You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine
November 22 2026 1.49am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Israel / Palestine


Page 8 of 80 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Nov 12 8.33am

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.


Your attempts to belittle Seth's occupation are actually quite tiresome. Rebutting his points by getting personal really doesn't cut it.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

johnfirewall Flag 23 Nov 12 1.01am

I can only assume the original post avoids outright condemnation of Israeli actions for the purpose of irony, or through an aversion to predictability.

This week I was at Goldsmiths Uni where I observed a wealth of pro-Palestinian material. Recently the rejection of a Palestinian student for non-political reasons manifested itself in the form of anti-Israeli sentiment such as the certification of 'no Israeli produce' by campus coffee shops. This somewhat undermines the stance irrespective of the current situation.

A recent blog took issue with the BBC's use of the term 'militant' in reference to the elected Hamas. This work was praised by the same people who are all too quick to throw slurs of a far less accurate and articulate nature towards our own governments. They would do well to remember Western meddlers gave Israel their power.

Edited by johnfirewall (23 Nov 2012 1.02am)

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 23 Nov 12 1.16am

Quote johnfirewall at 23 Nov 2012 1.01am

I can only assume the original post avoids outright condemnation of Israeli actions for the purpose of irony, or through an aversion to predictability.

This week I was at Goldsmiths Uni where I observed a wealth of pro-Palestinian material. Recently the rejection of a Palestinian student for non-political reasons manifested itself in the form of anti-Israeli sentiment such as the certification of 'no Israeli produce' by campus coffee shops. This somewhat undermines the stance irrespective of the current situation.

A recent blog took issue with the BBC's use of the term 'militant' in reference to the elected Hamas. This work was praised by the same people who are all too quick to throw slurs of a far less accurate and articulate nature towards our own governments. They would do well to remember Western meddlers gave Israel their power.

Edited by johnfirewall (23 Nov 2012 1.02am)


Goldsmith a good old Palestinian name.....

 


Pro USA & Israel

EagleEyedAlbert Flag ...too far north of the water. 23 Nov 12 1.57pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 22 Nov 2012 8.33am

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 21 Nov 2012 11.52am

Quote Seth at 21 Nov 2012 10.54am

Quote jcreedy at 21 Nov 2012 10.37am

I don't have time to read the whole thread, but why was a Jewish state created in an Arab land in the first place?


It's a complex issue but briefly, after WWII, Britain was in charge of Palestine, and the post-holocaust Jewish diaspora wanted a homeland where they would be safe.

They identified the "holy land" as their preferred destination and committed terrorist acts to persuade the British to let them have the Palestinian's land. The British shamefully capitulated and the state of Israel was born.

There's an excellent BBC documentary on this which you can see here: [Link]

Edited by Seth (21 Nov 2012 11.00am)


A revisionist at work.

No clients today, Master Seth?

The Arabs were the original usurpers of the 'Holy Land.' Your attempts to denigrate Jewish claims to the land of Israel speaks more about your anti-Israel agenda as much as your conceited leftist tendencies.

What an inconvenience it must be to you trying to reconcile a Jewish state in a Muslim region. Poor boy.


Your attempts to belittle Seth's occupation are actually quite tiresome. Rebutting his points by getting personal really doesn't cut it.


...says the master of the response.

Of which I'm now fully expecting.

 


"IS HE!!?"

-Can often be found on HOL Radio chatting Palace-related nonsense:

Catch it here, Sunday Nights 8pm: [Link]

HOL Radio Twitter: [Link]

Me on the Twitter: [Link]


"You don't own a dog & bark yourself, do you?"

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 24 Nov 12 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 24 Nov 12 8.51pm

It's so cyclical it's desperate.

However, my instinct is to align myself with the people deriding both sets of leaders for their focus on political aims.

Mind you, I take a more cynical view - I think it is to with guns. I think this is why the yanks have an interest. What sells weapons? Conflict, threat and paranoia. So, you are going to do things which exacerbate conflict. This whole region must be a banker.

Still, that's far from the only reason. But continually attacking each other is no grounds for success for either side.

 


A one and a two...

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 24 Nov 12 9.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Nov 2012 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.


[Link]

A better piece about the distorted reporting from the British media. A must read!

Also an interesting article on Pilfer.

[Link]

 

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 24 Nov 12 10.08pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 24 Nov 2012 9.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Nov 2012 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.


[Link]

A better piece about the distorted reporting from the British media. A must read!

Also an interesting article on Pilfer.

[Link]


By Melanie Phillips? You must be joking! She is probably the most blinkered columnist in the mainstream media, especially on Israeli issues where her postition is very well-known.

Pilger also has his agenda, but at least he enters into intelligent debate. No one takes Phllips seriously.

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Nov 12 10.44pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 24 Nov 2012 10.08pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 24 Nov 2012 9.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Nov 2012 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.


[Link]

A better piece about the distorted reporting from the British media. A must read!

Also an interesting article on Pilfer.

[Link]


By Melanie Phillips? You must be joking! She is probably the most blinkered columnist in the mainstream media, especially on Israeli issues where her postition is very well-known.

Pilger also has his agenda, but at least he enters into intelligent debate. No one takes Phllips seriously.


Phillips talks in absolutes, like you have here, of course some people take her seriously. She appears on Question time quite often.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

SloveniaDave Flag Tirana, Albania 24 Nov 12 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Nov 2012 10.44pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 24 Nov 2012 10.08pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 24 Nov 2012 9.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Nov 2012 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.


[Link]

A better piece about the distorted reporting from the British media. A must read!

Also an interesting article on Pilfer.

[Link]


By Melanie Phillips? You must be joking! She is probably the most blinkered columnist in the mainstream media, especially on Israeli issues where her postition is very well-known.

Pilger also has his agenda, but at least he enters into intelligent debate. No one takes Phllips seriously.


Phillips talks in absolutes, like you have here, of course some people take her seriously. She appears on Question time quite often.


Fair point. Of course some people do take her seriously, but pretty much only those who agree with her anyway. She is a a polemicist but unlike, for example, the HItchens brothers, she does not demonstrate an intellectual ability to defend her positions.

As with 80-90% of people who appear on Question Time, you know precisely how she will respond to any question asked and it adds nothing to real debate.

Edited by SloveniaDave (24 Nov 2012 11.13pm)

 


Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand!

My opinions may have changed, but not the fact that I am right.

(Member of the School of Optimism 1969-2016 inclusive)

Stirlingsays Flag 24 Nov 12 11.23pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 24 Nov 2012 11.08pm


Fair point. Of course some people do take her seriously, but pretty much only those who agree with her anyway. She is a a polemicist but unlike, for example, the HItchens brothers, she does not demonstrate an intellectual ability to defend her positions.

As with 80-90% of people who appear on Question Time, you know precisely how she will respond to any question asked and it adds nothing to real debate.

Edited by SloveniaDave (24 Nov 2012 11.13pm)


A tad harsh perhaps, but I take your points.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 25 Nov 12 3.00am

Quote SloveniaDave at 24 Nov 2012 11.08pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 24 Nov 2012 10.44pm

Quote SloveniaDave at 24 Nov 2012 10.08pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 24 Nov 2012 9.34pm

Quote nickgusset at 24 Nov 2012 4.08pm

[Link]

a good piece about the bbc and the distorted reporting Palestine/Israel conflict here. Pilger is always a good read.


[Link]

A better piece about the distorted reporting from the British media. A must read!

Also an interesting article on Pilfer.

[Link]


By Melanie Phillips? You must be joking! She is probably the most blinkered columnist in the mainstream media, especially on Israeli issues where her postition is very well-known.

Pilger also has his agenda, but at least he enters into intelligent debate. No one takes Phllips seriously.


Phillips talks in absolutes, like you have here, of course some people take her seriously. She appears on Question time quite often.


Fair point. Of course some people do take her seriously, but pretty much only those who agree with her anyway. She is a a polemicist but unlike, for example, the HItchens brothers, she does not demonstrate an intellectual ability to defend her positions.

As with 80-90% of people who appear on Question Time, you know precisely how she will respond to any question asked and it adds nothing to real debate.

Edited by SloveniaDave (24 Nov 2012 11.13pm)


That's a pretty sweeping statement. I would say that most commentators are polemicists, hence their contention for mass audiences.

I am aware that Melanie Phillips is castigated owing to her pro-Israeli stance, but having read most assertions/accusations made by both sides, I find it incredibly hard to disagree with anything that she has written in the above article.

I do not hide my standpoint, but I have always believed wholeheartedly that the truth tends to exonerate Israel of a great number of the baseless accusations thrown at her.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Nov 12 4.00am

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 25 Nov 2012 3.00am

That's a pretty sweeping statement. I would say that most commentators are polemicists, hence their contention for mass audiences.

I am aware that Melanie Phillips is castigated owing to her pro-Israeli stance, but having read most assertions/accusations made by both sides, I find it incredibly hard to disagree with anything that she has written in the above article.

I do not hide my standpoint, but I have always believed wholeheartedly that the truth tends to exonerate Israel of a great number of the baseless accusations thrown at her.


Phillips is castigated by the left, as is Hitchens. Personally while they both have a boorish quality they also share a rare articulance. An articulation which is often in excess of their detractors. They also both in my opinion have very sharp minds.

Because they are so heavily criticised...Some of it is bordering on ridiculous hatred. I think they also share a kind of paranoids born of this ever ending war with the liberal left, their nemesisic enemy.

Considering that Phillips was once a left wing columnist on the Guardian and Hitchens a communist there's rather a bittersweet comic twist to that.

Now, for myself I've always been rather neo con but I can't say that I'm as far too the right on foreign policy as they are.

Still, I enjoy reading their musings, I can recommend reading Phillips's blog....She certainly puts the work in.


 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 25 Nov 12 4.26am

Palestine/Israel, Israel/Palestine.
Politics/Historical Emnity/Religion.
I saw a newsreel from Gaza showing a man coming from the ruins with a baby who was obviously dead, The child was like a limp rag. Is it all worth it.
The death of a child far outweighs anything.
Stop the killing. It solves nothing.
Sorry but one of my sons presented my wife and I with a beautiful grandson, probably on the day that the child in Gaza died.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Nov 12 5.45am

Quote Sir James Hird at 25 Nov 2012 4.26am

Palestine/Israel, Israel/Palestine.
Politics/Historical Emnity/Religion.
I saw a newsreel from Gaza showing a man coming from the ruins with a baby who was obviously dead, The child was like a limp rag. Is it all worth it.
The death of a child far outweighs anything.
Stop the killing. It solves nothing.
Sorry but one of my sons presented my wife and I with a beautiful grandson, probably on the day that the child in Gaza died.

I'm afraid your viewpoint isn't shared by those in the actual situation. They live it, they get to decide how to respond.

Children die in their many thousands every day, from starvation and disease. Many of those deaths are preventable but they will never reach a TV screen. Far less than die in conflicts. This isn't a fair world and never will be.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sir James Hird Flag Mount Martha 25 Nov 12 7.09am

Whilst your view is accepted and it is by the majority I agree things will never change.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Nov 12 8.41am

Quote Stirlingsays at 25 Nov 2012 4.00am

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 25 Nov 2012 3.00am

That's a pretty sweeping statement. I would say that most commentators are polemicists, hence their contention for mass audiences.

I am aware that Melanie Phillips is castigated owing to her pro-Israeli stance, but having read most assertions/accusations made by both sides, I find it incredibly hard to disagree with anything that she has written in the above article.

I do not hide my standpoint, but I have always believed wholeheartedly that the truth tends to exonerate Israel of a great number of the baseless accusations thrown at her.


Phillips is castigated by the left, as is Hitchens. Personally while they both have a boorish quality they also share a rare articulance. An articulation which is often in excess of their detractors. They also both in my opinion have very sharp minds.

Because they are so heavily criticised...Some of it is bordering on ridiculous hatred. I think they also share a kind of paranoids born of this ever ending war with the liberal left, their nemesisic enemy.

Considering that Phillips was once a left wing columnist on the Guardian and Hitchens a communist there's rather a bittersweet comic twist to that.

Now, for myself I've always been rather neo con but I can't say that I'm as far too the right on foreign policy as they are.

Still, I enjoy reading their musings, I can recommend reading Phillips's blog....She certainly puts the work in.


Melanie Phillips is a guilty pleasure, she's actually a very good writer who is just a poor journalist with very low critical skills.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Jonny_Johnson Flag Tel Aviv 25 Nov 12 11.10am

I have always contended that the Israel-Palestinian conflict is not about land. It never has been and never will be. Instead, it is about religion - the aptly-called 'Clash of Civilisation.'

Indeed, a Palestinian Imam once remarked that if the population of Israel were Muslim, then there would be no hatred towards them. Israel is the emblematic bone of contention in the Muslim world.

(Bin Laden adopted a similar stance when he rather satirically urged the West to embrace Islam in order to end the Western-Islamic conflict)

Hence, why is it that when over 400 Palestinians have been killed in Syria (by Assad's forces), barely any media organisations, let alone the Islamist-apologist-Left pick up on it and call for solidarity rallies?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 25 Nov 12 1.33pm

Quote Jonny_Johnson at 25 Nov 2012 11.10am

I have always contended that the Israel-Palestinian conflict is not about land. It never has been and never will be. Instead, it is about religion - the aptly-called 'Clash of Civilisation.'

Indeed, a Palestinian Imam once remarked that if the population of Israel were Muslim, then there would be no hatred towards them. Israel is the emblematic bone of contention in the Muslim world.

(Bin Laden adopted a similar stance when he rather satirically urged the West to embrace Islam in order to end the Western-Islamic conflict)

Hence, why is it that when over 400 Palestinians have been killed in Syria (by Assad's forces), barely any media organisations, let alone the Islamist-apologist-Left pick up on it and call for solidarity rallies?

Because in Syria the situation isn't just about palestinians killed by a dominant state, but a brutal oppressive regime that doesn't hesitate to utilise violence as a means of social control.

Something most nations regard Israel of being above, or morally beyond, given their close alliance to the west.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Nov 12 2.08pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 25 Nov 2012 8.41am

Melanie Phillips is a guilty pleasure, she's actually a very good writer who is just a poor journalist with very low critical skills.



She views the world in a very traditional right wing fashion...,Well, in some respects very right wing. Still, her views on education are very close to Gove's for example and on some aspects (though it's a mixed picture) Gove is actually trying to improve state education....A charge no previous education minister, within living memory, could be brought up on.

I don't think she has low critical skills, I just think that she has decided to take sides very completely and sometimes as a consequence has lost her sense of balance.....Being a print journalist that development has been to her 'shock jock' advantage.

Being very pro Israeli/anti Palestinian has made her very much a minority in her profession.

It's rather amusing, in a sense, to view the sheer hostility that many on the left view her and others of that persuasion with. It flies in the face of their often passionately stated view that minorities should be treated fairly. It's noted that this liberalised mantra only really exists for when it's a minority that they deem worthy or powerless.

Phillips certainly isn't powerless but she is very much a small right wing fish within the huge ocean of left wing ( mainly broadcast) journalists.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 8 of 80 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Israel / Palestine