This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 14 Nov 2014 9.44am
Quote sydtheeagle at 12 Nov 2014 6.03pm
Quote matt_himself at 12 Nov 2014 5.28pm
Interesting. Firstly, there are many misunderstandings in the above and seeing as how neither Chomsky, Friedman or Hayek could agree on the term, I find it rather interesting that you think you can define it. Secondly, which blog did that come from? The term, surely, is irrelevant? It's just a word and words can have meaning ascribed to them by context. They're not absolute. More to the point, since neither Chomsky, Friedman or Hayek's support is critical to any definition of the word, who cares what they could or couldn't agree with? The Austrian/Chicago School of Economic thought is in any case now largely discredited. I see few misunderstanding in Nick's post, so I'd like to know where you think they are. Always the last refuge of a scoundrel to criticise someone, but to fail to point out the specific errors you're accusing them of making. Is Nick wrong only because you said so? This renders your post little more than fluffy vitriol. History, upon even a cursory examination, supports Nick's contention that corporations first appeared as organisations in the late 19th century to oversee large scale public projects. If governments can be said not have worked together OPENLY to ensure wealth transference upwards, they have certainly done so implicitly. How else do you account for the current, unbalanced, society we live in...the product of successive governments? Do you think working people are willingly disenfranchising themselves? Easy credit became the norm because it was an easy way for banks to make (more) money. In fact, there came a point when it was the only way. Once you have no more rich people to lend to, you cash in on the poor ones at prohibitive interest rates. It's the only option. The trouble is that the risk managers got their sums wrong about what the poor borrowers could afford. (The fact that these people became indebted and thus trapped was of neither concern nor interest to anyone in the structured products community of the Financial Services industry. At least until the excrement hit the ventilation extractor.) Deregulation of markets really amounted to little more than letting the poachers run the game estate. Or to use another metaphor, do you expect good behaviour if you give the lunatics the keys to the asylum? What do you think an institution that is designed to generate profit is going to do when it is deregulated. Take sensible risks? Settle for marginal returns? The real problem in all this is Stalin. And no, I'm not joking. History always holds the real answers (another point implicitly made by Nick's post). The discrediting of communism (rightly -- but with it -- and wrongly -- went the credibility of more or less every colour of left wing ideology) delivered two decades of unfettered right-wing dominance that delivered a world hallmarked, ultimately, by a divided society and economic collapse. That these regimes still have apologists beggars belief. The rebirth of Keynesian perspectives attests somewhat to this. You appear to be long on rhetoric and very short on detail. Edited by sydtheeagle (12 Nov 2014 6.03pm) Syd, I agree with your point about communism. Having lived in Berlin for seven years, I knew former East Germans who complain about things which were simply consigned to the dustbin when the overly-confident West Germans took over. (It wasn’t so much re-unification as a dissolution and annexation, but that’s another topic). Meanwhile, stuff which the East Germans did well – running kindergartens, for example, or looking after old people – have been quietly restored along the old lines, just with a lot more effort and expense to do it not quite as well. I disagree strongly that we need the “sweeping shift to the Left” you call for. The ‘Left’* has simply got no answer to the following: 1. Austerity 2. Globalisation 3. Post-industrial consumerism *for want of a better term. Disclaimer: I object to traditional conservative views (many of which I hold) being lumped in with radical economic liberalist views (which I don't) and calling it “right-wing”. Just like lumping Bennite socialism (with which I have some sympathy) with beer-and-sandwich Union baronialism (with which I do not) is an unfair caricature of “the Left”. 1. Is austerity actually working? People are starting to get austerity fatigue [Link] . Have the ideas of Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogof been shown to work? We're borrowing more, the deficit isn't going down [Link] * Union baronialism! Always makes me laugh when union leaders are referred to as barons. What is a baron (or baroness) Johnny. Definitely not someone democratically elected is it? Makes me laugh how language is b******ized for effect.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
P.S. Good to see a thread go off topic.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
Here's our Nige on channel 4 news last night looking rather uncomfortable when asked about working mums.
|
|
| nickgusset |
|
|---|---|
|
[Link]
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.