You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clattenburg in disguise?


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
bicycle repair man 26 Feb 17 6.52pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Perhaps he assumed it was Zaha, took out his card because, after all, the Laws do say that nothing done to Zaha counts as a foul, and then found himself face to face with McArthur whom, in all the years he has been playing for Palace, I have never, ever seen dive.


Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 6.38pm)

Like it, that's funny,and just about true.

 

Charlie Croker Flag Hampshire 26 Feb 17 7.12pm

Originally posted by Willo

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.

But you don't accept that - which is the basis for most of the threads on here where you defend any referee (but especially Clattenburg) regardless of the evidence against.

 


“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."

chateauferret Flag 26 Feb 17 7.20pm

Originally posted by Charlie Croker

But you don't accept that - which is the basis for most of the threads on here where you defend any referee (but especially Clattenburg) regardless of the evidence against.

I think he accepts that referees make mistakes. What he doesn't accept is that referees making loads of important mistakes means the referees are f****** s****. He also doesn't accept that the mistakes tend to favour one group of clubs over another, as we have seen yet again today in the EFL Cup Final.

Edited by chateauferret (26 Feb 2017 7.21pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Feb 17 7.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee obviously saw something hence the 'Yellow' card.He didn't have the benefit of 'Slow-Mo' of course and as I haven't availed of this I cannot comment about the specifics of the incident.

I look at the 'Bigger picture' and I can only re-iterate that a referee can only give what he sees from his angle or vantage point or what he is informed by his assistants.And yes there will be variances with what he/assistant sees and what others see, including the pundits.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 3.18pm)


He referred to lino, who was no distance from offence. Dont say otherwise I was right there they will give Wilf nothing end of...no excuses corruption at its most blatant

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Feb 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by Spiderman


He referred to lino, who was no distance from offence. Dont say otherwise I was right there they will give Wilf nothing end of...no excuses corruption at its most blatant

Sorry they will give Palace nothing Conspiracy against BS? Dont reply Willo unless you can prove otherwisew

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Feb 17 7.47pm

Originally posted by Willo

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.

Name him/her

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 26 Feb 17 7.48pm

Originally posted by Willo

He is far from invisible I can assure you.

As for my "Defending", I am NOT a 'defence lawyer' for Madley or any other referee and try to see decisions from the perspective of the man in the middle.

At least I accept that referees make mistakes - seemingly to the majority on here they are expected to be right 100% of the time. Of course I have witnessed many 'Faux Pas' over the years but can understand why mistakes were made.

Show us one threrad where you have said this.

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 26 Feb 17 7.59pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Name him/her

He cant because the friend only exists in willos head

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 26 Feb 17 8.22pm

Originally posted by Willo

Pundits who have seen 'Slow-mo' replays probably loads of times.A referee only sees things once from his angle and often his view is obscured. Trust me, I know and have spoken to many referees about this.

Do pundits in general heap praise on some brilliant decisions ? Do they focus on the referee when he makes terrific judgement calls ?

I saw Wilf pulled over the line in real time but the ref was nearer. I was too far away to give a verdict on McArthur but tv confirmed that both ref and linesman had an unobstructed view. I think it is fair to say that the ref was inconsistent in handing out yellow cards too.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (26 Feb 2017 8.24pm)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 26 Feb 17 8.44pm

Originally posted by Willo

The referee obviously saw something hence the 'Yellow' card.He didn't have the benefit of 'Slow-Mo' of course and as I haven't availed of this I cannot comment about the specifics of the incident.

So the ref was justified in issuing a yellow card to McArthur because he "saw something". The implication of your statement is that he saw McArthur dive. The ref didn't see that, for the simple reason that it never happened.

Edited by Willo (26 Feb 2017 3.18pm)

 

Phil H Flag 26 Feb 17 9.34pm

I think our mate Clatts was in disguise running the line at Wembley today...ridiculous offside decision against Soton and yet again Manure get away with it. I watched the England rugby and when in doubt the ref sends the decision upstairs, why oh why can't we do that in football?

 

palaceontheup Flag 26 Feb 17 9.41pm

Willo is a FAILED ref. Didn't even make the grade. got loads of abuse on the touchline about his decisions. Why do you think he idolises "Mark" and any other s*** ref. If he admits they are the dog s***e they are he is admitting to himself that he is and was a w*** ref. He comes on here acting as if he is some wise old professional who has regular meetings with top refs when in reality he was nothing more than a sunday league ref who knows no-one and uses online websites to get all his pointless bollocks. His dear old "mark" would laugh at this pathetic old fool. He loves all the controversy as it makes him feel like "mark" who to the same tune gets a lot of controversy (rightly so).

Now then Mr. Willo. Dare you to tell me I'm wrong.

 


Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha

Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.

Terry Vegetables Flag Forest Hill 27 Feb 17 1.46pm

Kammy didn't mention willo?

 


catford kid, caught up supporting "team of the 80s" in the 70s..
1st actual Match - PALACE 1-1 LEEDS (Sat 13 Nov 1982)

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 27 Feb 17 2.55pm

Mr.Madley's stats for issuing Yellow Cards reveal that he has greatly increased the quantity for this season.

His total for 15/16 season was 96 in 35 games(ave.of 2.74 per game),with the Premiership accounting for 70 in 26 games(ave.of 2.69 per game).

His total,so far,for the 16/17 season is 94 in 23 games (ave.of 4.09 per game), with the Premiership accounting for 77 in 19 games(ave.of 4.06 per game).

These figures are freely available on the internet.I have rounded up or down as appropriate.

 

Johnny Byrne Flag Pinner 27 Feb 17 3.06pm

Thank goodness Sakho's goal saving tackle on Stuani was not given as a pen then. We won, so onto the next game. I thought Jimmy Mac was very professional how he handled a clear mistake by Mr. Madley through the booking. He must have been quietly fuming!

 

The Dolphin Flag 27 Feb 17 3.10pm

A proper bad day for the Referee - I was sat with a 'Boro fan and we both agreed - crap all afternoon!

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 28 Feb 17 7.45am

Back in the bottom three on goal difference. Now tell me those decisions haven't hurt us.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Pierre Flag Purley 28 Feb 17 8.32am

Originally posted by palaceontheup

Willo is a FAILED ref. Didn't even make the grade. got loads of abuse on the touchline about his decisions. Why do you think he idolises "Mark" and any other s*** ref. If he admits they are the dog s***e they are he is admitting to himself that he is and was a w*** ref. He comes on here acting as if he is some wise old professional who has regular meetings with top refs when in reality he was nothing more than a sunday league ref who knows no-one and uses online websites to get all his pointless bollocks. His dear old "mark" would laugh at this pathetic old fool. He loves all the controversy as it makes him feel like "mark" who to the same tune gets a lot of controversy (rightly so).

Now then Mr. Willo. Dare you to tell me I'm wrong.

Yes and that's probably being unkind and unjust to all those kind generous people who give up their valuable time to officiate!

On the topic of the Jimmy Mac's incident Willo you are roundly in the majority of one again!

Willo I do remember that you mentioned in another thread that you were meeting with a top referee that very evening following your comments on 12/2/17 following the Arsenal v Hull match but I don't think you shared the outcome of this rendevouz and of course this professionals particular thoughts on the subject with us?


 

palaceontheup Flag 28 Feb 17 9.04pm

Originally posted by Pierre

Yes and that's probably being unkind and unjust to all those kind generous people who give up their valuable time to officiate!

On the topic of the Jimmy Mac's incident Willo you are roundly in the majority of one again!

Willo I do remember that you mentioned in another thread that you were meeting with a top referee that very evening following your comments on 12/2/17 following the Arsenal v Hull match but I don't think you shared the outcome of this rendevouz and of course this professionals particular thoughts on the subject with us?



He never did tell me I'm wrong...

 


Yannick Bolasie - Glenn Murray - Wilfried Zaha

Most exciting attacking trio at Selhurst Park in years.

GlaziertoEagle Flag Coventry 28 Feb 17 9.06pm

Apparently Mr Maddley does actually know how to give a penalty.. as he's given one to Brighton this evening...

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Clattenburg in disguise?