This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I dunno... To win elections these days you've got to be closer to the centre ground, as well as having a cohesive strategy. Also helps if you haven't been the incumbent for a decade. Demonstrably true. Also factually true as the majority of the electorate are neither left or right. But as you proved. We differ in our opinions the same as all voters. If the Tory party was too far to the right and reform were even farther why was their joint vote count so high?
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
To win modern elections in this country you need to be centre right or centre left. Muddled policies, a recent history of failure, poor campaigning with a lack of focus on swing voters and multiple unelected leaders in a short space of time, plus the incumbent problem did for the Tories. Just like those on the left, those on the right are guilty of confirmation bias when it comes to how large a portion of the electorate they actually have, or will ever have.' Also re. percentages, and overstating Reform performance, for ref. 'The Conservatives lost votes to everyone. 25% of the 2019 vote to Reform, 23% to the left. The latter count double. Losing votes to the left ensured election defeat. Bleeding so heavily to reform turned that defeat into a cataclysm.' Viewed from 2015, we've mostly seen the same ~15% of voters grow, collapse into the Tory vote, then re-spawn. It's not some new massive surge in right-populist voting. Edited by SW19 CPFC (09 Jul 2024 7.06pm) This is simply not true. The labour vote went down by 565,000 compared to 2019 so how could there have been a 23% swing from the tories to labour? This evaluation is based on percentages of vote for 2024 compared with 2019 without taking into account the turn out. Turnout was down 7.6% and there were an extra 1 million voters registered!!!! So the labour performance looks even poorer for a so called landslide. Reform achieved 4.1M votes, with 6 weeks of campaigning. The tories 6.8M. That cannot be over stated no matter what you say. And add those together and they beat labour! The tory vote was down by 7.14M!!!!! And before you do the math on those numbers and say Reform didn't take all of the tory vote turnout was down by 3.6M i.e. A lot of tory voters sat on their hands. The winner of this election was none of the above.
|
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
I dunno... To win elections these days you've got to be closer to the centre ground, as well as having a cohesive strategy. Also helps if you haven't been the incumbent for a decade. Demonstrably true. Also factually true as the majority of the electorate are neither left or right. The Tories literally ran as liberals and lost. Reform are a Thatcher lite party and Thatcher won three terms....Indeed Johnson won an eighty seat majority with the red wall thinking he was going to protect them from immigration. I predict you're wrong. Unless the Tories vote in someone like Braverman and move to the right they aren't going to compete at elections.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by The groover
This is simply not true. The labour vote went down by 565,000 compared to 2019 so how could there have been a 23% swing from the tories to labour? This evaluation is based on percentages of vote for 2024 compared with 2019 without taking into account the turn out. Turnout was down 7.6% and there were an extra 1 million voters registered!!!! So the labour performance looks even poorer for a so called landslide. Reform achieved 4.1M votes, with 6 weeks of campaigning. The tories 6.8M. That cannot be over stated no matter what you say. And add those together and they beat labour! The tory vote was down by 7.14M!!!!! And before you do the math on those numbers and say Reform didn't take all of the tory vote turnout was down by 3.6M i.e. A lot of tory voters sat on their hands. The winner of this election was none of the above. But they don’t beat a coalition of left wing parties, which is surely the appropriate comparison. The left vote is split in every single election - it happens to the right once and you get people trying to invent all sort of conclusions about what I means. The winner of the election is very clearly the party with a huge majority, with Reform and Greens performing very well.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Spin. What you were actually saying is that you think the Tories should pretend to care about immigration and all the mess that has come with it. They did that last time and look how well it went. No one trusts Labour or the Tories on immigration, be it illegal or otherwise. Reform will not go away. The electorate have heard all the lies and broken promises before. Despite some people’s obsession with it, it’s not all about immigration, and will be even less so in 2029. With a resurgent centre right Tory party pointing at Reform and telling the electorate that they were responsible for creating the circumstances that enabled Labour to produce the mess of the past 5 years they will be well placed to get back in. Decisive action now to isolate their right wing would help achieve that, even if in the short term it might mean a few defecting to Farage. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (10 Jul 2024 8.32am)
For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
But they don’t beat a coalition of left wing parties, which is surely the appropriate comparison. The left vote is split in every single election - it happens to the right once and you get people trying to invent all sort of conclusions about what I means. The winner of the election is very clearly the party with a huge majority, with Reform and Greens performing very well. That's certainly true with the Scottish and Welsh Nationalist parties whose rise cost Labour quite dearly.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Despite some people’s obsession with it, it’s not all about immigration, and will be even less so in 2029. With a resurgent centre right Tory party pointing at Reform and telling the electorate that they were responsible for creating the circumstances that enabled Labour to produce the mess of the past 5 years they will be well placed to get back in. Decisive action now to isolate their right wing would help achieve that, even if in the short term it might mean a few defecting to Farage. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (10 Jul 2024 8.32am) And that would be more lies. You are all about politics. That is depressing. I want what is best for this country. While the usual fools try hard to undermine the right, this country is falling apart, mainly due to mass immigration. Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (10 Jul 2024 9.09am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
I voted Reform, not because I thought(or cared about) Tories Lying to us, what they did in their personal lives, or how much taxpayers money they wasted(although that does irk me somewhat), but that I believed their policies were failing the country. I don't believe Labour would be any better, their policies on the major things aren't different enough. Reforms policies identified the issues this Country faced, however unpopular or unfashionable they may be, and offered a viable alternative to the same old, same old priorities and strategies offered up by anyone and everyone else. I do wonder what the chances are of a Tory-Reform Coalition at the next GE are, and how they'd perform... There can't be a formal coalition between wet Tories and Reform. There could be an agreement not to contest seats in the red wall for example, where Reform have greater support. They could then do likewise in seats where the Tories would do better. Whether that would work in practice really depends on where the Parties are come 2029.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CrazyBadger
I voted Reform, not because I thought(or cared about) Tories Lying to us, what they did in their personal lives, or how much taxpayers money they wasted(although that does irk me somewhat), but that I believed their policies were failing the country. I don't believe Labour would be any better, their policies on the major things aren't different enough. Reforms policies identified the issues this Country faced, however unpopular or unfashionable they may be, and offered a viable alternative to the same old, same old priorities and strategies offered up by anyone and everyone else. I do wonder what the chances are of a Tory-Reform Coalition at the next GE are, and how they'd perform... Did you ever consider that our apathy to things like politicians lying to us and stealing our money are linked to the country going in the wrong direction?
|
|
|
Just wait till labour come for our pensions and invite the world in without increasing services like schools, hospitals, transport etc....
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Did you ever consider that our apathy to things like politicians lying to us and stealing our money are linked to the country going in the wrong direction? Perhaps, if that was anything new. This country has been going in the wrong direction since WW2 because we spent what was left of our empire wealth defeating Hitler. We have to accept that we cannot continue to flood the country with immigrants or expect to provide lifestyles like the USA. We are on the road to self destruction if we continue with the same short sighted band aid policies.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eaglesdare
Just wait till labour come for our pensions and invite the world in without increasing services like schools, hospitals, transport etc.... The left are always guilty of applying short termism and ideological mumbo jumbo. They don't understand the longer term effects of filling jobs and propping up the age related costs via mass immigration. Taxation will not create growth. It will do the opposite.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
Perhaps, if that was anything new. This country has been going in the wrong direction since WW2 because we spent what was left of our empire wealth defeating Hitler. We have to accept that we cannot continue to flood the country with immigrants or expect to provide lifestyles like the USA. We are on the road to self destruction if we continue with the same short sighted band aid policies. Right, but lying and stealing public funds becomes a lot more problematic with the economic realities you highlight above.
|
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Right, but lying and stealing public funds becomes a lot more problematic with the economic realities you highlight above. I'm not going to defend politicians. They have screwed us royally.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
The Tories literally ran as liberals and lost. Reform are a Thatcher lite party and Thatcher won three terms....Indeed Johnson won an eighty seat majority with the red wall thinking he was going to protect them from immigration. I predict you're wrong. Unless the Tories vote in someone like Braverman and move to the right they aren't going to compete at elections. You're overlooking a lot of key reasons why the electorate chose not to vote Tory Clue – It wasn't only to do with how centre or right they were. Seems that you're being very binary as to why they lost, i.e. only because they weren't right enough. Fits with your ideology but not with reality. Contributing factor, sure, but not the only one.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons. |
|
|
Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow
Did you ever consider that our apathy to things like politicians lying to us and stealing our money are linked to the country going in the wrong direction? not really tbh. Afterall, the next political misdemeanor is only a sensationalist exposé away and I have as little faith in the existence of reasoned, balanced reporting than I do in to the aforementioned politicians. So the only thing I have to go on is the state of the nation.
"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one" |
|
|
Originally posted by SW19 CPFC
You're overlooking a lot of key reasons why the electorate chose not to vote Tory Clue – It wasn't only to do with how centre or right they were. Seems that you're being very binary as to why they lost, i.e. only because they weren't right enough. Fits with your ideology but not with reality. Contributing factor, sure, but not the only one. I tend to think you're doing the same thing. It wasn't only because they weren't right wing enough we certainly agree on that. Explaining the full reasons for what happened would take a couple of lengthy posts. Certainly, not being right wing enough was the factor that created Reform and thus allowed many dissatisfied and thus former Conservative voters their alternative vote. This idea that you can just ignore Reform and create a centralised Conservative party.....thus ignoring its right wing base is just unrealistic in my view. Farage is not Tice and he's a lot better at grandstanding than the rather boring collection of (excepting Johnson) centralised liberal Conservatives. As the country will just continue in its managed decline state under Starmer the attraction of a 'Thatcher lite' party (which isn't really my personal politics) will only grow. I certainly notice that the Conservative party staying in the centre is the opinion of many Labour supporters and/or centralists/leftists it's not hard to understand why. Edited by Stirlingsays (10 Jul 2024 12.14pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Despite some people’s obsession with it, it’s not all about immigration, and will be even less so in 2029. With a resurgent centre right Tory party pointing at Reform and telling the electorate that they were responsible for creating the circumstances that enabled Labour to produce the mess of the past 5 years they will be well placed to get back in. Decisive action now to isolate their right wing would help achieve that, even if in the short term it might mean a few defecting to Farage. But a lot is. The secondary effects are felt by all of us. NHS, schools, housing etc. it’s not just about the fact they are here. It’s about what they don’t do. Edited by Wisbech Eagle (10 Jul 2024 8.32am)
|
|
|
And labour want to give control to elected mayors.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.