You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace team v Newcastle.
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace team v Newcastle.


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
1969eagle Flag manchester 21 Oct 23 7.52pm

Worst display so far this season. Can’t think of anyone who played well against a fine Newcastle team not playing especially well. Defence was a mess for first time. Zero ideas going forward. Couldn’t hold the ball up.JRS Manca and Ozoh offered some hope as subs. Prefer any of them to Hughes or mateta for Friday. Hurry back Eze and olise. Friday WILL be better&#128591;

 

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Oct 23 8.07pm

Do feel we missed Jeff Schlupp on the left today ? Just a thought.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 21 Oct 23 8.08pm

Lost to the better team so no complaints here..Newcastle played some exciting football..

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 21 Oct 23 8.19pm

Originally posted by rob1969

Do feel we missed Jeff Schlupp on the left today ? Just a thought.

Absolutely &#128077;

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 21 Oct 23 10.16pm

Originally posted by rob1969

Do feel we missed Jeff Schlupp on the left today ? Just a thought.

Hate to admit it because I’m not a fan of his, but Mitchell obviously struggled on his own down the left today

 

1969eagle Flag manchester 21 Oct 23 10.18pm

Yep. Mitchell really missed schlupp

 

pax3908 Flag 21 Oct 23 11.11pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Outplayed today and we couldn’t cope with Newcastles intensity over the 90 minutes. Interesting to see we had 17 attempts at goal.

Yep and we still can't hit the barn door!!Do our forwards play in plimsolls&#129319; or ballet shoes&#128544;

 

CT Charlie Flag 22 Oct 23 5.51am

Originally posted by CT Charlie

I'll stick up for Mitchell. He was on an island today, and both Andersen and Guehi had below-average games, with some bad luck thrown in. Newcastle were overloading our left side, and we gave Mitchell no help.

One goal resulted from a likely mis-hit, one from Guehi's fall, and one from Hughes's lack of hustle. The fourth goal was a team effort, with Mitchell, Guehi, Andersen & Ward all being slow to react and not fast enough to catch up.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Oct 23 7.16am

The early goal undid all of Roy's usual game strategy of keeping it to 0-0 until half time. After that goes in, he has to think about a way to get back into the game with a side lacking in attacking quality and intent against a side that has those very qualities.
The game was over before it even began.
Just the one goal in four games now - Roy has gone back into his defensive shell, it's natural to him, it's what he does, particularly so when only having at most a PL standard first eleven and not a lot more. It's been said before but the board have a lot to answer for.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (22 Oct 2023 7.34am)

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 22 Oct 23 8.18am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

The early goal undid all of Roy's usual game strategy of keeping it to 0-0 until half time. After that goes in, he has to think about a way to get back into the game with a side lacking in attacking quality and intent against a side that has those very qualities.
The game was over before it even began.
Just the one goal in four games now - Roy has gone back into his defensive shell, it's natural to him, it's what he does, particularly so when only having at most a PL standard first eleven and not a lot more. It's been said before but the board have a lot to answer for.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (22 Oct 2023 7.34am)

I went yesterday first game I’ve seen this season. Newcastle were v good, relentless at times. And the crowd in that stadium is a tough place to go. But I thought we would have been more solid. We must have been better organised against Man U. We had no respite as our forwards couldn’t do anything with the ball. Once they scored that was effectively game over. Badly need Eze back.

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 22 Oct 23 8.38am

Can’t blame Roy for yesterday.
Our players were of a far inferior quality. With the team we were able to play we wouldn’t have beaten them if we played the game 10 times.
What does Parish expect?

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

cryrst Flag The garden of England 22 Oct 23 9.26am

Originally posted by rob1969

Do feel we missed Jeff Schlupp on the left today ? Just a thought.

Just a tad. Mitchell without him or some other protection in the mid left should avoid the wing back runs. Got caught I think for 3 of the goals down his side. Although from where I was standing it was like watching subbuteo

 

Aray Flag South London 22 Oct 23 9.29am

Roy should have swapped Ayew to the left within 10 mins. Failed to react to the facts - Lerma left Mitchell isolated. So the players really had a bad game but some of them were only just returning from injury and it showed. Roy felt he had to rush them back, I guess...I'd have preferred JRS on from the start as JPM is better as an impact substitution.

And much as I like him, Hughes isn't a replacement for Eze.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 22 Oct 23 9.37am

Originally posted by Aray

Roy should have swapped Ayew to the left within 10 mins. Failed to react to the facts - Lerma left Mitchell isolated. So the players really had a bad game but some of them were only just returning from injury and it showed. Roy felt he had to rush them back, I guess...I'd have preferred JRS on from the start as JPM is better as an impact substitution.

And much as I like him, Hughes isn't a replacement for Eze.

I said the same about swapping Ayew to the left further up this thread. It was a no brainer. I also said Lerma and Doucoure weren’t ready and that could be seen. I also don’t think Hughes works well with both of them playing. In truth most of our 11 were poor yesterday and Newcastle were on top form. I expect our starting 11 before injuries a few weeks back would have given them a much harder contest? It also didn’t help the fluke first goal and the less said about Edouard and Matteta the better :-(

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 22 Oct 23 9.43am

On one level this answers head on why players need longer to return from injury. Hopefully the positive is this game hastened their recovery to full match fit.

On another we had more shots than them. 17 with 3 on target. Finishing clearly a serious issue.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 22 Oct 23 9.52am

Originally posted by silvertop

On one level this answers head on why players need longer to return from injury. Hopefully the positive is this game hastened their recovery to full match fit.

On another we had more shots than them. 17 with 3 on target. Finishing clearly a serious issue.

The stats are flattering - Lot of long range stuff and headers under pressure that were nowhere near

 

Den1923 Flag 22 Oct 23 10.43am

Originally posted by Davepalace707

The stats are flattering - Lot of long range stuff and headers under pressure that were nowhere near

That is correct we have scored just seven goals with a conversion rate of shots to goals of circa 6%!

 

Painter Flag Croydon 22 Oct 23 12.03pm

Originally posted by Aray

Roy should have swapped Ayew to the left within 10 mins. Failed to react to the facts - Lerma left Mitchell isolated. So the players really had a bad game but some of them were only just returning from injury and it showed. Roy felt he had to rush them back, I guess...I'd have preferred JRS on from the start as JPM is better as an impact substitution.

And much as I like him, Hughes isn't a replacement for Eze.


Has anybody said he is?

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 22 Oct 23 3.43pm

Originally posted by kevlee

Can’t blame Roy for yesterday.
Our players were of a far inferior quality. With the team we were able to play we wouldn’t have beaten them if we played the game 10 times.
What does Parish expect?


Yes you can in part.

If you believe this inferior to be true why bother to turn up for over 50% of games you are saying we have no chance (Again another stupid comment)

Parish is happy to just stay in the league.


Originally posted by Aray

Roy should have swapped Ayew to the left within 10 mins. Failed to react to the facts - Lerma left Mitchell isolated. So the players really had a bad game but some of them were only just returning from injury and it showed. Roy felt he had to rush them back, I guess...I'd have preferred JRS on from the start as JPM is better as an impact substitution.

And much as I like him, Hughes isn't a replacement for Eze.


It was the incorrect setup from the start.

We see this often with Roy if he can't play all his favorite 11.

Ayew was on the right to offer protection for Ward who we have seen this season is a liability.

A lot of the issues is having players out of position.

I would have gone for a 3 CB system and only 1 up top.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

dreamwaverider Flag London 22 Oct 23 3.50pm

Mateta is like an Irish Wolfhound. Must have small lungs as he has no stamina at all. Poor guy looked f**ked after 20 minutes.
If we could only find a half decent fast striker we would really be buzzing.
That German lad at Stuttgart is meant to be good. Guirassy. Got a bit of pace on him too.

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace team v Newcastle.