You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic
November 16 2026 6.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (SIGNED) (LOCKED)


Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Petereagle Flag Brockley 06 Aug 19 1.18pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Being reported on Sky Sports transfer Center that we are back in for McCarthy.

`PALACE STILL IN FOR McCARTHY

Crystal Palace still want to sign James McCarthy from Everton, with talks back on according to Sky Sports News.

Having already had one bid rejected, Palace are understood to be trying to restructure a payment schedule.

We reported nine days ago that Everton had made a £55m bid for Zaha - and reported eight days ago they had made a second bid including McCarthy and Cenk Tosun.

Palace want McCarthy regardless of any potential swap deal involving Zaha.`

Suggests to me there is some doubt in us getting Camararsa over the line.

Edited by Mwncisee (06 Aug 2019 12.04pm)

Camarasa deal still seems to be inching its way forward and we seem to have seen if Burnley? McCarthy is a very different kind of midfielder who Hodgson seems to rate, so hopefully it’s an additional signing rather than instead of?

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Aug 19 1.23pm

Originally posted by Mwncisee

Being reported on Sky Sports transfer Center that we are back in for McCarthy.

`PALACE STILL IN FOR McCARTHY

Crystal Palace still want to sign James McCarthy from Everton, with talks back on according to Sky Sports News.

Having already had one bid rejected, Palace are understood to be trying to restructure a payment schedule.

Assuming that there is some truth in the various rumours surrounding ourselves and Everton I was amused at the fact that if we were to sell Zaha to them we would want to be paid in full up front yet when it's us trying to buy a player costing about one tenth of what Zaha is worth we are haggling over payment terms

 

Ecopalace Flag Wickham 06 Aug 19 1.31pm

Apparently Roy wants 3 signings, left back, right back and a striker. Not sure where this leaves us here. This signing would be a disaster IMO, adding an aging injury prone player to our existing crop. If we pay good money for Mccarthy I'll be extremley disappointed.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 06 Aug 19 1.34pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Assuming that there is some truth in the various rumours surrounding ourselves and Everton I was amused at the fact that if we were to sell Zaha to them we would want to be paid in full up front yet when it's us trying to buy a player costing about one tenth of what Zaha is worth we are haggling over payment terms

How about 'pay as you play' in McCarthys case?

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 06 Aug 19 3.03pm

If McCarthy is so good why isn’t anyone interested in buying him?
Because he isn’t any good and always injured and they are trying to give him away.
We were connected with him in the PAST. He is no longer worth his wages let alone a fee.
And as for Tosun, yes we were interested, in the PAST, when his agent brother was making out him to be some super striker because he scored some goals on the CL qualifying rounds- the equivalent of the FA Cup 3rd round. Since then Everton got mugged and everyone can now see that he is not actually very good.
It amazes me how anyone can even start to justify taking on these bags of s***e. Or am I living on another planet?? Even offering then was an insult to intelligence.

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

Spiderman Flag Horsham 06 Aug 19 3.27pm

Originally posted by Ecopalace

Apparently Roy wants 3 signings, left back, right back and a striker. Not sure where this leaves us here. This signing would be a disaster IMO, adding an aging injury prone player to our existing crop. If we pay good money for Mccarthy I'll be extremley disappointed.

Didn't he say in his interview he wanted 4 "and then we sold Wan Bissaka so now it's 5 without the goalkeeper"? or have I misunderstood?

 

CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 06 Aug 19 9.34pm

Supposedly according to various sites , we have bought him for £8 Mill.....

"If" he stays fit..... that's a good deal.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Aug 19 9.36pm

we've just signed him for £8mil acc to talksport

 

Aray Flag South London 06 Aug 19 9.44pm

Does this mean the Camarasa is off?

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 06 Aug 19 9.45pm

Originally posted by Aray

Does this mean the Camarasa is off?

No

[Link]

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 06 Aug 19 9.47pm

Pathetic. What a waste of £8mill plus more on his wages!!

 

bashy2 Flag London 06 Aug 19 9.48pm

who leaving than seem s strange to sign 2 midfielders when we have more than enough cover in that area

 

mileend Flag East London 06 Aug 19 9.50pm

The first post on this thread, back in January, says this:

"I like James McCarthy and think he is a good player, but he's been out for a while and surely he would leave Everton to seek regular playing time so why come when we have Luka, Jimmy, Max and Kouyate already there?"

so presumably the only reason is if we think Luka is off after this season, Jimmy is almost past it and we need some cover plus first choice from 2020 onwards?

Is it strategic? - clever? - preparing for the championship?

What?

Need the striker and right back still ...

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 06 Aug 19 9.59pm

Great to get more cover, and options, Camarasa, is a bit different, should make for a bit more variation. If we play a little differently may even limit the need for another ,so called striker.
Trying not to whinge. But where are the couple of fullbacks we need ? Just one for the right side might do.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 06 Aug 19 10.14pm

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

Supposedly according to various sites , we have bought him for £8 Mill.....

"If" he stays fit..... that's a good deal.

[Link]

 

davehuggins Flag 06 Aug 19 10.15pm

McCarthy and Camarassa in does this mean Wilf gone?

 

mileend Flag East London 06 Aug 19 10.17pm

Originally posted by davehuggins

McCarthy and Camarassa in does this mean Wilf gone?

no

 

pssguy Flag 06 Aug 19 10.17pm

Gotta love our scouting technique

Cahill. Recommended by Loftus-Cheek
McCarthy. Recommended by McArthur
Camarasa. Recommended by Warnock

 

mileend Flag East London 06 Aug 19 10.22pm

Originally posted by pssguy

Gotta love our scouting technique

Cahill. Recommended by Loftus-Cheek
McCarthy. Recommended by McArthur
Camarasa. Recommended by Warnock

HOL needs a thumbs up / like / kudos button for just these occasions

 

Dhutch23 Flag 06 Aug 19 10.32pm

I dont see the point of this transfer. 8 million on a player who will not improve the team, will be the 5th choice cm thats even before the potential move of camarassa. We need a RB, winger/striker preferably younger, as the ageing squad is a worry. We must have money if we are prepared to spend 8 million on a player who has played a handful of games in the last few years.

 

Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Transfer Talk > Topic