You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough
November 22 2026 2.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough


Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >
Superfly Flag The sun always shines in Catford 30 Jun 15 5.44pm

Quote kingdowieonthewall at 30 Jun 2015 5.26pm

Quote DanH at 30 Jun 2015 4.41pm

If everyone just stuck to the simple commandment of 'Be Nice' then none of this would happen anywhere in the World.

Unfortunately people are c*nts.


its 'be excellent to one another'
(bill n ted)


And 'Party on dudes'

Class film

 


Lend me a Tenor

31 May to 3 June 2017

John McIntosh Arts Centre
London Oratory School
SW6 1RX

with Superfly in the chorus
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 30 Jun 15 9.28pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jun 2015 10.36am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jun 2015 10.13am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jun 2015 9.31am

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
So you would allow someone who has through their own free, will gone to a country specifically to kill innocent people in the name of thier chosen sky fairy to come back to Britain abd carry on as normal ?

No, I'd try them for Terrorist offences, as they have a universal jurisdiction, and if found guilty, send them to prison, or if more suitable to the country involved extradite them to stand trial in that country.

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
It's simple really, you let it be known clearly and without any doubt that ISIS fighters from the UK will not be allowed back into Britain, end of chat.

Also you have to prove beyond reasonable doubt that a) they were in Syria b) they were part of IS. A lot of people are in Syria with NGO, aid workers and with non-IS rebel factions.

Travelling overseas for the purpose of terrorism is a crime in the UK, with up to a life sentence. We should implement this, or deport them to stand trial in a country in which they have been involved in terrorism.

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
That in turn will (I imagine ) push Turkey away from thier "shrugg of the shoulders" attitude if they know that the last place they flew from is where they will be returned to.

Turkey would then just put them on a plane back, refusing them entry, as they don't have Turkish citizenship.

Turkey isn't really too fussed about IS as its focused against their enemy the Kurds.


Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
f*** em.

This I definitely agree with. I don't like them, but just refusing them entry to the UK, isn't an option.



I'm sorry but when national security is at stake then anything is an option. Wait till people start dying in numbers and see how that plays out. I hope it doesn't happen, but it would be extremely optimistic to believe that all will just return to normal when these people return home.

Not saying that, I'm saying arrest the f**kers, try them, and send them to prison for the crimes they have committed (Terrorism is universal jurisdiction, so they can be tried anywhere), or specifically extradite them to stand trial elsewhere (notably where they have committed crimes). It also enables you to turn one or two of the less committed, to inform on others who they saw out there.

I'm not sure how that translates as 'just let them back in and hope for the best'.

Revoking citizenship, sounds good on rhetorical level and beats a good nationalist drum, but its utterly impractical, because you'd send them back to the country they came from and that country would just send them back to you.

Plus you'd need to go through the process of revoking citizenship, which presumably would require reasonable evidence of fighting with IS (which is going to be tricky to prove).

Not at all practical or workable


What I am suggesting is that all options will be on the table if the situation becomes serious. If security is threatened sufficiently, particularly their own, the government and security services will do what it takes, inside or outside of law.

 

johnfirewall Flag 30 Jun 15 9.47pm

I suppose if we avoid these places and fcuk their economy with 15% of GDP being through tourism we'd just end up with more nutters. They'd probably try to do something about it though.

 

legaleagle Flag 30 Jun 15 10.00pm

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jun 2015 9.28pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jun 2015 10.36am

Quote TheJudge at 30 Jun 2015 10.13am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 30 Jun 2015 9.31am

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
So you would allow someone who has through their own free, will gone to a country specifically to kill innocent people in the name of thier chosen sky fairy to come back to Britain abd carry on as normal ?

No, I'd try them for Terrorist offences, as they have a universal jurisdiction, and if found guilty, send them to prison, or if more suitable to the country involved extradite them to stand trial in that country.

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
It's simple really, you let it be known clearly and without any doubt that ISIS fighters from the UK will not be allowed back into Britain, end of chat.

Also you have to prove beyond reasonable doubt that a) they were in Syria b) they were part of IS. A lot of people are in Syria with NGO, aid workers and with non-IS rebel factions.

Travelling overseas for the purpose of terrorism is a crime in the UK, with up to a life sentence. We should implement this, or deport them to stand trial in a country in which they have been involved in terrorism.

Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
That in turn will (I imagine ) push Turkey away from thier "shrugg of the shoulders" attitude if they know that the last place they flew from is where they will be returned to.

Turkey would then just put them on a plane back, refusing them entry, as they don't have Turkish citizenship.

Turkey isn't really too fussed about IS as its focused against their enemy the Kurds.


Quote dannyh at 30 Jun 2015 8.42am
f*** em.

This I definitely agree with. I don't like them, but just refusing them entry to the UK, isn't an option.



I'm sorry but when national security is at stake then anything is an option. Wait till people start dying in numbers and see how that plays out. I hope it doesn't happen, but it would be extremely optimistic to believe that all will just return to normal when these people return home.

Not saying that, I'm saying arrest the f**kers, try them, and send them to prison for the crimes they have committed (Terrorism is universal jurisdiction, so they can be tried anywhere), or specifically extradite them to stand trial elsewhere (notably where they have committed crimes). It also enables you to turn one or two of the less committed, to inform on others who they saw out there.

I'm not sure how that translates as 'just let them back in and hope for the best'.

Revoking citizenship, sounds good on rhetorical level and beats a good nationalist drum, but its utterly impractical, because you'd send them back to the country they came from and that country would just send them back to you.

Plus you'd need to go through the process of revoking citizenship, which presumably would require reasonable evidence of fighting with IS (which is going to be tricky to prove).

Not at all practical or workable


What I am suggesting is that all options will be on the table if the situation becomes serious. If security is threatened sufficiently, particularly their own, the government and security services will do what it takes, inside or outside of law.

IMO, we go outside the law at our peril...

That means those that have no respect for the rule of law win and we can have no compelling argument about the lawlessness of others..

Historically (and leaving aside for the moment the civil liberties issues) even in war,things have generally been done within the law...even then caution should prevail.As an example,In 1939/40,the government introduced blanket internment of "alien nationals" without thinking it through.This meant many Jewish refugees from Austria and Germany who were "aliens" were put in camps next to their fellow Austrian and German nationals who might be Nazis.Some time later, more quietly,they realised the mess up and own goal aspect of this and released the jews and many subsequently made a valuable contribution to the war effort.

In terms of stripping citizenship from people who can't get any other,there are serious international law issues and once you ignore a few things,it threatens the whole edifice and would be taken advantage of by tin pot characters all over the place....and I say that acknowledging the issues when those wishing you harm have no regard for international law, and our own arguable ignoring of it when we went into Iraq.


Edited by legaleagle (30 Jun 2015 10.11pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 9.27am

Going outside the law and spirit of our law is something we should only ever pursue in specific individual case, where all other options are exhausted.

The recent cases where the Security Services have been implicit in torture and rendition shame us, and validate the cause of the enemy far more than they serve any real long term goal.

So far the only reason we've 'removed citizenship' from individuals, is to allow them to be targeted for drone strikes, without it violating our own laws of responsibility.

In reality, we have, along with the US, declared a war on some terrorism, specifically certain Islamist terrorists, we shouldn't really be too surprised when we then become the target of terrorist attacks against our citizens.

We need to remain firm but fair and just, ruled by due process whenever possible. We should of course reserve the right to retaliate and eliminate targets of opportunity that arise, militarily, judicially and when necessary through extra-judicial measures.

But we also must accept the responsibility when we get it wrong or get caught out breaking our own laws.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 01 Jul 15 10.01am

Both the previous posts are showing a little naivety I believe.
We are dealing with totally ruthless fanatics. The rule of law protects the individual in many cases but part of our civil liberties is to be safe from harm.

Make no mistake, this is an us or them situation and like in most conflicts, what is fair will come second to what wins. If people start dying in numbers in Britain, the gloves will be off if they are not already.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 10.50am

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 10.01am

Both the previous posts are showing a little naivety I believe.
We are dealing with totally ruthless fanatics. The rule of law protects the individual in many cases but part of our civil liberties is to be safe from harm.

Make no mistake, this is an us or them situation and like in most conflicts, what is fair will come second to what wins. If people start dying in numbers in Britain, the gloves will be off if they are not already.

Its a threat, but in terms of a real threat to national security, stability of the nation and the British way of life its fairly minimal. Its a serious matter, and one we need to remain focused on, but if we keep wetting our knickers in any conflict when the enemy causes casualties, civilian or military, we're only going to end up losing.

We're in a war, and its inevitable that people will die, that cannot be avoided. Acting as if its 1939, the Army is in retreat and the Germans are at the door, every time we suffer an attack ultimately will end up feeding into a defeat. Turning every casualty into a media story hampered the long term ambitions in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the same will apply to the war on terror.

We need to eliminate the threat, definitely, but in doing so, we will also have to accept that threat will now exist for at least another generation. The successes against Al-Qaeda groups has produced groups like IS, that have effectively formed a 'second generation' of Islamist terrorists aimed at the west.

Terrorist groups invariably see themselves as a vanguard movement, their aim is to create reprisals and repression of those they claim to represent, marginalizing those people, and drawing them onto their side of the fence (ultimately radicalizing them).

Its a long war situation, there isn't an easy way out, because even if we crushed IS militarily in Syria and Iraq, their affilates and ideological supporters have essentially become the new Al-Qaeda franchise.

Eventually IS will likely end up destroyed, and its survivors will form a new organization that will declare war on the west and so on.

Usually these kinds of conflicts run to 20-30 years before either petering out, negotiated settlements or being overtaken by social changes (or a combination of all these).

Each generation of terrorist group becomes more efficient and effective than its predecessor, as it learns from its failures.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

johnfirewall Flag 01 Jul 15 3.27pm

Of the family of 12 who went to Syria, one has cancer and one diabetes.

Are we obligated to let them back in for treatment? ISIS claims to have a health service but I wouldn't really trust the brochures.

Edited by johnfirewall (01 Jul 2015 4.13pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 4.02pm

Quote johnfirewall at 01 Jul 2015 3.27pm

Of the family of 12 who went to Syria, one has cancer and one diabetes.

Are we obligated to let them back in from treatment? ISIS claims to have a health service but I wouldn't really trust the brochures.

9 of the 12 definitely, given they're British children (oldest is 15), who aren't legally accountable. The other three, well as prisoners they are entitled to health care and treatment.

I'd imagine the ISIS Health service is more geared towards trauma treatment.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 01 Jul 15 4.24pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jul 2015 10.50am

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 10.01am

Both the previous posts are showing a little naivety I believe.
We are dealing with totally ruthless fanatics. The rule of law protects the individual in many cases but part of our civil liberties is to be safe from harm.

Make no mistake, this is an us or them situation and like in most conflicts, what is fair will come second to what wins. If people start dying in numbers in Britain, the gloves will be off if they are not already.

Its a threat, but in terms of a real threat to national security, stability of the nation and the British way of life its fairly minimal. Its a serious matter, and one we need to remain focused on, but if we keep wetting our knickers in any conflict when the enemy causes casualties, civilian or military, we're only going to end up losing.

We're in a war, and its inevitable that people will die, that cannot be avoided. Acting as if its 1939, the Army is in retreat and the Germans are at the door, every time we suffer an attack ultimately will end up feeding into a defeat. Turning every casualty into a media story hampered the long term ambitions in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the same will apply to the war on terror.

We need to eliminate the threat, definitely, but in doing so, we will also have to accept that threat will now exist for at least another generation. The successes against Al-Qaeda groups has produced groups like IS, that have effectively formed a 'second generation' of Islamist terrorists aimed at the west.

Terrorist groups invariably see themselves as a vanguard movement, their aim is to create reprisals and repression of those they claim to represent, marginalizing those people, and drawing them onto their side of the fence (ultimately radicalizing them).

Its a long war situation, there isn't an easy way out, because even if we crushed IS militarily in Syria and Iraq, their affilates and ideological supporters have essentially become the new Al-Qaeda franchise.

Eventually IS will likely end up destroyed, and its survivors will form a new organization that will declare war on the west and so on.

Usually these kinds of conflicts run to 20-30 years before either petering out, negotiated settlements or being overtaken by social changes (or a combination of all these).

Each generation of terrorist group becomes more efficient and effective than its predecessor, as it learns from its failures.


Most of what you say is generally reasonable but I would remind you that the IRA nearly killed the entire Cabinet and there were not really many active IRA members. A similar action would constitute a serious threat to national security I would suggest.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 4.38pm

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 4.24pm
Most of what you say is generally reasonable but I would remind you that the IRA nearly killed the entire Cabinet and there were not really many active IRA members. A similar action would constitute a serious threat to national security I would suggest.

They didn't nearly kill the entire cabinet, they managed to bomb the Brighton Hotel and launch a rocket attack on Downing Street. Neither attack would likely have resulted in the loss of the entire cabinet, and civil contingencies exist that can deal with that event anyhow.

The number of active IRA members, doesn't really describe the effectiveness or size of the organization. The Provisionals generally had very few active service units in operation at any given time. Those cells would carry out attacks and bombings, but they were supported by other cells that dealt with this like logistical support, intelligence, counter intelligence, operational planning etc that all would then be fed to an ASU. Someone would build the bomb, another group would move it from the bomb maker to the armoury, another group would then supply it to the ASU would would deploy it, and then another group would have set up 'escape plans' for the ASU (and many of these groups would have little or no interaction) - It makes the most of skill sets and allows focused training (and in theory makes it harder to infiltrate)

So you might have three active service units on the mainland, of say 15 people in total, but they would be backed by a much larger organization.


As such an ASU was only focused on conducting the operation. Most militaries work this way, there are those that 'engage the enemy' and those who 'make it possible'.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 4.40pm

What concerns me is that a group like IS could lose its entire leadership body, and keep functioning, where as if we 'lose the entire cabinet' its a national disaster.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

TheJudge Flag 01 Jul 15 9.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jul 2015 4.38pm

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 4.24pm
Most of what you say is generally reasonable but I would remind you that the IRA nearly killed the entire Cabinet and there were not really many active IRA members. A similar action would constitute a serious threat to national security I would suggest.

They didn't nearly kill the entire cabinet, they managed to bomb the Brighton Hotel and launch a rocket attack on Downing Street. Neither attack would likely have resulted in the loss of the entire cabinet, and civil contingencies exist that can deal with that event anyhow.

The number of active IRA members, doesn't really describe the effectiveness or size of the organization. The Provisionals generally had very few active service units in operation at any given time. Those cells would carry out attacks and bombings, but they were supported by other cells that dealt with this like logistical support, intelligence, counter intelligence, operational planning etc that all would then be fed to an ASU. Someone would build the bomb, another group would move it from the bomb maker to the armoury, another group would then supply it to the ASU would would deploy it, and then another group would have set up 'escape plans' for the ASU (and many of these groups would have little or no interaction) - It makes the most of skill sets and allows focused training (and in theory makes it harder to infiltrate)

So you might have three active service units on the mainland, of say 15 people in total, but they would be backed by a much larger organization.


As such an ASU was only focused on conducting the operation. Most militaries work this way, there are those that 'engage the enemy' and those who 'make it possible'.


Sounds like you wouldn't get twitchy until the IS flag was flying over Parliament. Glad you're not in charge.

 

legaleagle Flag 01 Jul 15 10.49pm

It really depends IMO on what one's terms of reference are.

I abhor ISIS and I abhor "salafist jihadism".I don't however regard the muslim population of the UK as a likely mass collective "fifth column" any more than I regarded the entire Catholic population of N Ireland or the entire Irish population of mainland UK as a collective "fifth column" in relation to the PIRA.

ISIS IMO presents no more of an existential threat to the UK than the PIRA was an existential threat to mainland UK.Or any more than in McCarthyite times,anyone remotely of the left presented a collective existential threat to the USA.That doesn't mean there is a not a clear and present risk of innocents being killed in numbers.

The period 1939-45 might reasonably be said to have represented an existential threat.It was basically dealt with generally ,successfully,within the law.

That said, one person dying from "terrorist acts" is one too many.

So,personally I remain unpersuaded by anyone who either speaks of abandoning the rule of law,or who posits a likely raising of the ISIS flag over Downing Street, as in the former case being appropriate,or in the latter case,anything more than possibly a modern day variant of McCarthyism and a vast over exaggeration.Over exaggeration is not helpful to considered analysis and strategy.

There is a very real problem and it needs to be understood and dealt with in a thought through and joined up way.That does not mean it shouldn't also be analysed and dealt with in a proportionate way ,preferably without playing into the hands of ISIS etc by responding in a way which would perfectly suit their aims and strategy.

Edited by legaleagle (01 Jul 2015 10.52pm)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 10.57pm

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 9.07pm

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jul 2015 4.38pm

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 4.24pm
Most of what you say is generally reasonable but I would remind you that the IRA nearly killed the entire Cabinet and there were not really many active IRA members. A similar action would constitute a serious threat to national security I would suggest.

They didn't nearly kill the entire cabinet, they managed to bomb the Brighton Hotel and launch a rocket attack on Downing Street. Neither attack would likely have resulted in the loss of the entire cabinet, and civil contingencies exist that can deal with that event anyhow.

The number of active IRA members, doesn't really describe the effectiveness or size of the organization. The Provisionals generally had very few active service units in operation at any given time. Those cells would carry out attacks and bombings, but they were supported by other cells that dealt with this like logistical support, intelligence, counter intelligence, operational planning etc that all would then be fed to an ASU. Someone would build the bomb, another group would move it from the bomb maker to the armoury, another group would then supply it to the ASU would would deploy it, and then another group would have set up 'escape plans' for the ASU (and many of these groups would have little or no interaction) - It makes the most of skill sets and allows focused training (and in theory makes it harder to infiltrate)

So you might have three active service units on the mainland, of say 15 people in total, but they would be backed by a much larger organization.


As such an ASU was only focused on conducting the operation. Most militaries work this way, there are those that 'engage the enemy' and those who 'make it possible'.


Sounds like you wouldn't get twitchy until the IS flag was flying over Parliament. Glad you're not in charge.

Not really, I like to understand how things work and operate. I think its vital to understand an enemy, who it is, what it wants, how it functions etc if you want to defeat it. This isn't a conflict that can be won purely on a militarily basis.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 01 Jul 15 11.00pm

Quote legaleagle at 01 Jul 2015 10.49pm

It really depends IMO on what one's terms of reference are.

I abhor ISIS and I abhor "salafist jihadism".I don't however regard the muslim population of the UK as a likely mass collective "fifth column" any more than I regarded the entire Catholic population of N Ireland or the entire Irish population of mainland UK as a collective "fifth column" in relation to the PIRA.

ISIS IMO presents no more of an existential threat to the UK than the PIRA was an existential threat to mainland UK.Or any more than in McCarthyite times,anyone remotely of the left presented a collective existential threat to the USA.That doesn't mean there is a not a clear and present risk of innocents being killed in numbers.

The period 1939-45 might reasonably be said to have represented an existential threat.It was basically dealt with generally ,successfully,within the law.

That said, one person dying from "terrorist acts" is one too many.

So,personally I remain unpersuaded by anyone who either speaks of abandoning the rule of law,or who posits a likely raising of the ISIS flag over Downing Street, as in the former case being appropriate,or in the latter case,anything more than possibly a modern day variant of McCarthyism and a vast over exaggeration.Over exaggeration is not helpful to considered analysis and strategy.

There is a very real problem and it needs to be understood and dealt with in a thought through and joined up way.That does not mean it shouldn't also be analysed and dealt with in a proportionate way ,preferably without playing into the hands of ISIS etc by responding in a way which would perfectly suit their aims and strategy.

Edited by legaleagle (01 Jul 2015 10.52pm)

True, but then every mistaken terrorist target, or collaterial damage, also results in new Jihadists and converts in the process.

Things like Internment and failing to deal properly with Bloody Sunday, did far more good for the PIRA than any IRA recruitment campaign ever could.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

legaleagle Flag 01 Jul 15 11.55pm

Agreed

 

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Jul 15 12.10am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jul 2015 10.50am

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 10.01am

Both the previous posts are showing a little naivety I believe.
We are dealing with totally ruthless fanatics. The rule of law protects the individual in many cases but part of our civil liberties is to be safe from harm.

Make no mistake, this is an us or them situation and like in most conflicts, what is fair will come second to what wins. If people start dying in numbers in Britain, the gloves will be off if they are not already.

Its a threat, but in terms of a real threat to national security, stability of the nation and the British way of life its fairly minimal. Its a serious matter, and one we need to remain focused on, but if we keep wetting our knickers in any conflict when the enemy causes casualties, civilian or military, we're only going to end up losing.

We're in a war, and its inevitable that people will die, that cannot be avoided. Acting as if its 1939, the Army is in retreat and the Germans are at the door, every time we suffer an attack ultimately will end up feeding into a defeat. Turning every casualty into a media story hampered the long term ambitions in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the same will apply to the war on terror.

We need to eliminate the threat, definitely, but in doing so, we will also have to accept that threat will now exist for at least another generation. The successes against Al-Qaeda groups has produced groups like IS, that have effectively formed a 'second generation' of Islamist terrorists aimed at the west.

Terrorist groups invariably see themselves as a vanguard movement, their aim is to create reprisals and repression of those they claim to represent, marginalizing those people, and drawing them onto their side of the fence (ultimately radicalizing them).

Its a long war situation, there isn't an easy way out, because even if we crushed IS militarily in Syria and Iraq, their affilates and ideological supporters have essentially become the new Al-Qaeda franchise.

Eventually IS will likely end up destroyed, and its survivors will form a new organization that will declare war on the west and so on.

Usually these kinds of conflicts run to 20-30 years before either petering out, negotiated settlements or being overtaken by social changes (or a combination of all these).

Each generation of terrorist group becomes more efficient and effective than its predecessor, as it learns from its failures.


I think you both make good points.

Jamie's point about media outcries over casualties speaks of a cultural mindset of western democracies which have avoided large scale conflicts for over fifty years.

There is a touch of the demise of the Roman empire about it, where the longer Rome went without a real external threat the more distant it became from even recognizing when it needed to fight to protect its interests.

To sum it up simplistically, in the end Rome fell because it forgot what it took to remain a superpower......Essentially this has been repeated throughout history since.

I see the way the western media deal with conflict as a small reminder of this......They see it through the eyes of people who have forgotten that all they have....All the privilege they take for granted....Was ultimately won by people who died violently in the dirt.

Ultimately, it always comes down to that.....As is the nature of cellular life.....As is the nature of man.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

suicideatselhurst Flag crawley 02 Jul 15 12.30am

Quote Stirlingsays at 02 Jul 2015 12.10am

Quote jamiemartin721 at 01 Jul 2015 10.50am

Quote TheJudge at 01 Jul 2015 10.01am

Both the previous posts are showing a little naivety I believe.
We are dealing with totally ruthless fanatics. The rule of law protects the individual in many cases but part of our civil liberties is to be safe from harm.

Make no mistake, this is an us or them situation and like in most conflicts, what is fair will come second to what wins. If people start dying in numbers in Britain, the gloves will be off if they are not already.

Its a threat, but in terms of a real threat to national security, stability of the nation and the British way of life its fairly minimal. Its a serious matter, and one we need to remain focused on, but if we keep wetting our knickers in any conflict when the enemy causes casualties, civilian or military, we're only going to end up losing.

We're in a war, and its inevitable that people will die, that cannot be avoided. Acting as if its 1939, the Army is in retreat and the Germans are at the door, every time we suffer an attack ultimately will end up feeding into a defeat. Turning every casualty into a media story hampered the long term ambitions in Afghanistan and Iraq, and the same will apply to the war on terror.

We need to eliminate the threat, definitely, but in doing so, we will also have to accept that threat will now exist for at least another generation. The successes against Al-Qaeda groups has produced groups like IS, that have effectively formed a 'second generation' of Islamist terrorists aimed at the west.

Terrorist groups invariably see themselves as a vanguard movement, their aim is to create reprisals and repression of those they claim to represent, marginalizing those people, and drawing them onto their side of the fence (ultimately radicalizing them).

Its a long war situation, there isn't an easy way out, because even if we crushed IS militarily in Syria and Iraq, their affilates and ideological supporters have essentially become the new Al-Qaeda franchise.

Eventually IS will likely end up destroyed, and its survivors will form a new organization that will declare war on the west and so on.

Usually these kinds of conflicts run to 20-30 years before either petering out, negotiated settlements or being overtaken by social changes (or a combination of all these).

Each generation of terrorist group becomes more efficient and effective than its predecessor, as it learns from its failures.


I think you both make good points.

Jamie's point about media outcries over casualties speaks of a cultural mindset of western democracies which have avoided large scale conflicts for over fifty years.

There is a touch of the demise of the Roman empire about it, where the longer Rome went without a real external threat the more distant it became from even recognizing when it needed to fight to protect its interests.

To sum it up simplistically, in the end Rome fell because it forgot what it took to remain a superpower......Essentially this has been repeated throughout history since.

I see the way the western media deal with conflict as a small reminder of this......They see it through the eyes of people who have forgotten that all they have....All the privilege they take for granted....Was ultimately won by people who died violently in the dirt.

Ultimately, it always comes down to that.....As is the nature of cellular life.....As is the nature of man.


Yes stirling both make good points but i take issue with jamies point above, every casulty is a story and we need to remember them and why they became a casulty..if we remember that maybe we wont have to keep going into conflict

 


Theres someone in my head ... But its not me

X/Box game Tag bazcpfc1961, clan (HMS)

Stirlingsays Flag 02 Jul 15 12.38am

Quote suicideatselhurst at 02 Jul 2015 12.30am


Yes stirling both make good points but i take issue with jamies point above, every casulty is a story and we need to remember them and why they became a casulty..if we remember that maybe we wont have to keep going into conflict


I think exactly the opposite.

Unless this attitude was also being culturally inputted into cultures like the Islamic State or any other group who wanted your resources then eventually they are just going to take everything you have.

The real world is like the playground...You can wish it wasn't all you like but you don't get anywhere by cowering away from conflict.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 8 of 12 < 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Tunisia Terrorism - It's time to get tough