You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread


Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
jeeagles Flag 22 Feb 20 5.17pm

Called it.

Roy totally bamboozled them by employing exactly the same tactics as every other week then PVA scoring a free kick from our only enforced change.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Feb 20 5.22pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Called it.

Roy totally bamboozled them by employing exactly the same tactics as every other week then PVA scoring a free kick from our only enforced change.

But that wasn't the same as every other week. Rather than playing completely passively we actually pressed the opposition and played positively in possession.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Feb 20 5.26pm

3 welcome points. Frustrating that there was only one goal, and that from a dead ball situation. How Ayew could do with a partner who works as hard as him, what a difference that would make to our overall game. Benteke must have some clause in his contract that gives him a start, I cannot understand how he gets a game, his work rate is a disgrace.
Nevertheless, very welcome, and a good sign for upcoming games.

 

mattteo Flag 22 Feb 20 5.31pm

Originally posted by Bangell

What are you on about? We were by far the better team today and deserved to win.

Meh. Played at home against a very weak team. Should have had 20 chances.

 

Texas Eagle Flag San Antonio, Texas (via Adelaide) 22 Feb 20 5.36pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

3 welcome points. Frustrating that there was only one goal, and that from a dead ball situation. How Ayew could do with a partner who works as hard as him, what a difference that would make to our overall game. Benteke must have some clause in his contract that gives him a start, I cannot understand how he gets a game, his work rate is a disgrace.
Nevertheless, very welcome, and a good sign for upcoming games.

h
Have to admit Ayew had a good game today but his last few appearances have been poor. Struggles to get back and defend when we aren't in possession and exposes our RB constantly. Not defending Benteke but he does hold up the ball well and wins his fair share of headers but misses way too many easy chances. Mystified why his contract was extended!

 


"Billy Gilbert really is God"

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Feb 20 5.55pm

They set up poorly against us, let us play to our strengths and their fans will not be happy. We were able to boss the midfield mostly because we were three against two in the middle. Because of that midfield control we were able to push on and pressure them up the pitch which we haven’t been able to do against other teams.

Yes we we were by far the better team today but I don’t think we will get such an easy game against Brighton and Watford. On the massive plus side Villa and Bournemouth lost and we probably only require 2 wins from 11 now as I think 39 points will be adequate.

 

EddieMac Flag 22 Feb 20 6.08pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

They set up poorly against us, let us play to our strengths and their fans will not be happy. We were able to boss the midfield mostly because we were three against two in the middle. Because of that midfield control we were able to push on and pressure them up the pitch which we haven’t been able to do against other teams.

Yes we we were by far the better team today but I don’t think we will get such an easy game against Brighton and Watford. On the massive plus side Villa and Bournemouth lost and we probably only require 2 wins from 11 now as I think 39 points will be adequate.

We won and we controlled the game,should have scored a few more and won very comfortably .We didnt win because they let us win we won because we deserved to win.

Fact not fiction.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 22 Feb 20 6.14pm

We had umpteen chances to score. We weren't clinical enough to kill the game early. Anyway, happy with 3 points.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Feb 20 6.15pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Lucky win. Played against the poorest team in the PL in terms of possession and attacking football (yes, much poorer than Norwich).

11 matches to go, still a long distance. Other matches won;t be as easy as against Newcastle. But perhaps the team can gain momentum

Next year definitely should be something else and I have no faith in the possibility of the management to make a good squad.

Did you actually watch the game. That was not a lucky win. We were clearly the better team throughout and their goal keeper was their best player. We played well today. We played higher up the pitch especially in the first half. Enjoy it and let’s stop moaning FFS

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Feb 20 6.22pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Lucky win. Played against the poorest team in the PL in terms of possession and attacking football (yes, much poorer than Norwich).

11 matches to go, still a long distance. Other matches won;t be as easy as against Newcastle. But perhaps the team can gain momentum

Next year definitely should be something else and I have no faith in the possibility of the management to make a good squad.

Lucky win? Have a day off mate.
It was a one nil hiding, should have been 3 up at half time, we hit the woodwork twice and scored a great goal. They had a couple of efforts from outside the box, that was it.
They were poor, but not as bad as Bournemouth were.

 

VinceHilaire Flag London 22 Feb 20 6.27pm

My sons and I enjoyed the game. It had a good tempo and a great atmosphere. Our weaknesses have been well documented..We thought PVA, Ayew, Dann and Cahill were excellent today.

The rest did the team the world of good.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Feb 20 6.31pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

We won and we controlled the game,should have scored a few more and won very comfortably .We didnt win because they let us win we won because we deserved to win.

Fact not fiction.

I think you are missing the point. If other teams set up like that against us I reckon we would win 8 matches out of 10. I already said we were by far the better team, but their formation helped us boss the game. Their tactics were poor or you could say they implemented their plan poorly, whereas our plan was good against that set up. Nothing to do with a team allowing another team to win

 

askyourself Flag 22 Feb 20 6.34pm

Just back from the game...
Thoroughly enjoyed the match.
We were by far the better side. Their MOM was easily their keeper. But for him it would have been three or more. Our Vince had to make one good save.
Gayle came on and I saw nothing of him.
Well done Palace ... all of you.

 


We move in the direction of our thoughts.
Just think a little.

Rainforest Flag London England 22 Feb 20 6.36pm

Glad to see Guiata kicking the ball up field more often instead of letting the back 4 played the ball up from the back. Also, I saw less of the backward and sideways passings.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Feb 20 6.42pm

Willo
Go home, hug the mrs and enjoy your evening.
I'm sure she will be mightily pleased to wake you up tommorrow with a nice poached egg on toast and a cuppa.

 

WJK1960 Flag 22 Feb 20 6.45pm

Van Aanholt's free kick was excellent of course but the delivery from corners, some taken by Pat and some by McCarthy were much more threatening than in recent weeks. I think Pat should be the nominated taker of free kicks..he has additional pace on his free kicks compared to Luka.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 22 Feb 20 6.49pm

Originally posted by WJK1960

Van Aanholt's free kick was excellent of course but the delivery from corners, some taken by Pat and some by McCarthy were much more threatening than in recent weeks. I think Pat should be the nominated taker of free kicks..he has additional pace on his free kicks compared to Luka.

100% agree, but expect Luka to take them all when he returns, unfortunately

 

Daddyorc Flag Atlantic Highlands, NJ 22 Feb 20 7.09pm

Great game. We bossed it, never really felt too nervous (well maybe a couple of times).

Didn't miss Luka at all, he's been poor all year, hope he is a sub from now on. Thought Kouyate was excellent today. As much as people said Zaha not in the game he single handedly made them have 3 yellows and a red. Sometimes it's more than it seems.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 22 Feb 20 7.21pm

Originally posted by Daddyorc

Great game. We bossed it, never really felt too nervous (well maybe a couple of times).

Didn't miss Luka at all, he's been poor all year, hope he is a sub from now on. Thought Kouyate was excellent today. As much as people said Zaha not in the game he single handedly made them have 3 yellows and a red. Sometimes it's more than it seems.

Yeah, I think I unfairly criticised him halfway through the game but with Newcastle playing with wingbacks it meant Wilf permanently had two markers on him which was always going to keep him a bit quiet. What that did though was open up the centre of midfield which we totally bossed. I agree, Kouyate was excellent and that run he made in the second half was Vieraesque.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Feb 20 7.22pm

For all our complaining it was our midfield three that bossed that game meaning Newcastle barely got a sniff. We should have won that by 3 or 4 and Newcastle were once again the worst PL team I've seen, but fair play to Roy and the team because they were far more dominant than the score suggests. If I was a Newcastle supporter I would be pretty worried as they play teams in the bottom half over the next 6 games but currently I fancy them struggling to get points against any of them. I would give PvA motm for doing what our strikers couldn't do and for some great free-kicks, but Kouyate a close second.

 

Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs Newcastle Match Thread