You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread
November 16 2026 3.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Everton match thread


Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 11 Nov 23 8.19pm

Originally posted by Gribbo

Apparently Roy did not want to buy Franca, so chooses not to play him. Only interested in defending, 0-0 is a good result and every now and then we will nick a goal for the win. Problem with Roy's tactics is there is no Plan B when we go a goal behind.

Time for the old fella to go I am afraid. Don't want more of this for the rest of the season.

I’m not dismissing this at all Gribbo but that was the astonishing thing about today. We conceded two from crosses into the box at the beginning of each half and one from faffing with the ball at the back, deep, and 5mins from the 90 mark.

I couldn’t see the game plan today beyond some sort or generic, halfhearted Palace performance. You’d like to see something representing a game plan for the opposition and to concede two headers immediately at the start of both halves against a Sean Dyche side is just ridiculous. We also seemed to lack any urgency against a team any armchair fan could tell you will pack the boxes, get it out wide to swing it in and try and hassle you as opposed to play any brilliant football.

Everton have been a mess for a while but they still have some decent players. I wouldn’t mind so much but we lost to a Sean Dyche side, who scored 3 Sean Dyche goals against us at home and were allowed to do so as though this was completely unexpected.

It was poor, really poor. I put this one squarely on Roy and it isn’t the typical moan about him nor characteristic of me to do so.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

CT Charlie Flag 11 Nov 23 8.41pm

My theories:

1) If we had played Richards and/or Clyne instead of Ward for the entire season, we would have conceded fewer goals.

2) If Rak-Sakyi had played instead of Edouard for the entire season, we would have scored more goals.

Neither Richards/Clyne nor JRS are brilliant solutions, but the former would have been beaten less often, and the latter would have made more of the opportunities that Edouard (and Mateta) have been given.

 

BrentisBack Flag Beckenham 11 Nov 23 8.46pm

Gutted about today. They had three shots and scored. Which is worrying. Eze was incredible on the ball. Lermar was class and I thought that the whole team were in fairness. Olise looked great when he came on.
Onwards and upwards.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 11 Nov 23 8.49pm

Bah, what is there to say that hasn't been said before? it's the same old s***...

 

Paaalaaace Flag Croydon 11 Nov 23 9.27pm

I dislike Pickford, but where would Everton be without him....don't think they would have won today without him.
Edouard may have scored, but he is a hard watch.
Thought we look pretty good today apart from 3 defensive mistakes.

 

Paaalaaace Flag Croydon 11 Nov 23 9.33pm

And what was the issue with HF today....didn't get what was with the banner complaining about Croydon Council.....did the Council confiscate their drum 1st half?

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Nov 23 9.36pm

Originally posted by BrentisBack

Gutted about today. They had three shots and scored. Which is worrying. Eze was incredible on the ball. Lermar was class and I thought that the whole team were in fairness. Olise looked great when he came on.
Onwards and upwards.

Thought we were really good today. Ridiculous first minute and first 5 minutes of the second half.
Have t seen their goals yet on tele , but thought everyone, apart from Eduard first half , done well.
Eze was great and Hughes really good.
Everton did to us , what we’ve been doing to teams for 10 years. They had a lot less possession and quality, but won the game.
Enjoyed the way we played today, play like that all season and we will see some good games.
Olise back, massive plus.

 

PatrickA Flag London 11 Nov 23 10.01pm

In a sense it's pretty futile to complain about Edouard.
He is not going to bully defenders, get in front off them or close them down at speed.
He is not going to win headers, outrun defenders or generally make a nuisance of himself.
It seems he's been asked to perform a role as lone target man that he's ill equipped to perform.
Therefore, the choice seems to be you either leave him out and play Ayew down the middle (in the knowledge that he'd at least perform some of the tasks) or you change the tactics to suit Edouard (if that's possible).
Edouard will score the occasional goal, but this doesn't compensate for the lack of contribution he makes in other areas.
This may sound harsh, but surely after all this time Edouard is not going to change the way he plays the game .

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 11 Nov 23 10.03pm

Originally posted by Painter

Olise came on in 69th minute. Franca isnt ready for the first team, whats the point of throwing him in. Olise was given little game time initially.


WOW one sub at 69th minute when we was behind

How do you know Franca isn't ready and how is a player suppose to be ready sitting on bench.

You do come out with so much tosh Painter constantly defending the club.


Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Well, Edouard was a liability first half, all the good work we did fell apart around him. We desperately need to get rid of both him and Mateta, bring in a decent striker and hope that Franca can turn into a goal scorer at PL level.

Again more nonsense.

How many clear chances did Palace create (birds chirping while waiting)

The whole game we had only 4 shots on target.

Originally posted by Paaalaaace

I dislike Pickford, but where would Everton be without him....don't think they would have won today without him.
Edouard may have scored, but he is a hard watch.
Thought we look pretty good today apart from 3 defensive mistakes.

Hardly he made 3 saves throughout the full game.

Palace lack proper movement too many players want to stand around ball to feet and why we don't like putting balls into the box is odd one all the other teams do this yet we want to come into center all the time.

I look back at when we had inferior players and played better attacking football with quick counter attacking football which was direct or via crosses

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

Gribbo Flag Bromley 11 Nov 23 10.24pm

Have you watched Franca in the U-21 games? He ain't all that.

 

VSEagle215 Flag New York 11 Nov 23 10.25pm

Cannot wait for season to be over already. Hodgson sucks the life out of me. Appointment made no sense except to stay up and the football is incredibly boring. We never beat Everton, except under Vieira. It is 15th or 16th this season at best. What a complete waste of a season.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 11 Nov 23 11.19pm

I know how grateful we have to be being in the top flight. I know we're a small skint club. Yet I still find being beaten by teams like Everton, so often, depresses me.

Is this really the best we can ever hope for?

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 11 Nov 23 11.31pm

Doucoure seems to have been missed today, and our defence looked vulnerable when Everton had the ball.

Conceding a goal that early is unforgivable and conceding a goal that late is rubbish too. This is a point dropped.

We now need a big win at Luton, who are not that bad of late.

I don't think Parish will spend money in January because he probably thinks that we will be OK.
It's clear that we need another striker, two backs and another winger. I'm not sure that we will be too far away from the bottom if we keep leaking goals like we did today.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Nov 2023 11.32pm)

 

Wilbraham413 Flag 12 Nov 23 3.01am

Edouard is like Benteke, in that he is abject sh-t, but will be playing for us for the next 5 years. I can't imagine a future where OE will not be our starting striker every match.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Elpis Flag In a pub 12 Nov 23 7.08am

Well first off it wasn't a bad game of football .We poked and probed as the home side ,Everton played the away game we are all too familiar with .

The goals conceded were poor ,no excuses there but Everton would probably say the same about our second . How Eze didn't get a second penalty is beyond me , the VAR which I hate can take three minutes looking at every goal from every angle before its confirmed but seemingly can't see a clear foul . That would/could have put our noses in front and we are then looking at a different game .

Wasn't our day as is often the case against these but it could be so much much better with the addition of a couple of players and a fit Doucoure .

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 7.32am

Edouard is our top scorer in a low scoring side, instructed to play negative defensive football. Excepting Olise, we have no real width, the full backs don't get up in support that often.
Edouard has 6 thus far, a few by anticipating the ball being put into the box from (surprise) wide areas.
Don't have a go at Edouard or Ayew for not scoring enough, the way the team is instructed to play by Hodgson means they are feeding on scraps.
A big test at Luton coming up, then on to West Ham and Bournemouth, before a difficult set of fixtures into the new year. Hodgson gone by then? It's a possibility - games thus far: Won 4 Drawn 3 Lost 5.
Not top ten material, and after the December fixtures probably we'll sit around 14th or below.


Edited by southnorwoodhill (12 Nov 2023 8.51am)

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 12 Nov 23 8.01am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Edouard is our top scorer in a low scoring side, instructed to play negative defensive football. Excepting Olise, we have no real width, the full backs don't get up in support that often.
Edouard has 6 thus far, a few by anticipating the ball being put into the box from (surprise) wide areas.
Don't have a go at Edouard or Ayew for not scoring enough, the way the team is instructed to play by Hodgson means they are feeding on scraps.
A big test at Luton coming up, then on to West Ham and Bournemouth, before a difficult set of fixtures into the new year. Hodgson gone by then? It's a possibility - games thus far: Won 4 Drawn 3 Lost 5.
Not top ten material, and after the December fixtures probably we'll sit around 14th or below.

I think we can have a go at Edouard as he had plenty of chances yesterday and does every week to hold the ball up and pass it to another one of his team. He fails constantly but we have no replacement for him in Hodgson’s eyes? If you look at the first goal yesterday you will see he failed to control a ball to him which then came back into our box. There was then mistakes by our defence but it was his initial misscontrol which started our downfall. He also doesn’t have any pace as showed when Eza put him through a few times. Not just knocking him as other individuals yesterday made mistakes including fan’s favourite Olise when he came on, especially with that last free kick which ballooned over. It wasn’t a typical tight Hodgson performance and that may be because our midfield was weak yesterday without Dacoure? His replacement Hughes wasn’t good enough and Lerma didn’t have a good game either. It was a typical Dyche team performance and we made more mistakes than them. Their defence throughout the team was better than ours with fewer errors. We need a forward badly to do all the things Edouard can’t including the one thing he can and that’s also being able to score. Certainly not knocking the 6 goals he has scored already but his overall play isn’t good enough at this level in my opinion?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 12 Nov 23 8.05am

Originally posted by Paaalaaace

And what was the issue with HF today....didn't get what was with the banner complaining about Croydon Council.....did the Council confiscate their drum 1st half?

Apparently they banned them from using flags etc. Police were deployed to stop them having access to the store room. It seems a long running battle with the Council who seem to want them stoped. I would have thought what goes on in the ground is up to the club and Police.

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 12 Nov 23 8.06am

Olise and Eze back, put Ayew up front and ditch Edouarde

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 12 Nov 23 8.17am

Originally posted by palace chick

I think we can have a go at Edouard as he had plenty of chances yesterday and does every week to hold the ball up and pass it to another one of his team. He fails constantly but we have no replacement for him in Hodgson’s eyes? If you look at the first goal yesterday you will see he failed to control a ball to him which then came back into our box. There was then mistakes by our defence but it was his initial misscontrol which started our downfall. He also doesn’t have any pace as showed when Eza put him through a few times. Not just knocking him as other individuals yesterday made mistakes including fan’s favourite Olise when he came on, especially with that last free kick which ballooned over. It wasn’t a typical tight Hodgson performance and that may be because our midfield was weak yesterday without Dacoure? His replacement Hughes wasn’t good enough and Lerma didn’t have a good game either. It was a typical Dyche team performance and we made more mistakes than them. Their defence throughout the team was better than ours with fewer errors. We need a forward badly to do all the things Edouard can’t including the one thing he can and that’s also being able to score. Certainly not knocking the 6 goals he has scored already but his overall play isn’t good enough at this level in my opinion?

Edouard isn't a hold up man, let's be frank. He's like that goal hanging kid in the playground and other parts of the game are not his forte. Surely Hodgson sees this and should adapt the tactics accordingly? And yet he's our top scorer at the same time?

 

Page 7 of 11 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Everton match thread