You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up
November 16 2026 7.58am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window Summing Up


Page 7 of 18 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 01 Feb 18 2.05am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Willo

I wasn't being critical. I was just commenting on how a lot of supporters will view the signings of what they will deem 'Unknown' players from lesser leagues.As opposed to other clubs in a relegation battle who have signed established players.

Time will tell if the 'Window' was good or bad I suppose.Hodgson talked about more additions than we have actually got and we missed some of our targets.This is very disappointing.

Edited by Willo (01 Feb 2018 1.02am)

No, I didn't think you were being critical, I was just responding to your initial comment. As you say, we probably have to wait and see but this is a little bit frustrating to some.

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Feb 18 2.07am

Riedewald, Lee and other squad players have a chance that they probably wouldn’t to make an impact because of certain deals collapsing.

We have a genuine striker to give Christian competition and we have some cover in defence and midfield which is what we needed.

Sakho is back, and hopefully some more bodies will be recovering in the next couple of weeks.

Not the best transfer window, the goalkeeper is the biggest blow. I wanted four players including a keeper and we got 3.

It’s not ideal but we at least have cover up top and should have enough fit players to name a 25.


Edited by coulsdoneagle (01 Feb 2018 2.08am)

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Feb 18 2.34am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Painter

On second thoughts, a poor window would see Zaha being sold.

A bit of perspective is needed sometimes.

That would depend on what you did with the money. I wouldn't be too happy if I were a Saints fan given that they fleeced the bin dippers to the tune of £75m for a somewhat ordinary centre-back and didn't put much of that money back into the squad.

Having said that if we sold Wilf we'd have our work cut out finding anyone who could replace him so yes, God forbid.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Feb 18 2.34am

I missed keeping up with what was going on in final hours and now just catching up.

I am shocked we have done nothing really Roy stated he needs bodies and again we do nothing and the ones we have in are loans or super cheap guys with no top league experience.

I never thought we could get any worse in the way we did past transfer windows but this is a joke.

To move forward we need to get rid off the current owners they would rather spend more time/money on this new stand then what really matters.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 01 Feb 18 2.37am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Debating what happened with Niasse doesn’t do much good, and the fact remains that until everyone in the room sits down and goes on the record as to what happened, it’s not confirmed.

Let me type what I am trying to say.

Not signing a goalkeeper last window was pretty terrible from Parish and co, but not signing one this time around is absolutely criminal.

The manager went on the record several times about the need for a goalie, as you need 3 - some might say that’s code for “I don’t like the 2 I have”.

I cannot comprehend how Parish and co could go into this window, and not come out of it having signed a goalkeeper, it is beyond belief.

It is very, very poor to not have got a keeper in during the last 2 windows. I wish we would not see this kind of poor performance from Parish but it happens time and again with transfers and managers.

Oh and the OP has it wrong, its not Parish's ego which is the problem, its that he is god awful at transfers and hiring and managing managers - 2 kind of important areas.

Edited by Maine Eagle (01 Feb 2018 1.05am)

The goalkeeper you talk of, is he to be better than Wayne or just another Goalkeeper.?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

europalace Flag Europe 01 Feb 18 3.05am

So funny to see so many comments about how the club should have done 'this or 'that' to secure deals and not wait until last minute etc. Nobody here knows anything about any of the negotiations and what any of the reasons are that certain players didn't join the club. Only the club management have those details.

Three new signings and many still moaning showing how clueless they really are.

Still, it's great entertainment to watch so many get so stressed and act like children over what at the end of the day is a few games of football, quite remarkable

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Feb 18 3.14am

Originally posted by alaneagle1

The goalkeeper you talk of, is he to be better than Wayne or just another Goalkeeper.?

Are you happy with Hennessey as our number 1? He is the worst keeper in the league. Your question seems somehow not serious, is it?

Guaita is a whole lot better than Hennessey, check his stats and reputation.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Wilbraham413 Flag 01 Feb 18 3.16am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by radicalsteve

Its so easy to be critical on acquisitions when the "playing field" is so competitive and dynamic, but I will chime in, because I have done M&A all my life... Frankly from the outside this looks like a total shambles. The targets in terms of positions were made so clear by management and so those responsible have failed miserably in meeting the gaps in the squad. Its not rocket science and the positioning of "its all down to the wire" is a complete cop out. I don't think those in charge know how to get deals across the line. Deal making is strategic, not jus last minute tactics on a "wing and a prayer". Piss poor stewardship of the club's assets. Agents and clubs must have figured out that CPFC are Championship quality when it comes to talent acquisition! I am so pissed that we couldn't get the basics done properly and our manager was clear from day 1 what needed to be done in this transfer window!

Hard to argue with any of these points. We've heard for 5 months what we need in the transfer window.

Maybe it will all work out, but there's no denying we didn't get what Roy and SP said we needed to get.

If we were currently in the bottom 3, I have to believe they would have been more serious about getting reinforcements.


 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Feb 18 3.19am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by alaneagle1

FOUR signings in the Summer.
THREE last January (not counting SAKHO).
THREE now.
Total TEN.
Are you Ian Holloway. ?


you rate this as good?

Roy said this window alone he needs 6.

Your numbers include loans right which should be excluded really we don't own them players.

We have a squad which is too small no depth and needed a lot of signings over the periods you are covering and all we did n that time span is 6-7 signings that is not good at all.

lets use Man City as example Peop stated aging squad which is why they did so many changes now we don't have money like him but it shows if you need to do the changes and new bodies you do it we messed about for month and then bring in what 2 players excluding loans which have not been that grat anyway.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Feb 18 3.19am

Originally posted by europalace

So funny to see so many comments about how the club should have done 'this or 'that' to secure deals and not wait until last minute etc. Nobody here knows anything about any of the negotiations and what any of the reasons are that certain players didn't join the club. Only the club management have those details.

Three new signings and many still moaning showing how clueless they really are.

Still, it's great entertainment to watch so many get so stressed and act like children over what at the end of the day is a few games of football, quite remarkable

I have some details. Hodgson said many times he wanted another keeper, that is a fact. Hennessey is not good enough, that is a fact. We have gone 2 transfer windows and have royally fouled up sorting this long standing problem out, that is a sad and pathetic fact.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 01 Feb 18 4.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

The signings we got will great next year in the champ...

I'm just surprised we have put our faith into players with no top flight experience. This striker has to hit he ground running and score goals or at least get CB scoring again.

The Defensive midfielder... not good enough for Benfica, so not too sure there. The Cb, who knows.

If we were 7th in the championship, going for it, i'd be impressed! Thing is, looking at the league, there are 9 other clubs 2/3 points either side of us. It is way too close to call and looks like it will go to the wire, where strong, experienced bodies will get us over the line, respecting the point or win.

But... the main issue is that Roy didn't get what he asked for.

 


This was once a quality forum....

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 01 Feb 18 4.20am

If you bother to read anything instead of reactionary slagging off of the chairman which seems to be an occurrence every season now you would know that the goalkeeper they had lined up was ready to come and Brondby decided to pull out of the deal at the last minute because they couldn't find a replacement.... So how is that SP or DF fault is beyond me. There are more things at play than 'ermmmmm I really like your player... Can I buy him'... 'yes of course you can, here he is'. That is the kind of talk people seem to expect to go on.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (01 Feb 2018 4.20am)

 

crvenaeagle Flag 01 Feb 18 5.09am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Perhaps Parish thinks Roy has already saved his hide and doesn't need to do anything more this season?

 

BelfastEagle Flag 01 Feb 18 5.19am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

So we ended up with a fat Swedish kid on loan for a couple of months, a pole valued at £2m which is what championship teams would play for a squad member and a forward from the mighty danish league.

I want Freedmans job it really is a piss take.

It’s no wonder we have such a huge turnover of managers is it. Even Sam rumbled it.

Edited by BelfastEagle (01 Feb 2018 5.20am)

 

Bitter Flag Harpenden 01 Feb 18 5.24am

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

If you bother to read anything instead of reactionary slagging off of the chairman which seems to be an occurrence every season now you would know that the goalkeeper they had lined up was ready to come and Brondby decided to pull out of the deal at the last minute because they couldn't find a replacement.... So how is that SP or DF fault is beyond me. There are more things at play than 'ermmmmm I really like your player... Can I buy him'... 'yes of course you can, here he is'. That is the kind of talk people seem to expect to go on.

Edited by CPFCwetrust (01 Feb 2018 4.20am)


The problem with always leaving things until the final day is that it relies on the chain of player movements being completed before anyone moves. Having said that, the only way to complete deals early is to pay over the odds and risk financial ruin.
There is clearly no easy solution. All these people who are calling for new owners overlook the minor detail of finding someobody willing to throw their money at Palace. Such people are unlikely to have any affilation for the club and the risk of ruining the club isn't a big deal to them. In terms of affiliation for their club, I think we have the best owners in the Premier League. The big issue here is that the transfer window forces the brinkmanship mentality where agents and clubs know they can hold the buyer to ransom. The sooner transfer windows are abolished, the better.

Edited by Bitter (01 Feb 2018 5.25am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Feb 18 5.54am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

I think the two we purchased are worth it they most very little so if they do not work out nothing really has been lost.

the problem is that is it no other players when our manager clearly stated he needed 6 and we all know from summer we needed a lot of players yet we keep messing about trying to save few mil here or their.

if owners of are club can't front funds required for this league then get out and sell the club SP always states he loves this club and wants best for it well how is with holding funds whats best.

people was saying in summer we needed 8+ players and we got what 2-3 excluding loans and look how small and poor the squad was.

The transfer for this Lille guy was a mess Lille needed the money now they are in trouble yet we are trying to do deals with delayed payments we could of just offered how much they wanted 17m weeks ago and had him.

I want to hear SP take on this whole thing I wonder if he will do another scripted holmsdale radio show

Other thing that annoys me is i heard they have spend over 30m regarding all this planning and so on for new stand so far

looks like Cabaye will have new deal to which really he doesn't deserve one the money he is on which is high we could get much better player in he is past it now even when AP had him come here you could see his legs was going he was looked after by AP

One positive we have spend very little so come summer we should have plenty of funds no excuses this time that we spent big in Jan

Edited by grumpymort (01 Feb 2018 5.57am)

Edited by grumpymort (01 Feb 2018 6.05am)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Feb 18 5.54am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect our supporters look at Swansea and see they have brought in Ayew and King who are pretty decent additions with PL experience.WBA have brought in Daniel Sturridge.Newcastle have signed Slimani.Stoke have brought in the combative Ndiaye for £14 Mill from Galatasaray.

By contrast our supporters will look at some of our signings and view them as unknown Squad players. They will see no goalkeeper addition (Not for the want of trying), a young striker with no experience in any top league etc etc and will question whether in the event of any further injuries the new additions will actually prove to be of any use.Of course the supporters have not seen the players perform but based on what is known about them they have formed a judgement - I suspect that overall they are underwhelmed !

You are talking about "our supporters" and what they might be thinking as if you are not one of them.

Why not "we are underwhelmed" instead of "they are underwhelmed"

 

europalace Flag Europe 01 Feb 18 5.57am

Originally posted by Bitter


The problem with always leaving things until the final day is that it relies on the chain of player movements being completed before anyone moves.
Edited by Bitter (01 Feb 2018 5.25am)


No one within the club management leaves anything to the 'last day'. In the real world, there are 2 parties to any deal, sometimes more. Do you really think that Steve Parish and his team simply wait until the last day before they make any bids for new players? If so then you don't know much about negotiation methods or dealing in the real market for any type of high value goods.

Edited by europalace (01 Feb 2018 5.58am)

 

The Dolphin Flag 01 Feb 18 6.02am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Not the best window by any means but we are where we are and there is no point whingeing about it.
I am not that fussed about the GK situation to be honest - it needs sorting in the summer but right now it might be better the devil you know for the rest of the team - we need consistency for the moment.
Interesting though that we seemed to back off one GK deal assuming the other one would happen and then the other club stopped the deal so we ended up with nothing?
If that is how it worked then it does show us being naive really - find the one you want and do the deal - don't wait assuming you will get a better deal elsewhere!

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 01 Feb 18 6.10am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Sums up this transfer window' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Not the best window by any means but we are where we are and there is no point whingeing about it.
I am not that fussed about the GK situation to be honest - it needs sorting in the summer but right now it might be better the devil you know for the rest of the team - we need consistency for the moment.
Interesting though that we seemed to back off one GK deal assuming the other one would happen and then the other club stopped the deal so we ended up with nothing?
If that is how it worked then it does show us being naive really - find the one you want and do the deal - don't wait assuming you will get a better deal elsewhere!


GK issue could be worse in summer both our current keeps deals are up so we either have to renew current ones now or we could end up not having any which will make the market even harder to get one for good price.

we have from what i know 9 players who contracts end this year that are in 25 squad.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 7 of 18 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window Summing Up