This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Seeing children killed and maimed is terrible, but I would ask exactly how a country should react when a neighbour stages a minor invasion in which it murders, tortures and mutilates women and children, takes hundreds of hostage and then hides in populated areas. What would you do? Would you have America abandon it's greatest ally in the Middle East?
To flip your question; given Israel were attacked on October 7th, do you think that should allow them complete free reign to do whatever they want in response? Should their be any limitations placed on the response of a country who is attacked? Is that how you think international relations should function?
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
To flip your question; given Israel were attacked on October 7th, do you think that should allow them complete free reign to do whatever they want in response? Should their be any limitations placed on the response of a country who is attacked? Should there? Let's look at the actual situation rather than dealing in politics. How does Israel stop Hamas attacking them in the long term? Rather than singing the same old tune, give me solutions. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Jan 2024 3.53pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Should there? Let's look at the actual situation rather than dealing in politics. How does Israel stop Hamas attacking them in the long term? Rather than singing the same old tune, give me solutions. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Jan 2024 3.53pm) I think there should, yes - I'm asking your view. Israel is a rich, military superpower that is more than capable of defending it's borders. The idea that you can destroy an ideology with bombs is just nonsense - Israel's campaign has very little to do with destroying Hamas, as evidence by the indiscriminate nature of their actions. With respect, you accuse me of 'singing the same old tune' whilst essentially still making the point "what about October 7th" 3 months and 25,000 dead later.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Should there? Let's look at the actual situation rather than dealing in politics. How does Israel stop Hamas attacking them in the long term? Rather than singing the same old tune, give me solutions. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (11 Jan 2024 3.53pm) Why should we care about which person in the middle east did which barbarism to whom? It's about as much as our business as what goes on in Yemen or any other middle eastern country. The solution is not to be involved in it. Israel have no right to use western taxpayer money to fund its wars with its enemies. How that became that case in the US.....now that's a question people should start looking at. However, as the British.....why should we give a feck? That's a hyperthetical of course because I know exactly why we do. It's because the US pays for Nato and allows European defence budgets to be low and hence our welfare systems to be nice and wide. So America say jump and Europe jumps....We play the US tune of Russia is a threat to us, when any practical look from our perspective see's that what Russia gets up to makes little difference to us in Britain. But America's policy to to keep Europe divided....specifically Germany and Russia because that's its geopolitical position. It worked to dismantle the British empire (not many people know that) and it works at keeping Russia as the bogey man as well. Even though this is true, the anglo/American genetic and cultural ties mean that our intelligence services are intertwined from many years....but the changing demographics and hence perspectives of both countries are also slowly changing. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Jan 2024 4.36pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think there should, yes - I'm asking your view. Israel is a rich, military superpower that is more than capable of defending it's borders. The idea that you can destroy an ideology with bombs is just nonsense - Israel's campaign has very little to do with destroying Hamas, as evidence by the indiscriminate nature of their actions. With respect, you accuse me of 'singing the same old tune' whilst essentially still making the point "what about October 7th" 3 months and 25,000 dead later. Not without US weapons and aid without significantly impacting its standard of living.....Israel is a small country and you have a civilian army in Gaza and all those men aren't working their civilian jobs. It's a costly war for Israel.....or perhaps we should say the US. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Jan 2024 4.19pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
South Africa's began presenting it's case against Israel to the International Court of Justice today - it's been very damning. Israel will have their opportunity to present tomorrow. Some quotes from the SA side below; "All of these acts individually and collectively form a calculated pattern of conduct by Israel indicating a genocidal intent. This intent is evident from Israel’s conduct in: Targeting Palestinians living in Gaza using weaponry that causes large scale, homicidal destruction, as well as targeted sniping of civilians. Designating safe zones for Palestinians to seek refuge and then bombing these. Depriving Palestinians in Gaza of basic needs – food, water, health care, fuel, sanitation, and communications. Destroying social infrastructure, homes, schools, mosques, churches, hospitals, and killing, seriously injuring, and leaving large numbers of children orphaned. Genocides are never declared in advance but this court has the benefit of the past 13 weeks of evidence that shows incontrovertibly, a pattern of conduct and related intention that justifies a plausible claim of genocidal acts."
Herzog’s comment that “it’s an entire nation out there that is responsible” for the 7 October attack was singled out, and the court was shown a video of Israeli soldiers joyfully singing in Gaza about fulfilling the biblical commandment of destroying Amalek after also being shown video of Netanyahu reminding the Israeli people of King Saul being commanded to destroy all men, women, children and animals of the Amalekite people. “The scale of destruction in Gaza, the targeting of family homes and civilians, the war being a war on children, all make clear that genocidal intent is both understood and has been put into practice. The articulated intent is the destruction of Palestinian life,” said lawyer Tembeka Ngcukaitobi. “What state would admit to a genocidal intent? Yet the distinctive feature of this case has not been the silence as such, but the reiteration and repetition of genocidal speech throughout every sphere of the state in Israel,” he said. / "In the speeches to this court today, South Africa has chosen as you’ve heard, to avoid the sharing of graphic videos and photos. It has decided against turning this court into a theatre for spectacle. It knows as well as your excellencies the temptation for both sides in a dispute to parade pictures to shock. South Africa’s application in this court today is built on a foundation of clear legal rights, not images, and the detailed material before the court is marshalled to show a case for provisional measures based firmly on this court’s prior decisions. South Africa advances its case on the basis that Palestinian’s rights are equally as worthy of protection on the unprecedented evidence before you as those of the victim groups that this honourable court has previously protected by its issuance of provisional measures in the past. The material confirms the rights and their violation that Israel has committed, and is committing, acts capable of being characterised as genocidal. You have heard from us about the direct extermination of thousands of people and children of the Palestinian population in Gaza since 7 October last year. And South Africa and the world together stand witness to the forced evacuation of over 85% of the population of Gaza from their homes, and the herding of them into ever smaller areas without adequate shelter or medical care, to be attacked, killed and harmed. So the rights are immediately and urgently in need of protection because of the ongoing denial by Israel of the conditions necessary for life." I don’t think SA are the best to preach about whether genocide is happening !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Why should we care about which person in the middle east did which barbarism to whom? It's about as much as our business as what goes on in Yemen or any other middle eastern country. The solution is not to be involved in it. Israel have no right to use western taxpayer money to fund its wars with its enemies. How that became that case in the US.....now that's a question people should start looking at. However, as the British.....why should we give a feck? That's a hyperthetical of course because I know exactly why we do. It's because the US pays for Nato and allows European defence budgets to be low and hence our welfare systems to be nice and wide. So America say jump and Europe jumps....We play the US tune of Russia is a threat to us, when any practical look from our perspective see's that what Russia gets up to makes little difference to us in Britain. But America's policy to to keep Europe divided....specifically Germany and Russia because that's its geopolitical position. It worked to dismantle the British empire (not many people know that) and it works at keeping Russia as the bogey man as well. Even though this is true, the anglo/American genetic and cultural ties mean that our intelligence services are intertwined from many years....but the changing demographics and hence perspectives of both countries are also slowly changing. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Jan 2024 4.36pm) On one level, I don't think we do. However, geopolitics does not allow one to ignore flashpoints when one wants to sit at the big table. That does not mean that the US ever puts anyone else's interests before their own, or that we do either.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I think there should, yes - I'm asking your view. Israel is a rich, military superpower that is more than capable of defending it's borders. The idea that you can destroy an ideology with bombs is just nonsense - Israel's campaign has very little to do with destroying Hamas, as evidence by the indiscriminate nature of their actions. With respect, you accuse me of 'singing the same old tune' whilst essentially still making the point "what about October 7th" 3 months and 25,000 dead later.
|
|
|
It makes me laugh when people think you can police wars. Perhaps they should introduce VAR.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But Israel failed to defend its borders and by failing to do so, it allowed us a taste of the kind of barbarism that Hamas and its followers are capable of. Israel is not attacking a peaceful neighbour. They are attacking a terrorist organisation who fires rockets into Israeli cities then hides among women and children and has weapons hidden under hospitals.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
On one level, I don't think we do. However, geopolitics does not allow one to ignore flashpoints when one wants to sit at the big table. That does not mean that the US ever puts anyone else's interests before their own, or that we do either. The only loyalty I have is to the pro Anglos/Europeans in the US....and that's because they don't hate us because we are related. I haven't forgotten that the US worked against the British empire (something Powell noted and distrusted them for) and those plastic paddies who funded the IRA in areas like New York. I'm fed up with being the US's automatic minion myself. Their past governments worked against our empire when we had one and personally I don't see their vision for Europe as actually good for Europe. I no longer view their interest is purely positive.....in fact now that we are in cold war I view it as positively disruptive and economically stupid.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I wonder what would be said if Israel stopped its war against Hamas who then regrouped and entered Israel again. Let’s say wiping out 1000s more. I think when it comes to the war between Hamas and Israel.....that's an intractable zero sum game. However, personally I'm against native people's being pushed out of their homelands. I'm against it here and I'm against it elsewhere. Let's not forget that Israel want those Palestinians to be your problem, not theirs. Israel didn't exist 76 years ago and all the people who were living where Israel exists had much of what happened to Israel on 7th October happen to them back then.....there just wasn't TV cameras recording it. Now people see Israel doing the same in Gaza. I argue that other than an humanitarian aspect as human beings none of this is our business. Israel is no one's 'greatest ally'.....it's nothing but a crown of thorns around the west's neck. The only reason its interests are pushed more than Arab interests is because the US and to a lesser extent elsewhere in Europe there are many western Jews disproportionally in prominent powerful positions ensuring that. When Britain becomes majority Muslim, later in the century those attitudes flip. As an Englishman I see no upside to any of it.....and I tend to wish to stay away from 'everybody loses' deals. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 6.19am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I wonder what would be said if Israel stopped its war against Hamas who then regrouped and entered Israel again. Let’s say wiping out 1000s more. If not Hamas then some new group will emerge somewhere. You don’t treat people like this and make their children lose their parents and siblings without creating an overwhelming desire for revenge. Israel is not solving their problem. They are prolonging it.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
But Israel failed to defend its borders and by failing to do so, it allowed us a taste of the kind of barbarism that Hamas and its followers are capable of. Israel is not attacking a peaceful neighbour. They are attacking a terrorist organisation who fires rockets into Israeli cities then hides among women and children and has weapons hidden under hospitals.
That's true - in the decades this conflict has been going on, how many times have Hamas managed to conduct an attack of that scale? So if for many decades Israel had maintained a reality where they regularly kill Palestinians, occupy their land and prevent their movement, with very little in terms of meaningful retaliation, why is the idea that they could return to this reality farfetched?
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
I wonder what would be said if Israel stopped its war against Hamas who then regrouped and entered Israel again. Let’s say wiping out 1000s more. From 2000-2014, there were 8,166 recorded conflict-related deaths, of which 7,065 are Palestinian and 1,101 Israeli. That means 87 percent of deaths have been Palestinian and only 13 percent Israeli. Put another way, for every 15 people killed in the conflict, 13 are Palestinian and two are Israeli. The idea that Hamas has the capability to wipe out 1000s of Israeli's is demonstrably false, as is the idea there is anything close to 'an eye for an eye' in this conflict.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
If not Hamas then some new group will emerge somewhere. You don’t treat people like this and make their children lose their parents and siblings without creating an overwhelming desire for revenge. Israel is not solving their problem. They are prolonging it. Everyone knows this, I have no idea why they pretend they don't.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
From 2000-2014, there were 8,166 recorded conflict-related deaths, of which 7,065 are Palestinian and 1,101 Israeli. That means 87 percent of deaths have been Palestinian and only 13 percent Israeli. Put another way, for every 15 people killed in the conflict, 13 are Palestinian and two are Israeli. The idea that Hamas has the capability to wipe out 1000s of Israeli's is demonstrably false, as is the idea there is anything close to 'an eye for an eye' in this conflict. These two are in a war....The very point of a war is that you kill more of them than they kill of you. I think the reason most people get shocked is that they don't realise that it's a war and believe the stuff coming out from politicians. Most of whom would regard honesty as coming from fairy tales. What we are seeing is barbarism......and western hypocrisy.....because if the side they favour is doing it then they are quieter. Realpolitik. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 10.06am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.