You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bedroom tax


Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 9.50am

Apparently from next April, those on housing benefit will lose money if they have a spare room. This will affect many disabled people
[Link]
Thoughts?

 

Ibanez 31 Oct 12 10.02am

Why should we pay for people to have a spare room?

Seems quite reasonable that if they want more rooms than they need then perhaps they should pay for it themselves?

 

Doctor Jazz Flag The Soul Cellar 31 Oct 12 10.03am

If people can't afford where they live they should move to somewhere smaller, get a caravan or a tent.

 


Keep calm, have courage and watch for signs.

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 31 Oct 12 10.11am

I am in full agreement with this. There are far too many people struggling to get any type of suitable housing for their families at the same time as other people have lived in large council properties for years that they simply don't need (i know this applies to all housing not just council). This along with other measures currently being taken by many councils should over time free up housing for those who need it. And by the way, it's not a tax.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 12 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.

 


Optimistic as ever

fallenangel1979 Flag 31 Oct 12 10.14am

They already do this, we claimed housing benefit for a short time, i have a three bedroom flat but because my children are still at an age where they can share a room we only go benefit for a two bedroom.

Understand completely, otherwise people would be renting four bedroom houses on the tax payer.

 


On the 24th December 2013 my life changed forever. Miss you

Fancy helping a charity [Link]

Or read my blog [Link]

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...

 

UnbornShaitan Flag Too close to Penge for my liking 31 Oct 12 10.16am

As i side note, I know someone who, in a way, is being affected by the many measures being taken over social housing. Quite simply she has a property she does not need (2 spare bedrooms) and the local authority have told her she can either downsize or face a massive increase in her rent. She feels this is unfair as its her "family home". Bull. It's social housing not your family home. However it appears to be a sentiment shared by many who have houses they don't need.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 12 10.23am

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.14am

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 10.13am

Get a lodger if you have a room to spare and not enough cash to pay your bills, simple really.


Not sure if you're allowed if claiming housing benefit...

It might outweigh said housing benefit.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 10.24am

My dad will be affected. His house has been altered at a great cost since he had a stroke. The spare room is used for him to do much needed physio.
The cost of doing up a smaller place would be quite expensive.
That said, there is a shortage of housing. But so many people would need to be moved that it would be a logistical nightmare!
What would the situation be if one of the kids goes to uni? Does their room become 'spare' whilst away.
As usual, the situation isn't as black and white as some believe.

It would be good if those with empty second homes were penalised too,but as usual, the better off seem to have things in their favour...

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 10.31am


From. [Link]

It's important to recognize that this blunt measure is not simply taking aim at families with bedrooms lying empty. For example, under the Government's restrictive new rules, same sex teenagers up to the age of 15 will be forced to share a bedroom. And foster parents will be affected even where their bedrooms are occupied by foster children, who for benefit purposes do not count as part of the household.

Others threatened with benefit cuts include lone parents or grandparents who use their 'spare' bedroom to share the care of their children or grandchildren, couples who sleep separately for medical reasons and disabled people who have had their homes specially adapted for their needs.

Crucially, that extra room often isn't 'spare'. It is the place a family carer stays when a parent is ill, or the space a teenage child needs for privacy and study. It is part of normal life. We believe that penalising some families for living the lives most people lead is unfair and unjust. Yet that is what is going to happen from April 2013 if the Welfare Reform Bill goes through unamended.

Of course, everyone understands the desire to make best use of our inadequate supply of affordable homes. But these families will be forced to choose between going into debt, struggling to meet payments by cutting back on essentials, or trying to move - even if no suitable alternative properties are available.

 

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 31 Oct 12 1.54pm

[Link]

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

becky Flag over the moon 31 Oct 12 2.01pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.24am

My dad will be affected. His house has been altered at a great cost since he had a stroke. The spare room is used for him to do much needed physio.
The cost of doing up a smaller place would be quite expensive.
That said, there is a shortage of housing. But so many people would need to be moved that it would be a logistical nightmare!
What would the situation be if one of the kids goes to uni? Does their room become 'spare' whilst away.
As usual, the situation isn't as black and white as some believe.

It would be good if those with empty second homes were penalised too,but as usual, the better off seem to have things in their favour...


I doubt anyone is having their empty second home funded by the taxpayer through housing benefits!

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 12 2.10pm

Quote becky at 31 Oct 2012 2.01pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.24am

My dad will be affected. His house has been altered at a great cost since he had a stroke. The spare room is used for him to do much needed physio.
The cost of doing up a smaller place would be quite expensive.
That said, there is a shortage of housing. But so many people would need to be moved that it would be a logistical nightmare!
What would the situation be if one of the kids goes to uni? Does their room become 'spare' whilst away.
As usual, the situation isn't as black and white as some believe.

It would be good if those with empty second homes were penalised too,but as usual, the better off seem to have things in their favour...


I doubt anyone is having their empty second home funded by the taxpayer through housing benefits!

no one is saying they are. However, it does highlight the different ways the well off and less well off are treated.

 

Johnny Eagles Flag berlin 31 Oct 12 2.25pm

Put me in charge of welfare, then you'd really have something to moan about.

 


...we must expand...get more pupils...so that the knowledge will spread...

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 31 Oct 12 2.33pm

Quote Johnny Eagles at 31 Oct 2012 2.25pm

Put me in charge of welfare, then you'd really have something to moan about.


LIKEWISE!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 12 2.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 2.10pm

Quote becky at 31 Oct 2012 2.01pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.24am

My dad will be affected. His house has been altered at a great cost since he had a stroke. The spare room is used for him to do much needed physio.
The cost of doing up a smaller place would be quite expensive.
That said, there is a shortage of housing. But so many people would need to be moved that it would be a logistical nightmare!
What would the situation be if one of the kids goes to uni? Does their room become 'spare' whilst away.
As usual, the situation isn't as black and white as some believe.

It would be good if those with empty second homes were penalised too,but as usual, the better off seem to have things in their favour...


I doubt anyone is having their empty second home funded by the taxpayer through housing benefits!

no one is saying they are. However, it does highlight the different ways the well off and less well off are treated.

No it doesn't. It highlights that no one can tell you what to do with a property you pay for yourself, in it's entirety, and rightly so.

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 12 3.09pm

Quote Ibanez at 31 Oct 2012 10.02am

Why should we pay for people to have a spare room?

Seems quite reasonable that if they want more rooms than they need then perhaps they should pay for it themselves?

Why not provide housing benefit for people so they can remain in their home during a period of transition between jobs.

Realistically speaking, rehousing people because they have a small spare room will just create even more strain on the system, as there is, as we all know a shortage of space, and moving someone in is going to be a nightmare of epic proporitions if they have a private landlord or family present.

Stupid, impractical and costly idea wheeled out by politicians dedicated to being popular rather than being practical.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 31 Oct 12 3.12pm

Quote Stuk at 31 Oct 2012 2.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 2.10pm

Quote becky at 31 Oct 2012 2.01pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 10.24am

My dad will be affected. His house has been altered at a great cost since he had a stroke. The spare room is used for him to do much needed physio.
The cost of doing up a smaller place would be quite expensive.
That said, there is a shortage of housing. But so many people would need to be moved that it would be a logistical nightmare!
What would the situation be if one of the kids goes to uni? Does their room become 'spare' whilst away.
As usual, the situation isn't as black and white as some believe.

It would be good if those with empty second homes were penalised too,but as usual, the better off seem to have things in their favour...


I doubt anyone is having their empty second home funded by the taxpayer through housing benefits!

no one is saying they are. However, it does highlight the different ways the well off and less well off are treated.

No it doesn't. It highlights that no one can tell you what to do with a property you pay for yourself, in it's entirety, and rightly so.

Of course the problem with second homes, and rental properties that remain vaccant is that they do cost the taxpayer, by artifical inflation of rental prices resulting in higher burdens of housing benefit. Its an indirect cost.

Arguably people who claim benefits also pay for property themselves, given the manner in which welfare operates, as most of those who are claiming benefits against property will have been tax payers.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 31 Oct 12 3.21pm

Quote nickgusset at 31 Oct 2012 9.50am

Apparently from next April, those on housing benefit will lose money if they have a spare room. This will affect many disabled people
[Link]
Thoughts?


It's not a tax though. Tax is what you pay on something, it's a reduction in benefits. They are getting less money.

If there is one thing guaranteed to piss of the general public quicker than anything else, it is people complaining about getting less free money.

 

Page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Bedroom tax