You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sadly....it's time to go
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Sadly....it's time to go


Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 06 Nov 16 8.35pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

EVERY manager in all four divisions would have got the sack by now with a record of five wins in thirty two games. Hes extremely lucky to still be here

Perhaps, but I suspect the loyalty from the chairman comes from the fact that Pardew has led us to two of the best seasons the club has had in its entire 111 year history.

Only two seasons have surpassed this record, when we came third in the league under Coppell in 1991, and when we took the cup final to a replay and came 15th in 1990.

Coppell also got us to 10th in 1992.

So far, Pardew has got us to 10th in 2015, matching Coppell and saving us from relegation at the same time. And he has got us to a Cup Final in 2016, and 15th in the league. matching Coppell.

So, of the clubs five best seasons in 111 years, three came under Coppell and two under Pardew.

I remember when we went down under Coppell and most fans wanted him to stay (although there were a few tossers who wanted rid), and quite right they were too given what he had done for us.

So, Pardew has played a role as player and manager in four out of five of our best ever seasons.

Some people on these boards talk about loyalty to players, etc., then many of those same people are quick to call for a player to be dropped or sold, or the manager to be sacked.

Results are crap, but the team look like they are still playing for the manager. Based on his record, I'm still backing him.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

matthau Flag South Croydon 06 Nov 16 8.45pm

well said.

but you could be on here all day trying to get thru to individual's like this.

sadly it's not just palace fans your trying to make see the obvious light...it's just pessimistic, argumentative, nastily sarcastic individuals who have way to much testosterone and not much else going on in their sad lives other than to call for the sacking of someone who has done a good job with a club our size in the best league in the world.

so we sack him. bring in a half decent foreign coach...then he has one good season making us finish 7th. then a bigger club nabs him and we then appoint Sam alladyce or millen then get relegated and forgotten.

that's what happens to a club like ours when you take chances to improve on a manager that is already doing an adequate job

if however we stick with him.....although he has taken us close at times...he has still proved he's a good bet at keeping us up either way.

it's the lesser of two evils and hopefully with a couple more transfer windows he can improve the depth of the squad...and that is really what is our problem. not much else. strength in depth.

we spent all summer chasing benteke. let's spend Jan sorting our left flank.

we will be OK.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 06 Nov 16 9.49pm

I cannot see Pardew being sacked unless we hit rock bottom and by that I mean bottom of the league. I can see us staying up, by a knife edge, to give us another season in the PL and with it hopefully some better players.
I cant see any realistic names put forward anyway. Big Sam? Come on!

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

essetwentyone Flag london 06 Nov 16 10.36pm

The trouble is that Parish has totally bought into Pardew's view that we have to change our style of play. The old style which kept us in the Prem and produced some of our best ever seasons ever is now deemed as wrong for some reason ??
Charlton made this very same mistake and have spiralled down ever since!

Although we have spent what for us historically is a huge amount of money we have not strengthened enough to adopt this new style. Our midfielders are just not good enough to both protect the defence and supply the forwards - the sort of players required for this job are all at the big money clubs.
Our success has been built on great team spirit, hard work and a system which got the best from the players we had.
The truth is we are not ready to adopt this new system because we don't have enough top players and although I can appreciate the wish to play more openly I know that it just won't work with the current squad. Parish and Pardew needs to realise this and go back to basics until we can get the right players in. If Pardew can't see this then he will have to go.

 

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 07 Nov 16 4.43am

Originally posted by Inapickle

Explain clearly how bad Mr Pardew has been with regards to making the players go out and do silly things with the ball on the pitch, I await with excitement.......

trying to play attacking football with Kelly and Ward as full backs

 

tristanisginger Flag 07 Nov 16 7.47am

Intrested reading all the thoughts on AP. I'm a Newcastle fan but always had a soft spot for Palace until they signed Pardew as I can't stand the man.

I hope he's sacked as I think you'll be better off for it, get Allerdyce (hippo heed) before the mackems do.

Have you scored from any corners yet? At Newcastle his record was impossibly bad.
Was selling Gayle was good business? It was for us.

In my opinion AP is good when first comes in, with pulis' team he did OK but many of us toon fans said just wait till his second season as then he will be found out.

 

edskan Flag 07 Nov 16 8.01am

I can't bare that word 'transitional' when giving a manager time. It's pretending like something miraculous is going to happen despite the current crap performances and results. If the manager is good enough a month should be long enough for new players to gel and to get your ideas across.

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 07 Nov 16 8.33am

Originally posted by NickinOX

Perhaps, but I suspect the loyalty from the chairman comes from the fact that Pardew has led us to two of the best seasons the club has had in its entire 111 year history.

Only two seasons have surpassed this record, when we came third in the league under Coppell in 1991, and when we took the cup final to a replay and came 15th in 1990.

Coppell also got us to 10th in 1992.

So far, Pardew has got us to 10th in 2015, matching Coppell and saving us from relegation at the same time. And he has got us to a Cup Final in 2016, and 15th in the league. matching Coppell.

So, of the clubs five best seasons in 111 years, three came under Coppell and two under Pardew.

I remember when we went down under Coppell and most fans wanted him to stay (although there were a few tossers who wanted rid), and quite right they were too given what he had done for us.

So, Pardew has played a role as player and manager in four out of five of our best ever seasons.

Some people on these boards talk about loyalty to players, etc., then many of those same people are quick to call for a player to be dropped or sold, or the manager to be sacked.

Results are crap, but the team look like they are still playing for the manager. Based on his record, I'm still backing him.

Good post. You can look at it slightly differently though. Pardew took over from Warnock and basically got the Pulis team playing properly again. That took us to safety and momentum continued into the following season until injuries stopped it. He has never been able to get anywhere near the team playing to the same standard again. The cup final was a fun day out but masked the stats.

This transition stuff is rollocks, we have not changed in fact I think we bang it up to Benteke more now.

For the record I don't hate Pardew but I don't think he has attributes for the job and want a change.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

The Dolphin Flag 07 Nov 16 8.42am

I have calmed down after the weekend now but still feel we have problems.
I agree that we should be thinking mid table as a Club right now and that doesn't mean pulling up trees all season.
I agree that I wouldn't want Sam Allardyce.
I agree that we got to an FA Cup Final and it was brilliant.
I agree no Manager is perfect and that we need to be careful what we wish for.
I agree that AP is almost certainly working hard and trying his best.
BUT
We are no longer a team with a plan.
We do not appeear to have a passion - maybe we never will until our backs are against the wall again?
We are dropping points to teams around us and we have to play Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal twice as well as some other good teams again - we cannot afford to be dropping these points now - the end of season run in is horrendous - have a look and see.
I do not feel that AP knows what to do.
He says we make terrible mistakes - it is for him to plan and eradicate them in training.
Something seems wrong - i have no idea what it is - whether it is him or the backroom team - but whatever it is it needs dealing with double quick.
His transfers on the whole have been poor - he just seems to buy players and then realise they are not good enough but by then they are tied up on long term contracts and it is too late.
Even Cabaye who is undoubtedly a very good player does not seem to tick - why not?
So many questions and so few answers.
I do also want to state that I and others are sick of being abused for questioning Pardew's ability to manage CPFC - this is a forum for views and discussion isn't it?
Just because we don't all agree doesn't make one set of fans wrong does it?
I want AP to succeed - trouble is I don't know how he will as he is a man without a plan.

Edited by The Dolphin (07 Nov 2016 8.45am)

 

premier fan Flag BR4 07 Nov 16 8.50am

Originally posted by tristanisginger

Intrested reading all the thoughts on AP. I'm a Newcastle fan but always had a soft spot for Palace until they signed Pardew as I can't stand the man.

I hope he's sacked as I think you'll be better off for it, get Allerdyce (hippo heed) before the mackems do.

Have you scored from any corners yet? At Newcastle his record was impossibly bad.
Was selling Gayle was good business? It was for us.

In my opinion AP is good when first comes in, with pulis' team he did OK but many of us toon fans said just wait till his second season as then he will be found out.

I don't get why so many of you Newcastle fans are still obsessed with Pardew? If you hate him so much why do you go out of you way following comments about him on opposition fans websites? Mind boggling! Are you still kidding yourselves you were better without him? Because you weren't you got relegated!

Gayle was always respected by us and we all knew he had 20 goals in him at championship level , so nothing new there my friend. We got decent money that afforded us an England international in Townsend. Gayle had a good crack here under 4 different managers but still couldn't hold down a regular spot so not Pardews doing alone.

I personally wouldn't go near anyone who is corrupt and neither would the board I reckon. So big Sam is a big no personally.

 

premier fan Flag BR4 07 Nov 16 9.00am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have calmed down after the weekend now but still feel we have problems.
I agree that we should be thinking mid table as a Club right now and that doesn't mean pulling up trees all season.
I agree that I wouldn't want Sam Allardyce.
I agree that we got to an FA Cup Final and it was brilliant.
I agree no Manager is perfect and that we need to be careful what we wish for.
I agree that AP is almost certainly working hard and trying his best.
BUT
We are no longer a team with a plan.
We do not appeear to have a passion - maybe we never will until our backs are against the wall again?
We are dropping points to teams around us and we have to play Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal twice as well as some other good teams again - we cannot afford to be dropping these points now - the end of season run in is horrendous - have a look and see.
I do not feel that AP knows what to do.
He says we make terrible mistakes - it is for him to plan and eradicate them in training.
Something seems wrong - i have no idea what it is - whether it is him or the backroom team - but whatever it is it needs dealing with double quick.
His transfers on the whole have been poor - he just seems to buy players and then realise they are not good enough but by then they are tied up on long term contracts and it is too late.
Even Cabaye who is undoubtedly a very good player does not seem to tick - why not?
So many questions and so few answers.
I do also want to state that I and others are sick of being abused for questioning Pardew's ability to manage CPFC - this is a forum for views and discussion isn't it?
Just because we don't all agree doesn't make one set of fans wrong does it?
I want AP to succeed - trouble is I don't know how he will as he is a man without a plan.

Edited by The Dolphin (07 Nov 2016 8.45am)

I got to this word/sentence and stopped reading.

You're tellin me the team doesn't have passion? Coming from 2 goals down at Burnley and Sunderland plus the attempted fight back against Liverpool which was going to plan in the second half if not for wilfs penalty shout to be missed!

Abused? It's just a forum, man up!

Edited by premier fan (07 Nov 2016 9.02am)

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 07 Nov 16 9.07am

As I say it's a concentration, focus thing. There's no jeopardy if you make a mistake. We need a hard nosed coach as number 2, someone who the players don't want to upset and then the mental side of the game will improve, I'm sure of it. It's up to AP to bring someone like that in.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Jacey Flag 07 Nov 16 9.08am

Believe if we fail to get maximum points against Swansea and Hull ,then not over confident of our prospects against City,United,Chelsea or Arsenal,it will be time for change, surely??
We should be beating newly promoted Championship sides like Burnley and Hull,in my humble opinion.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 07 Nov 16 9.16am

Originally posted by Jacey

Believe if we fail to get maximum points against Swansea and Hull ,then not over confident of our prospects against City,United,Chelsea or Arsenal,it will be time for change, surely??
We should be beating newly promoted Championship sides like Burnley and Hull,in my humble opinion.

I understand that Hull strikers Hernandez and Keane are likely to be out for some time.

With regard to Swansea, their manager has questioned their commitment against Man Utd and I understand has stepped up training sessions.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 07 Nov 16 9.56am

posted by Jacey

Believe if we fail to get maximum points against Swansea and Hull ,then not over confident of our prospects against City,United,Chelsea or Arsenal,it will be time for change, surely??
We should be beating newly promoted Championship sides like Burnley and Hull,in my humble opinion.

posted byWillo

I understand that Hull strikers Hernandez and Keane are likely to be out for some time.

With regard to Swansea, their manager has questioned their commitment against Man Utd and I understand has stepped up training sessions.

----------------------------------------------------

...Hull and Swansea are more in line with our standards and those of Burnley, it could very easily go either way and these games are often governed by luck, against City, United, Chelsea and Arsenal luck will play no part because the amount of it will be so heavily sided on the better teams.

With regard to Swansea stepping up their training sessions they are only able to train against themselves which is a little different when facing the likes of Manchester United, they can improve concentration and the like but speed of thought and feet they can not, which is the same for us against these teams, players being injured and out will be replaced by players wanting to prove themselves so doesn't mean much because they will be much the same standard as the rest of their team, the process of improving a side is very tricky and painful and it is one we are going through now.
I believe Mr Pardew is improving our side because in attack we are looking dangerous every time we go forward, it is because of this that our defending has become a little wayward through them putting more thought and effort going forward and pressing higher up in order to do this, we are in a way biting our own bum until our defence gets used to it.

Edited by Inapickle (07 Nov 2016 10.02am)

 

Inapickle Flag South West 07 Nov 16 10.17am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

I have calmed down after the weekend now but still feel we have problems.
I agree that we should be thinking mid table as a Club right now and that doesn't mean pulling up trees all season.
I agree that I wouldn't want Sam Allardyce.
I agree that we got to an FA Cup Final and it was brilliant.
I agree no Manager is perfect and that we need to be careful what we wish for.
I agree that AP is almost certainly working hard and trying his best.
BUT
We are no longer a team with a plan.
We do not appeear to have a passion - maybe we never will until our backs are against the wall again?
We are dropping points to teams around us and we have to play Man City, Man Utd, Chelsea and Arsenal twice as well as some other good teams again - we cannot afford to be dropping these points now - the end of season run in is horrendous - have a look and see.
I do not feel that AP knows what to do.
He says we make terrible mistakes - it is for him to plan and eradicate them in training.
Something seems wrong - i have no idea what it is - whether it is him or the backroom team - but whatever it is it needs dealing with double quick.
His transfers on the whole have been poor - he just seems to buy players and then realise they are not good enough but by then they are tied up on long term contracts and it is too late.
Even Cabaye who is undoubtedly a very good player does not seem to tick - why not?
So many questions and so few answers.
I do also want to state that I and others are sick of being abused for questioning Pardew's ability to manage CPFC - this is a forum for views and discussion isn't it?
Just because we don't all agree doesn't make one set of fans wrong does it?
I want AP to succeed - trouble is I don't know how he will as he is a man without a plan.

Edited by The Dolphin (07 Nov 2016 8.45am)

..nobody is abusing you, everyone needs to take a step back and realise we are trying to move away from relying on luck to win games against teams that are very similar in standards as ours, our attack is becoming better and stronger...against Liverpool it caused all sorts of problems for them and through luck for them it didn't hurt enough, this is because we didn't create quite enough luck in defence through being very very silly, and when I refer to defence I mean the entire team not just the back four.

 

Den1923 Flag 07 Nov 16 10.28am

Hopefully AP can do something quick to turn this around, although the run of fixtures coming is going to make that very difficult. What concerns me most is that we are now 1 pt away from the drop zone with a defence that is in tatters and a midfield that has lost all its ability to link the defence to the attack. We will clearly need new quality players in the next transfer window but anybody who is any good will not want to come to a team that may end up in the championship next season based on current form!

 

The Dolphin Flag 07 Nov 16 10.42am

Originally posted by premier fan

I got to this word/sentence and stopped reading.

You're tellin me the team doesn't have passion? Coming from 2 goals down at Burnley and Sunderland plus the attempted fight back against Liverpool which was going to plan in the second half if not for wilfs penalty shout to be missed!

Abused? It's just a forum, man up!

Edited by premier fan (07 Nov 2016 9.02am)

Two points - you must have read on because you got to "abused"!
As for man up - i can take whatever is thrown but sometimes the defence of AP is vitriolic - those who think differently are just pstong views - that's all - and we all have different ones.

 

dannyh Flag wherever I lay my hat....... 07 Nov 16 11.52am

much like the brexit thread, Mr Pardew is causing divide amongst us all.

I can see clearly that going forward we are looking better, but, and it's a big But, you have to look at chances missed, lets not forget that the two goals we did score against Liverpool were very fortunate, and also the equaliser at the weekend was a pen from an absolutely mind bogglingly stupid hand ball that won us a free shot at goal.

Point being as much as people bemoan our " bad luck" we have in our defeats had our fair share of fortune.

The loss on Saturday was down to nothing more than gun ho greed, and an arrogance on behalf of the manager. Instead of allowing HIS team to leave one defender on the half way line with seconds of a game left, he should have left Fryers, Ward, and Ledley back on the half way line, if he does that they don't score and we still have 7 to aim for in the box.

Possession football (in your own half) does not win you points,winning does, and we simply have not done enough of that under AP. We made West Ham and Bournemouth look like Barca.

And what is this new passing game all the remain campaign are going on about? Sure we knock it about across our back line with more confidence than before, but other than that there is no difference to the way we used to set up with Pulis, and actually since we have had Benteke there are a lot more long balls pumped up to him from 40 meters away.

Now we have a look at signings, Benteke is obviously a quality addition to any side, Initially I thought Townsend was at least as good as Yannick, not so sure about that now, as for the rest, they are just a bunch of championship players at best, and Jedi wasn't replaced as we were told he would be. And for me the Jury is out on Mandanda, not sure any keeper would look good in front of that back four, so time will tell with him.

As for who could replace AP. I firmly believe that there are many managers out there, that could pull more from the current squad than he is.

I also love that people are digging out Allardyce saying he's a boring one dimensional coach ? well even if that were true, I'd rather the slump was halted and we stayed up, than spend the season watching "thrilling" 3-2 defeats to the likes of West Brom and Swansea and then watch Brighton leap frog past us into the prem whilst we are away Leeds again, Won't be many mind the gap posts then will there ?

Lastly I can't actually believe there are alleged fans of the club on here stating that they would rather us go down than have Allardyce's brand of football at Selhurst. And I'm fairly certain the chairman would agree with me in saying as long as we stay up, the football is secondary.

And just one for the record, I post on here all the time win lose or draw, I wasn't sure about the AP appointment from the off's I thought he was erratic and that showed through in his teams, I have seen nothing to show me I was wrong, except of course we now have lost the ability to defend. Nothing would please me more than for AP to sort his s*** out and get the team playing the way we all know they can. But I firmly believe hos own self importance and arrogance will prevent him from doing so, and the casualty of that arrogance could be our premiership status.

Edited by dannyh (07 Nov 2016 12.01pm)

 


"It's not the bullet that's got my name on it that concerns me; it's all them other ones flyin' around marked 'To Whom It May Concern.'"

Jacey Flag 07 Nov 16 12.12pm

Originally posted by dannyh

much like the brexit thread, Mr Pardew is causing divide amongst us all.

I can see clearly that going forward we are looking better, but, and it's a big But, you have to look at chances missed, lets not forget that the two goals we did score against Liverpool were very fortunate, and also the equaliser at the weekend was a pen from an absolutely mind bogglingly stupid hand ball that won us a free shot at goal.

Point being as much as people bemoan our " bad luck" we have in our defeats had our fair share of fortune.

The loss on Saturday was down to nothing more than gun ho greed, and an arrogance on behalf of the manager. Instead of allowing HIS team to leave one defender on the half way line with seconds of a game left, he should have left Fryers, Ward, and Ledley back on the half way line, if he does that they don't score and we still have 7 to aim for in the box.

Possession football (in your own half) does not win you points,winning does, and we simply have not done enough of that under AP. We made West Ham and Bournemouth look like Barca.

And what is this new passing game all the remain campaign are going on about? Sure we knock it about across our back line with more confidence than before, but other than that there is no difference to the way we used to set up with Pulis, and actually since we have had Benteke there are a lot more long balls pumped up to him from 40 meters away.

Now we have a look at signings, Benteke is obviously a quality addition to any side, Initially I thought Townsend was at least as good as Yannick, not so sure about that now, as for the rest, they are just a bunch of championship players at best, and Jedi wasn't replaced as we were told he would be. And for me the Jury is out on Mandanda, not sure any keeper would look good in front of that back four, so time will tell with him.

As for who could replace AP. I firmly believe that there are many managers out there, that could pull more from the current squad than he is.

I also love that people are digging out Allardyce saying he's a boring one dimensional coach ? well even if that were true, I'd rather the slump was halted and we stayed up, than spend the season watching "thrilling" 3-2 defeats to the likes of West Brom and Swansea and then watch Brighton leap frog past us into the prem whilst we are away Leeds again, Won't be many mind the gap posts then will there ?

Lastly I can't actually believe there are alleged fans of the club on here stating that they would rather us go down than have Allardyce's brand of football at Selhurst. And I'm fairly certain the chairman would agree with me in saying as long as we stay up, the football is secondary.

And just one for the record, I post on here all the time win lose or draw, I wasn't sure about the AP appointment from the off's I thought he was erratic and that showed through in his teams, I have seen nothing to show me I was wrong, except of course we now have lost the ability to defend. Nothing would please me more than for AP to sort his s*** out and get the team playing the way we all know they can. But I firmly believe hos own self importance and arrogance will prevent him from doing so, and the casualty of that arrogance could be our premiership status.

Edited by dannyh (07 Nov 2016 12.01pm)

Very well said from one who became addicted to supporting Palace since I witnessed the late great Cliff Holton score a hatrick against Bury in the 60's.
Would rather see our top flight status retained at all costs,even if this means appointing Big Sam to do so,if we fail to beat Hull next month,at which point we may well be in the bottom three.

 

Page 7 of 10 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Sadly....it's time to go