This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
I suspect that what Carlson is referring to is related to today's story from "Gab" highlighting the existence of a co-operation between the US and Ukraine which dates back many years. Not something new started under the current administration. The detail can be found here:-https://nationalfile.com/archived-records-show-u-s-government-admitted-funding-biolabs-ukraine-including-vaccine-development/ If you read the official agreement, rather than the spin being put on it by Carlson, Gab and the "national File" this is about assisting Ukraine to eliminate nuclear weapons and to prevent proliferation of biological weapons. Not about developing their own. Helping a friendly nation defend itself against a threatening neighbour is hardly a crime. Recent work has been on Corona vaccines. Read the statement from the US Embassy. Carlson and Gab in presenting this in the way they have are gifting propaganda to Putin. It potentially gives him cover for using chemical weapons and then blaming the Ukrainians. It is therefore not too big a stretch to suggest that in seeking to make political gestures, they could cost the lives of thousands of Ukrainians and heap misery on millions. Alongside raising the risk of a major escalation. All in the name of "free speech". For feck's sake. Watch the bloody link before you comment, the Pentagon have literally changed their story several times now. As for you links....That's similar to your claims you made over no assurances made to Russia over Nato expansion when after looking into it I found the actual literal documents were released in 2017.....the fecking literal minutes. It's the liars in this world that drag us down. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 12.26pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Tucker Carlson seems to be the only mainstream journalist actually questioning official narratives. Here he is asking questions about the biolabs uncovered in Ukraine.....At first called a conspiracy theory and now admitted to be 'securing bio-chemical weapons'....stated to be Russian weapons from 2005....That's 17 years ago, why are they still there. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 7.47am)
Starting a couple of weeks back Russia ramped up all kind of Chemical weapons angles, that they would brazenly state on even their official accounts, including that Ukrainians were stockpiling massive amounts of Ammonia to use as a chemical attack on themselves, that the United States is training birds to migrate from Ukraine to Russia and distribute bacteriological weapons, that that the US is using a bio warefare nerve/covid/ethnicity production facility in order to stage an attack. The narrative is set to throw everything at this angle and see what sticks (possibly before committing atrocities using chemical weapons in the typical pattern follows). All of these narratives are propaganda, and inadvertently you are helping to push them at a time where clearly that won't help. The bio labs one has been picked up by the likes of Chinese Assistant Minister for Foreign Affairs, and of course Tucker Carlson (as a tool to attack the current president which yeah, how useful during a situation like this.). If you're going to accuse people of being 'hysterical' in what they take in, and that the mainstream is always BS, and to be 'desperate for peace', you might not want to factor those in with stuff like this as it's certainly no different. Tucker Carlson is 'mainstream', he just plays to the emotional and political biases on a different crowd. Helping to give momentum to Russia propaganda implying a nefarious angle on chemical weapons is hardly the peace or reality take, nor is it sensible when war has been waged to go hook, line and sinker with this anti US angle as if out of everything its some pivotal finding and aspect of the moment at hand. In truth, these bio labs are not in the least bit 'secret' or some shocking revelation even if those leaning into it wish to paint it as such. Officials talked openly about the labs *during the Trump administration,* noting the US is working with Ukraine to clean these Soviet relics up. Obama even toured these sites and covered them in a speech. In 2005 Republican senators worked to improve security at the facilities. There are bio labs in the majority of countries, often with support from other countries and by their nature they contain the kind of materials that people seem shocked about when it's convenient. It's just another example of how the US is so politically divided that people are more than happy to thumb the eye of their own countrymen and act against their country, than care about essentially giving cover for potential Russian chemical attacks and further inflaming an already precarious situation. " and I'm seeing the sudden commentary on chemical weapons very concerning" Then don't buy into and spread what is propagated by Russian disinformation and those acting against their own country. It makes perfect sense for the Russian government to push this false 'biowarefare' idea from the US, when very clearly nothing of the sort has or would take place. When the West start doing their dirty work for them by pushing aspects of their messages, that's what we're in trouble.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
All throughout this war, what Russia says one day is disproved the next. Right now to denying that they intended to go to war (then doing so the next day), to yesterday denying that an attack on Ukraine has even happened, and calling those injured in a bombed maternity ward 'crisis actors'. Starting a couple of weeks back Russia ramped up all kind of Chemical weapons angles, that they would brazenly state on even their official accounts, including that Ukrainians were stockpiling massive amounts of Ammonia to use as a chemical attack on themselves, that the United States is training birds to migrate from Ukraine to Russia and distribute bacteriological weapons, that that the US is using a bio warefare nerve/covid/ethnicity production facility in order to stage an attack. The narrative is set to throw everything at this angle and see what sticks (possibly before committing atrocities using chemical weapons in the typical pattern follows). All of these narratives are propaganda, and inadvertently you are helping to push them at a time where clearly that won't help. The bio labs one has been picked up by the likes of Chinese Assistant Minister for Foreign Affairs, and of course Tucker Carlson (as a tool to attack the current president which yeah, how useful during a situation like this.). If you're going to accuse people of being 'hysterical' in what they take in, and that the mainstream is always BS, and to be 'desperate for peace', you might not want to factor those in with stuff like this as it's certainly no different. Tucker Carlson is 'mainstream', he just plays to the emotional and political biases on a different crowd. Helping to give momentum to Russia propaganda implying a nefarious angle on chemical weapons is hardly the peace or reality take, nor is it sensible when war has been waged to go hook, line and sinker with this anti US angle as if out of everything its some pivotal finding and aspect of the moment at hand. In truth, these bio labs are not in the least bit 'secret' or some shocking revelation even if those leaning into it wish to paint it as such. Officials talked openly about the labs *during the Trump administration,* noting the US is working with Ukraine to clean these Soviet relics up. Obama even toured these sites and covered them in a speech. In 2005 Republican senators worked to improve security at the facilities. There are bio labs in the majority of countries, often with support from other countries and by their nature they contain the kind of materials that people seem shocked about when it's convenient. It's just another example of how the US is so politically divided that people are more than happy to thumb the eye of their own countrymen and act against their country, than care about essentially giving cover for potential Russian chemical attacks and further inflaming an already precarious situation. " and I'm seeing the sudden commentary on chemical weapons very concerning" Then don't buy into and spread what is propagated by Russian disinformation and those acting against their own country. It makes perfect sense for the Russian government to push this false 'biowarefare' idea from the US, when very clearly nothing of the sort has or would take place. When the West start doing their dirty work for them by pushing aspects of their messages, that's what we're in trouble.
I don't contend that I know what is. However, unlike you I'm willing to question what I'm fed. Apparently you regard questioning the information from the state department and mainstream media....which is effectively the same thing as doing the enemy's work. Yet, I don't believe what Russia say either. I have a side, I just don't believe in Santa. Where does your evidence come from on these biolabs? Oh and I have zero problems with what Carlson says being questioned....that's kind of the point. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 1.30pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
For feck's sake. Watch the bloody link before you comment, the Pentagon have literally changed their story several times now. As for you links....That's similar to your claims you made over no assurances made to Russia over Nato expansion when after looking into it I found the actual literal documents were released in 2017.....the fecking literal minutes. It's the liars in this world that drag us down. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 12.26pm) Of course I watched the links! I also read the statement from the Embassy. There we go again! Assuming that any one document means that the conclusion you want is a proven fact. I have now explained several times why this isn't so but, as with other subjects, once a fixed position is set in some minds it becomes as hard as concrete. No-one doubts the authenticity of the documents, but even they contain doubts, and uncertainties over what was said and what it meant. Most of it refers to exchanges between participants exploring possibilities, rather than the taking up of definitive positions. That some were more specific doesn't mean they spoke from a position of absolute authority. The final, and critical, key matters are that Nato itself wasn't involved. Only some key members. Whilst they can comment, they cannot commit. Only Nato can do that. The absolute key issue though is Putin himself. These discussions were pre-Putin and were held between people with some integrity, with whom some trust had been established. Putin has destroyed that. Macmillan's phrase about the most important thing in politics comes to mind, "Events, dear boy, events". Putin is an event. One that changed everything.
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Of course I watched the links! I also read the statement from the Embassy. There we go again! Assuming that any one document means that the conclusion you want is a proven fact. I have now explained several times why this isn't so but, as with other subjects, once a fixed position is set in some minds it becomes as hard as concrete. No-one doubts the authenticity of the documents, but even they contain doubts, and uncertainties over what was said and what it meant. Most of it refers to exchanges between participants exploring possibilities, rather than the taking up of definitive positions. That some were more specific doesn't mean they spoke from a position of absolute authority. The final, and critical, key matters are that Nato itself wasn't involved. Only some key members. Whilst they can comment, they cannot commit. Only Nato can do that. The absolute key issue though is Putin himself. These discussions were pre-Putin and were held between people with some integrity, with whom some trust had been established. Putin has destroyed that. Macmillan's phrase about the most important thing in politics comes to mind, "Events, dear boy, events". Putin is an event. One that changed everything. It wasn't one document! Didn't you actually go to the site and scroll down. There are dozens of documents detailing the promises and assurances given. Yes, they were pre-Putin, however I linked you to the speech Yelsin gave on Nato expansion....it reads like a prediction for today. Putin was always bad news, however in terms of Nato he did not start off where he is today, that's well documented as well......the Putin you have now comes after failure and failure of state-craft and it wasn't until around 2004 that things really turned bad.....and that was over the Ukraine....again.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
I don't contend that I know what is. However, unlike you I'm willing to question what I'm fed. Apparently you regard questioning the information from the state department and mainstream media....which is effectively the same thing as doing the enemy's work. Yet, I don't believe what Russia say either. I have a side, I just don't believe in Santa. Where does your evidence come from on these biolabs? Oh and I have zero problems with what Carlson says being questioned....that's kind of the point. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 1.30pm)
And of course, bio labs being bio labs, why is it such a shock that they may have preserved strains for research purposes? You're hardly some kind of 'truthseeker'. You're more one eyed than many of those you mock, just in a different direction. Your take here plays directly into the hands of a propaganda campaign suddenly throwing out so many insane and far fetched bio warfare angles at the west (in all likelihood to cover for their own intentions) that it's beyond ludicrous that you're helping to propel one of them. Backing up Russian propaganda and fixating on a biolab that's been known about for a decade plus as if its some disturbing turn of events, rather than cover for a possible attack on innocents. Anti western nonsense. If there's a chemical attack on the Ukrainian people in the coming days and you're back on here being all 'oh maybe they did it themselves, maybe it was the US lab', then we'll known you're totally mentally gone. It's possible to 'question' your own country, or that of allies without buying into aspects and momentum of bulls*** russian seeded narratives like you have here. But never mind, you know better don't you.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Do you think you are talking to some kind of f***ing hippy or something? I'm not an egalitarian, we have nuclear weapons because of our status as a world power. I'm not a plonker who thinks everyone should have the most f***ing dangerous weapons in human history, whose mass release is capable of sending us back to the stone age. The Ukraine had left over Soviet nukes....they weren't 'theirs' and the agreement you're talking about was struck during a very different time in their relations. I couldn't give a monkey's uncle over the rights and wrongs of those decisions. I care about my children growing up. I wish some posters on here would grow up.
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
God only knows why you take what Carlson said as the truth and an act of 'willing to question'. It contains various contortions .. at 5:34 he implies that the official government line at one time was that these facilities were worked on vaccines and potential outbreaks (with no mention of anything else). The only reason nothing else was mentioned is that he specifically didn't tell you about those parts of the statement. It also states "the U.S. Department of Defense’s Biological Threat Reduction Program works with the Ukrainian Government to consolidate and secure pathogens and toxins of security concern in Ukrainian government facilities". Under Trump, Obama, and prior they have not been particularly shy about the lab or what it contains. And of course, bio labs being bio labs, why is it such a shock that they may have preserved strains for research purposes? You're hardly some kind of 'truthseeker'. You're more one eyed than many of those you mock, just in a different direction. Your take here plays directly into the hands of a propaganda campaign suddenly throwing out so many insane and far fetched bio warfare angles at the west (in all likelihood to cover for their own intentions) that it's beyond ludicrous that you're helping to propel one of them. Backing up Russian propaganda and fixating on a biolab that's been known about for a decade plus as if its some disturbing turn of events, rather than cover for a possible attack on innocents. Anti western nonsense. If there's a chemical attack on the Ukrainian people in the coming days and you're back on here being all 'oh maybe they did it themselves, maybe it was the US lab', then we'll known you're totally mentally gone. It's possible to 'question' your own country, or that of allies without buying into aspects and momentum of bulls*** russian seeded narratives like you have here. But never mind, you know better don't you.
Again, Where does your evidence come from on these biolabs? I want to see where all this certainty comes from. Apparently Tucker Carlson has no reasons for questions....if that's right I'm open to knowing. Once again, I'm interested in proof for something before I believe it. Not emotive takes. It's quite funny that just questions counts as Russian propaganda...apparently Carlson is a 'russian tool'. Yet your regular posts of mainstream media takes on who does what isn't propaganda because the fog of war doesn't exist for you it seems. And again, the Ukrainians are the invaded and have the right to defend themselves. So I certainly support western support in that regard. However, over and above that we have the fog of war and propaganda which comes from both sides....even though your emotional investment only sees the Russian. I certainly do see myself as a 'truthseeker', that's a standard that I think less people care about today.......I won't always get it right of course but I will always try to be honest about it. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 2.06pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 8.33am) Again, the US fund and contribute towards bio labs in numerous countries. We know why they are there and what you class as 'lies', seems to be entirely counter to the fact that under the past three presidents the labs have been openly talked about and occasionally even visited by Presidents. How 'secret'. Again, in the last two weeks there has been an enormous propaganda push by Russians and their useful idiots, to infer that the US or Ukrainians are gearing up for a bio weapons type attack on Ukrainians or others. Much of what they pushed was so absurd;y far fetched that's it's laughable, and regardless of whether some run with one aspect of it, its still clearly part of that same campaign. The Russian gov has pushed so much that is clearly nonsense (including the idea that they have not invaded, and have not gone to war and that they are fighting 'neo nazis'
|
|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
Again, the US fund and contribute towards bio labs in numerous countries. We know why they are there and what you class as 'lies', seems to be entirely counter to the fact that under the past three presidents the labs have been openly talked about and occasionally even visited by Presidents. How 'secret'. Again, in the last two weeks there has been an enormous propaganda push by Russians and their useful idiots, to infer that the US or Ukrainians are gearing up for a bio weapons type attack on Ukrainians or others. Much of what they pushed was so absurd;y far fetched that's it's laughable, and regardless of whether some run with one aspect of it, its still clearly part of that same campaign. The Russian gov has pushed so much that is clearly nonsense (including the idea that they have not invaded, and have not gone to war and that they are fighting 'neo nazis'
Anyway, this idea that because Russia say something that it means it should be believed is nonsense. Russia lies, and it's an awful regime. I don't know anyone who is saying Russia is an innocent party. If a chemical attack happens, the details will matter. I have no doubt Russia are considering it...I put nothing pass them. As I say, I'm not stating that any of your takes are wrong....perhaps every single one of them or most of them are correct. What I've stated relates to objectivity, questions and propaganda. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 2.28pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
If a chemical attack happens, the details will matter. I have no doubt Russia are considering it...I put nothing pass them.
"Claims that Ukrainians were stockpiling massive amounts of Ammonia to use as a chemical attack on themselves, that the United States is training birds to migrate from Ukraine to Russia and distribute bacteriological weapons, that that the US is using a bio warefare nerve/covid/ethnicity production facility in order to stage an attack." Consider why this is their sudden angle, and how it diminishes any aspect as being a genuine concern. There lies a rational conclusion. Edited by BlueJay (11 Mar 2022 2.55pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
It wasn't one document! Didn't you actually go to the site and scroll down. There are dozens of documents detailing the promises and assurances given. Yes, they were pre-Putin, however I linked you to the speech Yelsin gave on Nato expansion....it reads like a prediction for today. Putin was always bad news, however in terms of Nato he did not start off where he is today, that's well documented as well......the Putin you have now comes after failure and failure of state-craft and it wasn't until around 2004 that things really turned bad.....and that was over the Ukraine....again. Lots of documents all saying similar things doesn't add up to anything. If you have ever watched the video of Yeltsin on the night Putin was elected, he knew what was coming from him. His face spoke volumes. He knew he had been conned and had made a huge mistake. Anything he said on Nato has to be seen in that context. Putin is clever, but if you study what he has said, he has always regarded the collapse of the Soviet Union as a disaster and that his mission is to restore Russia's pride. In his early days he conned us, like he conned Yeltsin, by appearing more progressive and accommodating. Last night I watched an address to the Oxford Union, by Sir John Sawyer, who was head of MI6 during the Blair years, and beyond, and who has observed Putin at close quarters. It was a fascinating insight by someone who was there, and really knows. You can watch it here:- [Link]
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Lots of documents all saying similar things doesn't add up to anything. I rather beg to differ. I'm not really interested in making points other than the Nato expansion statecraft, truth and lies which led....both to Putin and then eventually to this war.....Alongside Taiwan probably the most predicted war in history.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
You can watch it here:- [Link] Thanks for telling us about this Wisbech. Sir John Sawyer speaks eloquently about the events unfolding in Ukraine and how they may develop. It was a very interesting insight from someone who has a good understanding of International politics. Fascinating indeed.
Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled. |
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
For feck's sake. Watch the bloody link before you comment, the Pentagon have literally changed their story several times now. As for you links....That's similar to your claims you made over no assurances made to Russia over Nato expansion when after looking into it I found the actual literal documents were released in 2017.....the fecking literal minutes. It's the liars in this world that drag us down. Edited by Stirlingsays (11 Mar 2022 12.26pm)
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by croydon proud
I would think from a self interest perspective he must be rather pleased that the narrative has moved on. Important of course not to let wider realities that are clearly taking place become politicised though. As much I have no issue with Boris and co getting egg on their face, I'm not about to turn my back on clear realities taking place.
|
|
| BlueJay |
|
|---|---|
|
"The Air Force Command reports that Russian planes turned around above Ukraine, after which they struck the territory of Belarus. Source: Armed Forces Air Force Command of Ukraine on Facebook, State Border Guard Service According to the Air Force Command: "Today at 14:30 the State Border Guard Service received information that Russian planes entered the territory of Ukraine, turned over our towns of Horodychi and Tumeni, and then fired on the settlement of Kopani (Belarus)." Details: The Air Force added that currently the 9th Border Detachment is observing the occupation of the town of Kopani by enemy troops. "This is a provocation! The goal is to involve the Armed Forces of the Republic of Belarus in the war with Ukraine!" the statement reads." - [Link] Logically this would be a useful step for Russia to escalate the invasion so rationally it wouldn't be surprising 'if true'. A future ramping up of the war would certainly be bad news for Ukraine. Hopefully they are being sent enough weaponry to hold out, but even if they are we then have the likely chemical angle to contend with. Especially if Russia wish to retrain any functional infrastructure in Ukraine, rather than occupy a bombed out hell hole. Edited by BlueJay (11 Mar 2022 6.10pm)
|
|
| croydon proud |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by BlueJay
I would think from a self interest perspective he must be rather pleased that the narrative has moved on. Important of course not to let wider realities that are clearly taking place become politicised though. As much I have no issue with Boris and co getting egg on their face, I'm not about to turn my back on clear realities taking place. Yeah, im with the Ukraine 100 %obviously, we could be next, just saying the importance of trusting your pm, and everybody knows he lies, often, so him talking about people lying was so ironic!Definately came at a great time for him, makes you wonder if the 5 man table theory has some gravitas, you invade there, we give you this, you take credit for that, we put inflation and interest rates up everywhere, we sell you these arms, but when shall we start the war? "Start asap", says bungle," the sooner the better!"War blows over-(hopefully), bungle is hailed as the new churchill-by the usual subjects, they doff hats, win win for bungle, give him another 10 years!
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.