You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
TheJudge Flag 15 Jun 15 12.07pm

Quote Superfly at 15 Jun 2015 11.57am

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 9.58pm


I'd repeat the question to him if he has his brain cell switched on at the moment.


Judge

Please debate your point without insults.


This thread is littered with examples, I've only highlighted one.

It's just banter dude. I am capable of deadly serious debate if you would prefer. I can debate the absurdity of religion all day.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 15 Jun 15 12.39pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Jun 2015 11.46am

Quote reborn at 14 Jun 2015 9.12pm

You sound like you need a hug....go to the local church, they will be nice to you I promise.


There would be plenty of room inside.

The thing is Reborn, I don't need a hug from your God bothering friends or "Jesus", because I have a real family who I can hug any time I like. It is only your deluded, stupid, smug, blind arrogance that makes you think that people should all seek a religious crutch like the one you clearly need. Your whole basis of belief is flawed and made up by people who didn't know any better.
I'm being mean to you because your smug attitude really is quite repugnant.

Chill out mate, he was only joking.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

reborn 15 Jun 15 12.41pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Jun 2015 11.46am

Quote reborn at 14 Jun 2015 9.12pm

You sound like you need a hug....go to the local church, they will be nice to you I promise.


There would be plenty of room inside.

The thing is Reborn, I don't need a hug from your God bothering friends or "Jesus", because I have a real family who I can hug any time I like. It is only your deluded, stupid, smug, blind arrogance that makes you think that people should all seek a religious crutch like the one you clearly need. Your whole basis of belief is flawed and made up by people who didn't know any better.
I'm being mean to you because your smug attitude really is quite repugnant.


LOL whatever man, peace to you and yours.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 15 Jun 15 2.06pm

Palace is my Religion

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Jun 15 3.48pm

Quote derben at 14 Jun 2015 9.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Jun 2015 9.25pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 9.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 8.57pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 6.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 5.27pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.59pm

Well established principle! Basically what they are saying is, "we don't understand how the universe came into being, so we will just say it happened".

Because scientifically we can only demonstrate it as a theory, based on existing understanding, to within fractions of a second after the event (this is one of the principle reasons for particle accelerators to replicate).

Its one of a number of theories, that are in competition, the evidence accumilated points towards this being the most probable event, based on what is known.


Where was this 'singularity' and how did it come into existence?

There wasn't yet a where for it to occur (as the singularity created space-time). As to why a transition occurred creating the universe, that's the big question, can't say I know the answer to that. That's then next big question.

There is always a point at which knowledge gives way, to the unknown.

For the record, I don't reject the possibility of a 'god', only that of the god presented by Religion and the cases made by those faiths. Divinity is a metaphysical debate, and as such is an argument about abstract associated concepts, rather than quantifiable qualities.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (13 Jun 2015 9.01pm)

I don't see how there can be this singularity containing the universe in an infinitely condensed form if there is no place for it to exist.

Your view on the possibility of a God but a rejection of mankind's religions is pretty much my own view, although I've no idea what your last sentence means.

That's the hard bit to get your head around, the dimensional aspects. Space-time is a dimension of reality, but everything that exists in all dimensions, although it may appear differently (and be perceived differently, dependent on the point of perception).

Sorry, don't understand your banter old chap.

A good starting point in Dimensions is [Link]

Essentially as you traverse dimensions, properties of objects change. The same way a line, becomes a square, becomes a cube (3d) and then a tessarat (4d) (as you apply more dimensions). Topologically a similar phenomena applies to physical dimensions.

We exist kind of three dimensionally but experience the effect of a fourth dimesion (space and time) at any given instant (where as if we were fourth dimensional, experiencing existence of a 5th dimension, we'd experience time and space as constants, rather than processes of change).

So if the 'Big Bang' creates space-time, the universe is capable of existing prior to that, simply in a form in which space-time is non-existant (prior to that event).

As you can imagine at these kinds of points, we're talking about a universe that exists in a format we would be incapable of real description, given our entire perception is geared towards three and four dimensions.

Also, at this point you get into the really hard kind of maths that sounds more akin to people talking about LSD trips than the stuff you and I know from school


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 15 Jun 15 3.57pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 14 Jun 2015 11.52am
Ignorance is bliss. And the hope religion gives to the destitute (false in your opinion) and many others to me is something wholly positive.

Yes, but that is also potentially false hope, and a means by which people are manipulated, rightly or wrongly, towards others ends.

The value of religion isn't that it can make you feel better or give succor, but that it allows you to experience the world on a different basis and enrich you spiritually.

The failure of Religion, most notably montheasitic faiths, is that they are systems by which people are controlled and contained, rather than enlightened and developed. The appropriation of a 'correct' way, used in many Christian faiths, equates any alternative as being ultimately punished by eternal damnation. A threat, essentially, that unless you do as you are commanded by the religion, you shall suffer a fate beyond the most imaginable.

As such, the main faiths of the UK, have established spiritual tyranny over people, at the cost of spiritual enrichment. Rather than seek 'truth', they are dictated what truth is, and rather than seeking to understand good, they are told that good and god, is what they are told it is, and that they must accept that even when it contradicts Christ's own teachings.

What people believe is irrelevant, its what they do with that belief and how they utilise their beliefs personally and towards others. Not to necessarily allow a person to find their own good, or truth, but to force a gospel of the truth upon them, whether they like it or not.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

derben Flag 15 Jun 15 4.40pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jun 2015 3.57pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 14 Jun 2015 11.52am
Ignorance is bliss. And the hope religion gives to the destitute (false in your opinion) and many others to me is something wholly positive.

Yes, but that is also potentially false hope, and a means by which people are manipulated, rightly or wrongly, towards others ends.

The value of religion isn't that it can make you feel better or give succor, but that it allows you to experience the world on a different basis and enrich you spiritually.

The failure of Religion, most notably montheasitic faiths, is that they are systems by which people are controlled and contained, rather than enlightened and developed. The appropriation of a 'correct' way, used in many Christian faiths, equates any alternative as being ultimately punished by eternal damnation. A threat, essentially, that unless you do as you are commanded by the religion, you shall suffer a fate beyond the most imaginable.

As such, the main faiths of the UK, have established spiritual tyranny over people, at the cost of spiritual enrichment. Rather than seek 'truth', they are dictated what truth is, and rather than seeking to understand good, they are told that good and god, is what they are told it is, and that they must accept that even when it contradicts Christ's own teachings.

What people believe is irrelevant, its what they do with that belief and how they utilise their beliefs personally and towards others. Not to necessarily allow a person to find their own good, or truth, but to force a gospel of the truth upon them, whether they like it or not.

These days, I think a belief in God is optional in the C of E isn't it? I think you have to believe in 'progressive' politics though. You also have to respect 'other faiths' and hold acts of worship with them, even though the Bible says they are all false, so you would think the Archbishop of Canterbury would be criticising them all the time.

 

derben Flag 15 Jun 15 4.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jun 2015 3.48pm

Quote derben at 14 Jun 2015 9.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Jun 2015 9.25pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 9.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 8.57pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 6.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 5.27pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.59pm

Well established principle! Basically what they are saying is, "we don't understand how the universe came into being, so we will just say it happened".

Because scientifically we can only demonstrate it as a theory, based on existing understanding, to within fractions of a second after the event (this is one of the principle reasons for particle accelerators to replicate).

Its one of a number of theories, that are in competition, the evidence accumilated points towards this being the most probable event, based on what is known.


Where was this 'singularity' and how did it come into existence?

There wasn't yet a where for it to occur (as the singularity created space-time). As to why a transition occurred creating the universe, that's the big question, can't say I know the answer to that. That's then next big question.

There is always a point at which knowledge gives way, to the unknown.

For the record, I don't reject the possibility of a 'god', only that of the god presented by Religion and the cases made by those faiths. Divinity is a metaphysical debate, and as such is an argument about abstract associated concepts, rather than quantifiable qualities.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (13 Jun 2015 9.01pm)

I don't see how there can be this singularity containing the universe in an infinitely condensed form if there is no place for it to exist.

Your view on the possibility of a God but a rejection of mankind's religions is pretty much my own view, although I've no idea what your last sentence means.

That's the hard bit to get your head around, the dimensional aspects. Space-time is a dimension of reality, but everything that exists in all dimensions, although it may appear differently (and be perceived differently, dependent on the point of perception).

Sorry, don't understand your banter old chap.

A good starting point in Dimensions is [Link]

Essentially as you traverse dimensions, properties of objects change. The same way a line, becomes a square, becomes a cube (3d) and then a tessarat (4d) (as you apply more dimensions). Topologically a similar phenomena applies to physical dimensions.

We exist kind of three dimensionally but experience the effect of a fourth dimesion (space and time) at any given instant (where as if we were fourth dimensional, experiencing existence of a 5th dimension, we'd experience time and space as constants, rather than processes of change).

So if the 'Big Bang' creates space-time, the universe is capable of existing prior to that, simply in a form in which space-time is non-existant (prior to that event).

As you can imagine at these kinds of points, we're talking about a universe that exists in a format we would be incapable of real description, given our entire perception is geared towards three and four dimensions.

Also, at this point you get into the really hard kind of maths that sounds more akin to people talking about LSD trips than the stuff you and I know from school


There is no proof whatsoever that these extra dimensions exist, only theories. It is just used to try to explain where this singularity was before the Big Bang.

 

reborn 15 Jun 15 6.16pm

Quote TheJudge at 15 Jun 2015 12.07pm

Quote Superfly at 15 Jun 2015 11.57am

Quote TheJudge at 12 Jun 2015 9.58pm


I'd repeat the question to him if he has his brain cell switched on at the moment.


Judge

Please debate your point without insults.


This thread is littered with examples, I've only highlighted one.

It's just banter dude. I am capable of deadly serious debate if you would prefer. I can debate the absurdity of religion all day.


Banter LOL

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

TheJudge Flag 15 Jun 15 8.19pm

Unholy banter.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 15 Jun 15 8.27pm

It's banter lead to trouble. Just don't call anyone a t word.

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 15 Jun 15 8.51pm

Quote derben at 15 Jun 2015 4.40pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jun 2015 3.57pm

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 14 Jun 2015 11.52am
Ignorance is bliss. And the hope religion gives to the destitute (false in your opinion) and many others to me is something wholly positive.

Yes, but that is also potentially false hope, and a means by which people are manipulated, rightly or wrongly, towards others ends.

The value of religion isn't that it can make you feel better or give succor, but that it allows you to experience the world on a different basis and enrich you spiritually.

The failure of Religion, most notably montheasitic faiths, is that they are systems by which people are controlled and contained, rather than enlightened and developed. The appropriation of a 'correct' way, used in many Christian faiths, equates any alternative as being ultimately punished by eternal damnation. A threat, essentially, that unless you do as you are commanded by the religion, you shall suffer a fate beyond the most imaginable.

As such, the main faiths of the UK, have established spiritual tyranny over people, at the cost of spiritual enrichment. Rather than seek 'truth', they are dictated what truth is, and rather than seeking to understand good, they are told that good and god, is what they are told it is, and that they must accept that even when it contradicts Christ's own teachings.

What people believe is irrelevant, its what they do with that belief and how they utilise their beliefs personally and towards others. Not to necessarily allow a person to find their own good, or truth, but to force a gospel of the truth upon them, whether they like it or not.

These days, I think a belief in God is optional in the C of E isn't it? I think you have to believe in 'progressive' politics though. You also have to respect 'other faiths' and hold acts of worship with them, even though the Bible says they are all false, so you would think the Archbishop of Canterbury would be criticising them all the time.

Firstly, with regard to Jamie's citing of a section of one of my previous posts, I would just like to qualify its employment by him. The reason for this is that I did go on to say I was only writing in these base terms because it was on this level that the OP I was responding to was operating in his attitude towards all religions. I don't think such hope promoted is deliberately false or should be merited for being false yet positive.

I suppose that isn't really the point of Jamie's own post but it's necessary for me to clarify that.
What I would suggest in response about the controlling and subversive nature of monotheistic religions is that the alternative implied is basically an intellectually open Enlightenment style humanist attitude towards all religions. This Enlightenment style humanist (circa. The Renaissance) attitude differs from what we might understand humanism today (basically another word for atheism).

The problem with it is that, it is ultimately self defeating if it has any purpose in that it strives to be some sort of open intellectual platform for debate and respect. While respect is a great thing and should be maintained in attitudes towards faith, completely open-ended liberalism in this way cannot really establish any truths.

I personally am in favour of establishing moral truths. If that makes me a close-minded individual then so be it. However, I think that one thinks on quite subjective grounds if one regards any monotheistic religion that sees some truths in another faith but believes it is essentially wrong as being in itself backward and wrong to try and establish dogma and correct practice.

Religions do change naturally throughout the centuries but if the religious members of such a faith believe in revelation and the historical certainty of elements within religious texts, then I think it foolish for them not to try and establish what is correct. If they didn't, they could potentially leave the faithful without aim, confidence or certainty in anything. Not a particularly constructive or attractive proposition for me.

The idea of spiritual tyranny could easily be termed categorical truths. Just because you or I don't believe in X or Y doesn't mean the faithful believe they are being manipulated or potentially condemned. People generally seek personal guidance and group understanding to establish their own beliefs. Only academics try generally to push the boat out a bit in any field of study.

I think Jamie, that you expect and hope for too much of the human race in their search for understanding.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (15 Jun 2015 8.54pm)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

TheJudge Flag 15 Jun 15 9.09pm

Quote nickgusset at 15 Jun 2015 8.27pm

It's banter lead to trouble. Just don't call anyone a t word.


Tory ?

 

reborn 16 Jun 15 8.18am

Quote TheJudge at 15 Jun 2015 8.19pm

Unholy banter.

noun: banter

the playful and friendly exchange of teasing remarks.
"there was much good-natured banter"

Not much sign of that here from you;

Quote TheJudge at 15 Jun 2015 11.46am

Quote reborn at 14 Jun 2015 9.12pm

You sound like you need a hug....go to the local church, they will be nice to you I promise.


There would be plenty of room inside.

The thing is Reborn, I don't need a hug from your God bothering friends or "Jesus", because I have a real family who I can hug any time I like. It is only your deluded, stupid, smug, blind arrogance that makes you think that people should all seek a religious crutch like the one you clearly need. Your whole basis of belief is flawed and made up by people who didn't know any better.
I'm being mean to you because your smug attitude really is quite repugnant.


It wasn't banter by you, it was frothing at the mouth insults, so blinded by your own point of view that you couldn't even see that you were being 'bantered'

Called on it, you now insist on lying and pretending it was just some fun. Never mind, you can lie to yourself, you can lie to others even, but God sees all

Now THATS banter, even put it in bold so you couldn't miss it

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

TheJudge Flag 16 Jun 15 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.

 

SirPeanut Flag Keston 16 Jun 15 9.37am

[Link]

This is spot on.

 


There are two kinds of person in this world:
1) Those who can extrapolate from incomplete data

reborn 16 Jun 15 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 9.53am

Quote derben at 15 Jun 2015 4.46pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 15 Jun 2015 3.48pm

Quote derben at 14 Jun 2015 9.26pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 14 Jun 2015 9.25pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 9.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 8.57pm

Quote derben at 13 Jun 2015 6.14pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 13 Jun 2015 5.27pm

Quote derben at 12 Jun 2015 10.59pm

Well established principle! Basically what they are saying is, "we don't understand how the universe came into being, so we will just say it happened".

Because scientifically we can only demonstrate it as a theory, based on existing understanding, to within fractions of a second after the event (this is one of the principle reasons for particle accelerators to replicate).

Its one of a number of theories, that are in competition, the evidence accumilated points towards this being the most probable event, based on what is known.


Where was this 'singularity' and how did it come into existence?

There wasn't yet a where for it to occur (as the singularity created space-time). As to why a transition occurred creating the universe, that's the big question, can't say I know the answer to that. That's then next big question.

There is always a point at which knowledge gives way, to the unknown.

For the record, I don't reject the possibility of a 'god', only that of the god presented by Religion and the cases made by those faiths. Divinity is a metaphysical debate, and as such is an argument about abstract associated concepts, rather than quantifiable qualities.

Edited by jamiemartin721 (13 Jun 2015 9.01pm)

I don't see how there can be this singularity containing the universe in an infinitely condensed form if there is no place for it to exist.

Your view on the possibility of a God but a rejection of mankind's religions is pretty much my own view, although I've no idea what your last sentence means.

That's the hard bit to get your head around, the dimensional aspects. Space-time is a dimension of reality, but everything that exists in all dimensions, although it may appear differently (and be perceived differently, dependent on the point of perception).

Sorry, don't understand your banter old chap.

A good starting point in Dimensions is [Link]

Essentially as you traverse dimensions, properties of objects change. The same way a line, becomes a square, becomes a cube (3d) and then a tessarat (4d) (as you apply more dimensions). Topologically a similar phenomena applies to physical dimensions.

We exist kind of three dimensionally but experience the effect of a fourth dimesion (space and time) at any given instant (where as if we were fourth dimensional, experiencing existence of a 5th dimension, we'd experience time and space as constants, rather than processes of change).

So if the 'Big Bang' creates space-time, the universe is capable of existing prior to that, simply in a form in which space-time is non-existant (prior to that event).

As you can imagine at these kinds of points, we're talking about a universe that exists in a format we would be incapable of real description, given our entire perception is geared towards three and four dimensions.

Also, at this point you get into the really hard kind of maths that sounds more akin to people talking about LSD trips than the stuff you and I know from school


There is no proof whatsoever that these extra dimensions exist, only theories. It is just used to try to explain where this singularity was before the Big Bang.

Theories require proof, even if its a consistent mathematical construct based on existing knowledge, which is what separates a theory from a hypothesis. Proving something that is essentially non-existent - However as you can demonstrate the existence of higher and lower dimensions, its more than just 'faith or an idea'.

The entanglement process of photons and 'quantum strangeness' either are false, or require at least one higher dimension to function (subatomic particles do not follow a principle of persistence in time and space).

Of course its possible physics is wrong, and that there is a flaw in theory, that means only four dimensions exist, but to the best of human knowledge dimensions beyond space-time exist.

Of course proving something beyond a singularity point, at which human knowledge breaks down, and occurred potentially only once, is as impossible as disproving the existence of god, because you're into metaphysics (and you can only disprove traits related to a concept - ie you can disprove that god is merciful, but you cannot disprove the existence of god).

So whilst you can't prove it, it is consistent with what is known, and does not require that what is known is broken by the theory. Scientifically speaking, you work with the most probable of outcomes. No one works with proof, because to prove something to be definite requires measurement of all variables, and even then it becomes dependent on the scale of measurements.

Entropy demonstrates you can never be certain of any outcome, outside of strict control measures.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 10.02am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 15 Jun 2015 8.51pm
I think Jamie, that you expect and hope for too much of the human race in their search for understanding.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (15 Jun 2015 8.54pm)

Probably, although the point I'm trying to get at is that there is really a difference between being a Christian and someone who follows the teachings of Christ, and those two things are a massive difference.

Also, we should expect more of ourselves as a species than simply replacing ourselves and going with the flow. Especially when you're staking your immortal soul on the outcome (I don't believe in that, but if I did, I wouldn't necessarily base my decision on convenience). Especially as those 'major' players contradict one another.

I mean, how do you decide which God(or gods) are the right ones.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 10.04am

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.


Judge, you can pretty much say what you like but you can't insult other users. Have a read through the forum rules if you need clarification.

[Link]

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

Page 7 of 14 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero