Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 May 2015 2.25pm
Quote dannyh at 05 May 2015 1.59pm
Quote npn at 05 May 2015 1.46pm
I'm not voting UKIP.
I am amazed, however, that a lot of people I know (particularly left-leaning ones, to be fair) seem totally disgusted by them. I had to step into one of those pointless Facebook battles when someone posted that UKIP and their supporters are a disgrace. It seems everyone is in favour of free speech, provided the person speaking agrees with their views.
If you don't like UKIP, don't vote for them. Pretty simple. Shouting them down and referring to them as a disgrace, and even trying to associate them with the BNP because of some spurious, vague, and not even verified, assertion that Griffin will be voting for them (he's a far-right person, natural he's going to vote for the furthest right candidate, surely? Just like Mao would probably vote TUSC because they are the closest aligned to his own ideal, not because those ideals are the same) is surely a very poor effort at debate.
Yes but why let facts and common sense rule, when you can claim anyone who even knows how to spell Farage is a foaming at the mouth jack boot wearing Nazi.
As far as I can see:
he wants out of Europe ( no bad thing ) Tighter controls on immigration (something both Labour and Tory Governments have promised much on but have delivered little). Wants more money spent on the Armed Forces not less( no brainer for those that know) Wants to improve by the NHS by putting a stop to NHS tourism.
Have I missed the bit where he wants burning crosses at the end of every street where Johnny Foreigner lives.
Some people on here are so up them selves they can literally lick their own tonsils.
Edited by dannyh (05 May 2015 2.00pm)
This perception interests me, as its not actually entirely accurate. Both the Conservatives and previous Labour governments pursued and implemented policy restrictions on immigration and citizenship that were tough, and arguably very close to restrictive.
The problem is really with temporary EU migrant workers - and really only after the economic downturn (prior to that no one really cared that the woman making sandwiches in the canteen had Masters and was from Poland).
The issue, is of course that a large part of the UK economy is entirely dependent on a) foreign investment b) a cheap EU labour force.
UKIP can promise to end all that, because they don't have to ever do it. If Labour or the Conservatives make the same promise and win, then they actually have to shoot the UK economy in the head, over an issue that's really more 'ideological' due to the current economic situation, than anything else.
Taking the migrant labour out of the question means jobs either go abroad, or the wages rise, which means costs rise, which results people being worse off, overall, and the government getting the blame.
And then if growth does recover to a pre-2010 level, they'd need to rediscover that labour.
If your UKIP (or the Greens) you can promise to do all manner of things that are economic suicide, but are popular, because you'll never get called on it.
Unless of course you're the Lib Dems, who promised all kinds of things at the last election, and then got crucified by their own supporters for compromising them to form a coalition government (and now are likely to take more of a battering than a member of the Barrymore swim club).
Apologies: a rant, fuelled entirely by the utter fallacy of your argument.
Yes, no-one cared about the woman making sandwiches in the canteen, because she was just one of (on average) 30,000 extra people joining the UK workforce each year. Today that figure is 10 times higher
"Oh, but we need all 300,000* of those workers, to keep the economy growing". Go take a look at the history economic growth figures of the UK economy:
[Link]
Pay particular attention to pre-1995. Averages out at about +3% change in GDP. Now. What were the net migration figures for that time?
[Link]
Never more than 50,000 per year.
So why do we need 300,000 net migration annually? And why, if it is so bloody amazing, is growth only 0.4% (average) of GDP now?
[Link]
Ah, you say... "the crash". Right. Why then was it no better than a declining 4.0% (1997) to 2.0% (2007) despite the floodgates being open?
We are living in a huge cheap-labour bubble facilitated by the Tories and Labour, it's compressing wages, ghettoising regions of the UK, and causing serious strains on services like the NHS. Let's see what happens when that bubble pops, or fundamental infrastructure collapses. Whichever first.
If you are going to frame the immigration debate in terms of economics, please actually demonstrate where the UK has benefited from migration of this scale. Claiming that migrants "provide a net economic benefit" (tax credits not included in this statement...) should be supported by clear evidence that the economy is much stronger despite having to scale infrastructure fast enough to cope with the influx. From a sociological perspective, do we place our quality of life (population density, access to services) above this very borderline benefit, and at what cost to the harmony and cohesion of culture and community?
So, racist, bigoted, xenophobic, homophobic, swivel-eyed fruitcake little me will be voting for the one party that commits to doing anything about it: UKIP. Not to stop A getting in, or to let B get in, but because I am voting based on how their policies match my views.
*NB - this is net number of National Insurance registrations annually. This does not therefore include children, non-working spouses, grandparents coming to live alongside. All of these contribute to the pressure of public services, yet are completely unaccounted for. 300,000 net + dependents + illegal immigrants. How many are really flowing in? We have absolutely no idea. Shocking.
|