You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread


Page 7 of 16 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 25 Nov 23 5.44pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Actually, if you look at our squad, we only have circa 6 players who can truly say are first eleven quality, the rest just make up the numbers and probably would struggle in a championship side. Parish has just lost it, the manager can only shuffle around the pack of cards he has and frankly some of those are just not good enough for regular first team football in the EPL. Changing the manager will not solve the problem!

I make you right, I’ll raise you 7 though, Johnstone, Joa, Guehi, Lerma, Doucoure, Eze and Olise

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 25 Nov 23 5.44pm

It seems I was watching a different game. I thought we were unlucky. We lost 2 key players at almost the same time, yet still maintained our ascendancy. We had a good goal ruled out for an unlucky handball, scored a wonderful equaliser but made a defensive error to concede again.

The pressure at the end so nearly yielded results. The only reason it didn’t was luck.

Luton didn’t beat us. They are a poor side. Luck beat us. Play that another 10 times and we would win most of them.

That’s football.

Olise was outstanding.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Nov 23 5.45pm

Originally posted by kennybrowns leftfoot

No words really.. Its all very familiar from when Roy was last in charge. Imagine playing in that team and looking to the bench for some inspiration and a weathered, down trodden looking 76 year old elderly male is staring back at you... Thing is I don't blame Roy.. I blame our board.

We are a poor side that happens to have 3 or 4 very talented individuals in it. What's even more concerning is that this will definitely be Eze and Guehi last season with us and you can guarantee we won't replace them.

I said it the other week we will finish between 17th and 13th but our board and some on here will be more than happy with that.

Totally agree. That's about the amount that could play for higher placed clubs and do something with their careers. The others are treading water or going through the motions to collect what is in effect, easy money. Reason? No competition for places, firstly because the squad is paper thin, and secondly because the current manager has his favourites anyway, no matter how abysmally they play week in week out.
I recall Roy's debacle against Iceland - had the cream of England's crop to choose from, ends up with Hart, Cahill, and Smalling, with Dier in the centre of midfield. They too came unstuck against a team of limited ability but with plenty of va va voom.
Roy has the uncanny ability to take the joy out of the game, after a little while it starts to show, and we are at that point now.

 

Pinkfluff1981 Flag 25 Nov 23 5.46pm

Whilst possibly a lot of it not Roy’s fault he has to shift the dead wood . Ward shclupp and sorry but how did will hughes get professional . Stick some young un proven talent on . We literally have nothing to lose . At least the need to impress will be there . Shocking really same old . Like someone else said Roy is cheap and a safe bet for a s*** finish but another year in the prem. have some ambition parish ffs and yes my grammar is poor I am beer eyed

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 25 Nov 23 5.47pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Actually, if you look at our squad, we only have circa 6 players who can truly say are first eleven quality, the rest just make up the numbers and probably would struggle in a championship side. Parish has just lost it, the manager can only shuffle around the pack of cards he has and frankly some of those are just not good enough for regular first team football in the EPL. Changing the manager will not solve the problem!

So what does need to change because what is happening is not working.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 25 Nov 23 5.56pm

People saying we haven't got that many good players, well, how many do Luton have? They are assembled off a shoestring and freebies. We didn't just lose to Liverpool. The forwards seemingly had no plan. There were no obvious tactics at play. No overloads. No-one got tight on Barkley when he was clearly running the show for them. The subs were like for like with no change to the shape. We created chances because Luton aren't very good. I'm sorry but sometimes the manager is to blame.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Nov 23 6.03pm

Originally posted by askyourself

Okay, I'll bite on the bait....
So it's Roy's fault that we lost that, is it ???
Blame him for their keeper's saves from our players?
Blame him for the mix-up between two international players for their winner?
Blame him for injuries?
Blame him for J-PM being unable to do anything football?
To be polite, I'll just say that I disagree strongly.

I was annoyed at Roy’s return but for apparentl different reasons to most. He must’ve wanted to come (can make his own decisions) but you could foresee the lack of spending and struggle therefore I thought it was unfair on him especially after all he’s done for us.

That said, we’ve shipped 5 in the last two games against sides in the relegation zone who’ve a singular method of playing football as a result of it being the only option available to them.

Screaming ‘Roy Out’ completely misses the point, or a lot of it, as to why things are sh!t but is not a sentiment without any substance whatsoever - he’s the head coach. Things such as missed chances, injuries, mix-ups etc are something managers have to deal with. We’ve looked tactically bereft, without identity, low on morale and therefore lacking in intensity, effort and purpose the last two games against poor opposition, leading to two very disappointing and worrying losses.

The manager does not get a free pass unless we assume all footballing matters are determined completely separately to them. Part of the job is to remove, reduce or mitigate for such things.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

PatrickA Flag London 25 Nov 23 6.05pm

1) The side has a soft underbelly and lacks steel
2) Conceding 5 goals v Everton and Luton is unacceptable and any side playing direct and physical football against us will fancy their chances (n.b West Ham next ).
Fortunately Burnley don’t play that way so we got some joy there.
3) As we score so few goals and are so blunt in attack we will find it impossible to get results if we don’t tighten up defensively.
This is an assessment of our current form, rather than an attempt to apportion blame. Others can consider this aspect if so inclined.
There are plenty of games to play before the January transfer window which we will have to prepare for , and there’s no guarantee we’ll strengthen then in any event.
We just have to find a way with existing resources.

 

XKudu Flag The Midlands, England 25 Nov 23 6.09pm

Give Roy a gutsy little English striker like Andrew Johnson who can make darting runs, gets stuck in and find the back of net and we will finish 8th. Surely there’s someone like that in the lower leagues? I’m 57 and retired. Pay my expenses Mr Parish and I’ll scour the leagues and find you someone.

Edited by XKudu (25 Nov 2023 6.09pm)

 

Croydon-Trucker Flag 25 Nov 23 6.12pm

Originally posted by XKudu

I feel sorry for Roy as it must be soul destroying to look at our current strikers who are average at best. They aren’t even good let alone excellent. Parish and Freedman must take responsibility for not signing anyone decent up front. How long have we been saying this?? Our pleas for Right Back are also becoming embarrassingly repetitive but they seem intent on muddling through with Ward who is just too old and too slow.

To be honest we deserve to be a place or two below are current table position.

I’ll keep the faith but if there are no signings in January we will get relegated… And please no more keepers or midfield players.

I doubt very much if there wll be any signings in the Jan window unless we sell a big player for us , which we cant afford to do . I think we will be very luck to come out of this up and coming window with the player we have because if we sell i wouldnt trust the board to re invest in the team they would rather invest in the new stand .

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 25 Nov 23 6.13pm

Eze's injury record thus far suggests he is prone to them, which means that his transfer value may not be as high as some folks on here think. Yet without his creative ability we don't have any alternative to open up opposition defences. Olise is one such player, surrounded by donkeys...

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 25 Nov 23 6.15pm

Didn't see the match. From what's posted it sounds like we were complete sh1te. Yet the stats reveal that we had 61% possession. We had 16 shots of which 8 were on target, whereas Luton had 8 shots of which 3 were on target.

The stats seem to show that maybe we were a tad unlucky?

What can't be questioned is the huge problem we have again with injuries.

In some of the upcoming games, which we'll lose, why the hell not give some of our "not ready" players a chance to step up to the plate?

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

taylors lovechild Flag 25 Nov 23 6.16pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I was annoyed at Roy’s return but for apparentl different reasons to most. He must’ve wanted to come (can make his own decisions) but you could foresee the lack of spending and struggle therefore I thought it was unfair on him especially after all he’s done for us.

That said, we’ve shipped 5 in the last two games against sides in the relegation zone who’ve a singular method of playing football as a result of it being the only option available to them.

Screaming ‘Roy Out’ completely misses the point, or a lot of it, as to why things are sh!t but is not a sentiment without any substance whatsoever - he’s the head coach. Things such as missed chances, injuries, mix-ups etc are something managers have to deal with. We’ve looked tactically bereft, without identity, low on morale and therefore lacking in intensity, effort and purpose the last two games against poor opposition, leading to two very disappointing and worrying losses.

The manager does not get a free pass unless we assume all footballing matters are determined completely separately to them. Part of the job is to remove, reduce or mitigate for such things.

I agree with what you say, but I also don't understand when players are not performing Roy does nothing to change it. He hasn't even tried to see if Chris Richards might be the answer at right-back (he has the height and more pace than Ward and is a better passer). He hasn't given Ahamada more time when he clearly has more energy and speed than Hughes who again was at fault for not stopping one of the goals. He hasn't given Franca more than a cameo even when like today we needed some magic. He just throws JPM on around the 75 minute mark and starts launching balls at him. There's no seemingly no ideas or experimentation. It's boring, it's not working and I'm fed up. The hope seems to be hang in there and hope Eze or Olise do something.


 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 25 Nov 23 6.18pm

Originally posted by Crystal_Clear

Well, well, well, if those injuries are as bad as they seemed we will be missing Eze and Doucoure for quite a while.

No surprise we lost after that, our squad depth is poor and especially awful in offensive areas.

Once again it comes back to some exceptionally ridiculous transfer business in the summer, and massive amount of money wasted.

Franca is a luxury we simply cannot afford. 2 tied up in a player who is not ready for the PL and may not even make the grade on PL. Alright for the big clubs to take gamble but not is.

Freedman and Parish must have been gambling on getting no injuries.

I think we are going to have to sell Guehi in January, generate some funds and increase the quality of the squad. Trouble is after the summer would the fans trust the club not waste the money again ?

Not looking forward to the Christmas run in that's for sure.

I don’t know how you can be sure Franca isn’t ready for the PL when he can’t get on the pitch. Clearly Roy doesn’t think he’s good enough but let’s be honest he’s not renowned for giving new signings a chance. If we keep losing and the manager changes nothing he has to be part of the problem.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 25 Nov 23 6.19pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It seems I was watching a different game. I thought we were unlucky. We lost 2 key players at almost the same time, yet still maintained our ascendancy. We had a good goal ruled out for an unlucky handball, scored a wonderful equaliser but made a defensive error to concede again.

The pressure at the end so nearly yielded results. The only reason it didn’t was luck.

Luton didn’t beat us. They are a poor side. Luck beat us. Play that another 10 times and we would win most of them.

That’s football.

Olise was outstanding.

What game were you watching - we were awful..!!

Same old Roy playing his favourites not giving youth a chance..!!

If anyone says Ward is worthy of his place ahead of Richards I will do my cannister - bloke can't run and can't pass and is still playing week in week out and Captain - its getting beyond a joke..!!

We had some injuries - but Roy brings on Hughes - we already know he ain't prem standard - why not give Ozoh a go - but not even deemed worthy a place on the bench..!!

Whenever is Roy ever going to give Franca a go - no sticks with Schlupp - I'm still not sure what he is but whatever he is he definitely ain't left sided attacking player..!!

I backed Roy to stay for another season after the backend of last season - but I'm seriously beginning to doubt that now think he is just reverting to Roy of old and our performances are reflecting it..!!

Today was just woefully poor and anyone who says otherwise are just kidding themselves..!!

Today was embarrassingly poor..!!

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 25 Nov 23 6.20pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I agree with what you say, but I also don't understand when players are not performing Roy does nothing to change it. He hasn't even tried to see if Chris Richards might be the answer at right-back (he has the height and more pace than Ward and is a better passer). He hasn't given Ahamada more time when he clearly has more energy and speed than Hughes who again was at fault for not stopping one of the goals. He hasn't given Franca more than a cameo even when like today we needed some magic. He just throws JPM on around the 75 minute mark and starts launching balls at him. There's no seemingly no ideas or experimentation. It's boring, it's not working and I'm fed up. The hope seems to be hang in there and hope Eze or Olise do something.

Agree with all of this!


 

fishbone Flag London 25 Nov 23 6.21pm

This lost really hurts!!

 

YT Flag Oxford 25 Nov 23 6.23pm

Originally posted by YT

Well, aside from a debate over the merits of Ayew and Clyne, this ought to be thereabout the strongest XI we can muster this side of the window. So if this ain't good enough, it may be a long hard winter!

No extra comment needed from me.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 25 Nov 23 6.26pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

I agree with what you say, but I also don't understand when players are not performing Roy does nothing to change it. He hasn't even tried to see if Chris Richards might be the answer at right-back (he has the height and more pace than Ward and is a better passer). He hasn't given Ahamada more time when he clearly has more energy and speed than Hughes who again was at fault for not stopping one of the goals. He hasn't given Franca more than a cameo even when like today we needed some magic. He just throws JPM on around the 75 minute mark and starts launching balls at him. There's no seemingly no ideas or experimentation. It's boring, it's not working and I'm fed up. The hope seems to be hang in there and hope Eze or Olise do something.


Yep, completely agree TL.

We can’t of spent all that money on Franca (and nobody else) because he’s incapable of playing in the first team, Ahamada at least looks to have some energy, I quite like him, and when fit Richards is a very good player.

Roy’s rigidity is what provokes the questions, at least when it is not working. On another thread I stressed over the possibility that this game would be tight when potentially it didn’t have to be. Roy’s tactic of keeping things tight and hoping we nick a goal may seem effective against the top teams but against teams we’re clearly superior to in quality it leaves the door open for these type of results.

If you can’t come up with a different tactic for Luton than you do for Man City, you’re just as likely to lose as we did today as beat city like we have before. Stressful and baffling.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 25 Nov 23 6.27pm

Originally posted by askyourself

Okay, I'll bite on the bait....
So it's Roy's fault that we lost that, is it ???
Blame him for their keeper's saves from our players?
Blame him for the mix-up between two international players for their winner?
Blame him for injuries?
Blame him for J-PM being unable to do anything football?
To be polite, I'll just say that I disagree strongly.

I managed to watch most of the game on an illicit stream that kept breaking up and I agree with you. Roy has had his day and we need to find a new, young head coach, but the players must take responsibility for such a poor performance. I have stood by Ward in the past, but he was outplayed today.

Losing Eze and Doucoure through injury had a huge impact and I thought Luton were treacherous and played some reckless football.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Page 7 of 16 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Luton vs Crystal Palace match thread