You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?
November 22 2026 2.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?


Page 8 of 19 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Stirlingsays Flag 23 Jul 15 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 23 Jul 15 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

 

Hoof Hearted 23 Jul 15 5.46pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories


As a UKIP voter at the last election I can confirm that if UKIP hadn't been an option I would have voted Conservative.

If Labour was the only option on the voting slip I would have spoiled my paper.

Labour are a busted flush whoever they vote in as leader, but if I had to choose one of the current options then Burnham would offer the most hope. Corbyn would be as bad a choice as Michael Foot was.

 

ghosteagle Flag 23 Jul 15 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 23 Jul 15 6.04pm

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 5.46pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories


As a UKIP voter at the last election I can confirm that if UKIP hadn't been an option I would have voted Conservative.

If Labour was the only option on the voting slip I would have spoiled my paper.

Labour are a busted flush whoever they vote in as leader, but if I had to choose one of the current options then Burnham would offer the most hope. Corbyn would be as bad a choice as Michael Foot was.


6 percentage points behind the tories is hardly busted. It is UKIP that will disappear in two years. There are probably thirty seats I could immediately name because the Labour vote went to UKIP this time. Southampton, Clywyd, Corby etc etc

Essentially the UKIP vote is a working class vote - not entirely but largely. That vote will return to Labour. Some will vote tory but only the minority

But Labour does need to get its act together

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 23 Jul 15 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

ghosteagle Flag 23 Jul 15 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 23 Jul 15 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 23 Jul 15 6.24pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?


I said nothing about "not being left wing enough". Nor do I think it. but it needs to offer rather more than just being Tory-lite

 

palace_in_frogland Flag In a broken dream 23 Jul 15 6.31pm

Not all labour voters are party members. The latter are calling for a movement to the left, but this is not necessarily reflected in the wider labour leaning electorate.

The working class cannot be defined by the same criteria as a hundred years ago; great numbers of working people with mortgages, school and tuition fees etc. have different worries and concerns and may feel disconnected from far left dogma.

For me, labour need to find a way to reassure this "working middle class" without just looking like a cheap copy of the Tories.

 

ghosteagle Flag 23 Jul 15 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 23 Jul 15 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 23 Jul 15 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 23 Jul 15 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 23 Jul 15 7.30pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?

I didn't vote labour because they were not left wing enough.

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 23 Jul 15 7.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?


Because even they are waking up to the fact that Labour are a bunch of jokers who have totally trashed this once great country.

 

leggedstruggle Flag Croydon 23 Jul 15 8.06pm

Quote fed up eagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?


Because even they are waking up to the fact that Labour are a bunch of jokers who have totally trashed this once great country.

Not just Labour to blame, Tories, Liberals, BNP, TUSC, Greens, Monster Raving Looneys, SNP, Sein Fein, the media, various 'rights' organisations, teachers for sure, priests of all descriptions, the FA, Dancing on Ice, meerkats, cyclists, eco-warriors. (Sure there are loads more, but these are the first to come to mind.)

 


mother-in-law is an anagram of woman hitler

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 23 Jul 15 8.14pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 8.06pm

Quote fed up eagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?


Because even they are waking up to the fact that Labour are a bunch of jokers who have totally trashed this once great country.

Not just Labour to blame, Tories, Liberals, BNP, TUSC, Greens, Monster Raving Looneys, SNP, Sein Fein, the media, various 'rights' organisations, teachers for sure, priests of all descriptions, the FA, Dancing on Ice, meerkats, cyclists, eco-warriors. (Sure there are loads more, but these are the first to come to mind.)


Yep, especially those god dam meerkats, GRRRRRRRR!!!!

 

Stuk Flag Top half 24 Jul 15 1.20pm

How does Ken the c*** work out that voting Corbyn for leader might gain some Conservative voters?

I bet Corbyn loved being compared to Nigel Farage too.

 


Optimistic as ever

OldFella Flag London 24 Jul 15 2.59pm

Quote fed up eagle at 23 Jul 2015 7.40pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 7.19pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 7.02pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.46pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.32pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.24pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 6.22pm

Quote leggedstruggle at 23 Jul 2015 6.12pm

Quote ghosteagle at 23 Jul 2015 5.52pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.31pm

Quote Stirlingsays at 23 Jul 2015 5.26pm

Quote Sedlescombe at 23 Jul 2015 5.23pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 23 Jul 2015 11.15am

Quote Hoof Hearted at 23 Jul 2015 10.15am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 22 Jul 2015 12.01pm

If Labour had won the Scottish seats, no one would have won the election.



You need a maths lesson!

The Conservatives won an electable majority on their own to govern.

Giving Labour another 51 seats would change nothing.

Opps quite right - I misread the number. I thought the difference was a lot closer. 12 seats above the majority, not by 12 seats. Sorry.



You need 325 seats for an overall majority and the Tories have 330. Actually you probably need a few less than that because for example Sinn Fein don't tae their seats.

I was a lot closer. Tories 37% of the vote Labour 31%. Hardly a landside

Considering the fact that if they hadn't existed that most of Ukip's votes would have gone to the Tories....the underlying tale is that this was a massive rejection of Labour at a time where the working class isn't doing that well.


I don't think you have any basis for saying how UKIP voters would have voted. It seems that the one thing they didn't want to do is vote Conservative. The issue for Labour was that they didnt vote for them.

Your second point is undoubtedly true. My point was that there is all to play for if only Labour can elect a leader and re-find its identity as something other than nice-tories

I think you are spot-on, the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite. The present leadership battle is interesting because there seems to be such a disconnect between the MPs and the wider party members, who a clearly agitating for a move back to the left. I would also add that blairs speech the other day has only increased support for Corbyn.

So these Labour voters did not vote Labour because they were not left wing enough, then voted for a right wing UKIP party?

No.

You just said they lost because they were too Tory!

Please try harder, and also try reading what is actually written. It is a great aid to debate.

A quote from your post above: the faliure of Labour at the GE was mainly due to it's attempts to paint itself as tory-lite.


There is a little more to political ideas than 1.Copy the tories only be a bit nicer about it and 2. A left wing socialist platform.


Why do you think people who usually vote Labour did not at the General Election?


Because even they are waking up to the fact that Labour are a bunch of jokers who have totally trashed this once great country.

Is the correct answer

Now a choice of Burnham, Cooper, Corbyn or Kendall? Political pygmies. You deficit denying, sore loser lefties must be very proud


 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Page 8 of 19 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Labour Leadership - Bald men fighting over a comb?