This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Johnny Eagles at 24 Nov 2014 8.29am
Quote serial thriller at 22 Nov 2014 7.24pm
Quote Stuk at 21 Nov 2014 2.42pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Nov 2014 10.23pm
I went into reading 'revolution' ,his book with an open mind. The more I read, the better he is coming across. He is very self depreciating but makes good points and backs them up well. It's worth bearing in mind, to me any way, that he is only getting such a roasting in the press because he is speaking out against the status qui (no not that one Hoof before you mention it Edited by nickgusset (20 Nov 2014 10.23pm) Not because he's just saying popular things that have no chance of happening? "Do you think you're paying too much rent? Would you like to earn more? because there might be others out there who think the same." No s***, Russell. I'm sorry, what could you possibly have against those sentiments? Rent, particularly in the capital, is as high as it is anywhere else in the world, while 52% of those in poverty are in work. Neither of those things need to be, and it is not radical to suggest that a collective opposition to such policies is better than an apathetic passivity towards fundamental changes to our social fabric. Look at the grassroots movements in London against evictions and rent prices, and the successes they've had, and tell us again that these are just 'popular things that have no chance of happening'...
Everyone, that is, apart from self-hating middle class types who claim they love paying tax. That's a decent enough truism. Of course everyone would like to think they earned more and paid less, which is arguably why taxation for public services exists, it hides the actual cost of essential services that would likely be prohibitively expensive were they contracted individually. What the state often fails to do, in the UK, is utilize its capacity of a monopoly in its negotiation with suppliers (which is why the French and Germans can provide an excellent privatized national health system and we can barely get water to peoples homes without most of it P*ssing out the pipes on route).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote elgrande at 24 Nov 2014 6.35pm
Quote serial thriller at 24 Nov 2014 5.19pm
Quote Stuk at 24 Nov 2014 3.15pm
Quote serial thriller at 22 Nov 2014 7.24pm
Quote Stuk at 21 Nov 2014 2.42pm
Quote nickgusset at 20 Nov 2014 10.23pm
I went into reading 'revolution' ,his book with an open mind. The more I read, the better he is coming across. He is very self depreciating but makes good points and backs them up well. It's worth bearing in mind, to me any way, that he is only getting such a roasting in the press because he is speaking out against the status qui (no not that one Hoof before you mention it Edited by nickgusset (20 Nov 2014 10.23pm) Not because he's just saying popular things that have no chance of happening? "Do you think you're paying too much rent? Would you like to earn more? because there might be others out there who think the same." No s***, Russell. I'm sorry, what could you possibly have against those sentiments? Rent, particularly in the capital, is as high as it is anywhere else in the world, while 52% of those in poverty are in work. Neither of those things need to be, and it is not radical to suggest that a collective opposition to such policies is better than an apathetic passivity towards fundamental changes to our social fabric. Look at the grassroots movements in London against evictions and rent prices, and the successes they've had, and tell us again that these are just 'popular things that have no chance of happening'...
You can't dictate rent levels, and you certainly can't demand landlords take a reduction in current levels. The same goes for just giving everyone a payrise. The private sector is private. You set your prices and find out whether people will pay them/work for them, or not. No matter what a terrible actor decides to write in a book, for his own profit.
The comment in bold directly contradicts the society we live in today though. We don't live in a totally free market, because we bail out private banks with public money, have an obligatory minimum wage set by central government, have academy schools funded by private individuals that implement governmental syllabus' etc. etc. etc. You also can 'just give everyone a payrise' as we saw just the other week when the Tories raised the minimum wage, and as we see in the fact that Labour and the Greens want to increase it further. You also can have rent control, which we did before 1980, around the time the housing market exploded. I'm not recommending it, as I believe the abolition of Private Property would be of more use, but it's stupid to narrow your conception in to what one can and can't do. History shows you can do multiple things, with varying effects.
Pretty much, whilst I'm kind of in agreement in the ideology of abolition, I can't really see that kind of thing being accepted without somekind of major revolution or catastrophic natural disaster.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.