You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy
November 22 2026 2.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy


Page 79 of 174 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 >
Stirlingsays Flag 07 Aug 23 12.50am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

The ‘stops transmission’ claim, essentially implying that it stops ALL transmission made at the time is as noted, false. Plenty of papers out there about that since 2021. Almost like the scientific community doing its job there.

However the same papers also show that the impact of the virus is much less as a result of vaccine. Other vaccinated individuals simply wouldn’t have ‘caught’ it in the first place due to responding well to the vaccine, or being at risk of infection at peak vaccine effectiveness ( coming up, so to speak, after two weeks, then declining 20%-30% by 6 months and continuing thereafter).

So it’s was absolutely wrong to declare that ‘covid jab stops transmission of the virus’. Also false to claim that it meant ‘you can’t get it’. Even more so as they appear as 100% statements. However, the nuance there is that in some cases people didn’t pass it on because they dealt with it faster, or were at peak immunity/had a strong vaccine response and therefore didn’t catch it at all. But, certainly not everyone.

So, it had a significant positive effect, which is shown in the first few waves of data post the first mass adoption of the vaccines.

It’s a good thing that the scientific community didn’t just decide that whatever they or some other corporate hack said in 2020 was final, and didn’t continue to revisit, challenge and revise the data, theory and guidance, isn’t it.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (06 Aug 2023 9.17pm)

The reality that the vaccines reduced the death rate significantly is born out by the statistics when it was first introduced.

However, far more people have died as excess deaths since those vaccines than before it. Over two times more according to WHO figures.

What the cause is....In my opinion isn't being honestly investigated and if you watch Campbell's video on excess deaths that I posted recently you can see that the usual answers given don't stack up. He goes into where the excess deaths are happening in and where they aren't, age ranges...everything...all from official statistics.

Now I'm not saying what is causing these deaths but what I am complaining about the comparative lack of media focus and concern compared to the absolute saturation given to covid both in promotion and cost.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 07 Aug 23 12.53am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Fair point re. sudden illness etc

A great chance to wheel out the old stats classic.

Correlation does not imply causation[

This is true.

However all causation contains some form of correlation, so I find that particular 'classic' a little too one note.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2023 12.53am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 07 Aug 23 5.25am

I caught Covid a few days after a booster jab last Christmas. Covid was noticeable to me, but likely the symptoms were mitigated to some extent by having a booster jab.
I would say, from the press I read in the build-up to the vaccination roll-out, that Chris Whitty's scientific stance was diluted by political considerations. Whitty took the money, so he had to stand by what he preached.
What I would also say (from my own scientific perspective) is that I disagreed with some of the stances taken by Government and their reasoning for it. I was surprised that other more prominent scientists hadn't made public their own concerns about the vaccination/lock-down rationale. I don't know whether the media chose not to publicise opposing views, or whether alternative views were not made more public for fear of professional repercussions. etc.
I specifically didn't hear any mention of the vaccines giving immunity from Covid or making people less contagious. However, the wording about "opening up" and giving travel passes to only vaccinated people gave the distinct impression that by having the vaccine you presented less of a Covid risk.
In fact, the opposite was probably true. Because vaccinated people (who could still catch and transmit the infection) now had unlimited access to spread the virus in public places (without even facemasks in many instances) with these people wandering unhindered and when confronted, outing the mantra ,"you're OK mate, I've been vaccinated".
Exactly the opposite was true. They were carriers, exhibiting no/little symptoms, untested, wandering unhindered through vulnerable areas of society.
The Government not highlighting the obvious limitations of vaccination, effectively meant vaccinated people considered themselves to no longer be a risk. That is wholly the Government/scientific advisors fault for not communicating the information.
And these Inquiries are meaningless. It's a distraction. What are we learning from any of the revelations revealed thus far ? anyone ?

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 9.14am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

The reality that the vaccines reduced the death rate significantly is born out by the statistics when it was first introduced.

However, far more people have died as excess deaths since those vaccines than before it. Over two times more according to WHO figures.

What the cause is....In my opinion isn't being honestly investigated and if you watch Campbell's video on excess deaths that I posted recently you can see that the usual answers given don't stack up. He goes into where the excess deaths are happening in and where they aren't, age ranges...everything...all from official statistics.

Now I'm not saying what is causing these deaths but what I am complaining about the comparative lack of media focus and concern compared to the absolute saturation given to covid both in promotion and cost.


I stopped thinking I'm sure like yourself; that governments had our best intentions at heart.

The main stream news outlets may have touched upon excess deaths. This is normally linked to missed appointments and the backlog due to the lockdowns. Now I'm confident that this did indeed contribute. However except for fox or GB news, I have not seen a debate on the vaccine being a possibility. But I know there are a lot of people putting 2 and 2 together and getting 4.

If people don't like conspiracy theories. The best way to get rid of them is a fair and balanced debate.

Just a little outside the box thinking wouldn't go a miss for some. Don't trust your governments unquestionably for one. Don't necessarily trust anyone. Do your own research. Remember them telling us not to that?

One other thing. You mentioned the who figures on excess deaths. Are you aware that during the pandemic cases of flu pretty much banished. In fact on their website I had noticed not one case of the flu.

Makes you wonder doesn't it.

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.17am)

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.18am)

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Aug 23 10.18am

Originally posted by Forest Hillbilly

I caught Covid a few days after a booster jab last Christmas. Covid was noticeable to me, but likely the symptoms were mitigated to some extent by having a booster jab.
I would say, from the press I read in the build-up to the vaccination roll-out, that Chris Whitty's scientific stance was diluted by political considerations. Whitty took the money, so he had to stand by what he preached.
What I would also say (from my own scientific perspective) is that I disagreed with some of the stances taken by Government and their reasoning for it. I was surprised that other more prominent scientists hadn't made public their own concerns about the vaccination/lock-down rationale. I don't know whether the media chose not to publicise opposing views, or whether alternative views were not made more public for fear of professional repercussions. etc.
I specifically didn't hear any mention of the vaccines giving immunity from Covid or making people less contagious. However, the wording about "opening up" and giving travel passes to only vaccinated people gave the distinct impression that by having the vaccine you presented less of a Covid risk.
In fact, the opposite was probably true. Because vaccinated people (who could still catch and transmit the infection) now had unlimited access to spread the virus in public places (without even facemasks in many instances) with these people wandering unhindered and when confronted, outing the mantra ,"you're OK mate, I've been vaccinated".
Exactly the opposite was true. They were carriers, exhibiting no/little symptoms, untested, wandering unhindered through vulnerable areas of society.
The Government not highlighting the obvious limitations of vaccination, effectively meant vaccinated people considered themselves to no longer be a risk. That is wholly the Government/scientific advisors fault for not communicating the information.
And these Inquiries are meaningless. It's a distraction. What are we learning from any of the revelations revealed thus far ? anyone ?


Even if your opinions expressed here are all correct, and I don’t think they are but will ignore those for this, you and others are looking at this with the benefit of hindsight.

Covid was poorly understood in the early days. Advice was given which needed revision as knowledge improved. Variants emerged which changed the performance of the vaccines. We struggled but we managed. What you see as obvious now wasn’t when the decisions were taken. Of course some clever dick will claim they did, but lots of theories existed. One of them was always going to be right. The question was deciding what to do until we knew which one.

The enquiry is vital. We need to quietly and thoroughly understand what happened at every stage so we learn how to better respond should anything similar be faced again.

I don’t know if related to the enquiry but I heard today that we are establishing a new research lab at Porton Down to prepare for a theoretical new pandemic based on an imaginary virus X. So we are learning.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Aug 23 10.25am

Originally posted by Mattconrov


I stopped thinking I'm sure like yourself; that governments had our best intentions at heart.

The main stream news outlets may have touched upon excess deaths. This is normally linked to missed appointments and the backlog due to the lockdowns. Now I'm confident that this did indeed contribute. However except for fox or GB news, I have not seen a debate on the vaccine being a possibility. But I know there are a lot of people putting 2 and 2 together and getting 4.

If people don't like conspiracy theories. The best way to get rid of them is a fair and balanced debate.

Just a little outside the box thinking wouldn't go a miss for some. Don't trust your governments unquestionably for one. Don't necessarily trust anyone. Do your own research. Remember them telling us not to that?

One other thing. You mentioned the who figures on excess deaths. Are you aware that during the pandemic cases of flu pretty much banished. In fact on their website I had noticed not one case of the flu.

Makes you wonder doesn't it.

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.17am)

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.18am)

The reason flu, and all other respiratory infections diminished during the pandemic is well understood and pretty obvious. Less exposure to others reduced the chance of infection, but not just to Covid.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 10.30am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

The reason flu, and all other respiratory infections diminished during the pandemic is well understood and pretty obvious. Less exposure to others reduced the chance of infection, but not just to Covid.

I see. The flu took some time off. "Less exposure" "covid" seemed to do pretty well with less exposure.

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

eaglesdare Flag 07 Aug 23 10.52am

Originally posted by Mattconrov


I stopped thinking I'm sure like yourself; that governments had our best intentions at heart.

The main stream news outlets may have touched upon excess deaths. This is normally linked to missed appointments and the backlog due to the lockdowns. Now I'm confident that this did indeed contribute. However except for fox or GB news, I have not seen a debate on the vaccine being a possibility. But I know there are a lot of people putting 2 and 2 together and getting 4.

If people don't like conspiracy theories. The best way to get rid of them is a fair and balanced debate.

Just a little outside the box thinking wouldn't go a miss for some. Don't trust your governments unquestionably for one. Don't necessarily trust anyone. Do your own research. Remember them telling us not to that?

One other thing. You mentioned the who figures on excess deaths. Are you aware that during the pandemic cases of flu pretty much banished. In fact on their website I had noticed not one case of the flu.

Makes you wonder doesn't it.

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.17am)

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 9.18am)


Well said.

 

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 10.57am

Originally posted by eaglesdare


Well said.

I can see you and me are going to get on rather well. Lol

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 10.58am)

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 11.02am

When the"pandemic was in full flow. I recall seeing that on particular the USA were not even testing for "covid" but actually looking at the symptoms of it. As these symptoms were pretty much the same as flu, they were assumed to be covid.

Massive financial incentives were also given for covid deaths in the USA.

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

eaglesdare Flag 07 Aug 23 11.10am

Originally posted by Mattconrov

When the"pandemic was in full flow. I recall seeing that on particular the USA were not even testing for "covid" but actually looking at the symptoms of it. As these symptoms were pretty much the same as flu, they were assumed to be covid.

Massive financial incentives were also given for covid deaths in the USA.

It's widely known in many countries that if anyone died of somthing else, be it falling of a ladder, hit by a bus or passed away with stage 4 cancer and they had covid (or sometimes none at all) in their system it was counted as a covid death.

Edited by eaglesdare (07 Aug 2023 11.15am)

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Aug 23 11.27am

Originally posted by Mattconrov

I see. The flu took some time off. "Less exposure" "covid" seemed to do pretty well with less exposure.

Do you seriously not understand? If my explanation isn’t clear enough try these:-

[Link]

[Link]


 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 07 Aug 23 11.47am

Originally posted by eaglesdare

It's widely known in many countries that if anyone died of somthing else, be it falling of a ladder, hit by a bus or passed away with stage 4 cancer and they had covid (or sometimes none at all) in their system it was counted as a covid death.

Edited by eaglesdare (07 Aug 2023 11.15am)

This is the kind of poor understanding of the way statistics are gathered and used which clouds many debates on Covid.

Just about everyone who died with Covid mentioned on their death certificate would have been suffering with comorbidities. Some diagnosed, some not. The point about mentioning Covid was to establish trends and patterns. To see where death rates were increasing, why and how. Covid being the additional complication which tipped most who died over the top.

I am pretty sure that a person who died in an accident would not have anything else mentioned on the death certificate unless it contributed to them having the accident.

You might like to read this:-

[Link]

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

eaglesdare Flag 07 Aug 23 11.57am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

This is the kind of poor understanding of the way statistics are gathered and used which clouds many debates on Covid.

Just about everyone who died with Covid mentioned on their death certificate would have been suffering with comorbidities. Some diagnosed, some not. The point about mentioning Covid was to establish trends and patterns. To see where death rates were increasing, why and how. Covid being the additional complication which tipped most who died over the top.

I am pretty sure that a person who died in an accident would not have anything else mentioned on the death certificate unless it contributed to them having the accident.

You might like to read this:-

[Link]

That's a really big stretch even for you.

The Irish prime minister said "In Ireland we counted all deaths, in all settings, suspected cases even when no lab test was done, and included people with underlying terminal illnesses who died with Covid but not of it."

I am pretty sure other countries did the same.

[Link] - builder fell off a ladder and was a "covid death"


 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 07 Aug 23 12.28pm

Originally posted by Mattconrov

I see. The flu took some time off. "Less exposure" "covid" seemed to do pretty well with less exposure.

More contagious, and for longer, is COVID.

As is the case with competing flu strains, the ones that are most contagious win out each year. Same logic applies

There would undoubtably have been misdiagnosis going on but not to the extent that you're suggesting.

There were ~370m tests completed in the US by Feb 21. So it's not entirely accurate to say that the US wasn't testing, and unlike orange juice Flu is not known to be a positive covid test trigger.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 12.30pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Do you seriously not understand? If my explanation isn’t clear enough try these:-

[Link]

[Link]


Do you seriously think I believe that rubbish?

Firstly masks stopping viruses have been debunked for a long time. Plus how can social distancing stop airborne particles. How did your experts come up with 6 feet or whatever. Lol.

The PCR test was not even made for making a diagnosis. The PCR test is not a diagnostic test. Kacy Mullis the inventor told us explicitly that . "It's not a virus test." It's for amplifying genetic material. The more cycles used the greater chance you'll find anything - and that's what they did. Amplified the cycles.

The PCR test only needed to find a fragment of the genetic material. A bit like finding a horsetail and thinking you've found the horse.

Government scare tactics of people testing positive with a test not testing for a virus. Asymptomatic people testing positive.

Asymptomatic people never made People sick before this pandemic. Now all of a sudden they did. Just as on the masks. Fauci changed his mind on healthly people getting ill.

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 12.35pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

More contagious, and for longer, is COVID.

As is the case with competing flu strains, the ones that are most contagious win out each year. Same logic applies

There would undoubtably have been misdiagnosis going on but not to the extent that you're suggesting.

There were ~370m tests completed in the US by Feb 21. So it's not entirely accurate to say that the US wasn't testing, and unlike orange juice Flu is not known to be a positive covid test trigger.


I don't remember saying they weren't testing. If I did I apologize.

They were making a diagnosis based on symptoms in many cases.
Especially after the person had died. There were financial incentives.

So a pcr test was used yes. However that would have made no difference as the PCR test is not a diagnostic tool.

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 12.39pm)

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 07 Aug 23 12.37pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

This is true.

However all causation contains some form of correlation, so I find that particular 'classic' a little too one note.

Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Aug 2023 12.53am)

Yes a correlation doesn't imply causation, and causation always implies correlation.

However most people will look at correlations and without thinking jump to conclusions. I mean, this site is rife with examples like that one

For the benefit of those people – 'It’s possible to find a statistically significant and reliable correlation for two variables that are actually not causally linked at all. In fact, such correlations are common! Often, this is because both variables are associated with a different causal variable, which tends to co-occur with the data that we’re measuring.'

'Let’s think about this with an example. Imagine that you’re looking at health data. You observe a statistically significant positive correlation between exercise and cases of skin cancer—that is, the people who exercise more tend to be the people who get skin cancer. This correlation seems strong and reliable, and shows up across multiple populations of patients. Without exploring further, you might conclude that exercise somehow causes cancer! Based on these findings, you might even develop a plausible hypothesis: perhaps the stress from exercise causes the body to lose some ability to protect against sun damage.

But imagine that in reality, this correlation exists in your dataset because people who live in places that get a lot of sunlight year-round are significantly more active in their daily lives than people who live in places that don’t. This shows up in their data as increased exercise. At the same time, increased daily sunlight exposure means that there are more cases of skin cancer. Both of the variables—rates of exercise and skin cancer—were affected by a third, causal variable—exposure to sunlight—but they were not causally related.'

Essentially, the more thorough and peer reviewed papers are, the less likely you're going to have hypotheses that don't stack up under scrutiny or are based on surface level interrogation of what might appear to be obvious correlations.

That's the point

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Mattconrov Flag 07 Aug 23 12.38pm

Has anyone mentioned Swedon? Lol.

Peru had a strong lockdown. Brazil did not. 2 countries next to each other. Same result though.

 


" You're not laughing now are you". Nigel Farage 2016.

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 07 Aug 23 12.49pm

Originally posted by Mattconrov


I don't remember saying they weren't testing. If I did I apologize.

They were making a diagnosis based on symptoms in many cases.
Especially after the person had died. There were financial incentives.

So a pcr test was used yes. However that would have made no difference as the PCR test is not a diagnostic tool.

Edited by Mattconrov (07 Aug 2023 12.39pm)

If you're implying that a significant proportion of COVID diagnoses were Flu, I'm afraid I can't agree based on the facts around how competing viruses win out.

Can't dispute the fact that some misdiagnosis would have happened, and I'm sure there were financial incentives aplenty + obvious profit to be made. But based on current information I cannot agree with the unsaid insinuation.

As for PCR, it is a diagnostic. The question is more about what the result could indicate rather than what it does, to your point, there are several possibilities for someone testing positive with a PCR that are not all currently infected/contagious.

Antigen testing was/is much more accurate for that.

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

Page 79 of 174 < 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Coronavirus and the impact of Lockdown policy