You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke, welcome return to form
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke, welcome return to form


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
The Dolphin Flag 27 Jan 21 4.26pm

Belgium striker Christian Benteke, 30, is expected to stay at Crystal Palace despite interest from West Bromwich Albion. (Sky Sports)

The Eagles are prepared to offer Benteke a new deal at Selhurst Park to discourage clubs from making an offer. (Mail)

 

jeeagles Flag 27 Jan 21 4.31pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Belgium striker Christian Benteke, 30, is expected to stay at Crystal Palace despite interest from West Bromwich Albion. (Sky Sports)

The Eagles are prepared to offer Benteke a new deal at Selhurst Park to discourage clubs from making an offer. (Mail)

Right decision.

Without him, the only striker we'd have kn our books would be Ayew (who's contract is also up I think). People who are saying get rid of him are putting all their eggs in one basket with Mateta, a player most of us had only heard of a few weeks ago and doesn't have a permanent deal yet.

We could easily be left high and dry at the end of the season with no recognised striker.

A deal will cost £5m, a new untried striker would cost £20m and might be a flop.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 27 Jan 21 4.36pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Right decision.

Without him, the only striker we'd have kn our books would be Ayew (who's contract is also up I think). People who are saying get rid of him are putting all their eggs in one basket with Mateta, a player most of us had only heard of a few weeks ago and doesn't have a permanent deal yet.

We could easily be left high and dry at the end of the season with no recognised striker.

A deal will cost £5m, a new untried striker would cost £20m and might be a flop.

As opposed to the flop we have been carrying for 3 seasons.

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 21 10.38am

Originally posted by jeeagles

Right decision.

Without him, the only striker we'd have kn our books would be Ayew (who's contract is also up I think). People who are saying get rid of him are putting all their eggs in one basket with Mateta, a player most of us had only heard of a few weeks ago and doesn't have a permanent deal yet.

We could easily be left high and dry at the end of the season with no recognised striker.

A deal will cost £5m, a new untried striker would cost £20m and might be a flop.

His current salary is reported to be circa 120K per week, therefore to offer him a years extension now we would have to pay him for 78 weeks, therefore that means he would cost us just over 9.3mil just for sitting around on his backside and he is not worthy of regular starts, I would rather spend that money on Looking for a promising younger striker and CB from a lower league!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Jan 21 10.49am

I can only think that Benteke has incriminating photos of Steve Parish safely locked away somewhere. There's no other explanation for retaining his services, certainly not footballing, the stats speak for themselves, certainly not economic, miilions of pounds wasted on a complete flop, money that could have brought in a couple of decent strikers who can actually manage something better than a pathetic jog.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 28 Jan 21 11.02am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

I can only think that Benteke has incriminating photos of Steve Parish safely locked away somewhere.

Why? It's not Steve Parish that puts him in the team every week

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 28 Jan 21 11.27am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why? It's not Steve Parish that puts him in the team every week

No but its him that , agrees to extend contracts !

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Jan 21 11.28am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Why? It's not Steve Parish that puts him in the team every week

It was however Steve Parish who extended his contract, and heaven forbid, may do so again.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 28 Jan 21 12.00pm

We have to get rid of Bentenke. It sends out a bad message that a new contract is not reliant on performing well (or even playing in the case of Wickham!) The only reasonable reason I would see to offer him a new deal is if it was commensurate with him being a back-up striker, rather than being one of the top earners. Whether it is down to ability, confidence, attitude or injuries, since the first season he has been terrible bar a few isolated bright spots.

I had hoped he may be finally turning a corner, but against West Ham he looked like he was content just to do a couple of tidy lay-offs, as if that is sufficient for a PL striker. You watch how hard other team's strikers work and it makes you sick. Quite frankly if Mateta runs for more than 5 minutes a game he will be an upgrade.

I may well have contradicted my usually supportive and measured approach to the players and manager in the last couple of days, but quite frankly I'm sick of most of them at the moment.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 28 Jan 21 12.30pm

Benteke to be offered contract extension. Oh God. Stuck to us like s*** to a shoe. Instead of kicking it off, we pour ketchup on it. Hopeless.

WBA after another striker.

Benteke represents nothing but bad thoughts and negativity. If we go down, he will be like a symbol for everything that’s gone wrong.

I never wanted to buy the cheat anyway. Never forgotten the blatant, cheating dive for a pen for Pool against us.

 

Steve T Flag Cumbria 28 Jan 21 12.38pm

Damion Delany was apoplectic with that dive as was I

 

jeeagles Flag 28 Jan 21 12.42pm

Originally posted by Den1923

His current salary is reported to be circa 120K per week, therefore to offer him a years extension now we would have to pay him for 78 weeks, therefore that means he would cost us just over 9.3mil just for sitting around on his backside and he is not worthy of regular starts, I would rather spend that money on Looking for a promising younger striker and CB from a lower league!

78 weeks is a bit disingenuous.
He's already underconrract for the next 6 months so a chuck of that £9.3m is already accounted for.

I'd love us to sign a promising you striker and a CB from the lower leagues to.... but thats all ifs and maybes. Fact is, we need to ensure their is at least 1 senior striker under contract next season.

The club have worked themselves into a no win situation here, extend the contract or a player that divides opinion, or jump into the unknown without a striker.

 

Fatherken Flag 28 Jan 21 12.52pm

I agree that we should keep Benteke .
Zaha is only other striker [ we have to wait and see about the new chap ] we have on our books , that is if you call Zaha a striker not a winger .
All the others are a complete waste of time .
I will now put my tin hat now on

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 28 Jan 21 1.49pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

Right decision.

Without him, the only striker we'd have kn our books would be Ayew (who's contract is also up I think). People who are saying get rid of him are putting all their eggs in one basket with Mateta, a player most of us had only heard of a few weeks ago and doesn't have a permanent deal yet.

We could easily be left high and dry at the end of the season with no recognised striker.

A deal will cost £5m, a new untried striker would cost £20m and might be a flop.

nothing Benteke does would make anyone recognise him as a striker

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 21 3.00pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

78 weeks is a bit disingenuous.
He's already underconrract for the next 6 months so a chuck of that £9.3m is already accounted for.

I'd love us to sign a promising you striker and a CB from the lower leagues to.... but thats all ifs and maybes. Fact is, we need to ensure their is at least 1 senior striker under contract next season.

The club have worked themselves into a no win situation here, extend the contract or a player that divides opinion, or jump into the unknown without a striker.

78 weeks is based on a 12 month extension to the existing contract that is due to end 30 June. if we were to loan him out, then we may in probability still have to make some salary contribution to persuade someone to take on deadwood. Hopefully, our new striker "Mateta" will be an improvement on "Benteke" and will be our striker of choice in the weeks to come. I do understand what you say about having back up striker in case of injury or whatever, however, I would count "Benteke" as filling that role because he has demonstrated very well that he cannot run, harass defenders with or without the ball, most of his ball play skill is heading, more often than not to the opposition, he cannot play the ball very well on the floor has not lethal shot and lacks positioning, anticipation etc, most of all he can't score, more specifically, he is "useless" and we would be far better off without him right now, any extension to his last contract was madness or a mistake and the same would apply to any future contract extension!

 

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 21 3.04pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

I agree that we should keep Benteke .
Zaha is only other striker [ we have to wait and see about the new chap ] we have on our books , that is if you call Zaha a striker not a winger .
All the others are a complete waste of time .
I will now put my tin hat now on

Sorry but Benteke is a striker only in name and not for the meaning "scoring goals" keeping would be a waste of money, better off without him and let him go and make tea and toast tea cakes!

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Jan 21 3.12pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Sorry but Benteke is a striker only in name and not for the meaning "scoring goals" keeping would be a waste of money, better off without him and let him go and make tea and toast tea cakes!

He'd spill the tea and trip over the cakes

 

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 28 Jan 21 3.17pm

The wise move is to wait and see if the new striker is any good, if he is he wont be on 120k a week, if he is good we have him on 18 month contract, with an option to buy of about 13m, if we then just let Benteke go at the end of his contract the 6.2m we save on not paying him will go halfway to paying the new guys fee, if he turns out to be no good, the they could offer Benteke a contact, the new striker has 14 games, to prove himself before the obligatory purchase, it will depend on if Roy likes him if he gets his chance.

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Den1923 Flag 28 Jan 21 6.23pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

He'd spill the tea and trip over the cakes

 

Pierre Flag Purley 29 Jan 21 12.58pm

Most people have given CB so much sympathy, positivity and leeway since he joined us.
I like many others are just getting more than a little fractious now given his meagre contribution during matches and paltry return in terms of goals compared with his salary!

I now read that West Ham have signed Lingard on loan for £1.5m plus his wages till the end of the season.

Surely that must have been a far better option for us now than looking to keep Benteke beyond January and extend his contract further?

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke, welcome return to form