This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
These two are in a war....The very point of a war is that you kill more of them than they kill of you. I think the reason most people get shocked is that they don't realise that it's a war and believe the stuff coming out from politicians. Most of whom would regard honesty as coming from fairy tales. What we are seeing is barbarism......and western hypocrisy.....because if the side they favour is doing it then they are quieter. Realpolitik. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 10.06am) The point is to highlight that if Israel were to end their current action, they're not suddenly sitting ducks who might get massacred, as is being suggested.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
The point is to highlight that if Israel were to end their current action, they're not suddenly sitting ducks who might get massacred, as is being suggested.
It's maybe past the point of no return for them and it looks like we just all have to take it. They're getting away with ridding themselves of one part of their problem. Whether we like it or not, they're doing this. I don't see it making anyone safer in the long run. We've probably got about 50 years or more of worldwide terrorism to come. I don't see it escalating into a war with Arab states but maybe the US will need a war with Iran at some stage. Just before an election kind of thing.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
The point is to highlight that if Israel were to end their current action, they're not suddenly sitting ducks who might get massacred, as is being suggested. Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (12 Jan 2024 10.18am) Isn't that a bit like telling Hitler to stop after he'd killed ten million Russians or three million Jews? They went for it....Stopping isn't going to happen is it. Going into Gaza like they did was a crossing of the Rubicon moment...the die was cast. I don't see the logic in them stopping. It's a binary for them, succeed or fail. What do Israel fear? They fear two things....The US turning off the money and weapons tap (not going to happen) and they fear invasion....That's unlikely from anyone except Hezbollah in Lebanon (who will probably be high on the agenda next and both are juicing up for it). Everybody who hates or dislikes Israel already does....I'm not seeing what they are being offered to change tack.....humanitarian or empathy arguments aren't going to work on them.....Another darkly comic irony. You have Blinken.......seemingly constantly being sent around the middle east having 'ain't it awful' conversations and trying to get and reduce Arab reactions to what Israel is doing and trying to restrain Israel to some extent....which is just a PR game.....The Arab states aren't going to help any of this for several reasons. It is a mass human tragedy where the politicians are more keystone cops than serious players. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 11.21am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Isn't that a bit like telling Hitler to stop after he'd killed ten million Russians or three million Jews? They went for it....Stopping isn't going to happen is it. Going into Gaza like they did was a crossing of the Rubicon moment...the die was cast. I don't see the logic in them stopping. It's a binary for them, succeed or fail. What do Israel fear? They fear two things....The US turning off the money and weapons tap (not going to happen) and they fear invasion....That's unlikely from anyone except Hezbollah in Lebanon (who will probably be high on the agenda next and both are juicing up for it). Everybody who hates or dislikes Israel already does....I'm not seeing what they are being offered to change tack.....humanitarian or empathy arguments aren't going to work on them.....Another darkly comic irony. You have Blinken.......seemingly constantly being sent around the middle east having 'ain't it awful' conversations and trying to get and reduce Arab reactions to what Israel is doing and trying to restrain Israel to some extent....which is just a PR game.....The Arab states aren't going to help any of this for several reasons. It is a mass human tragedy where the politicians are more keystone cops than serious players. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 11.21am) No, it's not remotely like that - it's a direct response to a post making the exact suggestion that I have countered - the rest of your interpretation is completely your own.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
No, it's not remotely like that - it's a direct response to a post making the exact suggestion that I have countered - the rest of your interpretation is completely your own. Well, if they stop now and let Gaza build back up they will just get attacked at some future point......it's a cycle. If it isn't like that then tell me. What is in it for the Israeli government to stop? You just seem to be responding with a negative but with no actual meat to justify it. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 12.09pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Another battle rages,....in court. Only this time, Israel has viable opposition. "Israel has said South Africa has distorted the truth in its case to the International Court of Justice, where it is accusing Israel of genocide. South Africa had presented "a sweeping counter-factual description" of the Israel-Palestinian conflict, Israeli lawyer Tal Becker told the ICJ. South Africa says Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinians in its war in Gaza. It is also asking the court to order Israel to halt its military activity." (BBC website)
I disengage, I turn the page. |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The only loyalty I have is to the pro Anglos/Europeans in the US....and that's because they don't hate us because we are related. I haven't forgotten that the US worked against the British empire (something Powell noted and distrusted them for) and those plastic paddies who funded the IRA in areas like New York. I'm fed up with being the US's automatic minion myself. Their past governments worked against our empire when we had one and personally I don't see their vision for Europe as actually good for Europe. I no longer view their interest is purely positive.....in fact now that we are in cold war I view it as positively disruptive and economically stupid. Yes, it seems that tribalism is still part of global politics. The US suits itself, but it is in our interests to be aligned to the country with the biggest guns. Let's be honest, our armed forces couldn't do anything major without their assistance. We usually tag along just for old times sake. I am starting to think that Britain and Europe needs a much bigger military capability with the way things are going.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Well, if they stop now and let Gaza build back up they will just get attacked at some future point......it's a cycle. If it isn't like that then tell me. What is in it for the Israeli government to stop? You just seem to be responding with a negative but with no actual meat to justify it. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 12.09pm) A cycle that does not pose a huge threat to them - that's the point I'm making. Israel have likely killed more Palestinians this week than Hamas have killed Israelis in 15 years. There was one extreme exception to this on October 7th, but this is a 50+ year conflict and Israel have been relatively unharmed for the vast majority of that, certainly in recent times. The same is not true of Gaza. Let's please stop the pretence that Israel are at risk of being massacred at any moment if they stop bombing the s*** out of civilians - it's just a complete nonsense of an argument with decades of evidence to the contrary. The incentive for Israel to stop should come from the international community, if not wanting to commit genocide isn't enough of an incentive for them - Israel should be disgraced, expelled from the UN, should be excluded from sporting and cultural events, should be excluded from any academic corporation etc. in much the same way Russia has been. That's how you create the incentive to stop - whether they take it or not is up to them. I'm not sure how much more meat I can add on this thread - I think I've been very forthright with my views over many months.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
That's true - in the decades this conflict has been going on, how many times have Hamas managed to conduct an attack of that scale? So if for many decades Israel had maintained a reality where they regularly kill Palestinians, occupy their land and prevent their movement, with very little in terms of meaningful retaliation, why is the idea that they could return to this reality farfetched? I don't support the state of Israel, or its behaviour towards Palestine. However, I do wonder why you so obviously side with Palestine. It seems to be a leftist disease. I am totally in accord with you over the suffering and death of innocents, but I suspect that you would be cheering the rockets as they landed in Tel Aviv. The bottom line is that I don't want to see people of any kind being bombed unless they are bombing me and mine. I don't think there is a going back now. The die has been cast and we must hope that a major escalation can be avoided.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I don't support the state of Israel, or its behaviour towards Palestine. However, I do wonder why you so obviously side with Palestine. It seems to be a leftist disease. I am totally in accord with you over the suffering and death of innocents, but I suspect that you would be cheering the rockets as they landed in Tel Aviv. The bottom line is that I don't want to see people of any kind being bombed unless they are bombing me and mine. I don't think there is a going back now. The die has been cast and we must hope that a major escalation can be avoided. You wonder why I side with Palestine? Is that difficult to work out? I'd struggle to see how anyone could properly educate themselves on this conflict (which did begin before October 7th btw) and come to any other conclusion. I don't want to see civilians killed anywhere, and it's a pretty despicable suggestion that I would cheer the bombing of anyone.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
You wonder why I side with Palestine? Is that difficult to work out? I'd struggle to see how anyone could properly educate themselves on this conflict (which did begin before October 7th btw) and come to any other conclusion. I don't want to see civilians killed anywhere, and it's a pretty despicable suggestion that I would cheer the bombing of anyone. And yet you side with group who just tortured and murdered women and children.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
And yet you side with group who just tortured and murdered women and children. I don’t know if it’s a lack of intelligence or just dishonesty, but you’re clearly drowning. Enjoy the weekend.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
I don’t know if it’s a lack of intelligence or just dishonesty, but you’re clearly drowning. Enjoy the weekend. I guess you couldn't go anywhere other than insult after admitting that you basically sympathise with Hamas. I just wonder how many tears you shed for all those poor Israelis who met their death at the end of a Hamas knife. Just the usual brief tokenisms as I recall. Dishonest? Hmmm.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
I guess you couldn't go anywhere other than insult after admitting that you basically sympathise with Hamas. I just wonder how many tears you shed for all those poor Israelis who met their death at the end of a Hamas knife. Just the usual brief tokenisms as I recall. Dishonest? Hmmm. Yes dishonest, and intellectually lacking. You asked me if I support Palestine, and now you change it to Hamas. An honest mistake I’m sure, only an idiot could get the two confused.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Yes dishonest, and intellectually lacking. You asked me if I support Palestine, and now you change it to Hamas. An honest mistake I’m sure, only an idiot could get the two confused. I'm not stupid enough to think that there can ever be peace between Israel and Palestine all the time the likes of Hamas exist. Only a real idiot would think that. You need to wake up to reality.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
A cycle that does not pose a huge threat to them - that's the point I'm making. Israel have likely killed more Palestinians this week than Hamas have killed Israelis in 15 years. There was one extreme exception to this on October 7th, but this is a 50+ year conflict and Israel have been relatively unharmed for the vast majority of that, certainly in recent times. The same is not true of Gaza. Let's please stop the pretence that Israel are at risk of being massacred at any moment if they stop bombing the s*** out of civilians - it's just a complete nonsense of an argument with decades of evidence to the contrary. The incentive for Israel to stop should come from the international community, if not wanting to commit genocide isn't enough of an incentive for them - Israel should be disgraced, expelled from the UN, should be excluded from sporting and cultural events, should be excluded from any academic corporation etc. in much the same way Russia has been. That's how you create the incentive to stop - whether they take it or not is up to them. I'm not sure how much more meat I can add on this thread - I think I've been very forthright with my views over many months. I have sympathy for the fact that you care about what's happening over there. I think any decent person would care and be against the wanton barbarism that goes on, whether it's an Israeli or Palestinian doing it.....and of course you are right that since the 8th of October it's mainly been one way.....but this is war. Once the Israeli state was created this was how it was going to be.....it's a blood feud until that patch of land is either Jewish or Islamic. The two state solution died with the Clinton presidency....they should have given them access to water...ah well. Not that I think it would have worked anyway. There isn't going to be a boycott or ostracisation because the big bully US won't allow one. I predict that Gaza won't be the end of this and that unless the current Israeli administration is removed Iran and its proxies in Lebanon will be attacked with the aim of removing the Iranian regime......though that's one hell of a job in a country of eighty million.....So the Americans will probably try to keep it to Lebanon. However, I think Blinken has found that the Saudis won't get involved militarily....and they will probably up the bribe money to Egypt and Jordan to keep them sweet. I agree....it's all disgusting and as dirty as hell. We probably wouldn't agree on the Russian point but that's another thread. Edited by Stirlingsays (12 Jan 2024 2.41pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
A cycle that does not pose a huge threat to them - that's the point I'm making. Israel have likely killed more Palestinians this week than Hamas have killed Israelis in 15 years. There was one extreme exception to this on October 7th, but this is a 50+ year conflict and Israel have been relatively unharmed for the vast majority of that, certainly in recent times. The same is not true of Gaza. Let's please stop the pretence that Israel are at risk of being massacred at any moment if they stop bombing the s*** out of civilians - it's just a complete nonsense of an argument with decades of evidence to the contrary. The incentive for Israel to stop should come from the international community, if not wanting to commit genocide isn't enough of an incentive for them - Israel should be disgraced, expelled from the UN, should be excluded from sporting and cultural events, should be excluded from any academic corporation etc. in much the same way Russia has been. That's how you create the incentive to stop - whether they take it or not is up to them. I'm not sure how much more meat I can add on this thread - I think I've been very forthright with my views over many months. Israel are surrounded by Muslims. Muslims hate Jews. Don’t kid yourself about the fact they can’t be massacred. Maybe not by Hamas but many littles make a big big. You do realise that 2 nd on Muslims wish list of gone is me and you. Smell the coffee EDN. Hold your council of sympathy but don’t be disillusioned that you aren’t a target of the very people you want to stand up for. Gays for Palestine alphabet people blacks the west etc etc. all waving flags and falling into the great Quran trap.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cryrst
Israel are surrounded by Muslims. Muslims hate Jews. Don’t kid yourself about the fact they can’t be massacred. Maybe not by Hamas but many littles make a big big. You do realise that 2 nd on Muslims wish list of gone is me and you. Smell the coffee EDN. Hold your council of sympathy but don’t be disillusioned that you aren’t a target of the very people you want to stand up for. Gays for Palestine alphabet people blacks the west etc etc. all waving flags and falling into the great Quran trap. Ah! The bigger picture.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.