You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Steve Browett on January Signings


Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >
sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 10.53am

Two points:

1. I'm not remotely interested whether Browett (or any of the board) think Jelavic is no better than Jerome. But if Pulis feels he isn't then that's good enough for me. So as long as TP and not he board made the decision, I'm fine with it. But I wish Browett had said "Tony thinks..." rather than the way the OP here phrased it ("the board think...).

2. I don't know if you guys are medically aware at all, but Murray's injury was a major one. It's generally considered sensible to give it a year before returning; it's quite possible to do it in 9 months but that doesn't make it advisable. Anyway, my point is that anything we get out of Murray this season should be considered an unexpected bonus. We really should not be relying on him returning in any way.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Jan 14 10.58am

Quote paperhat at 23 Jan 2014 10.42am

Quote Ian J at 23 Jan 2014 10.24am

Quote sueagle2012 at 23 Jan 2014 10.15am

Always important to remember that the club belongs to owners and they are the ones who have the right to decide how to spend the money.
Supporters cannot have the arrogance to make statements like "board should stay out of football matters" and " I am not happy with attitude". If you are not happy ...are you going to put your hand in your pocket and fork out their wages". Know your place.

Legally you are correct as a football club is no different to any other limited company in that the directors run it on behalf of the shareholders but even our current board have admitted that ownership of a football club gives them a moral duty towards the fans and local community as effectively they are custodians of the club as well as owners.

They are two big ifs but if we don't add to our strike force this January and if as a consequence we end up being relegated I have a feeling that not being happy with the board's attitude will be the very least of the comments that will be made


What IF we sign two strikers and a midfielder on reasonably hefty contracts, £5 mill a piece and one breaks his leg getting out of the bath, the other turns into Shefti and the third is reasonable but we still get relegated?
We've lumped out £15 on players, umpteen £'s on wages and we're in the championship pit that all agree is hell to get back out of - look at the money QPR has spent and they aint assured of getting back up. They are forunate in that they have an endless supply of money - WE DON'T.

Look at Bendtner from ths Ar$e, we nearly had him on dumbass ages and now he's long term injured, just what we'd need.

I'd far rather BUSINESSMEN that know what they are doing, with guidance from the likes of Moody et al, carry on running the club like they are rather than spending money for the sake of it.

But we don't need two strikers and a midfielder - we can get by with just one decent striker so I've already slashed two thirds off your capital expenditure and wages budgets

 

beagle Flag pom tiddly om pom pom 23 Jan 14 11.01am

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 10.03am

Quote beagle at 23 Jan 2014 9.48am

Interesting one From the BBS 'questions to the board' forum - they (CpFC2010) were asked about teams around us strengthening. Here's the response:

If we are sitting around watching other teams buy players who are no better than what we have already for £5m transfer fees on £2m a year wages on 4 year contracts then that doesnt bother me.

We will always put sound business practice and the long term security of CPFC ahead of panic purchases.

We will strengthen the squad but we will not be ripped off.

I don't know about anyone else, but I'm quite happy with that attitude.

So we can deduce from that they think Cameron Jerome is the equal of Long or Jelavic. I see. Honestly, no. If that is what they think then my comment about the board needing to stay out of football matters is bang on. And no, I'm not happy with an attitude that will get us relegated.

If Long and Jelavic start banging in the goals then you may have a point.

Or they could do a 'Bent'. Who, interestingly, was going to be be our 'star signing' in the summer. Now, had I asked in the summer who everyone would prefer, Bent or Jerome, I think Bent would have been the first choice. Ask the same question now and I bet It'd be Jerome all day.

Finally, your conjecture that the board need to stay out of football matters is just that- conjecture. For all we know Browett may have asked Pullis and Moody about whether Long should be one of our targets. To which they said he's no better than what we have already.

Someone's got to be the mouthpiece, the conduit of information at Palace. I don't want to see Pullis or Moody wasting their time either constantly updating the media or spending time online answering questions. Let the people doing the actual work get on and do it, while members of the board keep up the updates.

However, if you don't like the updates, I maintain its conjecture to blame the messenger as the one one who is responsible for the implications of the content.

 


When the time comes, I want die just like my Dad - at peace and asleep.
Not screaming and terrified.
Like his passengers.

matthau Flag South Croydon 23 Jan 14 11.05am

i agree.

one decent striker and perhaps one decent CB we'll have a fighting chance.


but then, regarding CB....

Ward back as RB and Marriappas preffered position of CB back up if needed.

and push Guarduara back in as CAM.


sorted.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 23 Jan 14 11.21am

Quote beagle at 23 Jan 2014 11.01am

Someone's got to be the mouthpiece, the conduit of information at Palace. I don't want to see Pullis or Moody wasting their time either constantly updating the media or spending time online answering questions. Let the people doing the actual work get on and do it, while members of the board keep up the updates.

Well I would rather hear updates where necessary from Tony Pulis but only if he actually had something to say.

How do you think Arsenal supporters would feel if they were given regular updates that didn't actually say anything from Sir Chips Keswick. There would be an outcry as the only views that Arsenal supporters are interested in are those of Arsene Wenger

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Jan 14 11.30am

Quote Ian J at 23 Jan 2014 11.21am

Quote beagle at 23 Jan 2014 11.01am

Someone's got to be the mouthpiece, the conduit of information at Palace. I don't want to see Pullis or Moody wasting their time either constantly updating the media or spending time online answering questions. Let the people doing the actual work get on and do it, while members of the board keep up the updates.

Well I would rather hear updates where necessary from Tony Pulis but only if he actually had something to say.

How do you think Arsenal supporters would feel if they were given regular updates that didn't actually say anything from Sir Chips Keswick. There would be an outcry as the only views that Arsenal supporters are interested in are those of Arsene Wenger


We have, with both the previous and current regime, sufferred from 'chairman overload' when it comes to dealings with the media. I don't really mind who makes the important announcements (although I'd prefer it to be the manager) but could the designated spokespersons please button it until there is actually something of significance to say; to be fair, in that respect, TP is a model of rectitude.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 11.43am

I cannot believe how massively impressed with Tony Pulis I am. Bexley has just pointed out yet another reason why we're so lucky to have him. TBH if I had a senior manager like that in my company who was the expert in the area in which I did business, I'd keep my mouth zipped and wheel him out to be my spokesperson on every possible occasion. He is intelligent, informed, knowledgeable, media-genic, and articulate. In front of the cameras talking about any aspect of football, Parish simply pales in comparison.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 23 Jan 14 11.50am

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 10.53am

Two points:

1. I'm not remotely interested whether Browett (or any of the board) think Jelavic is no better than Jerome. But if Pulis feels he isn't then that's good enough for me. So as long as TP and not he board made the decision, I'm fine with it. But I wish Browett had said "Tony thinks..." rather than the way the OP here phrased it ("the board think...).

2. I don't know if you guys are medically aware at all, but Murray's injury was a major one. It's generally considered sensible to give it a year before returning; it's quite possible to do it in 9 months but that doesn't make it advisable. Anyway, my point is that anything we get out of Murray this season should be considered an unexpected bonus. We really should not be relying on him returning in any way.


...you're right syd, no way should we expect anything from Mr Murray, he is now left with trusting the repaired leg and that can reduce sadly his impact to a degree where everyone will end up hating him!
No one can predict how things are going to pan out for us with goalscoring and cover for players and of course we have no say... I still feel along the lines that we do not need to and that somebody is going to become a hero in that department, in so much that they will score enough.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 23 Jan 14 11.58am

Quote Willo at 23 Jan 2014 10.26am

Quote Rudi Hedman at 23 Jan 2014 10.19am

I agree that Shane Long & Jelavic are better than Jerome,

What's the odds that either Jelavic or Long score against us ?



...the reason of where we are now, is because of our preventions....not our goalscoring.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

cornwalls palace Flag Torpoint 23 Jan 14 12.01pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 11.43am

I cannot believe how massively impressed with Tony Pulis I am. Bexley has just pointed out yet another reason why we're so lucky to have him. TBH if I had a senior manager like that in my company who was the expert in the area in which I did business, I'd keep my mouth zipped and wheel him out to be my spokesperson on every possible occasion. He is intelligent, informed, knowledgeable, media-genic, and articulate. In front of the cameras talking about any aspect of football, Parish simply pales in comparison.


...Stoke are truly nuts.

 


.......has our coach driver done a Poo'yet, without thinking about Gus!

npn Flag Crowborough 23 Jan 14 12.15pm

Tricky one - if the board say nothing, we'd all be moaning about being kept in the dark. If they make announcements, they're media whores.

I don't for a moment suspect that "Jelovic is no better than what we have" is/was a decision taken by the board - it simply must have been with the approval of TP or IM and probably both. If that were not the case, I'd suspect TP would have been throwing his toys out of the pram (and rightly so).

I feel our current board are victims of their desire to keep us plebs informed (as fans themselves). We all congratulated them for that approach in the early days, now it seems there's a bit of a backlash and a percepotion that they court the limelight.

I'm personally not that bothered either way, as long as the players TP/IM want come in and the progress continues. Going down would see us financially secure, but I wouldn't see us coming back up for the foreseeable future (unless we get lucky again).

 

Plane Flag Bromley 23 Jan 14 12.22pm

Quote bexleydave at 23 Jan 2014 11.30am

Quote Ian J at 23 Jan 2014 11.21am

Quote beagle at 23 Jan 2014 11.01am

Someone's got to be the mouthpiece, the conduit of information at Palace. I don't want to see Pullis or Moody wasting their time either constantly updating the media or spending time online answering questions. Let the people doing the actual work get on and do it, while members of the board keep up the updates.

Well I would rather hear updates where necessary from Tony Pulis but only if he actually had something to say.

How do you think Arsenal supporters would feel if they were given regular updates that didn't actually say anything from Sir Chips Keswick. There would be an outcry as the only views that Arsenal supporters are interested in are those of Arsene Wenger


We have, with both the previous and current regime, sufferred from 'chairman overload' when it comes to dealings with the media. I don't really mind who makes the important announcements (although I'd prefer it to be the manager) but could the designated spokespersons please button it until there is actually something of significance to say; to be fair, in that respect, TP is a model of rectitude.

In fairness to SB these quotes that everyone has debated for 13 pages on here come from the BBS in answer to direct questions.


Edited by Plane (23 Jan 2014 12.28pm)

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 23 Jan 14 12.25pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 10.53am

Two points:

1. I'm not remotely interested whether Browett (or any of the board) think Jelavic is no better than Jerome. But if Pulis feels he isn't then that's good enough for me. So as long as TP and not he board made the decision, I'm fine with it. But I wish Browett had said "Tony thinks..." rather than the way the OP here phrased it ("the board think...).
2. I don't know if you guys are medically aware at all, but Murray's injury was a major one. It's generally considered sensible to give it a year before returning; it's quite possible to do it in 9 months but that doesn't make it advisable. Anyway, my point is that anything we get out of Murray this season should be considered an unexpected bonus. We really should not be relying on him returning in any way.

Completely understand where you're coming from on this however...is it 'really' such an issue that its not mentioned or phrased in the way you or I would like?

Surely the most important thing is that the club is built and moves forward on stable foundations getting the right player/manager/DoF that fits with the clubs aspirations at this moment in time, as opposed to semantics?

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jan 14 12.27pm

Quote npn at 23 Jan 2014 12.15pm

Tricky one - if the board say nothing, we'd all be moaning about being kept in the dark. If they make announcements, they're media whores.

.

I agree.
They are damned when they do and would be damned if they did not ! I think the engagement with supporters is to be welcomed.


 

turbohorsebox Flag Coulsdon 23 Jan 14 12.44pm

Quote Lyons550 at 23 Jan 2014 12.25pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 10.53am

Two points:

1. I'm not remotely interested whether Browett (or any of the board) think Jelavic is no better than Jerome. But if Pulis feels he isn't then that's good enough for me. So as long as TP and not he board made the decision, I'm fine with it. But I wish Browett had said "Tony thinks..." rather than the way the OP here phrased it ("the board think...).
2. I don't know if you guys are medically aware at all, but Murray's injury was a major one. It's generally considered sensible to give it a year before returning; it's quite possible to do it in 9 months but that doesn't make it advisable. Anyway, my point is that anything we get out of Murray this season should be considered an unexpected bonus. We really should not be relying on him returning in any way.

Completely understand where you're coming from on this however...is it 'really' such an issue that its not mentioned or phrased in the way you or I would like?

Surely the most important thing is that the club is built and moves forward on stable foundations getting the right player/manager/DoF that fits with the clubs aspirations at this moment in time, as opposed to semantics?

.........is the correct answer!

 


All good. Nothing bad.

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 12.49pm

Quote Willo at 23 Jan 2014 12.27pm

Quote npn at 23 Jan 2014 12.15pm

Tricky one - if the board say nothing, we'd all be moaning about being kept in the dark. If they make announcements, they're media whores.

.

I agree.
They are damned when they do and would be damned if they did not ! I think the engagement with supporters is to be welcomed.


I think ultimately this is true (that they are damned if they do and damned if they don't), but it's somewhat ironic. Here's why. In a number of posts recently, those who disagree with the board over our transfer policy have been criticised (often unfairly) as being a reflection of a modern age where we want everything immediately and are not prepared to wait for things to happen. It's true; in so far as a lack of patience is certainly a hallmark of the world we now live in. But it's not without irony that the same people who are lauding the board for their presumed patience and financial restraint are the same people who also applaud their engagement with supporters, which in reality is only likely to encourage false expectations, increase frustration, and encourage second-guessing.

This is not to criticise supporters or the board in any personal way. It is simply to raise the subject for discussion. My only conclusion is that for a long time (in history), the board of a football club would not have felt the need to directly update supporters on future policy (indeed, even as recently as a decade ago this was true) and I don't think it is at all clear that having a board who communicate with us through an Internet fan site and seem determined to talk in fairly granular detail on confidential subjects is a good thing.

Again, that is not to openly criticise CPFC2010...it it merely to say that I do not think it is absolutely clear that their communications strategy is sensible or desirable. And as Parish is a "media expert", I think it's quite appropriate to question him about this. I don't (personally) think it follows at all that "all noise is good noise" when it come to speaking out or that the board discussing future transfer possibilities with fans is a desirable state of affairs.

I think we need to move beyond the notion that the board are good because of the way they communicate with supporters. There isn't any evidence that at least some areas of their conversation are helping anyone and it's far from certain that discussion before the fact is preferable to a lucid and full explanation after the fact. Either way, I think this is a central point that merits discussion. I also think some fans are very lightweight and not intellectually very rigorous in their analysis; they are so flattered and impressed that the board is even speaking to them that their palpable delight blinds them to asking questions that still need to be asked.


Edited by sydtheeagle (23 Jan 2014 12.53pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 23 Jan 14 12.57pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 12.49pm

is only likely to encourage false expectations, increase frustration, and encourage second-guessing.

In actual fact I cannot help but think that this would be the case if the 'Board' adopted a vow of silence !


 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 23 Jan 14 1.03pm

Have we signed anyone yet?

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 23 Jan 14 1.07pm

Quote Willo at 23 Jan 2014 12.57pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 12.49pm

is only likely to encourage false expectations, increase frustration, and encourage second-guessing.

In actual fact I cannot help but think that this would be the case if the 'Board' adopted a vow of silence !


Well, I did agree they were damned if they did and damned if they didn't. But I think one way the world has changed is that the default option used to be silence, and you spoke when you had something to say. Now, the default option is start talking and grab the limelight, never mind if you have something to say or not. In my view, this is NOT a good thing.

A good barometer of this (as any journalist will confirm) is the PR industry. When I was first writing in the early 80s, Press Releases in general arrived when something had taken place or happened. Sure, the copy was exaggerated, but it was still demonstrably related to a "thing" of some sort. Nowadays, the media is deluged with PRs that aren't news at all...just noise, rubbish, the senders talking up themselves.

To me, if I own a football team in the transfer window I speak only about transfers I have concluded, when the deal is done. What possible benefit could there be in discussing something which hasn't happened, might well not ever happen, and which by putting in the public domain might even negatively impact my negotiating position? Do you really think our owners feel so beholden to or respectful of our supporters that they're keeping us in the loop out of the goodness of their hearts? If you do, good luck with that because they're just sating their egos as football club owners by playing to their audience. Personally, I can't see the wisdom in their communications strategy.


Edited by sydtheeagle (23 Jan 2014 1.09pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Plane Flag Bromley 23 Jan 14 1.08pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 23 Jan 2014 12.49pm

Quote Willo at 23 Jan 2014 12.27pm

Quote npn at 23 Jan 2014 12.15pm

Tricky one - if the board say nothing, we'd all be moaning about being kept in the dark. If they make announcements, they're media whores.

.

I agree.
They are damned when they do and would be damned if they did not ! I think the engagement with supporters is to be welcomed.


I think ultimately this is true (that they are damned if they do and damned if they don't), but it's somewhat ironic. Here's why. In a number of posts recently, those who disagree with the board over our transfer policy have been criticised (often unfairly) as being a reflection of a modern age where we want everything immediately and are not prepared to wait for things to happen. It's true; in so far as a lack of patience is certainly a hallmark of the world we now live in. But it's not without irony that the same people who are lauding the board for their presumed patience and financial restraint are the same people who also applaud their engagement with supporters, which in reality is only likely to encourage false expectations, increase frustration, and encourage second-guessing.

This is not to criticise supporters or the board in any personal way. It is simply to raise the subject for discussion. My only conclusion is that for a long time (in history), the board of a football club would not have felt the need to directly update supporters on future policy (indeed, even as recently as a decade ago this was true) and I don't think it is at all clear that having a board who communicate with us through an Internet fan site and seem determined to talk in fairly granular detail on confidential subjects is a good thing.

Again, that is not to openly criticise CPFC2010...it it merely to say that I do not think it is absolutely clear that their communications strategy is sensible or desirable. And as Parish is a "media expert", I think it's quite appropriate to question him about this. I don't (personally) think it follows at all that "all noise is good noise" when it come to speaking out or that the board discussing future transfer possibilities with fans is a desirable state of affairs.

I think we need to move beyond the notion that the board are good because of the way they communicate with supporters. There isn't any evidence that at least some areas of their conversation are helping anyone and it's far from certain that discussion before the fact is preferable to a lucid and full explanation after the fact. Either way, I think this is a central point that merits discussion. I also think some fans are very lightweight and not intellectually very rigorous in their analysis; they are so flattered and impressed that the board is even speaking to them that their palpable delight blinds them to asking questions that still need to be asked.


Edited by sydtheeagle (23 Jan 2014 12.53pm)

Read my post 4 above this.

 

Page 8 of 11 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Steve Browett on January Signings