You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth
November 22 2026 7.32pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Alexander Sörloth


Page 7 of 32 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Petereagle Flag Brockley 05 Aug 20 4.37am

[Link]

Let's see if he signs a new contract. Or, at 33, maybe best to let him go? But whilst he's a good goalkeeper, nobody would want him as Palace’s no 1 next season

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 05 Aug 20 4.45am

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]

Let's see if he signs a new contract. Or, at 33, maybe best to let him go? But whilst he's a good goalkeeper, nobody would want him as Palace’s no 1 next season

Sorry, should have started another thread, doesn't belong in one about Sorloth

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Aug 20 7.17pm

This whole Sorloth stuff we have looked like complete rookies again.

The loan club can purchase him for under 6m and with lots going about they may do that and sell him on for double.

This guy should of been give a shot or loan him to English/Scottish team.

I bet the loan deal has no recall either otherwise you would of thought we would use it when we had injuries.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

rossboss29 Flag Portsmouth 12 Aug 20 9.32pm

No recall and after certain amount of games played compulsory purchase price of around 6m. Best we can hope for is a injury to prohibit games played in order to get him back for the lash year of his contract and possibly sell on.

That being said, 6m will not be unwelcomed in the current climate. Management clearly didn’t rate him to sanction the deal.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 12 Aug 20 9.42pm

This is all very old news and very old belly aching.

Thank god we have such a great business savvy chairman and director of football.

 

EddieMac Flag 12 Aug 20 10.39pm

The bloke was s***e. The reason he wasn't loaned out with an option to bring him back is simply because the club didn't want him back. There is nothing silly about it. He was loaned out to Belgian league and was s***e then the club decided to get rid of him. Nobody wanted to buy him so it was decided to give him to Trobzonspor on these terms. It has happened a million times in football and will happen a million more. When have you ever seen a club sell a player then 6 months later saying actually no we want him back.

He was sold never to return again.Forget him and move on with your lives.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Aug 20 12.16pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

The bloke was s***e. The reason he wasn't loaned out with an option to bring him back is simply because the club didn't want him back. There is nothing silly about it. He was loaned out to Belgian league and was s***e then the club decided to get rid of him. Nobody wanted to buy him so it was decided to give him to Trobzonspor on these terms. It has happened a million times in football and will happen a million more. When have you ever seen a club sell a player then 6 months later saying actually no we want him back.

He was sold never to return again.Forget him and move on with your lives.


You sound very dumb in this post.

If he was s**t why has he just scored 44 goals in 40 games now don't state its because of the league because if someone was truly awful doesn't matter the league he would be just that awful.

He was never given a fair run here.

It's like they expected him to walk into to club and score 15 a season straight away plus again Roy wasn't even using him when he did on rare occasions correctly.

We don't know what happened in Belgium you are just guessing he had been dealing with injury problems maybe that was part of the issue.

No one mentioned about selling him they stated loan which their is no way you are telling me if you offered him to lower English or even Scottish leagues people wouldn't take him Sheff took Wickham so that sums it up doesn't it.

He hasn't been sold so not sure why you are stating this it's a 2 year loan with a buy out clause which they have not triggered plus they have just gotten in trouble with FFP.

They will purchase him if interest rumors are true for peanuts 6m and get double so Palace who paid 9m upfront with extras going to 16m plus % goes to his former club so it will be about 4m if lucky have done terrible business again.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Mapletree Flag Croydon 13 Aug 20 12.26pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

They will purchase him if interest rumors are true for peanuts 6m and get double so Palace who paid 9m upfront with extras going to 16m plus % goes to his former club so it will be about 4m if lucky have done terrible business again.

So they get a %age of the whole fee, not just of the excess over what we paid?

 

deleted 25 Flag 13 Aug 20 12.31pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


You sound very dumb in this post.

If he was s**t why has he just scored 44 goals in 40 games now don't state its because of the league because if someone was truly awful doesn't matter the league he would be just that awful.

He was never given a fair run here.

It's like they expected him to walk into to club and score 15 a season straight away plus again Roy wasn't even using him when he did on rare occasions correctly.

We don't know what happened in Belgium you are just guessing he had been dealing with injury problems maybe that was part of the issue.

No one mentioned about selling him they stated loan which their is no way you are telling me if you offered him to lower English or even Scottish leagues people wouldn't take him Sheff took Wickham so that sums it up doesn't it.

He hasn't been sold so not sure why you are stating this it's a 2 year loan with a buy out clause which they have not triggered plus they have just gotten in trouble with FFP.

They will purchase him if interest rumors are true for peanuts 6m and get double so Palace who paid 9m upfront with extras going to 16m plus % goes to his former club so it will be about 4m if lucky have done terrible business again.

I tend to agree with most of your post. Their is pressure to hit the ground running and if I remember judgements were made on him to quickly. I thought he was technically a good player and really it comes down to man management if he wasn't encouraged enough or made to feel wanted, as he seems to have made clear

A lot of managers have problems integrating players who may have been signed by scouts and that they personally were not involved with.

Jose at Chelsea with Salah, Debruyne, Moses - didn't fancy any of them but they all went onto win the league.

You could say Parish could have mediated with Roy but maybe his judgement was that he wasn't up to it.


What I saw of him was limited but it was games against good opposition where we were doing the usual high octane closing down approach. I thought he was good in the games I saw - he held the ball up well and generally found a team mate. Technically I thought he had enough attributes to succeed.

Maybe somebody at the club could mediate with him through his agent. See where he is at. The club cannot apparently buy him with FFP, so in a state of limbo


Edited by Vincehair (13 Aug 2020 12.34pm)

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 13 Aug 20 1.27pm

If we want him back (and that is a big if), we could talk to him and his advisors and persuade him that he has a future at Palace and promise him more game time etc.

Even with Sales Clause He would still have to agree to permanent transfer to Turkey and /or could make it plain he wants to return to EPL and Palace

 

EddieMac Flag 13 Aug 20 1.28pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


You sound very dumb in this post.

If he was s**t why has he just scored 44 goals in 40 games now don't state its because of the league because if someone was truly awful doesn't matter the league he would be just that awful.

He was never given a fair run here.

It's like they expected him to walk into to club and score 15 a season straight away plus again Roy wasn't even using him when he did on rare occasions correctly.

We don't know what happened in Belgium you are just guessing he had been dealing with injury problems maybe that was part of the issue.

No one mentioned about selling him they stated loan which their is no way you are telling me if you offered him to lower English or even Scottish leagues people wouldn't take him Sheff took Wickham so that sums it up doesn't it.

He hasn't been sold so not sure why you are stating this it's a 2 year loan with a buy out clause which they have not triggered plus they have just gotten in trouble with FFP.

They will purchase him if interest rumors are true for peanuts 6m and get double so Palace who paid 9m upfront with extras going to 16m plus % goes to his former club so it will be about 4m if lucky have done terrible business again.


Did you actually watch him play him play for us? The bloke was absolutely awful. He went on loan to Belgium and wasn’t much better. So that is 18 months that the club got to look at him and then decided to get rid. It wasn’t like he had 1 game. 18 long months and nothing. So don’t tell me that he wasn’t given a chance. He was given plenty. My main problem is that he was signed in the first place not that we got rid of him.

The fact that he has gone on to score goals in Turkey is great for him but nothing we can do about it, as I said in my previous dumb post this has happened a million times in football and will happen a million more.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 13 Aug 20 1.29pm

I think it’s easy to look in hindsight and make a decision on whether it was a good or a bad deal. If we look back to when the deal was actually agreed there was not too much noise around it being poor business. I agree with the poster above, we all saw him play. A team in belgium saw him play and no one saw him having the season he has had in Turkey.

4-5m seemed like a good deal to cut our losses and move on. Fair play to the Turkish club for taking him on. If we were linked with a 5m guy who had scored no goals in a brief spell in the premier league and 1-2 in a loan spell at a belgium club, I would see more questions being thrown at dougie’s door.

I personally don’t know how he has scored this many goals and stand by that he showed nothing in the games I saw him play. But his numbers do not lie.

Chelsea got rid of Salah and KdB. Happens all the time. We just need to move on from this one unfortunately.

I don’t recall us selling cheaply too many players who have then gone on to exceed expectations. (I mean us releasing players or selling players we felt surplus to requirements)

 

EddieMac Flag 13 Aug 20 1.37pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


You sound very dumb in this post.

If he was s**t why has he just scored 44 goals in 40 games now don't state its because of the league because if someone was truly awful doesn't matter the league he would be just that awful.

He was never given a fair run here.

It's like they expected him to walk into to club and score 15 a season straight away plus again Roy wasn't even using him when he did on rare occasions correctly.

We don't know what happened in Belgium you are just guessing he had been dealing with injury problems maybe that was part of the issue.

No one mentioned about selling him they stated loan which their is no way you are telling me if you offered him to lower English or even Scottish leagues people wouldn't take him Sheff took Wickham so that sums it up doesn't it.

He hasn't been sold so not sure why you are stating this it's a 2 year loan with a buy out clause which they have not triggered plus they have just gotten in trouble with FFP.

They will purchase him if interest rumors are true for peanuts 6m and get double so Palace who paid 9m upfront with extras going to 16m plus % goes to his former club so it will be about 4m if lucky have done terrible business again.

It was a sale dressed up as a loan because of their financial situation. Man Utd and Real Madrid's of this world wouldn't touch him in a million years. Your coming on here acting like you saw a good player when he was with us. You and nobody else gave a monkies arse when he was loaned out. You probably didnt even know he was loaned out. No use jumping on the bandwagon now because of a few headlines in the daily mail.

Edited by EddieMac (13 Aug 2020 1.39pm)

 

EddieMac Flag 13 Aug 20 1.41pm

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

I think it’s easy to look in hindsight and make a decision on whether it was a good or a bad deal. If we look back to when the deal was actually agreed there was not too much noise around it being poor business. I agree with the poster above, we all saw him play. A team in belgium saw him play and no one saw him having the season he has had in Turkey.

4-5m seemed like a good deal to cut our losses and move on. Fair play to the Turkish club for taking him on. If we were linked with a 5m guy who had scored no goals in a brief spell in the premier league and 1-2 in a loan spell at a belgium club, I would see more questions being thrown at dougie’s door.

I personally don’t know how he has scored this many goals and stand by that he showed nothing in the games I saw him play. But his numbers do not lie.

Chelsea got rid of Salah and KdB. Happens all the time. We just need to move on from this one unfortunately.

I don’t recall us selling cheaply too many players who have then gone on to exceed expectations. (I mean us releasing players or selling players we felt surplus to requirements)

Absolute spot on.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 13 Aug 20 1.47pm

Originally posted by EddieMac

It was a sale dressed up as a loan because of their financial situation. Man Utd and Real Madrid's of this world wouldn't touch him in a million years. Your coming on here acting like you saw a good player when he was with us. You and nobody else gave a monkies arse when he was loaned out. You probably didnt even know he was loaned out. No use jumping on the bandwagon now because of a few headlines in the daily mail.

Edited by EddieMac (13 Aug 2020 1.39pm)

Agreed, clearly Palace wanted a 1 year loan and then a sale, Turkish club wanted a longer loan so they don't need to pay until after 2 years. In principle i've got no issue with this other than at end of year 1 Palace should have had a release clause add.
It appears we must have been desperate to get rid of him (based on Roy's assessment) and bent over backward in negotiations to accommodate the other side.
If a club DID make an offer now technically he is still a Palace player so it would be interesting to see how that would play out.
Whilst the loan is 2 years the agreement to buy is at the end of the 2 years and not at any time up to 2 years

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Aug 20 3.13pm

Originally posted by palace99

Agreed, clearly Palace wanted a 1 year loan and then a sale, Turkish club wanted a longer loan so they don't need to pay until after 2 years. In principle i've got no issue with this other than at end of year 1 Palace should have had a release clause add.
It appears we must have been desperate to get rid of him (based on Roy's assessment) and bent over backward in negotiations to accommodate the other side.
If a club DID make an offer now technically he is still a Palace player so it would be interesting to see how that would play out.
Whilst the loan is 2 years the agreement to buy is at the end of the 2 years and not at any time up to 2 years


Contracts don't work like that he may be a Palace player technically but because of the deal done Palace has no say which is why if a club wants him as rumors suggest they go through his loan club because of that buy clause.

By the way regarding the other poster i mentioned when the deal was done it was poor so not just a case of moaning about it now go read all the old posts you will see this.

Also again shows you are being dumb United and Madrid give it a rest you expect top clubs to be after him you are just acting like a child use your brain but a loan to lower English or Scot team is well do able for good business people which we clearly don't have.

It was terrible deal anybody who think its good one needs to go back to GCSE math we paid 9m upfront with addons taking it to 16m his former club also gets a sell on fee of 20-25% we are now letting him go for 6m (lets not forget we paid 9m when that same club had only just purchased him for half a million yes great deal isnt it)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

lefty27 Flag ipswich 13 Aug 20 3.54pm

We hold his registration so in theory if a big club wants him now then it will be up to him to force a move.
The buyout cause is only triggered by appearances made this season apparently.
I listened to an athletic podcast the other day when they suggested we maybe able to recall him but would have to pay a fee to do so which is why we have been reluctant.
Who really knows what the truth is regarding his contract.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 13 Aug 20 4.15pm

Originally posted by grumpymort


Contracts don't work like that he may be a Palace player technically but because of the deal done Palace has no say which is why if a club wants him as rumors suggest they go through his loan club because of that buy clause.

By the way regarding the other poster i mentioned when the deal was done it was poor so not just a case of moaning about it now go read all the old posts you will see this.

)


Not actually the case re the contract Grumpy.
It is quite a complicated loan deal. The permanent deal after year 2 depends on the player playing x amount of games in year 2 too (probably inserted at their end, not ours).
He is technically a Palace player at this point in time - FACT

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 13 Aug 20 4.23pm

Personally i think the only reason we bought him and Jach was there was a distinct possibility that we were going to get relegated and would have lost Benteke, Andros, Wilf etc. the next season. The loan is what it is. Just put this to bed and move on. Plenty of clubs have made stupid transfer decisions, Arsenal with Ozil and Sanchez going to United pr Birmingham giving us £8m plus AJ for Clinton, c'mon we all laughed long and loud over that one.

we don't know the ins and outs of the total package but one thing is for certain he wouldn't be playing for us.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 13 Aug 20 5.56pm

Originally posted by palace99


Not actually the case re the contract Grumpy.
It is quite a complicated loan deal. The permanent deal after year 2 depends on the player playing x amount of games in year 2 too (probably inserted at their end, not ours).
He is technically a Palace player at this point in time - FACT


Wrong

You need to look into this you don't understand how it works.

Palace have no power here the only thing they can get is that buy out clause money nothing else so if some one else wants him now its doesn't matter it's nothing to do with them.

A lot of people get confused with how it used to be in the old days the modern system is completely different.

If he was a Palace player as such we can bring him back but we can't he has a deal with another club so we need to wait for that to expire which is no good anyway reports state his contract expires that same year loan deal ends.

easiest way to look at it is the same as a release clause you hit it the parent cant do anything thing the player has released himself this is same with the loan so palace has no say because they put that release number in.


 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Page 7 of 32 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Alexander Sörloth