You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Brighton match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Crystal Palace v Brighton match thread


Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Croydon-Trucker Flag 22 Dec 23 8.06am

Originally posted by Eaglehamster

Ah you're all spoilt. We've played 9 won 1 at home, what more do you want? Two?

Agreed a bunch of spoilt baby bed wetters 2 wins !!! Unheard of . Go support Man City . Happy Christmas Everyone and raise a glass for all the ones who have gone before us .

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Dec 23 8.15am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

The board know Roy, if they give him money to spend in January the likelihood is he won’t play them any way! Whats the point, they’ll wait until the new manager comes in. Roy’s so odd with new players

The board don't give Roy money to spend at all. The board buy players for him and it seems like if he doesn't like the players that have been forced on him he just doesn't play them

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Dec 23 8.32am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The board don't give Roy money to spend at all. The board buy players for him and it seems like if he doesn't like the players that have been forced on him he just doesn't play them

Roy only has one mission, and that is to keep the team up. He sees the season as a whole rather than game by game.

All we have to do is finish above three teams. He will be looking to get 38 points, and we are almost half way there.
The only really poor result we have had, given the form and quality of other teams is Luton. We have had a great draw at city and a win at United.

The bottom line is that we have had a lot of injuries to key players and are still on target to stay up. Critics of Roy should ask themselves who else we could attract to the club with anything like his quality and experience.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 22 Dec 23 8.36am

Originally posted by Painter

If he didnt bring Eze on, people would complain. You cant win as a manager everyone thinks they could do a better job than you, especially with hindsight.

My thoughts exactly, before the game everyone was complaining that Roy hadn't started the youngsters and put Hughes in - after the games its - 'why did you bring them on?'.

Hughes came off for Ozoh to give more legs to the midfield as Brighton were swarming us. As for Eze, he decided the game really.. He scores the easiest of tap ins and we win, instead he gives the ball away needlessly and we draw. As always in this league, its fine margins..

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Dec 23 8.40am

Brighton didn't have a fit full back, were without their top goalscorer from last season, the forward from Barcelona and one of their centre halves.
They still managed to play football at a different level to us. a They started with two 19 year olds and brought on an 18 year old in the second half who changed the game.
They played on the front foot with incisive forward passes and made a number of tactical tweaks during the game which had a positive impact on their game.
In contrast we constantly played the ball sideways and backwards, kept players behind the ball and were utterly predictable.
The difference in coaching,approach to the game and use of young players was marked.

When Roy left last time he said it was the right time to go as the club had new young players who needed a fresh face to take the club forward.
In my view I think we are at that stage again.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 22 Dec 23 8.55am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Brighton didn't have a fit full back, were without their top goalscorer from last season, the forward from Barcelona and one of their centre halves.
They still managed to play football at a different level to us. a They started with two 19 year olds and brought on an 18 year old in the second half who changed the game.
They played on the front foot with incisive forward passes and made a number of tactical tweaks during the game which had a positive impact on their game.
In contrast we constantly played the ball sideways and backwards, kept players behind the ball and were utterly predictable.
The difference in coaching,approach to the game and use of young players was marked.

When Roy left last time he said it was the right time to go as the club had new young players who needed a fresh face to take the club forward.
In my view I think we are at that stage again.

Zerbi said what I was saying earlier in the season, you play young players and you accept they will make mistakes and learn. I thought Ozoh was fine when he came on. Got a toe in on one occasion in the 18-yeard box to prevent them getting a shot away. Hughes was really struggling to keep up with the pace of the game in the second half so he had to come off. The issue was the whole midfield was chasing shadows. I was fine with Eze coming on, I just don't understand why he came on on the left. He has been brilliant since he moved to the middle. If you want to defend bring on Schlupp. I really hope Franca gets some minutes against Chelsea as after a great cameo it'd be a shame if Roy puts him back in his box of unused tools. To finish on a positive it's great to see an understanding developing between Olise and JPM.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 22 Dec 23 8.56am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

Roy only has one mission, and that is to keep the team up. He sees the season as a whole rather than game by game.

All we have to do is finish above three teams. He will be looking to get 38 points, and we are almost half way there.
The only really poor result we have had, given the form and quality of other teams is Luton. We have had a great draw at city and a win at United.

The bottom line is that we have had a lot of injuries to key players and are still on target to stay up. Critics of Roy should ask themselves who else we could attract to the club with anything like his quality and experience.

Sensible post but it didn't reply to Midlands post.

Perhaps the Board doesn't mind Roy not playing those who don't fit within his scheme. Roy is only holding us in place till the new management arrive. They will have the option to field the newbies.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Dec 23 9.02am

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Just got home and I know someone must have asked but I'm gonna ask anyway. Can anyone explain the reason for taking off Ayew and playing a half fit Eze out of position? This is nothing to do with Eze missing an open goal of gifting then an equaliser, it's about giving up the ball for the last half hour and hoping to hang on. It never works. If Ayew had to go off and we all know he didn't, then Schlupp or Ahamada would have made some sense, but not Eze. For once I would have been happy for Roy to make no subs in all honesty. Ozoh is gonna be great for us, but bringing on a holding midfielder for the more advanced playing Hughes was a clear signal of, we hold what we have. One of the worst halves of Football I've ever seen. Two points thrown away.

Hughes had been booked and Brighton were starting to cut through our midfield. So to me that one made sense. It may also have brought some people down to earth re Ozoh as I thought he struggled last night in comparison to Saturday - still work in progress.

I agree re Ayew - I think there was an expectation from Roy that Eze would get us more possession and offer a different kind of threat. Ebs looked well off the pace. If Schlupp had been introduced, I can imagine the amount of moaning that would have generated on here.

I think it was the classic game of two halves. We deserved to have our noses in front at half time and tactically were sound. Brighton moved the ball quicker in the second half and we struggled to stay with them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Robk Flag 22 Dec 23 9.06am

Contrary to what a few were saying Clyne kept Mitoma relatively quiet...I like Ozoh think he’ll develope into a top player.. pity Franca didn’t come on in place of Eze... Mateta had another good match and provided Eze with a golden opportunity which he surprisingly fluffed....

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 22 Dec 23 9.08am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

The board don't give Roy money to spend at all. The board buy players for him and it seems like if he doesn't like the players that have been forced on him he just doesn't play them

This is true of course, however that’s the model of the modern game. His approach to talent is outdated just like his playing style and management imo.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Dec 23 9.37am

Originally posted by PatrickA

Brighton didn't have a fit full back, were without their top goalscorer from last season, the forward from Barcelona and one of their centre halves.
They still managed to play football at a different level to us. a They started with two 19 year olds and brought on an 18 year old in the second half who changed the game.
They played on the front foot with incisive forward passes and made a number of tactical tweaks during the game which had a positive impact on their game.
In contrast we constantly played the ball sideways and backwards, kept players behind the ball and were utterly predictable.
The difference in coaching,approach to the game and use of young players was marked.

When Roy left last time he said it was the right time to go as the club had new young players who needed a fresh face to take the club forward.
In my view I think we are at that stage again.

Agreed. Judging by a number of comments on this site, some think that there are 3 worse clubs than us, and Hodgson is a safe pair of hands until the end of the season as we won't be going down in any case. If this is so why wait that long? Replace him now and let's get on with it, give the new manager the remainder of the season to settle his outlook and the close season to fully prepare.
I think of PV and his dismissal when the club were 12th, and compare it to Hodgson's record thus far this season, and have to conclude that Parish is not as straight up as he wishes us to believe.

 

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 22 Dec 23 10.36am

1 home win so far this season.

Next 5 home PL games:

Brentford (No Toney, Mbuemo, Mee)
Sheffield United
Chelsea
Burnley
Luton

There has to be 10 points minimum from that. If there isn't then we are going to be right in it.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 22 Dec 23 10.54am

Originally posted by ambrose7

1 home win so far this season.

Next 5 home PL games:

Brentford (No Toney, Mbuemo, Mee)
Sheffield United
Chelsea
Burnley
Luton

There has to be 10 points minimum from that. If there isn't then we are going to be right in it.

Should be rather than has to be

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 22 Dec 23 11.01am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Agreed. Judging by a number of comments on this site, some think that there are 3 worse clubs than us, and Hodgson is a safe pair of hands until the end of the season as we won't be going down in any case. If this is so why wait that long? Replace him now and let's get on with it, give the new manager the remainder of the season to settle his outlook and the close season to fully prepare.
I think of PV and his dismissal when the club were 12th, and compare it to Hodgson's record thus far this season, and have to conclude that Parish is not as straight up as he wishes us to believe.

Which new manager would this be ?

If it’s Cooper then I’m struggling to see the attraction. Just my opinion of course.

He’s the only one being spoken seriously about in the media probably due to the facts that he was previously interviewed and is available immediately. I would hope that a better candidate is on our radar but not available until next summer.

So if it’s not going to be Cooper now, the worse three clubs argument comes into play if the club are waiting for their preferred man.

PV’s dismissal is not a fair comparison given what we now know about his management style and the lack of quality coaching staff that he brought in.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Croydon-Trucker Flag 22 Dec 23 11.07am

Originally posted by ambrose7

1 home win so far this season.

Next 5 home PL games:

Brentford (No Toney, Mbuemo, Mee)
Sheffield United
Chelsea
Burnley
Luton

There has to be 10 points minimum from that. If there isn't then we are going to be right in it.

We should be winning all of these and i dont just mean at half time .

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 22 Dec 23 11.27am

We earned a point after losing our lead but perhaps if we'd come from behind to earn the same point people would have been happier?

Overall, we were too negative after being the better team in the first half. Next up (at home) ... Brentford.

Edited by Henry of Peckham (22 Dec 2023 11.28am)

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

Peter de Lisle Flag London 22 Dec 23 11.37am

I think responsibility has to lay at the door of those signing players. We really, really needed to strengthen our squad in specific areas in the summer. We didn't strengthen in those areas, and instead spent £20 MILLION on a keeper who is worse than Guaita (who had another year's contract but we allowed to leave for free), £20 odd million on a Brazilian reserve arriving with a stress fracture (?!) who can't get in our team, and £4m on a centre back we didn't need. How on earth can the people involved in transfers still be in jobs? The team needed full backs, wingers and a striker, and got none of the above, and what's worse, those in charge of transfers didn't utilise any loans to fill gaps. We can't use the excuse we didn't have any money, because £44m was spent on people that don't get in our team. How difficult is it to try and sign three or four of the best players from the Championship in positions we need for £5-10m each rather than frittering money in positions we didn't need people? If there is anyone in the recruitment/scouting/transfers team that reads these boards, please just consider actually strengthening the areas we clearly need to strengthen. We only have two strikers. We are desperately short on wingers (hence having to play non wingers on the wing). We have been desperately short on full backs for several years. Please stop signing players we don't need in positions we are covered with money that could be spent on strengthening the team where it desperately needs help.
If we don't have any money, fine, let's sign the best players we can possibly get on loan, free, or being opportunistic picking players up cheaply where contracts are running out.
Please stop signing players like Henderson for £20m odd and on £100k a week. It is brainless. ANY manager would struggle with the recruitment that Freedman et al are providing. I am THRILLED we aren't in the relegation zone and frankly Roy deserves incredible plaudits for the fact that we aren't. Come on Freedman et al. Wake up and do your job rather than waiting until transfer deadline day and wasting money on people we just don't need.

Edited by Peter de Lisle (22 Dec 2023 11.45am)

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 22 Dec 23 11.47am

My initial thoughts were that we were way too negative most of the second half. However, some have expressed the view that Brighton changed things up at half time, were too good for us and forced us onto the back foot.

Although Roy admitted the subs didn't have the impact he'd hoped we were crying out for Eze when he came on but unfortunately he fluffed his lines when it mattered and it cost.

Ozoh for Hughes also looked a good call but although he put in an honest performance he looked way off the level (at the moment) IMO.

We didn't protect the ball well enough when breaking from defence.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 22 Dec 23 12.07pm

Originally posted by Peter de Lisle

I think responsibility has to lay at the door of those signing players. We really, really needed to strengthen our squad in specific areas in the summer. We didn't strengthen in those areas, and instead spent £20 MILLION on a keeper who is worse than Guaita (who had another year's contract but we allowed to leave for free), £20 odd million on a Brazilian reserve arriving with a stress fracture (?!) who can't get in our team, and £4m on a centre back we didn't need. How on earth can the people involved in transfers still be in jobs? The team needed full backs, wingers and a striker, and got none of the above, and what's worse, those in charge of transfers didn't utilise any loans to fill gaps. We can't use the excuse we didn't have any money, because £44m was spent on people that don't get in our team. How difficult is it to try and sign three or four of the best players from the Championship in positions we need for £5-10m each rather than frittering money in positions we didn't need people? If there is anyone in the recruitment/scouting/transfers team that reads these boards, please just consider actually strengthening the areas we clearly need to strengthen. We only have two strikers. We are desperately short on wingers (hence having to play non wingers on the wing). We have been desperately short on full backs for several years. Please stop signing players we don't need in positions we are covered with money that could be spent on strengthening the team where it desperately needs help.
If we don't have any money, fine, let's sign the best players we can possibly get on loan, free, or being opportunistic picking players up cheaply where contracts are running out.
Please stop signing players like Henderson for £20m odd and on £100k a week. It is brainless. ANY manager would struggle with the recruitment that Freedman et al are providing. I am THRILLED we aren't in the relegation zone and frankly Roy deserves incredible plaudits for the fact that we aren't. Come on Freedman et al. Wake up and do your job rather than waiting until transfer deadline day and wasting money on people we just don't need.

Edited by Peter de Lisle (22 Dec 2023 11.45am)

I accept the greater part of your argument but where I differ is in what positions we need to find.

It is obvious for many seasons that we don't have a creative midfielder Our mode of playing the ball forward is quick passes to a marked forward. Nobody has the ability to hold the ball to allow time for forwards to find space. Contrast this with Brighton where they frequently found space. I have banged on about this since the days of Cabaye, Michael Hughes, Barry Bannon, Watson, etc.
We have never replaced them, maybe the feeling is that a holding mid-fielder is a luxury? If so please explain to me our dearth of goals. Not a great fan of Edouard or Mateta but if they got decent service they would score.
Protecting a 1-0 lead is a very negative method and one we are not very good at!

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 22 Dec 23 12.31pm

Originally posted by Painter

If he didnt bring Eze on, people would complain. You cant win as a manager everyone thinks they could do a better job than you, especially with hindsight.

Ye agree. When they were coming on I thought it was quite positive and earlier than normal. As it turned out it didn't work out at all. Tbh whoever came on I think we still would have conceded. If it'd been Schlupp as people are suggesting and we'd conceded then everyone would say why didn't we put on youth/ attacking players.

My view, first half decent, second half poor. But we seem to be at least getting players back from injury and look like we can at least pose a threat to Chelsea and Brentford. After that the board need to find a right back and striker.

 

Page 7 of 9 < 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Crystal Palace v Brighton match thread