You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 79 of 80 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 >
Stirlingsays Flag 26 Aug 14 10.20pm

Quote Kermit8 at 26 Aug 2014 9.59pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Aug 2014 9.53pm

Quote Kermit8 at 26 Aug 2014 9.00pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Aug 2014 8.56pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Aug 2014 8.34pm

Yes not wrong.


As we are talking about being wrong....May I remind you both that you posted on the other thread in support of the idea that Israel would be staying in Gaza to take over their oil industry.


Did I? Are you sure?

btw the Israeli gov are, apparently, already stealing gas supplies from Gazan waters.


You typed in support of Nick's idea.....You seem to be endorsing it here?

Stealing from waters? What legal rights does a city like Gaza have in terms of offshore?

It isn't a state.


Gaza is not a city it's an enclave. Under International law is the answer to your question.

Edited by Kermit8 (26 Aug 2014 10.01pm)


Seems a bit petty Kermy. Anyway you haven't answered the question upon what their legal access to oil offshore is......Saying international law isn't an answer.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 26 Aug 14 10.22pm

Quote nickgusset at 26 Aug 2014 10.17pm

Signed up? Was of the opinion that perhaps. I was wrong (for now) about Israel staying in Gaza, however, I didn't know that they are already taking the gas from Gazan waters, so I was also right.

What's most disappointing is that you - a fellow teacher - didn't pick me up on my misspelt 'their'.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

davidpercival Flag Croydon 27 Aug 14 2.39pm

Israel started this latest round and all they have done is increase world support for a Palestinian state and isolated themselves even more.

We don't know the details of the agreement yet but it seems Israel has had to accept that it cannot keep the border points closed and it looks like they may well have to accept that Gaza will have some sort of sea port and an airfield (something that they agreed before and then went back on).

It looks like Palestine has won this battle despite (or perhaps because of) the wicked killing of basically defenceless people by Israel.

Someone once said that it is better to die on your feet than to live on your knees. Think what you would do if our part of England was controlled by a foreign force that would not let us come and go as we pleased to other parts of England, and decided what we could and couldn't import and export. Surely we would fight back with whatever weapons we could get hold of. That is all the Palestinians have been doing after an occupation lasting 47 years.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 27 Aug 14 3.58pm

Quote davidpercival at 27 Aug 2014 2.39pm

Israel started this latest round and all they have done is increase world support for a Palestinian state and isolated themselves even more.

We don't know the details of the agreement yet but it seems Israel has had to accept that it cannot keep the border points closed and it looks like they may well have to accept that Gaza will have some sort of sea port and an airfield (something that they agreed before and then went back on).

It looks like Palestine has won this battle despite (or perhaps because of) the wicked killing of basically defenceless people by Israel.

Someone once said that it is better to die on your feet than to live on your knees. Think what you would do if our part of England was controlled by a foreign force that would not let us come and go as we pleased to other parts of England, and decided what we could and couldn't import and export. Surely we would fight back with whatever weapons we could get hold of. That is all the Palestinians have been doing after an occupation lasting 47 years.

I would say no one has won. Thousands are dead. The only difference is that Hamas have had their military capabilities weakened significantly, which was arguably why Israel responded so intensely to Hamas' provocation.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 30 Aug 14 1.06am

[Link]


Even the Palestinian Leader blames Hamas with around 2100 people killed on the Palestinian side and 200 of them civilians. Does that mean 1900 of them were terrorists?

 


Pro USA & Israel

Big Guy Flag 30 Aug 14 9.50am

This is a clear victory for Hamas and the Palestinian people. The Israeli war machine has been faced down and sent back with its tail between it's legs. Hamas remains intact and will continue to defend themselves. No peace without justice.

 


Time to go Alan

pefwin Flag Where you have to have an English ... 30 Aug 14 6.29pm

Quote Big Guy at 30 Aug 2014 9.50am

This is a clear victory for Hamas and the Palestinian people. The Israeli war machine has been faced down and sent back with its tail between it's legs. Hamas remains intact and will continue to defend themselves. No peace without justice.


Israel's win would have been not to invade in the first place, but to deal with the initial issue (the student killing)politically.

 


"Everything is air-droppable at least once."

"When the going gets tough, the tough call for close air support."

Stirlingsays Flag 30 Aug 14 6.54pm

Quote Big Guy at 30 Aug 2014 9.50am

This is a clear victory for Hamas and the Palestinian people. The Israeli war machine has been faced down and sent back with its tail between it's legs. Hamas remains intact and will continue to defend themselves. No peace without justice.


This is completely divorced from reality. Israel could flatten Gaza if they wanted to.

Survival isn't really victory mate.....It's errrr....survival. I'm very critical of Likud and this action in Gaza but as you are blowing hot air about Hamss I'm basically going to put to you that Hamas achieve nothing for Gaza but pain and poverty.

They play into Likud's hands and like Likud they are invested in keeping the current dynamic going....All they have to offer is extremism.

The IDF basically flattened the borderlands of Gaza alongside Israel and destroyed tunnels where they found them. That was their intention and after they finished they left......Of course Hamas will always have the deluded around to spin nonsense......Hundreds dead and thousands without homes and businesses....Some victory.....How about I come along with a bulldozer and flatten your home mate. You can stay in your neighbour's house and throw rocks at the bulldozer....When I'm gone you can declare victory.

Hamas can't be beaten because they hide amongst civilians...Suspended democracy, manipulate media and journalists and a terrible human rights record....They aren't IS but they aren't much better in my view.


Edited by Stirlingsays (30 Aug 2014 8.12pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 Sep 14 8.24am

And just when things are relatively calm the Israeli gov decide to steal more Palestinian land in the West Bank. They don't miss a criminal opportunity that Likud lot, do they? Gangsters dressed up as politicians.

[Link]

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


serial thriller Flag The Promised Land 01 Sep 14 6.04pm

Quote Kermit8 at 01 Sep 2014 8.24am

And just when things are relatively calm the Israeli gov decide to steal more Palestinian land in the West Bank. They don't miss a criminal opportunity that Likud lot, do they? Gangsters dressed up as politicians.

[Link]


If you get land based on every three kids who have died in conflict, Palestine must stretch to f***ing France by now...

 


If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Sep 14 8.17pm

[Link]

In other threads, some have said those leaving our shores to fight for IS shouldn't be allowed back. Do the same people feel the same applies in this case?
Just curious.

 

TUX Flag redhill 05 Sep 14 9.08pm

Quote nickgusset at 18 Nov 2012 7.11pm

Anyone else think Israel are being a tad heavy handed?

Yep. But they have the West on their side


 

legaleagle Flag 05 Sep 14 9.38pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Sep 2014 8.17pm

[Link]

In other threads, some have said those leaving our shores to fight for IS shouldn't be allowed back. Do the same people feel the same applies in this case?
Just curious.


Even more interesting if you apply the analogy to Brits fighting for the Kurds against ISIS...and European citizens who fought with HAMAS...

Historically, we had Brits fighting on both sides in the Spanish Civil War.

One person's freedom fighter can be another's aider of the oppressor or helper of the equally bad..

Do we all basically only raise points when it suits our own beliefs and agenda ...rather than hold indivisible moral views regardless...

30,000 demonstrating every week recently re Gaza...a radically lesser figure re Iraq/Syria more recently where far more brutality and deaths have occurred this year...

Your question is reasonable to raise but the more I think about it (and I do not advocate stopping people returning since it would breach international law))the harder it is to find an answer that is one size fits all globally...

Edited by legaleagle (05 Sep 2014 10.00pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Sep 14 6.10pm

Quote legaleagle at 05 Sep 2014 9.38pm

Quote nickgusset at 05 Sep 2014 8.17pm

[Link]

In other threads, some have said those leaving our shores to fight for IS shouldn't be allowed back. Do the same people feel the same applies in this case?
Just curious.


Even more interesting if you apply the analogy to Brits fighting for the Kurds against ISIS...and European citizens who fought with HAMAS...

Historically, we had Brits fighting on both sides in the Spanish Civil War.

One person's freedom fighter can be another's aider of the oppressor or helper of the equally bad..

Do we all basically only raise points when it suits our own beliefs and agenda ...rather than hold indivisible moral views regardless...

30,000 demonstrating every week recently re Gaza...a radically lesser figure re Iraq/Syria more recently where far more brutality and deaths have occurred this year...

Your question is reasonable to raise but the more I think about it (and I do not advocate stopping people returning since it would breach international law))the harder it is to find an answer that is one size fits all globally...

Edited by legaleagle (05 Sep 2014 10.00pm)

It would breach international law?

Quick hide under your beds....We have to spend loads of money watching even more nutcases and have a higher risk of being blown up because......We can't breach international law?

International law can do one.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 13 Sep 14 6.30pm

Think about that Stirling and the implications if all countries everywhere feel at ease completely ignoring it whenever they like.Forget having any credibility when criticising others for breaking it.You can't just pick and choose the bits you like and don't particularly when you chop and change depending on the circumstances.

Chuck it out the window when anyway you have all the powers you need to arrest and charge any "terrorists" upon re-entry.Think it through in a context of general principles,not ISIS or Israel/Palestine.


Forget any war crimes tribunals for a future ex Yugoslavia

Forger the Nuremberg trials

Forget international conventions on treatment of PoW's

Forget diplomatic immunity and sanctity of embassy premises

forget unified laws re rights concerning continental shelfs

forget international conventions re the environment.

forget unified laws re territorial integrity.

forget the law of the sea.

Yup,lets just chuck the whole lot out,Stirling.Fab idea.

Edited by legaleagle (13 Sep 2014 6.45pm)

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Sep 14 7.21pm

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Think about that Stirling and the implications if all countries everywhere feel at ease completely ignoring it whenever they like.Forget having any credibility when criticising others for breaking it.

Credibility?......Are you serious? Protecting your own citizens against stupidly framed catch all laws isn't going to damage credibility at all.

Other countries break international laws all the time and it makes no difference.....Not forgetting that 'international law' isn't set in stone or all important.

The US have broken it.....Israel breaks it....China breaks it....pakistan and India break it....I could go on and on.

What does following international law over and above your own national interest get you: Nothing.

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm


You can't just pick and choose the bits you like and don't particularly when you chop and change depending on the circumstances.

Yes you can.....and you should. I don't believe in world government....The centralization and policing of law.

Countries that believe in set principles should join together and enact those principles......Hell....That's what actually happens in all the important events in the world anyway..... 'International law' is a joke and always has been since the league of nations.

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Chuck it out the window when anyway you have all the powers you need to arrest and charge any "terrorists" upon re-entry.Think it through in a context of general principles,not ISIS or Israel/Palestine.

You don't need 'international law to arrest 'terrorists'....Extradition treaties have been doing that for centuries......Hell in effect that's the process under which most are arrested even now.


Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Forget any war crimes tribunals for a future ex Yugoslavia

Why? The States and the EU basically settled that war anyway.....Why can't they try who they want how they want?

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Forger the Nuremberg trials

Lets forget that the Nuremberg trials were hardly a great statement for 'international law' in the first place.....It simply wasn't needed.


Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Forget international conventions on treatment of PoW's

Forget diplomatic immunity and sanctity of embassy premises

You're kidding right? No unethical country follows those laws anyway and civilised countries were following them way way before they were called 'international'.

They mean little.....Germany had signed up before WW2 but just ignored them.....We probably did as well when it suited.


Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

forget unified laws re rights concerning continental shelfs


Ok.....I'll forget about that.

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

forget international conventions re the environment.

China opened up four coal plants a month in 2012.....I think I'll be ok not worrying about the effectiveness of International law on the environment.

The only chance for the environment is future technology.

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

forget unified laws re territorial integrity.

Seriously legal....Is that a one liner?

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

forget the law of the sea.

You mean how countries do all around the world all the time....Right is might.

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm

Yup,lets just chuck the whole lot out,Stirling.Fab idea.

Most of what you have stated doesn't need 'international law'. It can all be achieved regionally.


Edited by legaleagle (13 Sep 2014 6.45pm)


Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Sep 2014 7.24pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

legaleagle Flag 13 Sep 14 7.40pm

Sorry,but completely disagree with you and not convinced in any way by your responses,and yes I am indeed serious. Defects in aspects of adherence by some to international law including the UK (what is even remotely perfect in this world?) do not justify jettisoning it or the desirability of adhering to it.We'd all be a hell of a lot worse off without it IMO.Plus its in our national interests to promote adherence to it.We were a major player in developing it and those aspects of a liberal democratic system approach underpinning it.

Forgive me not having the energy tonight to debate the ins and outs.If you disagree? Fine,lets just chuck the whole lot out then Stirling.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Sep 14 9.24pm

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 7.40pm

Sorry,but completely disagree with you and not convinced in any way by your responses,and yes I am indeed serious. Defects in aspects of adherence by some to international law including the UK (what is even remotely perfect in this world?) do not justify jettisoning it or the desirability of adhering to it.We'd all be a hell of a lot worse off without it IMO.Plus its in our national interests to promote adherence to it.We were a major player in developing it and those aspects of a liberal democratic system approach underpinning it.

Forgive me not having the energy tonight to debate the ins and outs.If you disagree? Fine,lets just chuck the whole lot out then Stirling.

It's fine for you to disagree.

While I could pick holes in international law all night long and probably be the least distinguished person in a long line of people who could do it I'm not particularly bothered with jettisoning it.

Many egalitarians refer to it like it's some kind of world wide panacea when the reality is that it rarely if ever has been.

What I'd do is simply what all countries do that feel strongly about an issue....do what is in your best self interest.....The credibility argument just doesn't hold water......If what you are doing causes a problem with allied countries....Talk to them, if the issue has any reasonableness behind it a solution will be found.

In terms of not allowing 'British' fighters to come back from Syria.....Well, I'd do that......If I could come up with some bulls*** cover of words that resulted in the same thing, fine.....But the fact is I wouldn't allow for international law to decrease the safety and increase the costs for our citizens.

Real action in this world has always come from alliances of the willing and nods to 'international law' exist only to put a shiny veneer to the often bloody proceedings....Oh and to pay the lawyers.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Sep 14 9.15am

Quote Stirlingsays at 13 Sep 2014 9.24pm

Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 7.40pm

Sorry,but completely disagree with you and not convinced in any way by your responses,and yes I am indeed serious. Defects in aspects of adherence by some to international law including the UK (what is even remotely perfect in this world?) do not justify jettisoning it or the desirability of adhering to it.We'd all be a hell of a lot worse off without it IMO.Plus its in our national interests to promote adherence to it.We were a major player in developing it and those aspects of a liberal democratic system approach underpinning it.

Forgive me not having the energy tonight to debate the ins and outs.If you disagree? Fine,lets just chuck the whole lot out then Stirling.

It's fine for you to disagree.

While I could pick holes in international law all night long and probably be the least distinguished person in a long line of people who could do it I'm not particularly bothered with jettisoning it.

Many egalitarians refer to it like it's some kind of world wide panacea when the reality is that it rarely if ever has been.

What I'd do is simply what all countries do that feel strongly about an issue....do what is in your best self interest.....The credibility argument just doesn't hold water......If what you are doing causes a problem with allied countries....Talk to them, if the issue has any reasonableness behind it a solution will be found.

In terms of not allowing 'British' fighters to come back from Syria.....Well, I'd do that......If I could come up with some bulls*** cover of words that resulted in the same thing, fine.....But the fact is I wouldn't allow for international law to decrease the safety and increase the costs for our citizens.

Real action in this world has always come from alliances of the willing and nods to 'international law' exist only to put a shiny veneer to the often bloody proceedings....Oh and to pay the lawyers.



And there endeth this part of the conversation. Are we culling Scots related names in leiu of a yes vote on Thursday?

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 14 Sep 14 9.18am

I'll miss Stirling. A fantastic poster.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 79 of 80 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine