You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 16 Jul 20 11.30pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


It’s a good job for Kanu that he didn’t have to deal with this. His feet were so big he’d have been offside if he was standing behind the defender.

And let’s know forget Alex Kolinko.

His nose would have been offside whilst playing in goal for us.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Jul 20 11.33pm

The frustrating thing is that we have raised our game against two teams who have the ability to beat us with a few moments of quality, but have failed to do so against Burnley and Villa. Roy actually deployed the tactics I suggested (albeit with different personnel) so he can send the thank you to the usual address for what was a hugely improved performance If we play like that against Wolves and Spurs we have a chance and even if we don't get any points at least we can hold our heads up.

 

Paaalaaace Flag Croydon 16 Jul 20 11.40pm

Agreed

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

The frustrating thing is that we have raised our game against two teams who have the ability to beat us with a few moments of quality, but have failed to do so against Burnley and Villa. Roy actually deployed the tactics I suggested (albeit with different personnel) so he can send the thank you to the usual address for what was a hugely improved performance If we play like that against Wolves and Spurs we have a chance and even if we don't get any points at least we can hold our heads up.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 16 Jul 20 11.46pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

And let’s know forget Alex Kolinko.

His nose would have been offside whilst playing in goal for us.

Dion Dublin would’ve been in trouble too. Allegedly.

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 17 Jul 20 12.01am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Dion Dublin would’ve been in trouble too. Allegedly.

Subject to whom he was thinking about at the time, presumably?

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 17 Jul 20 12.04am

Cant recall the game, but Ayew played left back towards end of one match last season

Originally posted by EddieMac

Townsend could play left back as well. Doesn’t make him a left back

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 17 Jul 20 12.10am

How many subs did we have left to use?
How many did he use?
3 why not send the young lads on for the last five mins
But I think Roy turned round to the bench and saw no one there...
Roy they sit in the stands......

So we huffed and we puffed but we didnt blow any houses down.
Good to see Roy annoyed.. but time to get some tactics/players that can score.

And yet again in this match and every match, we are useless and perhaps dont train for them "Throw ons". we have a throw on in line with their penalty box but two seconds later either the other team are on the attack or we have passed to our keeper. Frustrates the hell out of me, we cant do the basics....

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 17 Jul 20 6.06am

Mitchell looked pretty comfortable during his cameo.
A bit awb type but on the opposite side.
Also pushed up and got back ok. Maybe we do have a little more talent than roy feels we have.

 

Brasilian Eagle Flag Londres 17 Jul 20 7.08am

Serious question:
The game carried on when they were checking VAR for the penalty during which time manc utd scored. If the penalty had been given, would their goal be chalked off? Could this be the main reason why they did not give the penalty to avoid embarrasment?

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Jul 20 7.24am

Originally posted by Brasilian Eagle

Serious question:
The game carried on when they were checking VAR for the penalty during which time manc utd scored. If the penalty had been given, would their goal be chalked off? Could this be the main reason why they did not give the penalty to avoid embarrasment?

I thought the same at the time but wasn’t sure what the rules are. I can’t remember whether there was a break in play at all between the penalty shout and their goal.

The whole VAR thing has ruined the flow of the game and made it almost impossible to celebrate a goal properly. The only thing it has really proven is that many still get the decisions hopelessly wrong after several replays and are clearly not fit to do the job..

 

stuckinbristol Flag In the woodwork. 17 Jul 20 8.05am

Originally posted by Brasilian Eagle

Serious question:
The game carried on when they were checking VAR for the penalty during which time manc utd scored. If the penalty had been given, would their goal be chalked off? Could this be the main reason why they did not give the penalty to avoid embarrasment?

Yep, it happened earlier in the season. Bournmouth v Burnley(?) Player shoulder balled it in own area, team went up the other end and scored. Chalked off and penalty given to Burnley.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 17 Jul 20 8.06am

Originally posted by Brasilian Eagle

Serious question:
The game carried on when they were checking VAR for the penalty during which time manc utd scored. If the penalty had been given, would their goal be chalked off? Could this be the main reason why they did not give the penalty to avoid embarrasment?

I believe the goal could have been chalked off, a similar situation occurred in the Bundesliga and the goal was disallowed. From what I heard this morning on the radio, there is some suggestion VAR did not even look at it. If so I would like to know the reasoning.
Even those pundits who thought it wasn’t a pen have been surprised how little time was spent on it.
FWIW my opinion is Lindelof clearly hit the back of Wilf’s leg first, not sure he touched the ball at all. Clear foul but Wilf was wearing wrong colour shirt.
I feel there is some truth in the theories that powers that be want CL race/relegation race to go to final game, as league already wrapped up. Makes me fall out of love with football this

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 17 Jul 20 8.37am

Originally posted by EddieMac

He has taken that photo of his telly on a phone. Iv seen the lines on BT and believe me they are parallel with the 6 yard box.


Edited by EddieMac (16 Jul 2020 10.45pm)


Wrong the tweet was the same image that BT Sport posted on twitter which is why it was removed on their.

Even if it was TV pictures it doesn't matter a straight line is a straight line.

VAR people do not do the lines correctly they appear to do it on the forward player then shift it excluding the lines of the pitch which is wrong doesn't matter what the camera angle is you should always line it up with the pitch markings.

Originally posted by Jaha

Don’t understand how that photo supports your point. Your new lines all wonky. How you can say that obvious, I don’t understand


The added line is inline with the line markings on the pitch the var one goes at an different angle it's very clear.


This is one taken off tv look at the pitch lines compared to the var lines they are not even straight you play to the pitch lines yet the dumb var people can't even get that right.

A square box which is edge of box to show if you look straight on which lines up with goal line which camera is looking straight at and then you have another which is same angle as the edge of the penalty box line it shows the difference clearly

If you can't understand this you really do have a low IQ and even returning to school may not help you.

Edited by grumpymort (17 Jul 2020 8.40am)

var.jpg Attachment: var.jpg (68.27Kb)

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 17 Jul 20 8.48am

Originally posted by grumpymort

The added line is inline with the line markings on the pitch the var one goes at an different angle it's very clear.


This is one taken off tv look at the pitch lines compared to the var lines they are not even straight you play to the pitch lines yet the dumb var people can't even get that right.

A square box which is edge of box to show if you look straight on which lines up with goal line which camera is looking straight at and then you have another which is same angle as the edge of the penalty box line it shows the difference clearly

If you can't understand this you really do have a low IQ and even returning to school may not help you.


Edited by grumpymort (17 Jul 2020 8.40am)

Coming from someone who struggles so badly with the English language? Priceless.

 

jeeagles Flag 17 Jul 20 8.59am

Originally posted by grumpymort


The added line is inline with the line markings on the pitch the var one goes at an different angle it's very clear.


This is one taken off tv look at the pitch lines compared to the var lines they are not even straight you play to the pitch lines yet the dumb var people can't even get that right.

A square box which is edge of box to show if you look straight on which lines up with goal line which camera is looking straight at and then you have another which is same angle as the edge of the penalty box line it shows the difference clearly

If you can't understand this you really do have a low IQ and even returning to school may not help you.

Edited by grumpymort (17 Jul 2020 8.40am)

Let's put this in perspective. Yellow line taken from the edge of the box. Blue from the penalty spot.

The VAR line is correct.

Capture.PNG Attachment: Capture.PNG (592.57Kb)

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 17 Jul 20 9.00am

You are not taking into account perspective. The yellow line might be parallel to the penalty box line but look at the grass lines to the right, they appear to be miles out of parallel and that is all down to camera perspective.

The only time you have a “pure” assessment is if the photo is taken in the exact spot on the pitch where the infringement occurs so that the photo is exactly in line. I presume they have some system that compensates for perspective, but for me, all that means is that they have added some guesswork and therefore exceptionally close calls like the one last night should be allowed.

The other issue of course is we never get to see when the ball leaves the players boot. That fraction of a second can make a big difference to whether the player is on or off. This is yet another reason why marginal decisions should back the attacker rather than the defender

The only way around this is to bring in the clear and obvious rule that seems to apply elsewhere or scrap offside altogether.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 17 Jul 20 9.15am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

You are not taking into account perspective. The yellow line might be parallel to the penalty box line but look at the grass lines to the right, they appear to be miles out of parallel and that is all down to camera perspective.

The only time you have a “pure” assessment is if the photo is taken in the exact spot on the pitch where the infringement occurs so that the photo is exactly in line. I presume they have some system that compensates for perspective, but for me, all that means is that they have added some guesswork and therefore exceptionally close calls like the one last night should be allowed.

The other issue of course is we never get to see when the ball leaves the players boot. That fraction of a second can make a big difference to whether the player is on or off. This is yet another reason why marginal decisions should back the attacker rather than the defender

The only way around this is to bring in the clear and obvious rule that seems to apply elsewhere or scrap offside altogether.

Exactly I just watched MOTD it's all well and good showing us the red line which proves he is millimetres offside but unless you can prove that that picture is taken at the exact moment the ball leaves the players foot there is always going to be an element of doubt.

In fairness to the makers of VAR they have acknowledged there is a tolerance and I believe they have said it is not meant to be used like that.

Would you just a speed gun that said you broke the law by 0.0001 mph, of course not.

The rule makers need to make it clear it has to be an obvious error and the benefit of the doubt should be with the goal scorer or team claiming a penalty. You should have a reason to rule it out not rule it in.

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 17 Jul 20 9.22am

Originally posted by grumpymort


The added line is inline with the line markings on the pitch the var one goes at an different angle it's very clear.


This is one taken off tv look at the pitch lines compared to the var lines they are not even straight you play to the pitch lines yet the dumb var people can't even get that right.

A square box which is edge of box to show if you look straight on which lines up with goal line which camera is looking straight at and then you have another which is same angle as the edge of the penalty box line it shows the difference clearly

If you can't understand this you really do have a low IQ and even returning to school may not help you.

Edited by grumpymort (17 Jul 2020 8.40am)

Have you thought about watching something you enjoy?

I appreciate being a miserable b****** comes naturally to you, but take a look around you there is so much more in the world to get depressed about*

Of course it’s entirely possible though that moaning is what you love. But to call others stupid continually is a bit unfair, as I wouldn’t back you not to get caught in a acme trap laid by Wile-e-Coyote.


*I too believe RH is stuck in his ways and should change things up - but bigger picture and all that.

 

cpj Flag Kent 17 Jul 20 9.42am

Robbed by the officials/VAR for the second game in a row. A much better performance - except from Luka who as usual committed too many fouls and misplaced too many passes, and Ayew who ruined at least two good breaks with awful final balls. Makes you wonder why we can put in good displays against Chelsea and Man U but are so dismal against Burnley and Villa. But at the end of the day we were opened up too easily again by the good team; that's 6 defeats in a row and we've only scored in one of those. Still for me the case that Hodgson must go.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Jul 20 10.07am

Originally posted by grumpymort


The added line is inline with the line markings on the pitch the var one goes at an different angle it's very clear.


This is one taken off tv look at the pitch lines compared to the var lines they are not even straight you play to the pitch lines yet the dumb var people can't even get that right.

A square box which is edge of box to show if you look straight on which lines up with goal line which camera is looking straight at and then you have another which is same angle as the edge of the penalty box line it shows the difference clearly

If you can't understand this you really do have a low IQ and even returning to school may not help you.

Edited by grumpymort (17 Jul 2020 8.40am)


Not sure if I've understood you right but as I look at the picture you posted, the angle of the camera is such that the purple line is parallel to the outer edge of the penalty area and the yellow line with the goal-line. Camera angles are strange optical illusions are they not?

I am increasingly of the opinion that the VAR system isn't yet good enough to enable officials to make the fine distinctions they are being asked to make. We are still left with the thorny question of whether the system is 100% accurate in identifying at what nano-second the ball left the supplier's foot/head etc.

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace vs. Manchester United Match Thread