You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Aston Villa Match thread
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace vs Aston Villa Match thread


Page 7 of 7 << First< 3 4 5 6 7
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Aug 22 9.07am

Originally posted by Willo

One might find criticism about the current ruling apropos 'Handball' but according to the ruling currently in place it was a penalty.

My criticisms were aimed at the rules as they currently stand Willo and not the referee, for clarity.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Aug 22 9.22am

An arm extended away from the body makes that body bigger, in an unnatural position.

One could argue that if this ruling was removed, players could extend their arms to block crosses,shots and headers knowing that if they did so they would not be penalised if the ball made contact with them providing of course they never deliberately moved their arm towards the ball.

Anyway, no more to add on this matter as I am mindful of the fact that this discussion veers away from the subject of the Thread.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Aug 22 9.32am

Originally posted by Willo

An arm extended away from the body makes that body bigger, in an unnatural position.

One could argue that if this ruling was removed, players could extend their arms to block crosses,shots and headers knowing that if they did so they would not be penalised if the ball made contact with them providing of course they never deliberately moved their arm towards the ball.

Anyway, no more to add on this matter as I am mindful of the fact that this discussion veers away from the subject of the Thread.

That is the point of the rule. Players would soon adapt their arms and hands if it wasn't a pen look at how many defenders put their arms behind their back if they think a ball might hit them.

 


One more point

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 22 Aug 22 9.46am

..but you can NOT jump for real without using your arms.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Aug 22 10.06am

Originally posted by thai-eagle

..but you can NOT jump for real without using your arms.

So it’s fair atm then. If the ball touches a defenders arm it’s a penalty and if it touches the attackers arm it’s a free kick. With arms up or down. It’s a disadvantage for a defender but one of those that works for both teams when in attack.

 

YT Flag Oxford 22 Aug 22 10.32am

I don't know if anyone has mentioned it yet, but for the penalty, the VAR recording clearly shows the Villa defender pulling Guehi's shirt as they both jump for the ball. He grabs a good handful of the sleeve and pulls Guehi downwards/himself upwards. That offence alone merits a penalty, but none of the 'Fun Boy Three' on MOTD noticed it.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 22 Aug 22 10.49am

Originally posted by YT

I hate to agree with the boy Lineker, but why not keep it simple and judge it on the position of the feet? The sport is called football, after all. Just plot the furthest-forward point of the attacker's foot and compare it with with the furthest-back point of the last defender's foot.

i agree with this. There used to be some skill wrong-footing the last man to run clear of the defense. As a defender when I was playing I used to love that battle with the offside trap. But it's all but evaporated because of the current rules.

 

ripleyeagle Flag Ripley Surrey 22 Aug 22 11.13am

Originally posted by Willo

An arm extended away from the body makes that body bigger, in an unnatural position.

One could argue that if this ruling was removed, players could extend their arms to block crosses,shots and headers knowing that if they did so they would not be penalised if the ball made contact with them providing of course they never deliberately moved their arm towards the ball.

Anyway, no more to add on this matter as I am mindful of the fact that this discussion veers away from the subject of the Thread.


How would you have felt if this decision had been given against us, anyone who has played the game knows it was a ridiculous decision!!

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Aug 22 11.16am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle


How would you have felt if this decision had been given against us, anyone who has played the game knows it was a ridiculous decision!!

It wasn't a good decision but at Palace we need the odd one to go our way. There's been far worse against us, so I'll take it.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Aug 22 11.24am

Originally posted by ripleyeagle


How would you have felt if this decision had been given against us, anyone who has played the game knows it was a ridiculous decision!!

I would still have concluded that it was the correct decision based on the current interpretation of handball and I mentioned this last night in conversation with a learned gentleman.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Aug 22 11.34am

Handball should revert to deliberate hand/arm to ball.

Offside should be when one foot is in front of the last man.

It's not difficult.

VAR is like the country, if it's broke we won't fix it.


 

YT Flag Oxford 22 Aug 22 11.36am

Originally posted by ASCPFC

It wasn't a good decision but at Palace we need the odd one to go our way. There's been far worse against us, so I'll take it.

It WAS a good decision in that the laws/interpretations as they currently stand dictate that it should be a penalty.

It was arguably a BAD decision on the basis that the law is an ass; but ultimately the law is the law.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Aug 22 11.39am

Originally posted by YT

It WAS a good decision in that the laws/interpretations as they currently stand dictate that it should be a penalty.

It was arguably a BAD decision on the basis that the law is an ass; but ultimately the law is the law.

I thought the same watching the Trippier / De Bruyne incident yesterday.

A Yellow card according to the law of the game. But morally a Red in my opinion.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Putitout Flag Oxford 22 Aug 22 1.13pm

Originally posted by Willo

An arm extended away from the body makes that body bigger, in an unnatural position.

One could argue that if this ruling was removed, players could extend their arms to block crosses,shots and headers knowing that if they did so they would not be penalised if the ball made contact with them providing of course they never deliberately moved their arm towards the ball.

Anyway, no more to add on this matter as I am mindful of the fact that this discussion veers away from the subject of the Thread.

As a young player years back I was coached to spread myself defending crosses in particular, and more than a few times a deflection off the arm saved the day.
The point being the rule was hand or arm to ball not the other way round.
It’s harsh in many cases but if it’s not penalised players will have an excuse for using the arm as an extension of the torso.
As for the Villa pen , they should get over it, they were getting clobbered anyway, and many teams have had to accept this ruling ,including our selves on more than one occasion.

 

pssguy Flag 22 Aug 22 3.27pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

Handball should revert to deliberate hand/arm to ball.

Offside should be when one foot is in front of the last man.

It's not difficult.

VAR is like the country, if it's broke we won't fix it.


Pretty much my view. They let much worse actions like Cucurella's hair incident and Maguire practically strangling an opponent at every corner go without a care

 

esox lucius Flag Deal 22 Aug 22 5.32pm

Although personally I think it was a harsh decision, it’s the current rule and everyone has to live with it.

As for Gerrard moaning about it, what goes around comes around. Was it 3 or 4 years ago Sakho scored a perfectly good goal at villa park off the top of his shoulder and that disallowed for handball.

 

Page 7 of 7 << First< 3 4 5 6 7

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace vs Aston Villa Match thread