You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Embarrassing
November 16 2026 9.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Embarrassing


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 13 Aug 17 1.31pm

Originally posted by samprior

Some of the play yesterday was hard to watch. Dann and Ward on the ball look so uncomfortable. Puncheon as Captain did next to nothing productive all game. All worrying signs if we are not to find replacements.

However as bad as some of these things were equally appalling were fans jeering and booing when the game was in the balance when players played a ball back or played it short, only to then jeer Hennessy when he did kick it long. Hardly going to fill an already jittery bunch of players with confidence.

Yes it was not good, yes a lot of things need to change, yes it was a concerning display, yet we need to support not create more anxiety so early on in the game/season.

Dann and Ward looked ponderous and uncomfortable.
I have been critical of Puncheon for a while and yesterday he was as abject as ever - which hardly surprised me.

Yes, all round very worrying.

Edited by Willo (13 Aug 2017 1.32pm)

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 13 Aug 17 2.25pm

Originally posted by Willo

Dann and Ward looked ponderous and uncomfortable.
I have been critical of Puncheon for a while and yesterday he was as abject as ever - which hardly surprised me.

Yes, all round very worrying.

Edited by Willo (13 Aug 2017 1.32pm)

Yes, neither Dann nor Ward look up to it. Between them they are giving up a goal a game at the moment. Sign Chambers, and a gk. Play Fosu-Mensah as RWB and we might have a decent defence. Alternatively stick Luka back in as RCB, then play Loftus-Cheek as DM alongisde Punch. Then play Townsend in th etoo 3. Something like that! Personally I would also give Schlupp a go as LWB.

PS Snaffle a really good back up striker for no more than £10m!

 

rattus2002 Flag 13 Aug 17 2.53pm

As I have written on another thread..it doesn't matter how many negatives there were from yesterday, there is no excuse for booing the decisions of a 20 year old youngster who is making his debut in a new league. If this was a Crystal Palace academy player this would not have happened. Regardless of his experience (how much can you have as a 20 year old?) he would have been extremely nervous and was probably only following instructions anyhow. The booing would have delighted the opposition and provided them with encouragement they needed. It's pathetic and needs to stop. Boo at the end of the game if you are unhappy but not during the game when there is already enough tension around.

We have to face facts. We bought our way out of trouble last year. We cannot continue to do this as Parish has alluded to. We have to change the way in which the club operates and attempt to compete by developing our own academy players and taking very promising youngsters on Loan, whilst trying to pick up a few purchases along the way.

We cannot continue to give the opposition 65-70% of the possession in each game as per last year...whilst those tactics will earn you the occasional win against the big 6 they will not work against the Burnley's, West Ham's etc as they will just invite you on to them and as witnessed last year when we have more of the ball we were terrrible. That is what FDB is trying to change and it will take probably 7/8/9 games but we have to be patient.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 2.55pm

That's fair enough rattus but you don't need to completely reshape the team to do that and decide it's the best thing to do with the players you have before you assess them, then bring in 3 and need another 2-3. That I'm afraid is bullsh1t if ever I've smelt it.

 


COYP

Pikester Flag Worthing 13 Aug 17 3.12pm

First game of the season. Keep it tight, carry on the form of last season and integrate the new players. Hope for a win but take a 1-1 draw.

I hope we haven't got a massive ego on our hands and will give Frank time (like it matters to him if I don't) but that seemed a foolish way to start his Palace career...

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 13 Aug 17 3.41pm

Let's recognise that both the first 2 goals came from Ward being beaten by his man when actually stood in a normal RB position. That would have happened regardless of the system we were playing, as would the resultant defending from the crosses.

Dann ducking out of a long ball and letting Ince go through 1 on 1 was nothing to do with the system either.

On another day, Dann would've scored, Benteke would've scored from the corner, and Benteke/Wilf would've scored from Townsend's low cross. All, again, nothing to do with the system. Wilf got put into loads of space in the box in the first half and did nothing with it too.

Rather than calling the new manager and system doomed after 1 game, let's recognise some really poor individual performances, unrelated to the system, which would have seen us battered regardless of how we set up. The players have at least as much blame to take from yesterday.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

rattus2002 Flag 13 Aug 17 4.00pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

That's fair enough rattus but you don't need to completely reshape the team to do that and decide it's the best thing to do with the players you have before you assess them, then bring in 3 and need another 2-3. That I'm afraid is bullsh1t if ever I've smelt it.

But we didn't have a winning formula or team last season did we? We got soundly beat by a fair amount of 2nd rate opposition and stayed up by some pretty freakish results against some of the top 6.

His philosophy and tactics would have been discussed in the meetings with Parish and itnwould have been obvious that it would take time to evolve. It is clear we need a couple of people for key positions but don't make out we had a successful setup and unit last season.

 

europalace Flag Europe 13 Aug 17 4.23pm

didn't we lose 0-4 at home to Sunderland under Allardyce?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 4.41pm

Originally posted by rattus2002

But we didn't have a winning formula or team last season did we? We got soundly beat by a fair amount of 2nd rate opposition and stayed up by some pretty freakish results against some of the top 6.

His philosophy and tactics would have been discussed in the meetings with Parish and itnwould have been obvious that it would take time to evolve. It is clear we need a couple of people for key positions but don't make out we had a successful setup and unit last season.


So it's imperative we play 3-4-3 to do it. Is that what you're saying? No other clubs evolve unless it's 3-4-3? Really mate?

 


COYP

rattus2002 Flag 13 Aug 17 5.31pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

So it's imperative we play 3-4-3 to do it. Is that what you're saying? No other clubs evolve unless it's 3-4-3? Really mate?

Nope, that's not what I am saying at all.

We played 4-3-3 last season and it produced more poor results than it did good ones. Each manager has a preferred formation and preferred tactics, whether that be Alladyce, Pardew or de Boer. De Boer's formational preference appears to be happens to be 3-4-3 with the emphasis on keeping posesssion as opposed to letting the opposition having the ball for the best part of 90 minutes. It's a change that would have been discussed with Parish and both would have known it would have taken time to adapt too.

Look at Conte last year..carried on with the 4-4-2 from the season before..chels were crap. Changed to 3-5-2 after 5 games and put Moses rwb and suddenly a 20 game unbeaten run.

If will take the original players some time to adapt to this new style but players like Fosu-Mensah and RLC & Wieldewald more adept to playing with the ball than without it. They will also try not to give possession of the ball away as easily which may mean the odd backwards pass every now and then and not a Delaney style hump up the pitch (which oddly I don't remember too much booing of!).

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 5.49pm

We were more 4-2-3-1 until Luka came in. When he and a decent ball playing centre mid or 2 are in the team we were and will be effective.

Those 3 plus Benteke, Zaha and Townsend and you have a very talented 6 in front of defence. Have full backs able to overlap rather than have gaps in front of them there you are.

Frank's preferred formation till now, well actually the minute he was hired before knowing the squad, was 4-3-3. At some point without actually knowing it, he deemed us suited to 3-4-3, having the players for it. Yet he's signed 3 and needs another 3. That's 6 of 11 before subs. Get the picture?

Oh and he's relying on Benteke to press from the front. Yep, Frank knew the squad was perfect for it.

 


COYP

Painter Flag Croydon 13 Aug 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by europalace

didn't we lose 0-4 at home to Sunderland under Allardyce?

Maybe because we didn't play them under Allardyce?

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 13 Aug 17 5.57pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

Let's recognise that both the first 2 goals came from Ward being beaten by his man when actually stood in a normal RB position. That would have happened regardless of the system we were playing, as would the resultant defending from the crosses.

Dann ducking out of a long ball and letting Ince go through 1 on 1 was nothing to do with the system either.

On another day, Dann would've scored, Benteke would've scored from the corner, and Benteke/Wilf would've scored from Townsend's low cross. All, again, nothing to do with the system. Wilf got put into loads of space in the box in the first half and did nothing with it too.

Rather than calling the new manager and system doomed after 1 game, let's recognise some really poor individual performances, unrelated to the system, which would have seen us battered regardless of how we set up. The players have at least as much blame to take from yesterday.

But the 2nd goal didn't happen that way. Ward was left 2 on 1 and Luka didn't cover behind so Mooy(?) had a clear run for the cross. Riedewald then didn't jump and gave Mounie a free header. Ward's been harshly treated on that goal IMO. He also really had no chance on the 1st goal it just got him.
As you said Benteke should have scored twice and was denied by the keeper once, Wilf was denied by him twice and Dann should have scored. System had nothing to do with that.
As Souness just said, don't be fooled by opening days. Some teams start bang on it, some need 2 or 3 games to get going. We are always the latter.

Edited by Dangermouse (13 Aug 2017 6.04pm)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

andyeagle Flag 13 Aug 17 6.01pm

The one thing I keep hearing is give it time!! In the priemership time is what you don't have, has before you know it we are points adrift and catching up with the rest

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 13 Aug 17 6.06pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

But the 2nd goal didn't happen that way. Ward was left 2 on 1 and Luka didn't cover behind so Mooy(?) had a clear run for the cross. Riedewald then didn't jump and gave Mounie a free header. Ward's been harshly treated on that goal IMO.

This is correct. The main culprit for goal no 2 was Riedewald behaving like a rabbit in headlights and not even challenging. Basic defensive skills not deployed, whether you are Dutch, English or anyone.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 13 Aug 17 6.07pm

Originally posted by andyeagle

The one thing I keep hearing is give it time!! In the priemership time is what you don't have, has before you know it we are points adrift and catching up with the rest

We have 37 games.
In every season in the prem this time around we have flirted with relegation at some point in the season, yet have actually only been really in danger once. So maybe we should have a little faith.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Part Time James Flag 13 Aug 17 6.14pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

We have 37 games.
In every season in the prem this time around we have flirted with relegation at some point in the season, yet have actually only been really in danger once. So maybe we should have a little faith.

Very true. We always manager to hire a manager mid season to dig us back out of the poo. I'll be more patient.

Edited by Part Time James (13 Aug 2017 6.14pm)

 




Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 13 Aug 17 6.17pm

Originally posted by kevlee

This is correct. The main culprit for goal no 2 was Riedewald behaving like a rabbit in headlights and not even challenging. Basic defensive skills not deployed, whether you are Dutch, English or anyone.

I saw it as Ward going for the player with the ball when he had 1 to mark himself. Luka or someone was in front of the player with the ball and Ward was in front of his own marker. Ward going to the ball was what I thought did it at the time, and that was after a bad 10 minutes for him.

Maybe I had a bad angle but that's what I saw. An easy one two when all he had to do was stay and be patient. Schoolboy error if that's what it was and possibly pressure in his head from being done several times before as a wing back, without someone in front of him and without the defence part of the game as his priority.

 


COYP

coulsdoneagle Flag London 13 Aug 17 6.19pm

Cold hard fact of the matter is that the formation and system didn't work. It's not just to do with Personel and certainly nothing to do with spending money. We can't recruit a whole new team, and frank has to use what he has.


Our best players are Benteke and Zaha and we played all the balls to Bentekes feet and let Zaha get outnumbered and kicked around by having a massive disconnect between the back 3/5 and anyone ahead of them.

RLC looks a real talent and a dynamic forward thinking midfielder, yet for most of the game he was played on the wing and couldn't influence the game.

Frank has his system, but we have our players and they don't seem to fit, he needs to be able to adapt his system or he needs to go, the outcome of yesterday has to rest at his feet at the end of the day. He picked that team and they played under his instructions.

He said in the interview we lost the game in 15 minutes. I don't know what game he watched but the one I saw we were second best for almost all the game.

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 13 Aug 17 6.20pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I saw it as Ward going for the player with the ball when he had 1 to mark himself. Luka or someone was in front of the player with the ball and Ward was in front of his own marker. Ward going to the ball was what I thought did it at the time, and that was after a bad 10 minutes for him.

Maybe I had a bad angle but that's what I saw. An easy one two when all he had to do was stay and be patient. Schoolboy error if that's what it was and possibly pressure in his head from being done several times before as a wing back, without someone in front of him and without the defence part of the game as his priority.

Luka was behind Ward.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Embarrassing