You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dave Whelan
November 22 2026 2.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dave Whelan


Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 1.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 12.50pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 12.32pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 11.18am

Quote Seth at 23 Nov 2014 1.35am

I'll never stop finding it amusingly ironic that the poster known as Hrolf The Ganger, that hater of all things multicultural and one so terribly put out by the "waves of immigrants" he perceives, and so terrified of being "swamped" by foreigners, takes his name from a Viking invader who conquered foreign lands and imposed his culture on them at the point of a sword.

The historian Adhemar recorded that on nearing his death Rollo [Hrolf] had a hundred Christian prisoners beheaded in front of himself to appease and honour the old gods
[Link]

Edited by Seth (23 Nov 2014 1.35am)

Ayran blonde haired blue eyed invaders are acceptable maybe?


LOL.
Actually he was a relation of mine. (apparently)
He was quite a nasty bugger by some accounts but that was in a world of nasty buggers of course.

It does show a commitment to faith when you have to behead 100 Christian prisoners, personally, just to appease the old gods. Most people complain about giving up a Sunday lie in.

Old gods don't mess about.



That was in the 10th century of course. Unfortunately there are those who still think beheading of infidels is fashionable. Obviously the last 1000 years or so passed them by.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 24 Nov 14 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 1.21pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 1.16pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.07pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 24 Nov 2014 1.03pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 12.25pm

It was also a demonstration of the sort of middle class, liberalism that the Labour party seems to stand for these days.

Labour put the rights of immigrants before those of the average working class white man.

So it's about class, then? We agree after all.


There is certainly a tenancy for some in the middle class to defend the rights of others, whether they want it or not, but this particular episode was about politics.

Indeed the middle class isn't really a class that's easily defined, it tends to be much more schizophrenic, drawing attributes from the upper class, working class and aristocratic classes.

Also most people mistake upper working classes for middle classes (a moot point, as in a post-industrial UK definitions of class defined by industrial relationships are meaningless).



Perceptions of class seems to be more about upbringing, education and taste these days.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 24 Nov 14 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 24 Nov 14 2.17pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

I've already made the point once in this thread but what is the difference between insulting the Chinese and Jewish communities which everyone seems up in arms about and insulting the gay community which seems a popular pastime on this forum


 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

Maybe he thinks that people are way to sensitive these days and are far to keen to jump on the bandwagon of condemnation. I would agree with that sentiment. I could be called a honky or a round eye mo fo all day long and I wouldn't bat an eyelid. racial descriptions of that sort just don't bother me and therefore they can't hurt me.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 24 Nov 14 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.


That's a big statement, there will some people offended, there will be some who wuill know what he meant and just thonk of him as a silly old fart and in all likely hood some who won't give it a moments thought.


People make mistakes and whilst that does not excuse what he said, to throw away a lifes work because of poorly phrased interview seems more than a little harsh. As I've said before maybe judge him on his actions rather than his words.

I do wonder why Croydon is such a dump when there are so many perfect people who live in the area.


I never thought I'd see the day I would actually be sticking up for Whelan

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Nov 14 2.44pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 24 Nov 2014 11.33am

It amuses me no end that the same board right wingers who were so astoundingly offended by Emily Thornberry's lazy classist remarks last week find Dave Whelan's lazy racist remarks this week so palatable. At least those of us on the left are not hypocrites, and criticise all 'isms not matter the source. Right-wingers, as usual, are not equal opportunity observers.


Try reading everyone's posts. Otherwise you're just being lazy.

Not to mention the hypocrisy of the claim you make.


Edited by Stuk (24 Nov 2014 2.46pm)

 


Optimistic as ever

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Nov 14 2.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

Maybe he thinks that people are way to sensitive these days and are far to keen to jump on the bandwagon of condemnation. I would agree with that sentiment. I could be called a honky or a round eye mo fo all day long and I wouldn't bat an eyelid. racial descriptions of that sort just don't bother me and therefore they can't hurt me.

I think the whole insult thing tends to jar less if your come from the group that did the 'persecuting and oppressing'. Its more akin to referring to the working class of Rochester as flag waving white van driving mild racists.

The historical context is essential. Which is why it doesn't really affect you when your called a honkie, but call one black bloke in the pub a cotton picking **** and it can turn into something serious


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Nov 14 2.56pm

Quote Ian J at 24 Nov 2014 2.17pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

I've already made the point once in this thread but what is the difference between insulting the Chinese and Jewish communities which everyone seems up in arms about and insulting the gay community which seems a popular pastime on this forum


You slit eyed gas huffing yiddy bumboy.

Or no difference, really, except certain forms of discrimination and abuse are more acceptable socially. All are wrong, obviously.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 4.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 2.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

Maybe he thinks that people are way to sensitive these days and are far to keen to jump on the bandwagon of condemnation. I would agree with that sentiment. I could be called a honky or a round eye mo fo all day long and I wouldn't bat an eyelid. racial descriptions of that sort just don't bother me and therefore they can't hurt me.

I think the whole insult thing tends to jar less if your come from the group that did the 'persecuting and oppressing'. Its more akin to referring to the working class of Rochester as flag waving white van driving mild racists.

The historical context is essential. Which is why it doesn't really affect you when your called a honkie, but call one black bloke in the pub a cotton picking **** and it can turn into something serious



I've heard that argument many times but how far in the past does this stuff have to be before we let it go ?
Should I still resent Germans, Romans and the French.
Harbouring historical resentment only hurts ones self ultimately.
Anyway didn't we liberate the Jews from Hitler and give them a homeland. And don't we keep many Chinese families in 4x4's by buying sweet and sour chicken balls most weekends. I rest my case.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 24 Nov 14 4.17pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.


That's a big statement, there will some people offended, there will be some who wuill know what he meant and just thonk of him as a silly old fart and in all likely hood some who won't give it a moments thought.


People make mistakes and whilst that does not excuse what he said, to throw away a lifes work because of poorly phrased interview seems more than a little harsh. As I've said before maybe judge him on his actions rather than his words.

I do wonder why Croydon is such a dump when there are so many perfect people who live in the area.


I never thought I'd see the day I would actually be sticking up for Whelan


Nobody is perfect not you,not me and definitly NOT Dave Whelen,the thing is his comments are in the public eye unlike everyone's comments on here.

his a chairman who the good people off Wigan look up to and respect.

Dave Whelen has let himself and Wigan football club down.

Yes i've lived in Croydon all my life and it's the dump that i love and my CPFC represents the people Croydon and fans around the world including Wales.



 

buzby1 Flag Devon 24 Nov 14 4.45pm


I've heard that argument many times but how far in the past does this stuff have to be before we let it go ?
Should I still resent Germans, Romans and the French.
Harbouring historical resentment only hurts ones self ultimately.
Anyway didn't we liberate the Jews from Hitler and give them a homeland. And don't we keep many Chinese families in 4x4's by buying sweet and sour chicken balls most weekends. I rest my case.

There really is no point bothering to engage with level of argument. Dim beyond belief.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 4.53pm

Quote buzby1 at 24 Nov 2014 4.45pm


I've heard that argument many times but how far in the past does this stuff have to be before we let it go ?
Should I still resent Germans, Romans and the French.
Harbouring historical resentment only hurts ones self ultimately.
Anyway didn't we liberate the Jews from Hitler and give them a homeland. And don't we keep many Chinese families in 4x4's by buying sweet and sour chicken balls most weekends. I rest my case.

There really is no point bothering to engage with level of argument. Dim beyond belief.


It was intended to be somewhat humorous but if you want to dispute that statement on a historical basis, I'm ready to go.
I notice you didn't highlight the Chinese bit.

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Nov 2014 4.54pm)

Edited by Hrolf The Ganger (24 Nov 2014 4.55pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 24 Nov 14 4.55pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 4.17pm

Quote Y Ddraig Goch at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.


That's a big statement, there will some people offended, there will be some who wuill know what he meant and just thonk of him as a silly old fart and in all likely hood some who won't give it a moments thought.


People make mistakes and whilst that does not excuse what he said, to throw away a lifes work because of poorly phrased interview seems more than a little harsh. As I've said before maybe judge him on his actions rather than his words.

I do wonder why Croydon is such a dump when there are so many perfect people who live in the area.


I never thought I'd see the day I would actually be sticking up for Whelan


Nobody is perfect not you,not me and definitly NOT Dave Whelen,the thing is his comments are in the public eye unlike everyone's comments on here.
his a chairman who the good people off Wigan look up to and respect.

Dave Whelen has let himself and Wigan football club down.

Yes i've lived in Croydon all my life and it's the dump that i love and my CPFC represents the people Croydon and fans around the world including Wales.




So if they weren't it would be ok to say those things? As I have said I do not think what he said was acceptable, whilst you are right he has let himself and his club down, I do think that context, the man himself and numerous other factors should be taken in to consideration before he is hung out to dry.

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Nov 14 4.58pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 4.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 2.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

Maybe he thinks that people are way to sensitive these days and are far to keen to jump on the bandwagon of condemnation. I would agree with that sentiment. I could be called a honky or a round eye mo fo all day long and I wouldn't bat an eyelid. racial descriptions of that sort just don't bother me and therefore they can't hurt me.

I think the whole insult thing tends to jar less if your come from the group that did the 'persecuting and oppressing'. Its more akin to referring to the working class of Rochester as flag waving white van driving mild racists.

The historical context is essential. Which is why it doesn't really affect you when your called a honkie, but call one black bloke in the pub a cotton picking **** and it can turn into something serious



I've heard that argument many times but how far in the past does this stuff have to be before we let it go ?
Should I still resent Germans, Romans and the French.
Harbouring historical resentment only hurts ones self ultimately.
Anyway didn't we liberate the Jews from Hitler and give them a homeland. And don't we keep many Chinese families in 4x4's by buying sweet and sour chicken balls most weekends. I rest my case.

Not really, they'd murdered 6m Jews by the time we got around to liberating them. Hardly the greatest liberation. Also, given most of the death camps were on the 'other side' of Europe, a lot of the liberating was done by the Red Army.

I suspect that white English people being a bit anti-semetic gets a lot less vitriol than say a right wing German or an Arab, simply because it runs deeper in the offending parties history.

My Grand dad died hating the Germans, showing that he could personally hold a grudge for 70 odd years. Didn't matter if they were born before or after the war, he had no time for them.

Prejudice and how people react to prejudice, is very personal. And no one race has ever had quite the level of persecution as the Jewish people (well not without effectively ceasing to exist as a people).

As for Israel, they took it through a protracted guerilla warfare / terrorist campaign.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 24 Nov 14 5.18pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 4.58pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 4.16pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 2.54pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 2.30pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 2.06pm

Quote Hrolf The Ganger at 24 Nov 2014 1.23pm

Quote black eagle. at 24 Nov 2014 1.21pm

The fact that Whelen says he will resign as Wigan chairman is disgusting on his part.

he is more or less saying what i said about Jewish and Chinese people is right.

Your stuck in a time warp Dave and i hope you are charged.

An interesting interpretation. What would you have him do ?


He should resign off course but he should be resigning for offending the entire Chinese and Jewish community.

Not saying if i am charged i will resign,Whelen saying he will resign if he is charged is him more or less justifying what he said about Jewish and Chinese people.

Maybe he thinks that people are way to sensitive these days and are far to keen to jump on the bandwagon of condemnation. I would agree with that sentiment. I could be called a honky or a round eye mo fo all day long and I wouldn't bat an eyelid. racial descriptions of that sort just don't bother me and therefore they can't hurt me.

I think the whole insult thing tends to jar less if your come from the group that did the 'persecuting and oppressing'. Its more akin to referring to the working class of Rochester as flag waving white van driving mild racists.

The historical context is essential. Which is why it doesn't really affect you when your called a honkie, but call one black bloke in the pub a cotton picking **** and it can turn into something serious



I've heard that argument many times but how far in the past does this stuff have to be before we let it go ?
Should I still resent Germans, Romans and the French.
Harbouring historical resentment only hurts ones self ultimately.
Anyway didn't we liberate the Jews from Hitler and give them a homeland. And don't we keep many Chinese families in 4x4's by buying sweet and sour chicken balls most weekends. I rest my case.

Not really, they'd murdered 6m Jews by the time we got around to liberating them. Hardly the greatest liberation. Also, given most of the death camps were on the 'other side' of Europe, a lot of the liberating was done by the Red Army.

I suspect that white English people being a bit anti-semetic gets a lot less vitriol than say a right wing German or an Arab, simply because it runs deeper in the offending parties history.

My Grand dad died hating the Germans, showing that he could personally hold a grudge for 70 odd years. Didn't matter if they were born before or after the war, he had no time for them.

Prejudice and how people react to prejudice, is very personal. And no one race has ever had quite the level of persecution as the Jewish people (well not without effectively ceasing to exist as a people).

As for Israel, they took it through a protracted guerilla warfare / terrorist campaign.



Your historical details are more or less correct.
And it was quite reasonable for your grand dad to hate Germans but it wouldn't be reasonable for you to do so. That was really my point. If we put old grievances behind us and stop being so easily offended then perhaps the world just might be a better place.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 24 Nov 14 5.20pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 24 Nov 2014 4.58pm

Not really, they'd murdered 6m Jews by the time we got around to liberating them. Hardly the greatest liberation. Also, given most of the death camps were on the 'other side' of Europe, a lot of the liberating was done by the Red Army.

Absolutely correct. The Holocaust was largely ignored early in the war because the British upper classes were historically anti-semitic and Churchill, who recognised Hiter's greater threat, knew that for the general British public, protecting the Jewish population of Eastern Europe would not be an acceptable reason to enter the war. The same for America...millions of Jews had been exterminated at the time of Pearl Harbour.

Real Western recognition of the Holocaust was belated; it really started in the late 50s and 60s and retrospectively has been the source of a considerable amount of Allied guilt. But this was not the case at the time. It is this guilt that, I'm afraid, the Israeli government frequently leverages to its advantage to abuse the Palestinian communities today. They protest that if we don't support them the State of Israel could be wiped out by its hostile neighbours but I am unaware of a single Israeli politician who actually believes that threat is remotely credible.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 27 Nov 14 4.16pm

He's been charged by the FA, the BBC are reporting.

EDIT: [Link]

Dave Whelan: Wigan chairman charged by Football Association

Wigan Athletic chairman Dave Whelan has been charged by the Football Association over comments he made about Jewish and Chinese people in an interview.
More to follow.

Edited by Seth (27 Nov 2014 4.25pm)

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Page 8 of 9 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Dave Whelan