we didn't expect to get anything from Spurs and we won against Stoke. Tuesday will be a big test.
I hope our lack of dealings does not cost us vital points.
SB says on the BBS that obviously some of the money from the PL will go on Stadium development. If we are not in the PL whats the point. 12,000 gates. Then they should only spend money on what absolutely needs doing and forget all the luxury stuff.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Jan 14 2.07pm

Quote geoff at 26 Jan 2014 1.58pm

I have a feeling that Tuesday against Hull will be a massive game for lots of reasons. Our transfer activity will either be justified or slated. Win and people will be happy hoping we will get a couple in before the window ends. Draw at home and it will be points dropped especially if we miss some good chances or show little quality. Lose and and especially if one of their new signings scores and that relationship with SP/TP will be under scrutiny as will the lack of transfer activity.
So far signing nobody has not cost us any points. If we are honest we didn't expect to get anything from Spurs and we won against Stoke. Tuesday will be a big test.
I hope our lack of dealings does not cost us vital points.
SB says on the BBS that obviously some of the money from the PL will go on Stadium development. If we are not in the PL whats the point. 12,000 gates. Then they should only spend money on what absolutely needs doing and forget all the luxury stuff.


Quite likely scenarios. On the ground. The main stand was built in 1924 and is 90 years old. I don't know when people would prefer it done, but it needs doing, and it costs money.

 


COYP

Sg Bilko Flag Deurne Holland 26 Jan 14 2.14pm

Quote bubble wrap at 26 Jan 2014 1.10pm

Quote Rudi Hedman at 26 Jan 2014 1.03pm

Quote sidman at 26 Jan 2014 12.48pm

Who knows if the story is true or not, but you do have to think is this why Dougie Freedman went?

You do have question why Parish went on holiday in the transfer window?


It was Steve Browett who went to Barbados a few weeks ago.


Steve Browett went to Hong Kong and around that region, Parish went to Barbados for 10 days

That story went out on the 13th Jan, yet on the 18th either he or a cardboard cutout was sitting in the stand talking to Ian Moody, so who do you believe, your own eyes, or the Daily Mirror.

 

cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 14 2.20pm

Quote geoff at 26 Jan 2014 1.58pm

I have a feeling that Tuesday against Hull will be a massive game for lots of reasons. Our transfer activity will either be justified or slated. Win and people will be happy hoping we will get a couple in before the window ends. Draw at home and it will be points dropped especially if we miss some good chances or show little quality. Lose and and especially if one of their new signings scores and that relationship with SP/TP will be under scrutiny as will the lack of transfer activity.
So far signing nobody has not cost us any points. If we are honest we didn't expect to get anything from Spurs and we won against Stoke. Tuesday will be a big test.
I hope our lack of dealings does not cost us vital points.
SB says on the BBS that obviously some of the money from the PL will go on Stadium development. If we are not in the PL whats the point. 12,000 gates. Then they should only spend money on what absolutely needs doing and forget all the luxury stuff.


True, but actually signing players might gain our rivals extra points that they wouldn't have otherwise got.

I don't know where I stand on this - we need some extra quality - especially up front, central defence and possibly left-back - but the former depends on the likelihood of Murray getting fit. I agree with SP that we should be getting in younger players from the lower leagues who would have a resale value (eg Rhodes, Ince) rather than PL journeymen at the tail-end of their careers who will mess up our wage structure (eg Crouch). However, if those journeymen could make the difference between us staying up and going down then it would be worth it. Tricky.

 

homes Flag New Eltham 26 Jan 14 2.23pm

Quote geoff at 26 Jan 2014 1.58pm

I have a feeling that Tuesday against Hull will be a massive game for lots of reasons. Our transfer activity will either be justified or slated. Win and people will be happy hoping we will get a couple in before the window ends. Draw at home and it will be points dropped especially if we miss some good chances or show little quality. Lose and and especially if one of their new signings scores and that relationship with SP/TP will be under scrutiny as will the lack of transfer activity.
So far signing nobody has not cost us any points. If we are honest we didn't expect to get anything from Spurs and we won against Stoke. Tuesday will be a big test.
I hope our lack of dealings does not cost us vital points.
SB says on the BBS that obviously some of the money from the PL will go on Stadium development. If we are not in the PL whats the point. 12,000 gates. Then they should only spend money on what absolutely needs doing and forget all the luxury stuff.

Given our league position now wouldn't you say our summer transfer
policy is working

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

sydtheeagle Flag England 26 Jan 14 2.26pm

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Don’t get me wrong I am a massive Parish fan and think he has done more for our club than anyone in decades

He's done no more and no less than at least half a dozen others. Ron Noades. Jim Cannon. Steve Coppell...shall I go on?

These days, it's fashionable for people to pretend that Parish is the second coming and Simon Jordan is evil incarnate, even though I suspect that 12 months into his tenure, the Jordan loyalists then are mainly the same people who are the Parish loyalists now. Those types of people inclined to ask no questions rarely change; the owner may be new but the sheep remain the same.

I see surprisingly little difference between Jordan and Parish with the main exception being their attitudes towards money (which, admittedly, is a big thing). Jordan spent wildly, Parish spends reluctantly but other than that? Both of them have huge egos. Both of them are ostentatious. Both of them think they know how to run a business they clearly don't know how to run. Both of them think they know more than the football people they've hired. Both of them can't get out of their own way or the manager's way when it comes to renouncing a degree of control. And both of them will sink the Premiership ship before not getting their own way. Both have a bad case of "my way or the highway". Jordan lost a vastly experienced football expert in Coppell...now Parish is trying hard to emulate him in his deteriorating relationship with TP.

New year. Different kind of idiot at the helm. Same old Palace. If we go down, it will be the usual case of squandering an opportunity by shooting ourselves in the foot. The fact that the best the pro-Parish brigade seem to be able to do in defending him is to call their opponents names and otherwise insulting them speaks volumes about the lack of quality of their arguments.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

cpj Flag Kent 26 Jan 14 2.31pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Jan 2014 2.26pm

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Don’t get me wrong I am a massive Parish fan and think he has done more for our club than anyone in decades

He's done no more and no less than at least half a dozen others. Ron Noades. Jim Cannon. Steve Coppell...shall I go on?

These days, it's fashionable for people to pretend that Parish is the second coming and Simon Jordan is evil incarnate, even though I suspect that 12 months into his tenure, the Jordan loyalists then are mainly the same people who are the Parish loyalists now. Those types of people inclined to ask no questions rarely change; the owner may be new but the sheep remain the same.

I see surprisingly little difference between Jordan and Parish with the main exception being their attitudes towards money (which, admittedly, is a big thing). Jordan spent wildly, Parish spends reluctantly but other than that? Both of them have huge egos. Both of them are ostentatious. Both of them think they know how to run a business they clearly don't know how to run. Both of them think they know more than the football people they've hired. Both of them can't get out of their own way or the manager's way when it comes to renouncing a degree of control. And both of them will sink the Premiership ship before not getting their own way. Both have a bad case of "my way or the highway". Jordan lost a vastly experienced football expert in Coppell...now Parish is trying hard to emulate him in his deteriorating relationship with TP.

New year. Different kind of idiot at the helm. Same old Palace. If we go down, it will be the usual case of squandering an opportunity by shooting ourselves in the foot. The fact that the best the pro-Parish brigade seem to be able to do in defending him is to call their opponents names and otherwise insulting them speaks volumes about the lack of quality of their arguments.

Good post. The best chairmen seem to be the ones you never hear or see.

 

Jordan555x Flag Bromley 26 Jan 14 2.36pm

How would they even know this?! Pulis is never going to tell anybody especially a journalist about this. I doubt even SLP would know until the very last minute. No manager would tell a newspaper like Daily Mirror about something as confidential as this.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 2.38pm

Quote cpj at 26 Jan 2014 2.31pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Jan 2014 2.26pm

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Don’t get me wrong I am a massive Parish fan and think he has done more for our club than anyone in decades

He's done no more and no less than at least half a dozen others. Ron Noades. Jim Cannon. Steve Coppell...shall I go on?

These days, it's fashionable for people to pretend that Parish is the second coming and Simon Jordan is evil incarnate, even though I suspect that 12 months into his tenure, the Jordan loyalists then are mainly the same people who are the Parish loyalists now. Those types of people inclined to ask no questions rarely change; the owner may be new but the sheep remain the same.

I see surprisingly little difference between Jordan and Parish with the main exception being their attitudes towards money (which, admittedly, is a big thing). Jordan spent wildly, Parish spends reluctantly but other than that? Both of them have huge egos. Both of them are ostentatious. Both of them think they know how to run a business they clearly don't know how to run. Both of them think they know more than the football people they've hired. Both of them can't get out of their own way or the manager's way when it comes to renouncing a degree of control. And both of them will sink the Premiership ship before not getting their own way. Both have a bad case of "my way or the highway". Jordan lost a vastly experienced football expert in Coppell...now Parish is trying hard to emulate him in his deteriorating relationship with TP.

New year. Different kind of idiot at the helm. Same old Palace. If we go down, it will be the usual case of squandering an opportunity by shooting ourselves in the foot. The fact that the best the pro-Parish brigade seem to be able to do in defending him is to call their opponents names and otherwise insulting them speaks volumes about the lack of quality of their arguments.

Good post. The best chairmen seem to be the ones you never hear or see.

And as I have mentioned many times - I doubt whether anyone actually knows who the chairman of Arsenal is

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Jan 14 2.40pm

Quote crystal-purley at 26 Jan 2014 1.51pm


Steve Browett went to Hong Kong and around that region, Parish went to Barbados for 10 days

tbh I am no big fan of SP but the summer transfer window is between the last game of one season and the first of the next, so when exactly would he/they go on their hols?


During the season when the football is being looked after by the football experts or is Steve Parish now involved in the training too

 

Green Bin Flag Carshalton Beeches 26 Jan 14 2.44pm

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Don’t get me wrong I am a massive Parish fan and think he has done more for our club than anyone in decades but I believe his role at the club needs addressing before we lose our 3rd manager in quick succession.

Parish has no real knowledge of football, he is NOT a football man yet professes to know everything about the game.
He is trying to run the club including the team. He needs to quit micro managing. Isn’t it his role to provide a budget for his manager then leave the buying and selling of players to the management team?

Why did Freedman leave? I believe he had big issues with Parish so wanted out. Parish later admitted in hindsight he could and should of done more to keep Freedman at Palace.
Why did Holloway leave? I believe Holloway found Parish too draining with his constant helicopter (hovering over him) micro managing of everything Holloway did.

1) Parish is a Palace fan...so based on all the 'wisdom' I see on the various forums he must know an awful lot about football

2) Parish is a business man, so he is trying to run a tight ship and invest prudently

3) Managers come and go, DF got a better offer from Bolton, I am not sure what the big issues were with SP, you might know better...but it's interesting that after our poor start last year there were fans saying that Parish needed to be talking to DF to sort the team out....mind you they were probably fans who knew more about football than Parish

4) I don't think IH had a problem with SP, after all he was allowed to bring some of his footballing mates in, and was provided with a big squad. I think IH was actually stressed out by the prospect of keeping Palace up, whilst not acting like the clown he did when previously with Blackpool (i.e. he wanted to be taken seriously), in addition he probably needed more time to craft the football team in the style he wanted, that he didn't get as he pretty much had to achieve promotion with the team he inherited. And lets be fair given the hysteria and panic that surrounds the transfer window and the 24/7 effort to get names across the line, that would be enough to do anyone in

5) If you remember from the Vincent Tan/Malky Mackay punch up over transfers, commentators made the point that the owners would always in the end sign off the deals. Given that SP is acting for 4owners it's hardly surprising he would have a fair bit of involvement, after all in many clubs the manager has littled involvement in signing players

6) I have never seen a comment from SP saying he knew everything about the game, if anything it's been the opposite. In the end someone has to lead, and things look very different in retrospect than in the fevered atmosphere of the time. As anyone can point out even the greatest football manager of our time made some pretty poor transfer decisions, so it would hardly be surprising if SP did


Edited by Green Bin (26 Jan 2014 2.46pm)

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 26 Jan 14 2.54pm

Quote Green Bin at 26 Jan 2014 2.44pm

2) Parish is a business man, so he is trying to run a tight ship and invest prudently

Edited by Green Bin (26 Jan 2014 2.46pm)

Aaah, so this fact wins your trust and confidence?

Oh dear. Simon Jordan was a businessman. Mark Goldberg was a businessman...

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

BangholeLee Flag West Wickham 26 Jan 14 2.58pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Jan 2014 2.26pm

Quote movingforward at 26 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Don’t get me wrong I am a massive Parish fan and think he has done more for our club than anyone in decades

He's done no more and no less than at least half a dozen others. Ron Noades. Jim Cannon. Steve Coppell...shall I go on?

These days, it's fashionable for people to pretend that Parish is the second coming and Simon Jordan is evil incarnate, even though I suspect that 12 months into his tenure, the Jordan loyalists then are mainly the same people who are the Parish loyalists now. Those types of people inclined to ask no questions rarely change; the owner may be new but the sheep remain the same.

I see surprisingly little difference between Jordan and Parish with the main exception being their attitudes towards money (which, admittedly, is a big thing). Jordan spent wildly, Parish spends reluctantly but other than that? Both of them have huge egos. Both of them are ostentatious. Both of them think they know how to run a business they clearly don't know how to run. Both of them think they know more than the football people they've hired. Both of them can't get out of their own way or the manager's way when it comes to renouncing a degree of control. And both of them will sink the Premiership ship before not getting their own way. Both have a bad case of "my way or the highway". Jordan lost a vastly experienced football expert in Coppell...now Parish is trying hard to emulate him in his deteriorating relationship with TP.

New year. Different kind of idiot at the helm. Same old Palace. If we go down, it will be the usual case of squandering an opportunity by shooting ourselves in the foot. The fact that the best the pro-Parish brigade seem to be able to do in defending him is to call their opponents names and otherwise insulting them speaks volumes about the lack of quality of their arguments.

Jordan spent wildly?
On what, certainly not players, do you mean Hotel bills, a s*** west end play & film, setting up his own magazine, Spanish property, or maybe the yacht.
Jordan took more out of Palace, than he ever put.

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 26 Jan 14 2.58pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 25 Jan 2014 10.48pm

[Link]


Although the rumour comes from The Mirror, there is often a degree of truth to them.

Since when has the Mirror been truthful and reliable as a news media ? However, I must say I do hope Parish is not among the many bodies who now appear to be directing Palace one way or another!. However again,if Parish did torpedo the signing of Crouch and Ellerington from Stoke I would heartily support Parish in that regard!.
While this may sound as if I want my cake and eat it ,surely Parish explained in depth to Pulis what he envisioned in the transfer market or at least gave him some guide lines in which to function. While I still am very skeptical of The report in The Mirror, I do believe there are some questions to be answered as to why we are frozen out of the transfer market. May be we are just too inflexible in our approach to signing players, who knows?.

 

blind eagle Flag Covington.Tennessee 26 Jan 14 3.00pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 25 Jan 2014 10.48pm

[Link]


Although the rumour comes from The Mirror, there is often a degree of truth to them.


 

The Sash Flag Now residing in Epsom - How Posh 26 Jan 14 3.02pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 26 Jan 2014 2.54pm

Quote Green Bin at 26 Jan 2014 2.44pm

2) Parish is a business man, so he is trying to run a tight ship and invest prudently

Edited by Green Bin (26 Jan 2014 2.46pm)

Aaah, so this fact wins your trust and confidence?

Oh dear. Simon Jordan was a businessman. Mark Goldberg was a businessman...

Indeed being a 'business man' also involves knowing when to take opportunities even if that involves a certain amount of risk


 


As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014

sydtheeagle Flag England 26 Jan 14 3.03pm

Quote BangholeLee at 26 Jan 2014 2.58pm

Jordan spent wildly?
On what, certainly not players, do you mean Hotel bills, a s*** west end play & film, setting up his own magazine, Spanish property, or maybe the yacht.
Jordan took more out of Palace, than he ever put.

This says it all about how little some people understand about running a business; the assumption that wild spending can only be related to player expenditure. Jordan didn't blow a 50 million pound + fortune by investing it; shrewdly it doesn't matter what he blew his money on; it matters than he blew it.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Page 7 of 17 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rumour: Pulis To Quit In The Summer