You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher
November 19 2026 5.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Margaret Thatcher


Page 75 of 76 < 71 72 73 74 75 76 >
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 16 May 13 8.03pm

I was gutted to hear the news of the demise of Baroness Thatcher who will, no doubt, be seen by future historians as one of the finest Prime Ministers this country was privileged to have.

Anyone who believes differently is a poof, a queer, a softie and a leftie bender.

Edited by Cucking Funt (16 May 2013 8.03pm)

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Catfish Flag Burgess Hill 16 May 13 8.35pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 16 May 2013 8.03pm

I was gutted to hear the news of the demise of Baroness Thatcher who will, no doubt, be seen by future historians as one of the finest Prime Ministers this country was privileged to have.

Anyone who believes differently is a poof, a queer, a softie and a leftie bender.

Edited by Cucking Funt (16 May 2013 8.03pm)

You forgot bed-wetter.

 


Yes, I am an agent of Satan but my duties are largely ceremonial

reborn 17 May 13 1.29pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 16 May 2013 8.03pm

I was gutted to hear the news of the demise of Baroness Thatcher who will, no doubt, be seen by future historians as one of the finest Prime Ministers this country was privileged to have.

Anyone who believes differently is a poof, a queer, a softie and a leftie bender.

Edited by Cucking Funt (16 May 2013 8.03pm)


 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 07 Oct 13 12.07pm

BUMP

And a purely self-satisfying bump at that.

I posted a thread about a week ago about Katie Hopkins, the modern-day Thatcherite who does such things like 'tells it like it is', whatever the f*ck 'it' is, and 'isn't afraid to tackle the big questions', even if the views which she comes out with are patronising, bigoted, stereotypical and mainly fact-less.

Well one of the things she said at least I felt held some sway. She said that people such as me - people too young to have experienced first hand Thatcher - were in no position to comment on her, and the changes she made. At first it seemed sensible. I was too young to live through her era, therefore who am I to have such strong opinions on her, if she ostensibly didn't affect me?

I thought about this for a while, and then realised that this, like most of her views, was complete nonsense. Because the person 'Thatcher' means nothing to me, but the concept of 'Thatcherism' is still f*cking gnawing away at the society I live in and affecting me personally. She was always to me just some demented old woman that occasionally popped up on the tele in a big coat and a veil, but her politics have driven this country for the last 30 odd years, thus I feel I am able to comment on them at least.

The majority of pro-Thatcher posts seem to me to be mainly rhetorical. Phrases are churned out like 'She made Britain great again', 'this country was going to the dogs', 'she took on the unions when no one else would'. Maybe these things are true, but for me, looking at FACTS, which I feel should be the basis of any reasoned argument (although I understand that many on here see them as a mere barrier to the witty sniping and bitching that should be at the core of any HOL debate) they seem to paint a different picture.

Here are some facts.
1st fact: In 1970, the average Chief Executive of a company earned 30% more than their workers. Today they earn 500% more.
2nd fact: The top 1% of our society has doubled their share of the national income since 1982
3rd Fact: Unemployment more than doubled during her tenure, and even the economic growth towards the end didn't result in her cutting the unemployment level from when she took office
4th fact: Inequality rose dramatically between the highest and lowest in society, the Gini coefficient (which measures these things) went from 0.25 to 0.34
5th fact: poverty rose year on year under Thatcher and reached a high when she left office which hasn't been reached since.

Now based on those, and other facts, I fail to see how anyone can come to the conclusion that 'Thatcher made this country great again'. Certainly if you were wealthy, Thatcher was f*cking brilliant. But for the majority of us who aren't in the top 1%, and especially for those at the bottom, life was, and is, just sh*t.

And yet Thatcherism continues. Blair implemented many of the philosophies the Tories brought in, or to be more precise, didn't overturn too many of her policies, this current austerity government has reduced the rate of income tax to 45%, ensuring that the wealthy's earnings are as high as they've ever been, while horrendously victimising those at the bottom by slashing benefits and introducing things such as the bedroom tax. But to say that longevity is a sign of success is completely incorrect. It sadly shows that media spin and the degradation of the working classes, which begun under Thatcher, have been so effective that people will believe things that even very simple facts completely counteract. For example, 'benefit scrounging' represents less than 1% of total welfare spending, and is an even more insignificant fraction in contrast to, say, tax avoidance. Or the fact that there are in many cases dozens of applicants for one job position, suggests that the 'lazy' unemployed that Norman Tebbit, and now Jeremy Hunt et al speak of is simply not true.

So, for a 'youngster' to comprehend Thatcher, and Thatcherism. What do I learn about our country and its people? That we are gullible in our blind following of media rhetoric. That we are disingenuous, rather believing that the poor are 'lazy' and 'greedy' than just really damn unlucky. That we are worryingly conservative; there seems to be a widely-held belief that it's just the way of the world now and we have no other plausible option than this sort of neo-capitalism that on the face of it is so clearly benefitting the wealthy and detrimental to the majority.

So to echo Cucking, I will be pleased if I see the death of Thatcherism in my lifetime if it is replaced by something more in the interests of the majority, and anyone who isn't is an ignorant, bigotted, selfish and conservative arsehole.


Edited by serial thriller (07 Oct 2013 12.15pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 07 Oct 13 12.27pm

Thank god for that, I was worried seeing this bumped that she had risen from the dead.

And in more of a Zombie way than any religious connotation.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Pussay Patrol Flag 07 Oct 13 12.32pm

I suppose it's a case of if people believe Governments shape and determine people's lives or people themselves.

I believe the latter. If it isn't it should be.

And if people strongly think the former - then there is no society as the lady once said....

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 07 Oct 13 12.47pm

Quote serial thriller at 07 Oct 2013 12.07pm

So to echo Cucking, I will be pleased if I see the death of Thatcherism in my lifetime if it is replaced by something more in the interests of the majority, and anyone who isn't is an ignorant, bigotted, selfish and conservative arsehole.


Edited by serial thriller (07 Oct 2013 12.15pm)


[Link]

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Bin Liner Flag London , Southfields 07 Oct 13 12.48pm

I detest those well worn clichés like she made Britain great again/ took on the unions etc, one you missed out was "I'm alright jack I bought my council house!"

 


Portillo's teeth removed to boost pound

Boy roasts himself in sacrifice to Chris Kelly

npn Flag Crowborough 07 Oct 13 12.59pm

I don't know it's as easy to judge as people on both sides seem to sometimes think.

ST has listed some of the down sides of the Thatcher legacy, and there are more besides. Many of them are nasty and very unpalletable, but we have no way of knowing what would have happened had she not been in charge.

We were coming off of the back of power shortages, the three day week, and final the winter of discontent when seemingly the whole country was grinding to a halt in strikes supporting ridiculous pay claims of 40% or more.

If Thatcher had not taken on the unions, would that have just got worse with the unions basically holding the country to ransom, or would the calming down of the economy and the reduction of inflation have poured oil on the troubled waters anyway? I guess we'll never know.

One thing's pretty certain, the Falklands would now be Argentinian (probably not a big deal for any of us, but a pretty massive one if you happen to live there).

So, did she get everything right? Of course not, but I can't think of another high profile politician of the time - with the possible exception of Heseltein (sp) and Tebbit - who would have had the brass b0llocks to take them on.

I would call her a product of the time, and necessary, with a little lapse into megalomania!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Oct 13 1.03pm

Quote Pussay Patrol at 07 Oct 2013 12.32pm

I suppose it's a case of if people believe Governments shape and determine people's lives or people themselves.

I believe the latter. If it isn't it should be.

And if people strongly think the former - then there is no society as the lady once said....

Its a combination of the two, probably with an emphasis on the former, rather than the later. Modern Social Psychological research points very much against the idea of an autonomous self, seperated from its enviroment, but that the ideas of self are more social narratives constructed and reconstructed on a continual basis in the process of social interaction. Its more effictive to see these discourses in contention and support of other discourses.

Government policy is determined largely in lines with the media refelection of selective popular discourses in society. This is problematic, because popular discourses are not necessarily 'right' in terms of facts, and nor do they address causal factors inherent in impact they have on discourses.

An example of this is 'fear of crime' is stimulated by the way in which crime is reported, enhancing discourses in support of combatting, even though crime rates are generally falling. In order to appeal governments increase Law and Order bills, which in turn result in people being more concerned about crime, which is then reflected in the media, resulting in more rhetoric about crime.

The lady was close, she just got it around the wrong way, individuals don't 'really exist', society does.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 Oct 13 1.15pm

I loved her.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 07 Oct 13 1.16pm

Quote npn at 07 Oct 2013 12.59pm

I don't know it's as easy to judge as people on both sides seem to sometimes think.

ST has listed some of the down sides of the Thatcher legacy, and there are more besides. Many of them are nasty and very unpalletable, but we have no way of knowing what would have happened had she not been in charge.

We were coming off of the back of power shortages, the three day week, and final the winter of discontent when seemingly the whole country was grinding to a halt in strikes supporting ridiculous pay claims of 40% or more.

If Thatcher had not taken on the unions, would that have just got worse with the unions basically holding the country to ransom, or would the calming down of the economy and the reduction of inflation have poured oil on the troubled waters anyway? I guess we'll never know.

One thing's pretty certain, the Falklands would now be Argentinian (probably not a big deal for any of us, but a pretty massive one if you happen to live there).

So, did she get everything right? Of course not, but I can't think of another high profile politician of the time - with the possible exception of Heseltein (sp) and Tebbit - who would have had the brass b0llocks to take them on.

I would call her a product of the time, and necessary, with a little lapse into megalomania!


It's all speculative though isn't it. We can debate well in to next week what may or may not have happened if this or that hadn't occurred, but in the end it will get us nowhere. What we have only really to discuss is was what she did effective?

In terms of the unions, they do seem to have exerted an inordinate power in political life at the time, and one which had to be challenged. But you have to remember that they represented a significant enough percentage of society as to have been treated with far greater respect by a person who, and let's not forget this, is meant to serve her people. Equally and perhaps more importantly, the Trade Unions, like the council houses and industrial works, were predominantly working class institutions that Thatcher dismantled. When we talk about rising poverty, unemployment etc. it all stems from these faculties being removed as aid to those worse off in society, as welfare currently is today.

In any discussion with a need for compromise, flexibility is needed, and Thatcher's rigidity was certainly not needed when it came to issues such as the unions, as well as Northern Ireland. The effects of this egotistical obstinacy were catastrophic, and are still being felt today in many towns and cities in England.

Edited by serial thriller (07 Oct 2013 1.17pm)

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 07 Oct 13 1.24pm

Two points in reply:

1. If you were ‘too young’ you shouldn’t comment
Someone on here (I shan’t name names, but it was someone who doesn’t like Thatcher) said that anything I said, even if it was based on well-researched books and biographies, was irrelevant, because I was “too young” when Thatcher was around. Whereas his memory is presumably flawless and perfect after 30 years. It’s bollocks. Desperation from a scoundrel who has run out of proper arguments.

2. The “Thatcher made us great” myth
I agree that the myths around Thatcher are bollocks. But that’s true on both sides. One problem is there is no counterfactual. What would have happened if she hadn’t taken over? Three words: IMF, inflation, unions. We could write tomes and tomes on the pros and cons, but bottom line: she definitely fixed some problems. She exacerbated some others and created a fair few of her own, but if she wasn’t all good, then equally she couldn’t have been all bad.

With respect, most of the rest of your post is frankly just piggy-backing various injustices (idleness, sloth, selfishness, greed) on the back of a woolly concept (“Thatcherism”) as though you’re saying, ‘if it wasn’t for her everything would be dandy’. If that’s not a bullsh*t myth then I don’t know what is.

I would respond to the other points if I had more time.

One thing I do have to pick you up on:

Quote serial thriller at 07 Oct 2013 12.07pm

ignorant, bigotted, selfish and conservative arsehole.

Being ignorant, bigoted and selfish are character flaws.
Are you saying you think holding conservative views is a character flaw? Will definitely find the time to argue about that one if you are.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

Ketteridge Flag Brighton 07 Oct 13 1.36pm

Quote pefwin at 07 Oct 2013 12.27pm

Thank god for that, I was worried seeing this bumped that she had risen from the dead.

And in more of a Zombie way than any religious connotation.

My thoughts exactly, going to have to have a sit down I'm quite shaky.

 


One supporter of hacking argued that without it "you will do away with the courage and pluck of the game, and I will be bound to bring over a lot of Frenchmen who would beat you with a week's practice -Blackheath secretary at first meeting of the F.A

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 07 Oct 13 1.48pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Oct 2013 1.15pm

I loved her.


What a wonderful woman and she changed this country for the BETTER until Labour took over with Boy Blair in charge who really made a pigs ear of running the country and getting us into the biggest debt crisis we have ever known...Also we have so many immigrants that we are overflowing and all our services are stretched to the limit.....All because he wanted the votes from his unchecked migration plans.......Boy are we suffereing now and will be for some time yet!!!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 07 Oct 13 2.03pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 07 Oct 2013 1.24pm

Two points in reply:

1. If you were ‘too young’ you shouldn’t comment
Someone on here (I shan’t name names, but it was someone who doesn’t like Thatcher) said that anything I said, even if it was based on well-researched books and biographies, was irrelevant, because I was “too young” when Thatcher was around. Whereas his memory is presumably flawless and perfect after 30 years. It’s bollocks. Desperation from a scoundrel who has run out of proper arguments.

2. The “Thatcher made us great” myth
I agree that the myths around Thatcher are bollocks. But that’s true on both sides. One problem is there is no counterfactual. What would have happened if she hadn’t taken over? Three words: IMF, inflation, unions. We could write tomes and tomes on the pros and cons, but bottom line: she definitely fixed some problems. She exacerbated some others and created a fair few of her own, but if she wasn’t all good, then equally she couldn’t have been all bad.

With respect, most of the rest of your post is frankly just piggy-backing various injustices (idleness, sloth, selfishness, greed) on the back of a woolly concept (“Thatcherism”) as though you’re saying, ‘if it wasn’t for her everything would be dandy’. If that’s not a bullsh*t myth then I don’t know what is.

I would respond to the other points if I had more time.

One thing I do have to pick you up on:

Quote serial thriller at 07 Oct 2013 12.07pm

ignorant, bigotted, selfish and conservative arsehole.

Being ignorant, bigoted and selfish are character flaws.
Are you saying you think holding conservative views is a character flaw? Will definitely find the time to argue about that one if you are.

I'm not too good at fancy quoting Johnny so bear with me.

I don't think I am saying 'everything would be dandy' if she wasn't in power. I admit that, from what I can see, unions needed a level of restraining that she promised to tackle. All I am saying is that Thatcherism, or the major conservative social and economically liberal policies which she established and proceeding governments have continued goes against my fundamental political beliefs, and in my eyes, goes against the interests of the majority in a capitalist society. If we are to persist with Capitalism, we should be working towards egalitarianism and and fairness. Again that is simply my opinion. For me, the reduction in restrictions on finance and business in this country, coupled with the destruction of several key working class institutions as I have mentioned, resulted in the opposite effect, while the pernicious rhetoric her government, and the supporting media, have and continue to give with regards to people who are less financially well off is hugely detrimental to our society as a whole.

As for being conservative, it was mainly in reference to the point I previously made about the common misconception that Thatcherism was and remains the only plausible solution in this country. I accept I perhaps could've used a better word to express it though.

Ultimately as with any character judgement, you weigh up the pros and cons based on your personal beliefs. For me, the inequalities and injustices which are part of her legacy can in no way be redeemed by the benefits of her tenure. I should also add that my whole argument is based on the legacy of her policies, as much as it is based on their effects at the time.

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 07 Oct 13 3.51pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Oct 2013 1.15pm

I loved her.

Did you dig her up then?


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 07 Oct 13 3.59pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 07 Oct 2013 3.51pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 07 Oct 2013 1.15pm

I loved her.

Did you dig her up then?



I'm saying nothing.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 07 Oct 13 4.34pm

At the risk of going off on a tangent, I would dispute that ‘Thatcherism’ was in any way socially conservative. Closing down traditional industries, flogging off council houses, centralising power at number 10, Thatcher was anything but a social conservative. She was a radical.

Economically she was ultra-liberal. I have a lot of sympathy for that (I am a strange, conflicted mixture of social conservatism and economic liberalism) and I think she achieved a great deal. Take privatisation. Many sclerotic state-run industries became economic powerhouses (eg, British Airways, British Telecom) and transformed the British economy permanently for the better. Indeed the rest of the world copied and continues to copy her with much success. (There were of course exceptions, eg, utilities and railways.)

Interestingly, there are also some world-leading British chemical and manufacturing companies which you don’t hear about in the mainstream media (unless you’re sad like me and listen to lots of business programmes on the radio) which were spun off out of the likes of ICI. Thatcherism isn’t all about fat cats and inequality.

Which isn’t to say it was all to the good. A socially more conservative PM would have recognised that you can’t just let the market rip up traditional industries and not expect a massive social fall-out. She was either naïve or just indifferent to that bit.

If she was indifferent, then you might justifiably call her cruel and callous. Personally, I suspect she was more naïve than indifferent. She once expressed regret that charitable giving and volunteering didn’t increase as she cut taxes. Coming from a strict Methodist background, she just assumed that if you got government out of the way, then you’d free up space for people to look after each other. It wasn’t her fault that most of them chose only to look after themselves.

I’m interested by your comments on Capitalism. For me, capitalism is just a fact of life, like gravity. Of course you can *officially* banish market forces, but ask anyone who lived in East Germany, capitalism was at work there alright, albeit preferring those with access to political capital rather than the financial kind.

As for “working towards egalitarianism”: I’d say that ideology’s been responsible for even more damage than Thatcherism!

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 29 Oct 14 2.43pm

How to deal with the Thatcher stamp...

10686896_10154975386918125_4804113426627546264_n.jpg Attachment: 10686896_10154975386918125_4804113426627546264_n.jpg (40.78Kb)

 

Page 75 of 76 < 71 72 73 74 75 76 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Margaret Thatcher