Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Think about that Stirling and the implications if all countries everywhere feel at ease completely ignoring it whenever they like.Forget having any credibility when criticising others for breaking it.
Credibility?......Are you serious? Protecting your own citizens against stupidly framed catch all laws isn't going to damage credibility at all.
Other countries break international laws all the time and it makes no difference.....Not forgetting that 'international law' isn't set in stone or all important.
The US have broken it.....Israel breaks it....China breaks it....pakistan and India break it....I could go on and on.
What does following international law over and above your own national interest get you: Nothing.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
You can't just pick and choose the bits you like and don't particularly when you chop and change depending on the circumstances.
Yes you can.....and you should. I don't believe in world government....The centralization and policing of law.
Countries that believe in set principles should join together and enact those principles......Hell....That's what actually happens in all the important events in the world anyway..... 'International law' is a joke and always has been since the league of nations.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Chuck it out the window when anyway you have all the powers you need to arrest and charge any "terrorists" upon re-entry.Think it through in a context of general principles,not ISIS or Israel/Palestine.
You don't need 'international law to arrest 'terrorists'....Extradition treaties have been doing that for centuries......Hell in effect that's the process under which most are arrested even now.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Forget any war crimes tribunals for a future ex Yugoslavia
Why? The States and the EU basically settled that war anyway.....Why can't they try who they want how they want?
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Forger the Nuremberg trials
Lets forget that the Nuremberg trials were hardly a great statement for 'international law' in the first place.....It simply wasn't needed.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Forget international conventions on treatment of PoW's
Forget diplomatic immunity and sanctity of embassy premises
You're kidding right? No unethical country follows those laws anyway and civilised countries were following them way way before they were called 'international'.
They mean little.....Germany had signed up before WW2 but just ignored them.....We probably did as well when it suited.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
forget unified laws re rights concerning continental shelfs
Ok.....I'll forget about that.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
forget international conventions re the environment.
China opened up four coal plants a month in 2012.....I think I'll be ok not worrying about the effectiveness of International law on the environment.
The only chance for the environment is future technology.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
forget unified laws re territorial integrity.
Seriously legal....Is that a one liner?
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
forget the law of the sea.
You mean how countries do all around the world all the time....Right is might.
Quote legaleagle at 13 Sep 2014 6.30pm
Yup,lets just chuck the whole lot out,Stirling.Fab idea.
Most of what you have stated doesn't need 'international law'. It can all be achieved regionally.
Edited by legaleagle (13 Sep 2014 6.45pm)
Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Sep 2014 7.24pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)
|