You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy's comments


Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Nov 23 10.26am

Originally posted by Putitout


In most respects that is what I have said. It’s not a tear jerker, but an appreciation of what’s actually happening . You don’t have to like it, or respond to it.
We know what you would say to Roy, you publicise your attitude to him constantly..
Your reasoning is rarely better than just a personal dislike , for him.
You might give him your orders to win the next three games, no matter how depleted his squad is. Because you don’t respect him. No other reason. That’s by the by , what’s relevant is you wouldn’t know what to do if he lost those games, that could possibly mend the situation. That’s if you had to, which you don’t, some sort of safety net wouldn’t you say.

It's Roy's job to find out how to win a game with what he has at his disposal. Staying in this league means winning every now and again, particularly against teams that are lower, other wise they catch you up and you sink down lower, simple really.
Considering the teams we have upcoming, I think playing for a win is reasonable. And if Roy plays out for another 0-0 (Oooh I don't have the players, the youngsters contribute nothing etc) don't be surprised when the other team take the lead and there's no plan B.
btw - I don't know Roy so I can't dislike him. I do dislike however his overly negative approach to the game, which, given time affects all the players. We've seen this in his 3rd and 4th season here, and his term with the national side, ending with the debacle against Iceland.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Nov 23 10.35am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

The big conundrum. They are not good enough as they lack experience and they can’t gain experience because we can’t risk playing them. In my opinion this is why you should only introduce one youngster at a time. Putting all three on was asking for trouble, but as others have mentioned, perhaps that’s Roy saying that these are his only alternatives for fresh legs.

For this reason I would have started with either JRS or Franca and if they were struggling, take them off.

This becomes moot shortly as hopefully Eze and Olise will be back but it does beg the question then where the youngsters will gain their experience. Personally I think JRS should be on loan as should Ebiowei.

I really don’t think after a life time of avoiding these situations like the plague Hodgson would have given his views in public if it hadn’t become the subject of a hard to bare frustration. As we see here some condemn some don’t, but sticking purely to the football aspect of this, players have to be good enough , at Premier level there are absolutely no ifs or buts.
Franca,and Ahamada, are a slightly different question, but for all those coming through the academy , most are well short of the levels needed, in fact almost all struggle to establish in league 1and 2, why anyone thinks that gets a place in our team is hard to know.
The only times we have, or even should be playing three youngsters at time, was the team of the eighties, or more common if we were in administration. The one things for sure is we shouldn’t be forced to do so for lack of credible personnel in a normal season. Any idea Hodgson was ever up for this is just not credible .
Franca, and Ahamada. Call them out as not yet fit for purpose is surely a crack at the people that spent a lot of money buying them on the basis that they could be fit for purpose. Hodgson words, they are not as good as people pump them up to be, Francas only nineteen , more training needed. Who is people , other than people willing to put about thirty million on them?

Edited by Putitout (02 Nov 2023 11.10am)

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 02 Nov 23 2.32pm

Roy in his latest press conference has conceded that he was wrong to make the comments and has apologised to the three players.

He did say he has got faith in them and suggested it was more the fact that they were expected to change the game against top of table Spurs and hopefully next time they get a chance it'll be against lesser opposition.

Also hinted that Eze and Olise may start against Everton and that Eze may be close to signing a new contract!

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 02 Nov 23 2.37pm

Here's his apology from Sky . . . [Link]

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Nov 23 3.01pm

Well done Roy. Whether it was Parish having a word, or Roy realising that he'd said the wrong thing at the wrong time and it had been picked up by pundits and fans alike, he's come out and done the right thing, apologising to the youngsters for his over reaction.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 02 Nov 23 3.12pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Well done Roy. Whether it was Parish having a word, or Roy realising that he'd said the wrong thing at the wrong time and it had been picked up by pundits and fans alike, he's come out and done the right thing, apologising to the youngsters for his over reaction.

Agree.

It's the best possible thing he could of done, although it shouldn't have happened in the first place, though we're all human and he's done his best to address it and make amends.

Onwards and upwards.

COYP

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

The Dolphin Flag 02 Nov 23 3.25pm

Well done Roy Hodgson!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Nov 23 3.28pm

Well done to Roy for holding his hands up and admitting his error. Many PL managers have too big an ego for that. Of course we'll really know how he feels by his actions.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 02 Nov 23 6.21pm

Just to add my twopenneth, I agree that Roy recovered the situation well in his presser today.

I know there was a lot of speculation about how he'd referred to the three young subs, but I believe he genuinely has faith in their development and he spoke those words out of frustration very shortly after a tough game.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

eritheagle Flag Erith 02 Nov 23 6.32pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Just to add my twopenneth, I agree that Roy recovered the situation well in his presser today.

I know there was a lot of speculation about how he'd referred to the three young subs, but I believe he genuinely has faith in their development and he spoke those words out of frustration very shortly after a tough game.

Totally agree!!! I saw it as him challenging them to establish themselves in the first team but due to frustration of losing he didn’t convey the message very well.

 

palaceexile Flag hastings 02 Nov 23 6.58pm

Takes a big man to apologise like this - good on him.
I have often felt that Roy is clumsy in his choice of words at press conferences. I suspect he didn't mean to say what he said - it just came out wrong.
He needs to be a bit more cautious in his choice of words in future (although I never thought I'd find myself urging Roy to be even more cautious than he already is!)

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 02 Nov 23 7.03pm

Well done Roy

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 02 Nov 23 7.11pm

That's pretty much what I said (see below) is Roy reading my posts - I'm wasted - LOL..!!

COYP

IMHO - Roy’s comments were unnecessarily negative - especially in a media environment..!!

What he should have said is something like “the premier league is tough, especially when you are playing a team at the top the of table and our younger players will learn from today’s experience” - same connotation - but without the negativity..!!

I get he may be frustrated with injuries and lack of investment - but there’s a time and a place to make those feelings known - and the full glare of the media wasn’t either the time or the place..!!

Conversely - this is the same Roy that has consistently ignored/discounted younger talent over his “favourite” under performing elder “more experienced” players - prime example - why was Riedewald in Fridays squad over Ozoh..??

Beyond that he has now got to pick these players up and motivate them…!!

In summary inappropriate comments at the wrong time to the wrong audience - not something you would expect from a Manager of Roy’s experience..!!

COYP

 

glazedallover Flag Allier 02 Nov 23 7.23pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

That's pretty much what I said (see below) is Roy reading my posts - I'm wasted - LOL..!!

COYP

IMHO - Roy’s comments were unnecessarily negative - especially in a media environment..!!

What he should have said is something like “the premier league is tough, especially when you are playing a team at the top the of table and our younger players will learn from today’s experience” - same connotation - but without the negativity..!!

I get he may be frustrated with injuries and lack of investment - but there’s a time and a place to make those feelings known - and the full glare of the media wasn’t either the time or the place..!!

Conversely - this is the same Roy that has consistently ignored/discounted younger talent over his “favourite” under performing elder “more experienced” players - prime example - why was Riedewald in Fridays squad over Ozoh..??

Beyond that he has now got to pick these players up and motivate them…!!

In summary inappropriate comments at the wrong time to the wrong audience - not something you would expect from a Manager of Roy’s experience..!!

COYP

No it isn't .

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 02 Nov 23 7.37pm

Originally posted by glazedallover

No it isn't .

Not sure how you come to that conclusion..!!

Pretty much everything I mentioned is in Roy's presser - but just phrased in a different way..!!

Anyway - it was only a tongue in cheek remark, so don't wet yourself over it - well done Roy it takes a big man to admit they were wrong..

COYP

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Nov 23 7.56pm

Well it can be put to bed now. He made his thoughts public on the night. Now he is man enough to admit he was wrong to have done that , hurting the sensibilities of the players, and as it turns out quite a few fans.
He still only says he believes in the potential of all of our young players , including those that were the subject of his original comments. It looks like he is back in full diplomatic mode.
The way he made his comments became the debate. But maybe it should have been about just how good are even the best of our younger group , and should the club have ended up with three or four on the bench ,against some of the best teams in Europe?

 

Charles Flag Forest Hill 03 Nov 23 2.01pm

I haven't read all this thread but after my initial shock at Roy's exceedingly out of character remarks I concluded that it was a lot more measured than it might have sounded and a tactic to try and tip JRS over the very narrow threshold from exciting prospect to successful Premier league player- whatever Roy may have subsequently said which to my mind is part of the same narrative. Expressing disappountment is also betraying reasonable expectation. If Roy thinks JRS just needs to deal with a mindset issue to crack it, his form says he's probably right and also that he's good at helping players with that sort of thing. Let's all hope so. Burnley offer a defence much like those many of us thought JRS needed a year in the Championship to practice against.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 03 Nov 23 5.15pm

Originally posted by Charles

I haven't read all this thread but after my initial shock at Roy's exceedingly out of character remarks I concluded that it was a lot more measured than it might have sounded and a tactic to try and tip JRS over the very narrow threshold from exciting prospect to successful Premier league player- whatever Roy may have subsequently said which to my mind is part of the same narrative. Expressing disappountment is also betraying reasonable expectation. If Roy thinks JRS just needs to deal with a mindset issue to crack it, his form says he's probably right and also that he's good at helping players with that sort of thing. Let's all hope so. Burnley offer a defence much like those many of us thought JRS needed a year in the Championship to practice against.

JRS just needs to put on his shooting boots and let fly more often. He is so nearly there. Split second decision. Listen to Olise and copy. "Got the ball. Shot. Scored." Simple!!


Edited by dreamwaverider (03 Nov 2023 5.15pm)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 03 Nov 23 8.06pm

Having watched the whole press conference following the outrage I don't think there was much to see.

Fair play to Roy for apologising but I'd love to be a fly on the wall when he discussed it with SP.

I love the assumption that these boys are delicate little chaps who need an arm round them from nasty old Roy. I'd hazard a guess that they're lairy f***ers with plenty to say who've had smoke blown up their arses by some tinpot agent and other cronies.

 

VSEagle215 Flag New York 11 Nov 23 10.29pm

Hoping to hear how he called out Hughes today who was terrible defensively all match. Had that been a young player vs Everton would not hear the end of it.

 

Page 7 of 8 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy's comments