You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works
November 22 2026 1.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Austerity Works


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 3.56pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

What street cleaners are these Jamie?

They don't come round here... if I want tins, bottles, crisp packets picked up I do it myself.

Councils keep making cuts to so called front line services - they only empty my dustbin every 2 weeks now!

Why not "employ" the unemployed to tidy our streets?

What else are they doing?

We have some, admittedly not as many as we used to have, largely thanks to people on community service doing jobs that the council used to pay people to do. Similarly, you see the same thing with charities - jobs that used to involve employing people in local function, being replaced by volunteers.

If we actually employed the people currently in these kinds of jobs to direct this initiative, I think it might be viable.

Problem is, as soon as you 'introduce free workers' the local authorities use that rather than pay someone to do the job.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 4.05pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

more psycho babble

-.-'

Just get them off their arses and doing stuff rather than making it easy to drop out and still lead a cushy life.

So except for it putting people out of work, costing more, creating a black market, requiring a complex bureaucracy to implement, being utterly inflexible and massively open to abuse.

I'd agree if there was a surplus of jobs, that paid a reasonable wage, rather than the actual situation where jobs actually are less viable than being unemployed - Which is not because unemployment pays well, but because employment doesn't even reach the actual cost of living.

No one on benefits lives what I would call a cushy life - A subsistence existence at best.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 16 9.35pm

[Link]

The following account was posted in the comments section of the Guardian website:
I personally know a fifty-six year old man who worked at Tesco for 40 hrs a week for 6 weeks for no pay. He said he was given the worst job, constantly filling freezers in the hope he would be taken on. After the 6 weeks were up the manager asked him if he would like to stay on for some extra weeks, my friend asked “with pay”? The manager said why would he pay him when he can pick the phone up and get more unemployed people who have to work for nothing of face sanctions meaning loss of ALL benefits for up to three years!

My friend wasn’t alone, he was part of twelve extra staff taken on to cover the xmas rush, no one was given a job at the end of the xmas period.

He told me they had all worked really hard and were gutted they were abused in such a way. The worst was one day he had to throw out lots of food one day over the use by date. He asked the manager if he could take some home as he was having to eat more due to being active all day. The manager refused saying if he gave him free food he wouldn’t come through the front door and buy it!

Also see [Link]

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Feb 16 10.40pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

[Link]

The following account was posted in the comments section of the Guardian website:
I personally know a fifty-six year old man who worked at Tesco for 40 hrs a week for 6 weeks for no pay. He said he was given the worst job, constantly filling freezers in the hope he would be taken on. After the 6 weeks were up the manager asked him if he would like to stay on for some extra weeks, my friend asked “with pay”? The manager said why would he pay him when he can pick the phone up and get more unemployed people who have to work for nothing of face sanctions meaning loss of ALL benefits for up to three years!

My friend wasn’t alone, he was part of twelve extra staff taken on to cover the xmas rush, no one was given a job at the end of the xmas period.

He told me they had all worked really hard and were gutted they were abused in such a way. The worst was one day he had to throw out lots of food one day over the use by date. He asked the manager if he could take some home as he was having to eat more due to being active all day. The manager refused saying if he gave him free food he wouldn’t come through the front door and buy it!

Also see [Link]

This relates to having to work in order to retain benefits I assume?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 16 10.50pm

Originally posted by chris123

This relates to having to work in order to retain benefits I assume?

Yes, under IDS's workfare scheme.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Feb 16 10.53pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

So except for it putting people out of work, costing more, creating a black market, requiring a complex bureaucracy to implement, being utterly inflexible and massively open to abuse.

I'd agree if there was a surplus of jobs, that paid a reasonable wage, rather than the actual situation where jobs actually are less viable than being unemployed - Which is not because unemployment pays well, but because employment doesn't even reach the actual cost of living.

No one on benefits lives what I would call a cushy life - A subsistence existence at best.

There are plenty in this neck of the woods jamie.

Get their dole money, go to food banks and buy/sell "acquired items" on eBay.

They have the latest iPhones, Smart TV's and drink premium lager at our local pub and get takeaway on the way home.

I'd like a "subsistence existence" too please!

With regard to the rest of your post you're just creating barriers - implementing a food voucher system rather than giving them cash is not Rocket Salad!

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Feb 16 11.03pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

Yes, under IDS's workfare scheme.

So it's better to work for benefits than not work surely?

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 22 Feb 16 11.07pm

Originally posted by chris123

So it's better to work for benefits than not work surely?


It's better to work for a wage!
It's better not to give tesco's or such like an excuse to pay no wages rather than pay someone an hourly rate for working.
Or do you think that allowing companies to get 'free' workers is ok?

Edited by nickgusset (22 Feb 2016 11.08pm)

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Feb 16 11.22pm

Originally posted by nickgusset


It's better to work for a wage!
It's better not to give tesco's or such like an excuse to pay no wages rather than pay someone an hourly rate for working.
Or do you think that allowing companies to get 'free' workers is ok?

Edited by nickgusset (22 Feb 2016 11.08pm)

I'm sure like most things it's not perfect, but in principle I am in favour of job seekers working for their benefits.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 16 12.44am

Originally posted by chris123

I'm sure like most things it's not perfect, but in principle I am in favour of job seekers working for their benefits.

How about working for a wage rather than working for peanuts?

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Feb 16 7.47am

Originally posted by nickgusset

How about working for a wage rather than working for peanuts?

Well if it includes, JSA, housing benefit and council tax - it's not peanuts. My criticism would be if the training was not properly designed to help people back to work.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 16 8.17am

Originally posted by chris123

Well if it includes, JSA, housing benefit and council tax - it's not peanuts. My criticism would be if the training was not properly designed to help people back to work.

I've not seen anything that says it does. It's used as cheap labour.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Feb 16 8.48am

Originally posted by nickgusset

I've not seen anything that says it does. It's used as cheap labour.

I suppose it depends on how skilled the labour is and how good the training is.

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 16 9.11am

Originally posted by chris123

I suppose it depends on how skilled the labour is and how good the training is.

Apologies for the links to blogs, I can't for the life of me think why the mainstream media don't report this stuff!

[Link]

[Link]

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 9.23am

Originally posted by chris123

I'm sure like most things it's not perfect, but in principle I am in favour of job seekers working for their benefits.

Me too, but they should not be performing work for profit or jobs that are otherwise done by paid workers. Nick's example is exactly how these schemes get abused - and then derailed - essentially creating slave labour.

Community projects staffed by the unemployed is something I can get behind - Maybe with an incentive bonus to welfare. We shouldn't be punishing people for not having a job, or being made unemployed.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 9.30am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

There are plenty in this neck of the woods jamie.

Get their dole money, go to food banks and buy/sell "acquired items" on eBay.

They have the latest iPhones, Smart TV's and drink premium lager at our local pub and get takeaway on the way home.

I'd like a "subsistence existence" too please!

With regard to the rest of your post you're just creating barriers - implementing a food voucher system rather than giving them cash is not Rocket Salad!

I'm curious as to what kind of dole scheme they're on that pays so well. That said, an mobile phone, TV, drinking 'premium lager' and getting a takeaway is hardly the life of Riley. A lot of people who are unemployed, and on benefits, also work legally and essentially top up their benefits.

The problem with a food voucher system is you'd also need a transport voucher system, clothing voucher system, fuel purchase voucher system, utility voucher system etc. The problem isn't with handing these vouchers out, its with private firms recouping them, and then being credited which is a logistic nightmare to implement - Especially if you want the vouchers to be traceable to the person they were issued to. These schemes when tried before elsewhere in the world have only lead to greater cost to the state, increased problems for the unemployed, a black market in the vouchers.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 9.34am

Originally posted by chris123

I suppose it depends on how skilled the labour is and how good the training is.

Its like the old YTS scheme, for some people it worked (me included) but for an lot of people it was a scheme that was abused by employers to obtain cheap labour, delivered minimal to no training - It worked best when it was tied to apprenticeships.

In situations like the one Nick refers to it actually increases unemployment, because employers will use it obtain free staff, rather than paying someone to do the job.

The idea of any scheme must be to create employment for the unemployed, provide skills and experience. Not for companies to obtain free labour.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 23 Feb 16 9.42am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Its like the old YTS scheme, for some people it worked (me included) but for an lot of people it was a scheme that was abused by employers to obtain cheap labour, delivered minimal to no training - It worked best when it was tied to apprenticeships.

In situations like the one Nick refers to it actually increases unemployment, because employers will use it obtain free staff, rather than paying someone to do the job.

The idea of any scheme must be to create employment for the unemployed, provide skills and experience. Not for companies to obtain free labour.

Then there should be proper metrics to establish the quality of training - it's the principle I'm in favour of and it should be fit for purpose and measurable.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Feb 16 9.56am

Originally posted by chris123

Then there should be proper metrics to establish the quality of training - it's the principle I'm in favour of and it should be fit for purpose and measurable.

The best method of achieving that is to properly fund apprenticeships into modern businesses, including larger private enterprise such as large corporate entities, and restrict the 'vocational degree' approach where by companies simply just fill their ranks with graduates.

Problem is that this route has been massively undercut since the 90s. Go back a generation, and your chances of obtaining a solicitor position, for example, was just as well served through an apprenticeship as having studied law.

The problem was it was more expensive to the state and companies.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Feb 16 10.10am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Its like the old YTS scheme, for some people it worked (me included) but for an lot of people it was a scheme that was abused by employers to obtain cheap labour, delivered minimal to no training - It worked best when it was tied to apprenticeships.

In situations like the one Nick refers to it actually increases unemployment, because employers will use it obtain free staff, rather than paying someone to do the job.

The idea of any scheme must be to create employment for the unemployed, provide skills and experience. Not for companies to obtain free labour.

Interestingly, those on 'workfare' schemes are not counted in unemployment figures.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works