This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 05 Jun 2015 12.29pm
You are not talking about numbers. The Romans and Normans influenced the country because the took control of government by force. Out culture is being eroded now by stealth and numbers. Some people might be happy with that, but a very significant number are not. Racism is is largely about self interest. The idea of the hate of skin colour is a myth for all but a tiny minority of knuckle draggers. For many, dislike or suspicion of other races/religions/nationalities is based on perceived practical matters. What is this shared culture we have, that's being eroded, that your talking about. I don't disagree that migration causes change, but all cultures are fluid and change according to the ideas and social interactions. Arguably, migration has generally benefited British Culture in fields such as the arts and cusine, by exposing it to new influences and even in politics by exposing us to different political ideas and voices. What it means to be British is defined subjectively, not collectively. The idea of erosion is a false notion, as culture is continually in a state of entropy, irrespective of the race or nationality of people. What you generally mean is some people are, understandably, upset because their position and status in society has been undermined by migration. But that's nothing to do with culture, its to do with competition. Its framed as an erosion of culture to give it a great imperative, by which it cannot be questioned without appearing to being anti-British.
rather than self interest, racists are quite good at acting against their self interest if it means 'getting one over' on the hate group of the week (Indeed Far Right groups are generally based around this principle, where by they use popularity ideas about race and nationality in order to obtain power).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 05 Jun 2015 12.29pm
You are not talking about numbers. The Romans and Normans influenced the country because the took control of government by force. Because no one actually has any real knowledge of the actual numbers. Certainly the number were presumably sufficient for say William to defeat Harold militarily and put down the Northern Rebellion shortly after. And of course once settled they brought family over and servants, and over time began to marry into the local populations. The roman army of Claudius invasion was four legions, about 20,000 troops and around 20,000 auxilleries. The estimated population of the UK at the time is around 4m. Which is pretty big. Notably when the Doomesday census put the population of England, during the 11th century at between 1.5m and 2m - Estimates of Williams Army are between 8,000 and 12,000 men. Later backed by about 8000 initial settlers given lands and titles by William etc. So not exactly insignificant numbers, with a population even of 2m. Edited by jamiemartin721 (05 Jun 2015 1.10pm)
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 05 Jun 2015 1.09pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 12.54pm
What is this shared culture we have, that's being eroded, that your talking about. I don't disagree that migration causes change, but all cultures are fluid and change according to the ideas and social interactions. It's all those things associated with the British working class that ironically the lefties frown upon, such as dogs, fish and chips, getting drunk and fighting. So except for the fish and chips, the Eastern European working classes should be commended for their efforts at fitting right in. I thought it was conservatives who frowned on things like fighting and drinking, and generally having a good time. Certainly those of the Thatcher era were kill joys for football, drinking, raving, partying and hooligans. Didn't they also do something about dogs and Cod
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
I love it when hundreds, if not thousands, of year's old history is trotted out as if it's relevant to migration today.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Quote johnfirewall at 05 Jun 2015 1.09pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 12.54pm
What is this shared culture we have, that's being eroded, that your talking about. I don't disagree that migration causes change, but all cultures are fluid and change according to the ideas and social interactions. It's all those things associated with the British working class that ironically the lefties frown upon, such as dogs, fish and chips, getting drunk and fighting. Dunno where you get that idea from john, but this leftie likes dogs(well behaved non aggressive ones), eats fish and chips about once a fortnight, drinks to excess a little more often than is healthy, but does abhor fighting. Unless it is an organised sport with rules, like boxing or wrestling. Even those two don`t interest me in the slightest though. Still, getting one out of four right is about par for the course for righties I suppose.
Is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour? [Link] |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote TheJudge at 05 Jun 2015 1.16pm
I don't strongly disagree with what you say. It is a question of the language we use to describe things. I would suggest that the problem isn't so much one of migration per se, but the impact that has had on wages and employment among working class British citizens. The failure of the minimum wage to be linked to inflation or the actual cost of living in areas, has created an environment where people are priced out of working, whilst those overseas, typically being young, single, can afford to work for much lower wages, especially given the exchange rates to their home nation (coming to work in the UK is a very good way to create a nest egg in say Poland). The reason for the supposed 'rise in racism' in the working class has nothing to do with a) race or b) nationalism, not really, its about erosion of wages by UK employers maximizing profitability by utilizing cheap migrant temporary labour. I believe that the political parties of the UK like to make it about Nationalism, because of course they can pursue other agendas, and keep their corporate sponsors happy. I also believe that migrant workers also are quite heavily exploited by their employers, in a manner that they'd never get away with if their employees were british.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 3.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 9.37am
Even the Royal Families of England and the UK have often been born abroad and of a very different nationality than the people they ruled. During early periods of Norman rule, you had Normans, Norman Franks, Saxons, Angles, Danish, Jute, Dane, Cymri and celtic peoples making up the population of England in significant numbers or positions of authority. Europe has always been a melting pot of cultures. There never has been a dominant culture not really (Culture tends to exist in flux of different internal cultural ideas, in conflict. The idea of a national shared culture is really a myth, rather there are a number of shared and disputed ideas about national culture).
It resulted in wars......Just because migration has happened regularly in the past doesn't mean that it was accepted and so should be considered so. I also find your ideas on 'dominant culture' to be way off. To say that generations of peoples who live in the same areas don't share rituals, language and knowledge bases and hence a culture is just wrong. You nit pick in proving your point but its more a play of words than an actual convincing argument. I think its related to dislike of nationality rather than a balanced analysis of what culture is. I think people in areas do share rituals, dialects (culturfied language) and ideas, but these are localized, knowledge and regionalized, rather than national - but I also believe that these factors are not shared in a 'we are all of agreement' but exist in conflict. I've never really seen a definition of British Culture that's applicable to all British people. Is there really a culture that connects people from Cornwall, Berkshire, Essex, Norfolk, Yorkshire and binds them with Belfast, Glasgow and Bridge end? That's shared - I'd argue that British National Culture exists on the basis of the differences of ideas between those groups than the similarities shared.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 05 Jun 2015 3.08pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 05 Jun 2015 9.37am
Even the Royal Families of England and the UK have often been born abroad and of a very different nationality than the people they ruled. During early periods of Norman rule, you had Normans, Norman Franks, Saxons, Angles, Danish, Jute, Dane, Cymri and celtic peoples making up the population of England in significant numbers or positions of authority. Europe has always been a melting pot of cultures. There never has been a dominant culture not really (Culture tends to exist in flux of different internal cultural ideas, in conflict. The idea of a national shared culture is really a myth, rather there are a number of shared and disputed ideas about national culture).
It resulted in wars......Just because migration has happened regularly in the past doesn't mean that it was accepted and so should be considered so. I also find your ideas on 'dominant culture' to be way off. To say that generations of peoples who live in the same areas don't share rituals, language and knowledge bases and hence a culture is just wrong. You nit pick in proving your point but its more a play of words than an actual convincing argument. I think its related to dislike of nationality rather than a balanced analysis of what culture is. It was never accepted. Culture is based in the very nature of conflicting ideas, being resolved through historical discourse within society (not necessarily by violence). For example, cultural imperitives about race, gender and sexuality, have developed through conflicting ideas about those subjects, and their expression and conflict with the 'dominant idea of their time' and resulted in change. Change is of course neither good, nor bad, it just is, the subjective value judgement generally is about which factional idea you identify with and how it fares, rather than any real truth. The Celts didn't welcome the Romans, nor the Cymri the Saxons, but for us, we see it inevitably as a good thing, because it creates our world (ie that Ultimately the Saxons, and then the Normans would go on to inform our culture, and ultimately we end up in a position where we are judging the 'value' from our position, which of course is inherently biased by the 'victor'. Which of course is why so few people speak Gallic and so many speak English (Saxon and Norman dominance).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.