You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > ASHES 2015 Thread
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

ASHES 2015 Thread


Page 7 of 15 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
01CPFC Flag central coast NSW (The Mariners Mi... 20 Jul 15 1.24pm

Quote Ian J at 20 Jul 2015 7.08am

Quote 01CPFC at 19 Jul 2015 10.37pm

England 1 v Dads Army 1

If that is supposed to be sarcasm let me remind you that it was your very own Jason Gillespie who referred to them as Dad's Army


Sorry if I have ruffled a few feathers Ian,
its only a game of cricket
ho ho ho
COYP

 


Where is the Joker shown, I haven't used it ?

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jul 15 1.42pm

Quote fed up eagle at 20 Jul 2015 1.13pm

I know Australia are number one in the world and yes, they played well in the second test, but I'm really not impressed with them. England are effectively playing with only seven wickets because Lythe, Balance and Bell are s***e. Bairstow needs to come in, maybe Morgan and as I've seen somewhere else on this thread Hales. I still believe we can win the series, even after the weekends surrender because for me Australia aren't all that, just my humble opinion of course.

Chris Rogers scores 173 and Steve Smith 215 against an attack that includes bowlers rated 5th and 6th in the world and you think that "they aren't all that"

I don't think that playing Morgan will solve any problems as he is currently averaging just 10 for Middlesex and even Steven Finn has a higher batting average this season

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 20 Jul 15 1.44pm

Quote 01CPFC at 20 Jul 2015 1.24pm

Quote Ian J at 20 Jul 2015 7.08am

Quote 01CPFC at 19 Jul 2015 10.37pm

England 1 v Dads Army 1

If that is supposed to be sarcasm let me remind you that it was your very own Jason Gillespie who referred to them as Dad's Army


Sorry if I have ruffled a few feathers Ian,
its only a game of cricket
ho ho ho
COYP

That's heresy


 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 20 Jul 15 1.54pm

Quote Ian J at 20 Jul 2015 1.42pm

Quote fed up eagle at 20 Jul 2015 1.13pm

I know Australia are number one in the world and yes, they played well in the second test, but I'm really not impressed with them. England are effectively playing with only seven wickets because Lythe, Balance and Bell are s***e. Bairstow needs to come in, maybe Morgan and as I've seen somewhere else on this thread Hales. I still believe we can win the series, even after the weekends surrender because for me Australia aren't all that, just my humble opinion of course.

Chris Rogers scores 173 and Steve Smith 215 against an attack that includes bowlers rated 5th and 6th in the world and you think that "they aren't all that"

I don't think that playing Morgan will solve any problems as he is currently averaging just 10 for Middlesex and even Steven Finn has a higher batting average this season


Yes, I still think they aren't all that. If England had won the toss, I'm pretty sure we would have racked up a decent score and put them under pressure. It's only because England are playing players that aren't up to the job ie Lythe, Balance and Bell. IMHO Morgan can only be an improvement on any of those three, and Bairstow is a form player at the moment, racking up another century at the weekend, albeit in county cricket. If the top order is sorted out there's absolutely no reason why England should fear Australia.

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 20 Jul 15 2.02pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Jul 2015 11.12am

Lyth, Ballance and Bell are not up to it.


Lyth can be replaced by Alex Hales.

Ballance can be replaced by Root moving to 3 (with Bairstow replacing Root).

Bell can be replaced by moving Stokes up the order and bringing in Rashid as an all rounder (spinner as well as a half decent batsman).

Batting order...

Cook
Hales
Root
Stokes
Bairstow
Ali
Butler
Rashid
Broad
Wood
Anderson

I'd keep my eye on Cook as well... he is still getting caught playing outside his off stump to deliveries he can leave alone


That looks a better line up compared to the current one. Bairstow is in form and definitely deserves to be in the team. The collapse at the weekend was absolutely pathetic. Lythe needs to go, along with Balance and Bell.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 20 Jul 15 2.12pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Jul 2015 11.12am

Lyth, Ballance and Bell are not up to it.


Lyth can be replaced by Alex Hales.

Ballance can be replaced by Root moving to 3 (with Bairstow replacing Root).

Bell can be replaced by moving Stokes up the order and bringing in Rashid as an all rounder (spinner as well as a half decent batsman).

Batting order...

Cook
Hales
Root
Stokes
Bairstow
Ali
Butler
Rashid
Broad
Wood
Anderson

I'd keep my eye on Cook as well... he is still getting caught playing outside his off stump to deliveries he can leave alone


Not sure I'd have Ali and Rashid in the same team but otherwise I agree. Lyth and Balance are out of their depth, completely scared of Johnson's pace. Bell woefully out of form...couldn't hit the ground let alone the ball right now.

I want to see guts and fight in the final 3 tests whether we win or lose them. Yesterday was a disgrace.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 20 Jul 15 2.17pm

Quote Andy_G at 20 Jul 2015 2.12pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 20 Jul 2015 11.12am

Lyth, Ballance and Bell are not up to it.


Lyth can be replaced by Alex Hales.

Ballance can be replaced by Root moving to 3 (with Bairstow replacing Root).

Bell can be replaced by moving Stokes up the order and bringing in Rashid as an all rounder (spinner as well as a half decent batsman).

Batting order...

Cook
Hales
Root
Stokes
Bairstow
Ali
Butler
Rashid
Broad
Wood
Anderson

I'd keep my eye on Cook as well... he is still getting caught playing outside his off stump to deliveries he can leave alone


Not sure I'd have Ali and Rashid in the same team but otherwise I agree. Lyth and Balance are out of their depth, completely scared of Johnson's pace. Bell woefully out of form...couldn't hit the ground let alone the ball right now.

I want to see guts and fight in the final 3 tests whether we win or lose them. Yesterday was a disgrace.

Spot on. Losing is part of sport, as long as guts and determination are shown it becomes a little more easy to take if we've gone down with a fight, not a whimper.

 

Hoof Hearted 21 Jul 15 10.57am

My nephew mentioned James Taylor - Notts batsman as a potential replacement.

Anyone aware of his credentials?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 15 1.05pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Jul 2015 10.57am

My nephew mentioned James Taylor - Notts batsman as a potential replacement.

Anyone aware of his credentials?

Excellent middle order batsman who has just scored 291 for Notts against Sussex. He has plenty of international experience playing for England Lions (including as captain) but he has probably never faced such hostile bowling as that being meted out by the pair of Mitchells before


 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 21 Jul 15 1.26pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Jul 2015 10.57am

My nephew mentioned James Taylor - Notts batsman as a potential replacement.

Anyone aware of his credentials?

He's a decent player with international experience. As Ian J says, he is in good form and a decent middle order batsman. It will certainly be a baptism of fire for him, but in all honesty he can only be a better option than Lythe and Balance. Move Root up the order and Taylor can go in at Root's old spot. Either way, it has to be goodbye to Lythe and Balance, and maybe Bell as well. We will see, with Bairstow and Taylor coming in.

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 21 Jul 15 1.30pm

I still can't help but think we've shot ourselves in the foot with excluding Pietersen from the line up. I reckon he would excel in these situations.

 

west coast eagle Flag 21 Jul 15 2.53pm

England's first test victory stung the Aussies and even with a doctored Lords pitch their performance was woeful. As an Aussie beating the old enemy (especially in cricket) is always top of my Xmas list but I'm actually hoping for a series right down to the wire like the last couple over there.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 15 4.02pm

So it's Ballance out and Bairstow in with Bell and Root moving up a place and Bairstow batting at five.

Let's hope that Bell rediscovers his form pretty quickly as if Lyth lasts as long as normal Bell will be facing a nice hard shiny new ball being bowled by a fresh, well rested fast bowler

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Jul 15 4.15pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jul 2015 4.02pm

So it's Ballance out and Bairstow in with Bell and Root moving up a place and Bairstow batting at five.

Let's hope that Bell rediscovers his form pretty quickly as if Lyth lasts as long as normal Bell will be facing a nice hard shiny new ball being bowled by a fresh, well rested fast bowler

Think Lyth is in the "Last chance saloon".

 

Hoof Hearted 21 Jul 15 5.30pm

Quote Ian J at 21 Jul 2015 4.02pm

So it's Ballance out and Bairstow in with Bell and Root moving up a place and Bairstow batting at five.

Let's hope that Bell rediscovers his form pretty quickly as if Lyth lasts as long as normal Bell will be facing a nice hard shiny new ball being bowled by a fresh, well rested fast bowler


Bell and Lyth looked more out of touch than Balance!

Typical half-arsed response from the England selectors.

Keeping those two in the team and actually promoting Bell up the order to 3 is just plain stupidity.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 21 Jul 15 5.45pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 21 Jul 2015 5.30pm


Bell and Lyth looked more out of touch than Balance!

Typical half-arsed response from the England selectors.

Keeping those two in the team and actually promoting Bell up the order to 3 is just plain stupidity.

As they say, form is temporary whilst class in permanent and Ian Bell is a class player so let's hope that he rediscovers his touch pretty quickly.

It would help players like Bell and Lyth if the ECB brought in bowlers like Tymal Mills and Mark Footitt as net bowlers with the former being the closest that we've got to Mitch Johnson


 

chateauferret Flag 21 Jul 15 8.52pm

Quote


Bell and Lyth looked more out of touch than Balance!

Typical half-arsed response from the England selectors.

Keeping those two in the team and actually promoting Bell up the order to 3 is just plain stupidity.

It's a pathetic bottle job. Lyth couldn't have been more sh!te in that second test, Ballance has gone well off the boil and Bell's time has run out. They've dumped one batsman pour encourager les autres, by the looks of it, and are presumably supposing that that plus a few strong b0llockings will be enough to make them get there arses in gear.

Looking forward then to another instalment of The Muppets.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Jul 15 7.38am

Quote chateauferret at 21 Jul 2015 8.52pm

It's a pathetic bottle job. Lyth couldn't have been more sh!te in that second test, Ballance has gone well off the boil and Bell's time has run out. They've dumped one batsman pour encourager les autres, by the looks of it, and are presumably supposing that that plus a few strong b0llockings will be enough to make them get there arses in gear.

Looking forward then to another instalment of The Muppets.

Listening to the opinions of various cricket experts after the Lords Test people like Nasser Hussain and David Lloyd said that it would be wrong to drop Lyth and he needed to spend the off week learning which balls to leave.

In fact the only person that I can recall suggesting that Lyth should be replaced was Bob Willis and he always likes to be contrary


 

Hoof Hearted 22 Jul 15 10.56am

Anyways....... it is what it is and we have to put up with it.

I doubt that we'll see much improvement in Bell and Lyth, but Bairstow has a good heart and will add value compared to Ballance.

The Aussies tails will be up, so we're in for a torrid time batting and need a good start.

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 22 Jul 15 11.38am

Lythe should have gone too. He clearly ain't up to the job. Sadly it looks like the selectors are waiting until we're 2-1 down in the series until taking the action they should. Lythe just ain't up to the job, it's as simple as that. Bell is out of form but is a class player when he's on top of his game. There are better options than Lythe, Taylor for example, even Eoin Morgan would do a better job than Lythe, hell even I would do better than Lythe, I couldn't do any worse.

 

Page 7 of 15 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > ASHES 2015 Thread