You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero
November 22 2026 2.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Richard Dawkins Hero


Page 8 of 14 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 10.05am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jun 2015 10.02am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 15 Jun 2015 8.51pm
I think Jamie, that you expect and hope for too much of the human race in their search for understanding.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (15 Jun 2015 8.54pm)

Probably, although the point I'm trying to get at is that there is really a difference between being a Christian and someone who follows the teachings of Christ, and those two things are a massive difference.

Also, we should expect more of ourselves as a species than simply replacing ourselves and going with the flow. Especially when you're staking your immortal soul on the outcome (I don't believe in that, but if I did, I wouldn't necessarily base my decision on convenience). Especially as those 'major' players contradict one another.

I mean, how do you decide which God(or gods) are the right ones.



Fight?

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 10.34am

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 10.05am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jun 2015 10.02am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 15 Jun 2015 8.51pm
I think Jamie, that you expect and hope for too much of the human race in their search for understanding.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (15 Jun 2015 8.54pm)

Probably, although the point I'm trying to get at is that there is really a difference between being a Christian and someone who follows the teachings of Christ, and those two things are a massive difference.

Also, we should expect more of ourselves as a species than simply replacing ourselves and going with the flow. Especially when you're staking your immortal soul on the outcome (I don't believe in that, but if I did, I wouldn't necessarily base my decision on convenience). Especially as those 'major' players contradict one another.

I mean, how do you decide which God(or gods) are the right ones.



Fight?

So its the Norse gods then, they seem to be pretty fight orientated. Still, it'll make summer holidays more interesting.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 16 Jun 15 11.24am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 16 Jun 2015 10.02am

Quote EaglesEaglesEagles at 15 Jun 2015 8.51pm
I think Jamie, that you expect and hope for too much of the human race in their search for understanding.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (15 Jun 2015 8.54pm)

Probably, although the point I'm trying to get at is that there is really a difference between being a Christian and someone who follows the teachings of Christ, and those two things are a massive difference.

Also, we should expect more of ourselves as a species than simply replacing ourselves and going with the flow. Especially when you're staking your immortal soul on the outcome (I don't believe in that, but if I did, I wouldn't necessarily base my decision on convenience). Especially as those 'major' players contradict one another.

I mean, how do you decide which God(or gods) are the right ones.


Well certainly in academic circles, being someone who follows the teachings of Christ is highly debated. The method of interpretation of parables themselves is one such area.
That, I suppose, proves your point that it is possible to engage in and explore the many investigations and viewpoints in the area of Christ's teaching. That's fair.

I wouldn't like to think I, or many other Christians would base their faith on a sense of convenience or hedging one's bets. That undoubtedly happens among some people but I see that genuine inspiration and a feeling of real faith and love is inspired in people.
I agree it isn't a particularly attractive feature of monotheistic faiths that the immortal soul of the believer is at stake, but I would say that when living one's life according to Christian principles (which may be drawn up by churches) a religious person does not constantly have his mind on avoiding condemnation. Although it is implicit, I think that one's actions became a natural almost instinctive facet to the way one lives.

Edited by EaglesEaglesEagles (16 Jun 2015 11.25am)

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 16 Jun 15 11.48am

The guy just coppies the words of David Hume, he argues poorly, not a hero in my eyes but he is entitled to his opinion

 

reborn 16 Jun 15 12.12pm

Quote Shifty97 at 16 Jun 2015 11.48am

The guy just coppies the words of David Hume, he argues poorly, not a hero in my eyes but he is entitled to his opinion


Yes he is, but sadly he doesn't believe that right should be extended to others.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 12.51pm

Quote Shifty97 at 16 Jun 2015 11.48am

The guy just coppies the words of David Hume, he argues poorly, not a hero in my eyes but he is entitled to his opinion

I assume you're talking about the 'God Delusion', which is where I departed company with Dawkins, as I agree it tends towards being critically quite poor in constructing an argument.

Quite the opposite of the Blind Watchmaker and the Selfish Gene, the first of which is an excellent defense of evolutionary theory.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 1.00pm

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 12.12pm

Quote Shifty97 at 16 Jun 2015 11.48am

The guy just coppies the words of David Hume, he argues poorly, not a hero in my eyes but he is entitled to his opinion


Yes he is, but sadly he doesn't believe that right should be extended to others.

Even in the God Delusion, Dawkins main issue isn't with forcing his opinion on others, but the degree to which religion is represented in state, without supporting evidence. Dawkins, for example, would point at Abortion laws in Ireland, and argue that these laws represent Catholic influence, rather than actual government policy, and that in doing so, people are oppressed by the opinions of others, not by knowledge.

As such, political parties will co-opt Religion to support their political basis, irrespective of evidence, and as such creates a bias in society by which religious ideas wield power over non-religious people.

Somehow along the way Dawkins seems to have managed to sideline a very valid point, into becoming some kind of rent-a-quote attack dog for Atheism and secularism, probably because he's good 'interview'.

But he did have a very valid point about the role of religion in society, and influence.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 16 Jun 15 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 10.04am

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.


Judge, you can pretty much say what you like but you can't insult other users. Have a read through the forum rules if you need clarification.

[Link]

Apologies Superfly.

There is a fine line and I will endeavor not to cross it.
I will say that posting on this site is a pleasure because the mods are fair minded and the debate is civilized. I have been on the BBS where insults and any accusation imaginable are allowed (provided you are in the clique with the mods)Not a nice place.

 

TheJudge Flag 16 Jun 15 1.40pm

I will accept that some are not keen on the God delusion but aside from the book reviews, Dawkins' message is clear and constant. Religion is not the answer and never will be.
To fit god into the blank spaces where our knowledge is lacking is just a cop out and such a policy is guaranteed to keep large numbers of people in perpetual ignorance.

 

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 2.25pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 10.04am

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.


Judge, you can pretty much say what you like but you can't insult other users. Have a read through the forum rules if you need clarification.

[Link]

Apologies Superfly.

There is a fine line and I will endeavor not to cross it.
I will say that posting on this site is a pleasure because the mods are fair minded and the debate is civilized. I have been on the BBS where insults and any accusation imaginable are allowed (provided you are in the clique with the mods)Not a nice place.


Cheers Judge

I agree the BBS is much more lax when it comes to dissing but we try and keep it down (although I'm sure you'll spot discretions occasionaly) - to our credit imo. I think it ruins a thread when it turns all playgroundy.

'Banter' cussing is wholy encouraged though Of course, there's a danger of going overboard but as long as the recipient knows it's just leg pulling then there's generally no harm done. Even if you're ribbing someone on a cast iron stone solid dyed in the wool fact like dannyh's olympic gold for shirt lifting

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

derben Flag 16 Jun 15 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?

 

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 3.04pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?


From the forum list page. Not too sure if it's up to date but I think so.

Guntrisoft, Hambo, Moose, Old Chap, PassDribbleShoot, Penge Eagle, SloveniaDave

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

derben Flag 16 Jun 15 3.07pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.04pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?


From the forum list page. Not too sure if it's up to date but I think so.

Guntrisoft, Hambo, Moose, Old Chap, PassDribbleShoot, Penge Eagle, SloveniaDave

But you are not on it?

 

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 3.21pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 3.07pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.04pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?


From the forum list page. Not too sure if it's up to date but I think so.

Guntrisoft, Hambo, Moose, Old Chap, PassDribbleShoot, Penge Eagle, SloveniaDave

But you are not on it?


Me? No, I'm not a mod. Did I say I was?

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

derben Flag 16 Jun 15 3.28pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.21pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 3.07pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.04pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?


From the forum list page. Not too sure if it's up to date but I think so.

Guntrisoft, Hambo, Moose, Old Chap, PassDribbleShoot, Penge Eagle, SloveniaDave

But you are not on it?


Me? No, I'm not a mod. Did I say I was?

I got that impression from your posts on this thread. But now I know you are not, I'll feel free to take the mick.

 

Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 16 Jun 15 3.35pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 3.28pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.21pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 3.07pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 3.04pm

Quote derben at 16 Jun 2015 2.53pm

Is there an up to date list of mods?


From the forum list page. Not too sure if it's up to date but I think so.

Guntrisoft, Hambo, Moose, Old Chap, PassDribbleShoot, Penge Eagle, SloveniaDave

But you are not on it?


Me? No, I'm not a mod. Did I say I was?

I got that impression from your posts on this thread. But now I know you are not, I'll feel free to take the mick.


No, not me. Mod's on this site tend to hold off unless a post is reported on so it's fairly self moderated really. Just thought I'd give Judge a friendly nod to let him know he was possibly risking a card.

You take the mick all you like Del boy Taking the mick is about 98.4% of all my posts. When that get's veto'd I'm bang in trouble.

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Jun 15 4.01pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 1.40pm

I will accept that some are not keen on the God delusion but aside from the book reviews, Dawkins' message is clear and constant. Religion is not the answer and never will be.
To fit god into the blank spaces where our knowledge is lacking is just a cop out and such a policy is guaranteed to keep large numbers of people in perpetual ignorance.

Its certainly not scientific or rational to do that, particularly, of course it also doesn't really matter unless you take a fundamentalist approach where god creates man and the universe, and the earth literally (rather than figuratively).

There is room for evolution and faith, similarly Big Bang and faith, if your faith is based in a spiritual relationship with god, rather than demanding that the bible is 'the literal' truth of the world. Genesis is a creation myth, passed down through generations of the tribes of Israel until they could write it down.

And even then, its the old testament, so its largely irrelevant, as the bit that relates to being a Christian begins with the New Testament anyhow.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

reborn 16 Jun 15 4.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 10.04am

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.


Judge, you can pretty much say what you like but you can't insult other users. Have a read through the forum rules if you need clarification.

[Link]

Apologies Superfly.

There is a fine line and I will endeavor not to cross it again
I will say that posting on this site is a pleasure because the mods are fair minded and the debate is civilized. I have been on the BBS where insults and any accusation imaginable are allowed (provided you are in the clique with the mods)Not a nice place.

Fixed.

#banter

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

TheJudge Flag 16 Jun 15 10.06pm

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 4.05pm

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 1.35pm

Quote Superfly at 16 Jun 2015 10.04am

Quote reborn at 16 Jun 2015 9.49am

Quote TheJudge at 16 Jun 2015 8.59am

I don't want to upset Superfly again so I will just have you imagine me sitting in front of my laptop with a " I'm glad he doesn't live next door to me" look on my face.


Well done, you're learning, that actually IS banter.


Judge, you can pretty much say what you like but you can't insult other users. Have a read through the forum rules if you need clarification.

[Link]

Apologies Superfly.

There is a fine line and I will endeavor not to cross it again
I will say that posting on this site is a pleasure because the mods are fair minded and the debate is civilized. I have been on the BBS where insults and any accusation imaginable are allowed (provided you are in the clique with the mods)Not a nice place.

Fixed.

#banter



I'm not convinced that you are displaying a "Christian" attitude.
Me thinks you are one of those types who pays lip service to Bible bashing because you like to belong to a little club. Typical.

 

reborn 17 Jun 15 8.36am

LOL sadly for you I live it, I spend all my days when I am not working trying to help other people and significant amounts of my money. You see its not a club, its a way of life.

I think the thing that irritates you the most is I don't fit into your close minded and prejudiced view of what a Christian is.

I will pray for you, not least for a sense of humour. Lighten up man, you seem so angry at everything.

 


My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs

Page 8 of 14 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Richard Dawkins Hero